THE AUSTRALIAN
ntomologist
published by
THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF QUEENS LAND
Volume 26, Part 3, 10 December 1999
Price: $5.00 per part
Published by: THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF QUEENSLAND
ISSN 1320 6133
THE AUSTRALIAN ENTOMOLOGIST
The Australian Entomologist (formerly Australian Entomological Magazine) is a
non-profit journal published in four parts annually by the Entomological Society
of Queensland. It is devoted to entomology of the Australian region, including
New Zealand, Papua New Guinea and islands of the south-western Pacific. Articles
are accepted from amateur and professional entomologists. The journal is
produced independently and subscription to the journal is not included with
membership of the Society.
The Editorial Panel
Editor: Dr D.L. Hancock
Dept of Primary Industries
Assistant Editors Dr G.B. Monteith
Queensland Museum
Dr C.J. Burwell
Queensland Museum
Mr G. Daniels
University of Queensland
Business Manager Mr P. Bouchard
University of Queensland
Subscriptions
Subscriptions are payable in advance to the Business Manager, The Australian
Entomologist, P.O. Box 537, Indooroopilly, Qld, Australia, 4068.
For individuals A$16.00 per annum Australia
A$20.00 per annum elsewhere
For institutions A$20.00 per annum Australia.
A$22.00 per annum elsewhere.
Cheques in currency other than Australian dollars should include an extra A$5.00.
ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF QUEENSLAND
Membership is open to anyone interested in Entomology. Meetings are normally
held in the Department of Zoology and Entomology, University of Queensland on
the second Monday of March-June and August-December each year. Meetings are
announced in the Society's News Bulletin which also contains reports of
meetings, entomological notes, notices of other Society events and information
on Members' activities.
Enquiries relating to the Society should be directed to the Honorary Secretary,
Entomological Society of Queensland, C/- Department of Zoology and
Entomology, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld, 4072.
Sustaining Associates
Arrest-A-Pest Pty Ltd, Rhone-Poulenc Rural Australia Pty Ltd.
Cover: Ornate false spider mites (Tuckerellidae) are early derivative members of
the economically important Tetranychoidea - spider mites, clover mites, flat
mites, etc.. This species, Tuckerella sp. nr. flabellifer Miller, feeds on the stems
of the introduced weed lantana and on a variety of native trees and shrubs.
Illustration by Juanita Choo, Department of Zoology and Entomology,
University of Queensland.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 65-70 65
A NEW SPECIES OF LEUCIACRIA ROTHSCHILD & JORDAN
(LEPIDOPTERA: PIERIDAE) FROM MONTANE NEW IRELAND,
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
C.J. MULLER
Centre for Ore Deposit Research, University of Tasmania, GPO Box 252-79, Hobart, Tas 7001
Address for correspondence: PO Box 228, Dural, NSW 2158
Abstract
Leuciacria olivei sp. nov. is described and illustrated from high elevations in southern New
Ireland, Bismarck Archipelago, Papua New Guinea. The new species is compared with
L. acuta Rothschild & Jordan, 1905, within the previously monotypic genus.
Introduction
The genus Leuciacria Rothschild & Jordan (1905) was proposed for the type
species, the previously unique L. acuta Rothschild & Jordan. Klots (1933),
in his extensive paper dealing with the family Pieridae in general, considered
Leuciacria to be closest to Elodina C. & R. Felder, although he stated that the
genus was somewhat isolated in terms of its affinities. Klots (1933) stated
that neither the venation nor the genitalia of Leuciacria suggested any
definite relationships.
The followings abbreviations are used in this work: ANIC - Australian
National Insect Collection, CSIRO, Canberra; BMNH - The Natural History
Museum, London; CJMC - Private collection of C. J. Muller, Sydney; JOC -
Private collection of John Olive, Cairns
Leuciacria olivei sp. nov.
(Figs 1-3, 5)
Types. Holotype & (ANIC genitalia slide No. 13096), PAPUA NEW GUINEA:
“Hans Meyer Ra., 2400 m, S. New Ireland, 22.viii.1998, C.J. Muller” in ANIC.
Paratypes:'1 0°, same data as holotype (BMNH); 1 0”, same data as holotype (JOC);
1 ð, same data as holotype but dated 20.viii.1998 (CJMC); 1 d, same data as
holotype, with genitalia dissected and attached to specimen (CJMC).
Description. Male (Figs 1-3). Forewing length 24.8 mm, antenna 12.9 mm.
Head black with dense, deep grey hair-tufts, whitish-grey ventrally; antenna
black, with conspicous flat club, ventrally white-centered; labial palpus black
and hairy. Thorax black above with numerous fine grey hairs, cream
beneath; legs grey, tending light brown at end. Abdomen white, with black
dorsal ridge tapering posteriorly, claspers grey. Forewing concave between
apex and vein M,, strongly convex between tornus and vein M,, costa slightly
bowed toward base, apex pointed; above cream, costa and apex narrowly
black, base with yellow suffusion and with scattering of black scales, cilia
cream; beneath cream with costa marginally black, apex light grey-fawn,
strong yellow suffusion particularly in distal portion of cell, lessening
= $
66 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Figs 1-2. Leuciacria olivei sp. nov., male. (1) Upperside; (2) underside. Scale bar =
5mm.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) s
towards termen, cell and veins greenish proximally. Hindwing slightly
rounded, above cream with fine hairs in distal area near inner margin, yellow
suffusion in costal and inner margin to basal areas, scattering of black scales
at base, cilia cream; beneath cream with faint greenish tinge, costa yellow,
slight scattering of grey scales in postmedian area between veins CuA, and
3A, parallel linearly with termen near tornus, cell and veins greenish
proximally.
Figs 3-4. Adult males of Leuciacria spp., comparing extent of dense white scales.
(3) L. olivei, (4) L. acuta. Scale bar = 8 mm.
68 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Figs 5-6. Male genitalia of Leuciacria spp. 5. L. olivei. (a) dorsal view; (b) vinculum
and tegumen ring, lateral view; (c) left valva, lateral view; (d) aedeagus, lateral view.
6. L. acuta. (a) dorsal view; (b) vinculum and tegumen ring, lateral view; (c) left
valva, lateral view; (d) aedeagus, lateral view. Scale bar = 0.5 mm.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 69
Genitalia (Fig. 5). Vinculum and tegumen ring broadly oval, indented
anteriorly; uncus long, slender, gently dipping, apex dorsally sharply pointed,
blunt laterally with median dorsolateral toothed processes; valva long, rather
narrow, covered with fine setae, apex with tip hooked, curved inwards,
ventrum irregular; tegumen short and bent upwards; aedeagus sharp,
irregular basally, squared apically, post-zonal portion bowed strongly.
Female. Unknown
Etymology. Named in honour of Mr John Olive, Trinity Park, Queensland.
Discussion
The discovery of Leuciacria olivei sp. nov. in New Ireland is somewhat
surprising, as the genus previously has not been recorded outside mainland
New Guinea. Parsons (1991, 1998) stated that L. acuta flies at 1200-2000 m
and is generally a rare taxon. L. olivei has been observed and/or collected
between 1700 and 2400 m in the Hans Meyer Ra., southern New Ireland.
Since intervening New Britain has several mountains that rise above 2000 m,
it is suggested that Leuciacria may occur there also.
Leuciacria olivei may be separated readily from L. acuta (Fig. 4) by the
shape of the forewing, which in L. acuta is strongly concave between the
apex and vein M2. The costa is nearly straight in L. olivei, while it is
strongly bowed in L. acuta, particularly towards the apex. The forewing
black apical tip is far more reduced in L. olivei than in L. acuta and there is a
strong yellowish suffusion on the ventral surface of both wings in the former
that is not present in L. acuta.
In addition, the male genitalia of the two taxa bear several distinguishing
features (Figs 5, 6). The uncus in L. olivei is slender with toothed dorsal
processes, whilst in L. acuta it is more simple and diamond-shaped.
Laterally, the uncus of L. acuta is beak-like in appearance, while that of
L. olivei is comparatively blunt. The valvae of L. olivei are much longer and
narrower than in L. acuta and the apical hook is much less pronounced than
in the latter species. The aedeagus in L. acuta is fairly simple and blunt both
anteriorly and posteriorly, whereas that of L. olivei is sharp and irregular
basally, and squared apically.
The habitat for the type series of L. olivei is a mixed moss/heath forest which
is peculiar to andesitic (ancient volcanic) mountain crests and slopes above
1800 m in southern New Ireland. Adults were taken, together with
Graphium kosii Miiller & Tennent (Papilionidae), Delias messalina lizzae
Miiller (Pieridae), Parantica fuscela Parsons and Cethosia vasalia Miiller
(Nymphalidae), as they flew directly and quite rapidly above the canopy
which is as low as 6 m in the highest parts of the Hans Meyer Range (Fig. 7).
70 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Fig. 7. Type locality of L. olivei, Hans Meyer Range, 2400 m, southern New Ireland.
Acknowledgments
The expedition into remote southern New Ireland was made possible by a
number of local people, particularly Joel Todiai, and the author is grateful to
them all. Permits to acqhire material were issued by the Department of
Primary Industries, Namatanai, and the Provincial Government, Kavieng.
References .
Klots, A.B. 1933. A generic revision of the Pieridae (Lepidoptera), together with a study of the
male genitalia. Entomologica Americana 12(4): 139-242.
Parsons, M.J. 1991. Butterflies of the Bulolo-Wau valley. Bishop Museum, Honolulu; 280 pp.
Parsons, M.J. 1998. The butterflies of Papua New Guinea; their systematics and biology.
Academic Press, London; 736 pp.
Rothschild, W. and Jordan, K. 1905. On some new Lepidoptera discovered by A. S. Meek in
British New Guinea. Novitates Zooligicae 12: 448-478.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 71-76 71
POSSIBLE POSTCOPULATORY MATE GUARDING
IN ORNITHOPTERA EUPHORION (GRAY)
(LEPIDOPTERA: PAPILIONIDAE)
A.G. ORR
Cooperative Research Centre for Tropical Rainforest Ecology and Management,
Environmental Sciences, Griffith University, Nathan, Qld 4111
Abstract
Observations were made on the courtship behaviour of Ornithoptera euphorion (Gray) at
Bramston Beach, north Queensland. An instance is described of a male, known to have mated
with a female, following her for about a day and driving off other males who courted her.
Three one examples of apparent guarding involving pairs where mating was not observed are
also noted.
Introduction
Following insemination, males of many butterfly species produce a mating
plug, which seals the ostium bursae or copulatory opening and prevents or
delays remating by the female (Ehrlich and Ehrlich 1978, Dickensen and
Rutowski 1989). Owing to the ditrysian arrangement of the female
reproductive tracts found in all higher Lepidoptera, the plug does not impede
oviposition and may remain in place for life. When freshly formed the plug
is soft and gelatinous and over a period of one to two days it contracts and
hardens (Orr 1988, Matsumoto and Suzuki 1992). It has been shown in
Atrophaneura alcinous Klug that the freshly formed plug can be easily
penetrated or pushed aside by the aedeagus of another male and that males
sometimes cling to mating pairs and mate successfully with the female when
the original pair separate (Suzuki and Matsumoto 1990, Matsumoto and
Suzuki 1992). This behaviour sometimes also occurs in Ornithoptera
richmondia (Gray) maintained in captivity (Orr, unpublished observations).
It would seem logical therefore, that if males could successfully drive off
potential mates in the period following mating while the plug remains soft,
they would minimize the risks of the female remating with another male and
using his sperm to fertilize her eggs.
The details of courtship behaviour in Ornithoptera Boisduval and Troides
Hiibner species have never been fully described and vary considerably with
circumstances. However in all species of the two genera for which
information is available, including O. euphorion (Gray), the male hovers
briefly below the female, then flies directly in front of her, possibly brushing
her antennae with the androconia which fringe the anal margin of the
hindwings, then hovers about half a metre above her. Immediately before a
mating or mating attempt, it is common for the male to splay his hindwings
slightly and bring them together in an abrupt scissor action, which may serve
to disseminate pheromones. Mating is attempted generally only when the
female is quiescent, or at least has ceased to flap her wings. This cycle may
be repeated many times. It may be performed on newly emerged females,
72 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
where mating follows very quickly, or on feeding females and flying
females; in the latter case the male describes a series of progressive ellipses
about the female as he follows her. Brief accounts of courtship in
T. oblongomaculatus papuensis Wallace and in O. richmondia are given by
Parsons (1983) and Orr (1988) respectively. Most of the courtships observed
in nature probably involve already mated females and remating seldom
results but, as in O. richmondia between 10-20% of old females contain more
than one spermatophore, polyandry evidently does occur in nature and a
small proportion of such courtships must be successful (Orr 1988,
unpublished observations).
Methods
Between 8-15 February 1999 I spent a total of 14.5 hours observing the
courtship and other sexual interactions of O. euphorion around cultivated
Hibiscus flowers at Bramston Beach, near Innisfail, north Queensland.
Owing to legal restrictions on handling this species I was unable to capture
and mark individuals, but at least four males and three females were
identifiable by the distinctive wing damage. Much wing chipping may have
been caused by Yellow-bellied Sunbirds (Nectarina jugularis), which
frequently pecked the butterflies, apparently in defence of their feeding
territories. The butterflies were observed by using compact wide angled
binoculars. Any distinguishing marks were noted and recorded. Notes of
behaviour were made using a small hand held dictophone.
Results
Five interactions in which a male continually courted a female were followed
for approximately half an hour to one hour, until either the pair was lost from
sight or the male ceased courtship attempts. Although males often alighted
beside or on top of the female and attempted mating, successful coupling was
never achieved and, following such attempts, females invariably alighted and
flew at least a few metres before resuming feeding, whereupon the male
recommenced courtship. On two occasions the male grappled with the
female and carried her to the ground but was unable to hold her in either
case. In all cases the female was almost certainly mated and probably bore a
mating plug, which would have been difficult to dislodge. After such
aggressive mating attempts females normally departed. The frequency of
mating attempts varied but typically took place every five to fifteen minutes
over a period of up to an hour or more.
Such observations are typical of the courtship behaviour of males with mated
females which is frequently observed. However on one occasion (12 Feb.
1999) I observed a mated pair arrive at the flowers at 0920h, where they
commenced feeding. At 0935h they separated and as both bore distinctive
damage I was able to recognize them on subsequent enounters and
intermittently observe their behaviour throughout the day. Following
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 73
separation the pair remained at the flowers and continued feeding for another
63 minutes. The male remained close to the female and was rarely more than
a metre from her. Five minutes after they separated a smaller male arrived at
the nectar and, after feeding briefly, began to court the female. The original
male tolerated his presence until he had been hovering above the female for
about three minutes, when he flew at the intruder and chased him for about
50 metres, then returned to an inflorescence near the female. Over a period
of 58 minutes the small male returned and courted the female persistently,
only to be attacked and routed by the first male on five occasions. Two cues,
which were correlated, seemed to trigger his aggression. He attacked either
when the female ceased to flutter her wings while the second male was
hovering above her, or when the second male splayed and then snapped his
hindwings against his abdomen, a movement which normally indicates an
intention to attempt mating. On two occasions the first male grappled with
the second and carried him to the ground. At no time did the first male court
the female for more than a few seconds and this was only immediately
following a serious altercation with the interloper. At 1038h the female flew
off, closely followed by the first male. I relocated the same pair later in the
day at another clump of Hibiscus about a kilometer distant, with the male still
in close attendance but not courting the female. On this occasion the pair
were observed for 42 minutes, during which time the male drove off two
other males, both quite distinct from the original interloper. The pair
reappeared at the original location at 1515h. They fed undisturbed for 12
minutes when a small male, almost certainly the original interloper, arrived
and after feeding at nectar for five minutes began again to court the female.
Between 1520 and 1710h the pair continued to feed with the small male
almost continually courting the female. He was driven off on six occasions
by the first male. The final interaction, at 1708h, was particularly dramatic.
Following a prolonged period of courtship, the interloper dived on the female
and carried her to the ground. The first male swooped onto the struggling
pair and seized the male, whereupon the female was freed and flew away.
After the males had grappled on the ground for about 30 seconds the second
male escaped and few away rapidly, with the first in pursuit. I did not see
them again that day. Also during this period (i.e. 1520-1710h) two other
males arrived and courted the female, sometimes at the same time as the
small male, but these were eventually driven off by the original male or lost
interest following a series of altercations with the small male.
The following morning at the original site I saw the female again between
0820 and 0930h, this time unaccompanied by the first male, who I observed
nectaring at the same site later in the day, between 1310 and 1320h, and
again between 1600 and 1630h. On that day, between 1510 and 1640h, I
also observed another pair, which although not observed in copula, exhibited
similar apparent guarding behaviour to that described above. This male bore
no distinguishing marks but he was seen constantly defending the female
74 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
from several interlopers, including the male from the previous pair, and
particularly the small original interloper described above who he attacked
and chased on seven occasions, three times seizing him and taking him to the
ground. The female was recognizable and was observed two days later
without an escort.
Prior to these observations (8-9 Feb. 1999), I twice observed between 1600
and 1800h a similar series of interactions between a guarding male which fed
and did not attempt courtship, a feeding female, and one or more courting
males which seldom fed. Other unguarded females also visited the flowers
and were subjected to courtship without result, but these usually did not
remain at the site for more than half an hour. In the light of the above
observations it seems reasonable to suggest that in these cases too the
guarding male had mated with the (guarded) female that day, and both were
replenishing their energy reserves.
Discussion
While these results do not provide a statistical sample they are sufficiently
unique to merit recording. Non-contact mate guarding is widespread in some
insects, especially the Odonata (Corbet 1961), but has never been reported in
the Lepidoptera. Following mating, females of most species are
unresponsive to male courtship for several days, even in polyandrous species
(Obara et al. 1975, Suzuki et al. 1977) and hence a mating plug, if present, is
likely to have hardened and be effective by the time the female accepts
another mating. Mate guarding would be most expected in species in which
forced copulation without courtship occurs. This happens only in sphragis
bearing species such as Cressida cressida Fabricius and Acraea andromacha
Fabricius (Orr 1988, 1995, 1999) and a few highly polyandrous species in
which males secure many matings and do not produce a mating plug, such as
Danaus plexippus Linnaeus (occasionally, Pliske 1975) or Acraea natalica
Boisduval (Orr 1988). In C. cressida the female is not normally released
until the sphragis is completely hardened (Orr and Rutowski 1992, Orr
1999), a situation analogous to contact mate guarding in the Odonata, and in
A. andromacha females are usually intercepted at hilltops and at the site of
the larval foodplant, rather than at nectar sources which are mostly dispersed;
hence freshly mated females are less likely to be molested although this has
been recorded (Epstein 1987). Males of polyandrous species which produce
no mating plug would be expected to direct their efforts to seeking more
mates, rather than attempting to guard one who may be almost guaranteed to
remate eventually.
Observations of caged O. richmondia suggest that females will accept
matings while the plug is still soft, especially if the first male has donated a
small spermatophore and the second male is especially persistent. Forced
copulation such as occurs in C. cressida is probably physically impossible as
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 75
the male must force the female to evert her sinus vaginalis, which would be a
difficult if not impossible operation if the female did not acquiesce to some
extent; but it is possible that a female might accept a mating soon after the
first if only to escape the attentions of an especially persistent male. I have
not previously witnessed the probable guarding behaviour described above,
in either O. richmondia or O. euphorion, perhaps partly because I have
seldom seen such a concentration of Ornithoptera in such easy terrain, but it
is also possible that the male guarding behaviour occurs only facultatively
when population densities are high and females are likely to be subjected to
intense courtship from other males immediately after mating.
Acknowledgments i
I thank the many residents of Bramston Beach who supported me and my
family while floodbound for six days by Cyclone Rona, during which time
many of these observations were made.
References
CORBET, P.S. 1961. The biology of dragonfies. Witherby, London.
DICKINSON, J.L. and RUTOWSKI, R.L. 1989. The function of the mating plug in the
chalcedon checkerspot butterfly. Animal Behaviour 38: 154-162.
EHRLICH, A.H. and EHRLICH, P.H. 1978. Reproductive strategies in the butterflies:
I. Mating frequency, plugging and egg number. Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society
51: 666-697.
EPSTEIN, M. 1987. Mating behaviour of Acraea andromacha andromacha (Fabricius) in New
Caledonia. Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society 41: 119-121.
MATSUMOTO, K. and SUZUKI, N. 1992. Effectiveness of the mating plug in Atrophaneura
alcinous (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 30: 157-163
OBARA, Y., TATEDA, H. and KURABARA, M. 1975. Mating behaviour of the cabbage
butterfly, Pieris rapae crucivora Boisduval. V. Copulatory stimuli inducing changes in female
response patterns. Dobut Zasshi 84: 71-76.
ORR, A.G. 1988. Mate conflict and the evolution of the sphragis in butterflies. Unpublished
PhD thesis, Griffith University, Nathan; 348 pp.
ORR, A.G. 1995. The evolution of the sphragis in the Papilionidae and other butterflies.
Chapter 16, in: Scriber, J.M., Tsubaki, Y. and Lederhouse, R.C. (eds), Swallowtail butterflies:
their ecology and evolutionary biology. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville; pp 155-164
ORR, A.G. 1999. Biology of Cressida cressida (Fabricius) (Papilionidae: Troidini). In:
Kitching, R.L., Scheermeyer, E., Jones, R.E. and Pierce, N.E. (eds). Biology of Australian
butterflies. Monographs on Australian Lepidoptera 6. CSIRO Publications, Melbourne.
ORR, A.G. and RUTOWSKI, R.L. 1991. Mating plug carried by female signals mated status to
male in the Big Greasy, Cressida cressida (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). Journal of Natural
History 25: 703-710.
PARSONS, M.J. 1983. Notes on the courtship of Troides oblongomaculatus papuensis
(Papilionidae) in Papua New Guinea. Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society 37: 83-85.
PLISKE, T.E. 1975. Courtship behaviour of the monarch butterfly Danaus plexippus L..
Annals of the Entomological Society of America 68: 143-151.
76 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
SUZUKI, N. and MATSUMOTO, K. 1990. Pair clinging behaviour of Atrophaneura alcinous
(Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). Journal of Ethology 8: 45-51.
SUZUKI, Y., NAKANISHI, A., SHIMA, H., YATA, O. and SAIGUSA, T. 1977. Mating
behaviour of four Japanese species of the genus Pieris (Lepidoptera, Pieridae). Kontyu 45:
300-313.
CORRIGENDA
In Figure 1 of Orr and Kitching (1999), captions (i) and (j) are transposed.
Fig. (i) is Beara falcata; fig. (j) is Scaphidriotis sp.
ORR, A.G. and KITCHING, R.L. 1999. A checklist of macrolepidoptera
collected from rainforest and former forest areas on basalt soils on the
Atherton Tableland. Australian Entomologist 26(1): 15-27.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 77-82 77
USE OF ODONATA AS PREY BY SAND WASPS, BEMBIX SPP.
(HYMENOPTERA: SPHECIDAE)
A.D. AUSTIN
Department of Applied and Molecular Ecology, Waite Campus, The University of Adelaide,
PO Glen Osmond, SA 5064 (email: aaustin@waite.adelaide.edu.au)
Abstract
The sphecid wasp Bembix minya Evans & Matthews from southern South Australia is recorded
for the first time as preying on damselflies (Odonata). Details of its nest structure and prey
range are presented, as is a discussion of the evolutionary transition within the genus to
utilising prey other than Diptera.
Introduction
Bembix F. is a large cosmopolitan genus of sphecid wasps comprising about
330 described species, 82 of which occur in Australia (Evans and Matthews
1973, Bohart and Menke 1976). They are often extremely common in sandy
habitats such as along beaches and the dunes of arid and semi-arid deserts.
With one exception (Evans 1978), species elsewhere in the world exclusively
provision their brood chambers with various paralysed adult Diptera (usually
muscoids, syrphids, dolichopodids and therevids) as food for a single
developing larva (Evans and Matthews 1973, Bohart and Menke 1976). It is
this biology and the fact that nest construction and provisioning can be
observed easily that has lead to the genus being used in studies of
comparative insect behaviour (e.g. Evans 1957, 1966, Evans and Matthews
1973).
Compared with other continents, the Australian Bembix fauna is particularly
interesting in that several species prey on insect groups other than Diptera,
including thynnine wasps, colletid, halictid and Trigona Jurine bees,
myrmeleontid lacewings and Odonata (Evans and Matthews 1973, Evans et
al. 1982). Two species have been recorded as provisioning their nests with
damselflies, B. coonundura Evans & Matthews from Lake Violet in Western
Australia, and B. variabilis Smith from Darwin and the Ord River near
Kununurra (Evans and Matthews 1973). A third species, B. allunga Evans &
Matthews, is known to utilise adult libellulid dragonflies at Kemp Beach near
Yeppoon, Queensland (Evans et al. 1982). However, B. variabilis and
B. allunga, both of which are widely distributed across the continent, are not
obligate predators of Odonata. More commonly they prey on a wide variety
of other insects, which include at least 12 dipteran families in the case of
B. variabilis, while B. allunga preys on various families of Diptera and
Neuroptera. In this study a fourth species, B. minya Evans & Matthews from
southern South Australia, is also recorded as preying on damselflies. Details
of its nest structure and prey range are presented, as is a discussion of the
evolutionary transition within the genus to utilising prey other than Diptera.
78 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Materials and Methods
Observations were made over a period of two days in mid-March 1993 at
Wistow, 4 km south of Mt Barker in the Adelaide Hills, South Australia (Fig.
1). The nests originally were discovered by accident when a two-tonne pile
of builder’s sand that had been at the site for the previous seven days, was
moved using a spade. Five nests were discovered, two of which were
partially disturbed by the spade, while the other three were completely
destroyed but recognisable by three semi-discrete groups of damselfly prey.
One adult wasp and all damselfly prey were collected into 70% alcohol from
a total of five nests, for later identification. Observations were undertaken
every 30-60 minutes during daylight hours but when no wasp activity was
observed at the end of the second day, the nests were gently exposed using a
small spoon to elucidate their structure.
Fig. 1. Localities where Bembix spp. have been recorded preying on Odonata:
B. variabilis on damselflies (@); B. coonumdura on damselflies (®); B. minya on
damselflies (3); B. allunga on libellulid dragonflies (m).
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 79
Results and Observations
Several species of sphecid wasps, including B. minya, had constructed nests
in the pile of builder’s sand described above. All nests were on the north-
western side of the sand pile and the entrances about 50 cm from ground
level. The two partially disturbed nests had slightly curved entrance tunnels,
estimated at 20 and 25 cm in length and angled downwards at about 30° to
the horizontal. At the end of each tunnel a single elongate brood chamber
was found that was horizontal and about 10-12 cm in length (Fig. 2). One
chamber contained 15 damselflies, comprising two obvious species based on
colour differences, and a single small Bembix larva. The other chamber
contained 19 damselflies, again comprising at least two species. These prey
were retained with the damselflies from the other three nests and totalled 79
individuals, which later identification revealed to comprise four species, two
coenagrionids and two lestids (Table 1).
Fig. 2. Lateral aspect of the nest of Bembix minya showing elongate brood chamber
(scale line = 5 cm; tunnel diameter not to scale).
One adult B. minya was collected from one of the two partially disturbed
nests and no other individuals were recorded at the sand pile over the next
day and a half. It is therefore possible that all five nests were constructed by
the one adult female and some of them had been fully provisioned and sealed
off. Given that 79 damselflies were recovered from the five nests, it seems
reasonable to assume that this species provisions its brood chamber with an
average of 16 prey items, a figure commensurate with the 15 and 19 prey
recorded from the two partially disturbed nests.
80 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Extensive searching of the area showed that the closest source of damselflies
was from two farm dams, one approximately 200 metres to the west of the
nest site and the other about 380 metres to the south-east. Several other dams
were located 400-600 metres in various directions. A small number of
damselflies were seen flying over the water surface of the closest dam.
Several individuals were netted and these were later identified as Austrolestes
analis (Rambur) and A. annulosus (Selys), the two commonest species
collected by B. minya (Table 1).
Table 1. Damselfly species recorded from five nests of Bembix minya at Wistow,
South Australia.
Damselfly prey Number of individuals
Coenagrionidae
Ischnura aurora (Brauer) 1
Xanthagrion erythroneurum (Selys) 17
Lestidae
Austrolestes analis (Rambur) 30
Austrolestes annulosus (Selys) 31
TOTAL 79
Discussion
The observations made during this study show that predation by Bembix spp.
on Odonata, particularly damselflies, is geographically widespread in
Australia (Wheeler and Dow 1933, Evans and Matthews 1973, Evans et al.
1982) (Fig. 1). They also lend support to the proposal that some Bembix spp.
may be obligate specialists on Odonata (damselflies), rather than the latter
being alternative prey for polyphagous species that mostly feed on Diptera.
Although there are insufficient data on prey for the genus to make definitive
statements about prey group specificity, the detailed studies of Evans and
Matthews (1973) and Evans et al. (1982) on the Australian fauna provide
information on 27 of 82 described species. All except three of these 27
species specialise on a single prey group, viz. Diptera, thynnine wasps,
Apidae s.l. (Colletinae, Halictinae, Trigona) myrmeleontid lacewings and
Odonata. The exceptions are: B. variabilis, which preys mostly on Diptera
but at two localities has been observed to also prey on damselflies, either
exclusively (Kununurra) or in combination with Diptera so that brood
chambers are provisioned with both prey groups (Darwin); B. allunga, which
also mostly preys on Diptera as well as ascalaphid, chrysopid and
myrmeleontid Neuroptera and libellulid dragonflies; and B. moma Evans &
Matthews, the nests of which usually contain a mixture of prey groups
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 81
comprising to date three subfamilies of Apidae s.l., five families of wasps
(Ichneumonidae, Gasteruptiidae, Tiphiidae, Pompilidae, Sphecidae) and at
least five families of flies (Evans and Matthews 1973).
The elongate brood chamber described here for B. minya (Fig. 2) is
somewhat atypical for Australian Bembix in that most species construct a
short chamber (Evans and Matthews 1973). However, at least one other
species, B. variabilis, also constructs a similar elongate chamber which is
undoubtedly necessary to accommodate the elongate bodies of multiple
damselfly prey.
Clearly, Bembix spp. provide an ideal group to examine the evolutionary
pathways that have led to prey switching. There is already some evidence
that prey specificity is an evolutionary (fixed) trait in that the three species
which exclusively prey on bees are contained within a single (presumably
monophyletic) species-group. Further, the two species apparently restricted
to damselflies, B. minya and B. coonundura, are closely related
(R.W. Matthews, pers. comm.) and may be sister taxa. A prerequisite for
such evolutionary studies would be the generation of a robust phylogeny for
the Australian species, a not insurmountable task but one that would probably
require molecular techniques given the likely level of morphological
homoplasy within the genus.
The observations reported here are consistent with those documented for
B. coonundura in regard to the number of damselflies provisioned per nest,
and for this species and B. variabilis for nest structure. The three intact nests
of B. coonundura excavated by Evans and Matthews (1973) at Lake Violet
each contained about 10 damselflies, comprising two of the four species
recorded here for B. minya, viz. Xanthagrion erythroneurum (Selys) and
A. annulosus. This number and that recorded for B. minya are substantially
lower than for the larger numbers of smaller flies recorded from nests of
some Bembix spp., which often number in excess of 50. Bembix coonundura
and B. minya presumably expend less energy in foraging for a smaller
number of prey and this may explain why a single wasp was collected from
the Wistow site; i.e. with fewer prey required it is possible for one wasp to
provision multiple nests sequentially in a relatively short period of time,
given that prey abundance is not limiting.
Finally, although the information presented here was the result of a fortuitous
encounter, this study has revealed the potential for using artificial sand piles
for observing and recording the nesting behaviour of Bembix spp. and other
sphecids. At sites where soil types are mostly inappropriate for nest
construction by sand wasps, artificial sites could be provided using sand of
different coarseness to examine the effect of particle size on nesting success.
Artificial sites provided at various times would also allow for the collection
of data on seasonality in nesting and its effect on species composition of
prey, plus rates of colonisation by different species.
82 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Acknowledgments
I wish to thank the late Tony Watson for identification of the damselflies, Ian
Naumann for identifying the Bembix species, and Bob Matthews and Sally
Collins for their comments on the manuscript.
References
BOHART, R.M. and MENKE, A.S. 1976. Sphecid wasps of the world: a generic revision.
University of California Press, Berkley; 694 pp.
EVANS, H.E. 1957. Studies on the comparative ethology of digger wasps of the genus Bembix.
Comstock Publishing Associates, Ithaca, New York; 248 pp.
EVANS, H.E. 1966. The comparative ethology and evolution of the sand wasps. Harvard
University Press, Cambridge; 526 pp.
EVANS, H.E. 1978. A solitary wasp that preys upon lacewings (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae;
Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Psyche 85: 81-83.
EVANS, H.E., EVANS, M.A. and HOOK, A. 1982. Observations on nests and prey of
Australian Bembix sand wasps (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae). Australian Journal of Zoology 30:
71-80.
EVANS, H.E. and MATTHEWS, R.W. 1973. Systematics and nesting behaviour of Australian
Bembix sand wasps (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae). Memoirs of the American Entomological
Institute 20: 1-387.
WHEELER, W.M. and DOW, R. 1933. Unusual prey of Bembix. Psyche 40: 57-59.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 83-86 83
A NOTE ON UNSUCCESSFUL OVERWINTERING OF LARVAE OF
DANAUS PLEXIPPUS (L.) (LEPIDOPTERA: NYMPHALIDAE)
IN THE BLUE MOUNTAINS, NEW SOUTH WALES
David G. James
Irrigated Agriculture Research and Extension Center, Washington State University, 24106
North Bunn Road, Prosser, Washington 99350, USA
Abstract
Fortnightly observations were made on a larval population of Danaus plexippus (L.) at
Hazelbrook, New South Wales to provide information on winter survival in the Blue
Mountains. The population was decimated in July and August apparently by strong, cold
winds. Only small numbers of larvae and pupae survived until September and none produced
adult butterflies.
Introduction
The monarch or wanderer butterfly, Danaus plexippus (L.), has an extensive
summer range in eastern Australia, breeding wherever suitable host plants
occur (Smithers 1977). During autumn the southern part of this range (in
NSW) contracts, forming overwintering populations in the Sydney and
northern coastal areas of New South Wales. The Sydney basin harbours both
breeding and non-breeding overwintering populations (Smithers 1965, James
1979, 1981). The westward limit of reproductive populations in the Sydney
area has not been established, although larvae have not been recorded west of
the Great Dividing Range during winter (Smithers 1977).
The two prime requirements for the survival and development of
D. plexippus larvae are an adequate food supply and body temperatures
greater than the developmental zero of 11-12°C for much of the time
(Rawlins and Lederhouse 1981, Zalucki 1982). Milkweed, Gomphocarpus
(= Asclepias) fruticosus (L) (Asclepiadaceae), the major host plant of
D. plexippus in New South Wales, occurs at elevations of up to at least 700 m
during winter in the Blue Mountains, west of the Sydney basin (James,
unpub. obs.). The presence of host plants, together with the ability of
D. plexippus larvae to increase body temperatures substantially when
exposed to sunshine (James 1986), indicate that survival of larvae during
winter in the Blue Mountains may be possible.
This study provides information on overwintering by larvae of D. plexippus
during 1984 at one site in the Blue Mountains.
Materials and Methods
The author’s garden at Hazelbrook, 17 km east of Katoomba at an altitude of
650 m, was chosen as the study site. A small patch of 25-30 milkweed
plants, occupying an area of approximately 1 m’, was established on a south-
facing slope in December 1983. Plants ranged in size from, 0.5-1.5 m tall.
The surrounding area was cultivated with vegetables. Natural bushland
occurred 5 m down-slope of the milkweed.
84 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
On 26 May 1984, 100 second instar larvae of D. plexippus were introduced
to the milkweed patch. One month later (24 June) a second batch of 100
third instar larvae was released. The milkweed was examined at fortnightly
intervals until the end of September and data recorded on number and instar
of larvae. Plants were searched thoroughly on each occasion and it is likely
that only a small number of larvae escaped detection. Pupae found on the
plants and general information on larval development and mortality were
recorded. Weather conditions were recorded also; the ambient temperature
was continuously monitored by a thermohygrograph situated 1 m above
ground level.
Results
The population of 200 larvae introduced to the milkweed in early winter
failed to produce a single butterfly. Numbers of larvae, fairly stable in June,
declined dramatically during July and August (Table 1). Small numbers of
pupae were produced but many were malformed and all died. The
substantial depletion of larvae during July and August coincided with the
occurrence of frequent cold and strong south to south-westerly winds which
were often accompanied by rain, sleet or snow. Such weather systems often
persisted for many days. The first of these severe cold fronts occurred in the
first week of July. On 4 July snow covered the ground for more than 5
hours. Subsequent examination of the milkweed revealed many larvae had
been blown to the ground by the gale force winds and had died. Similar
conditions occurred at the end of July and on four occasions during August.
Table 1. Number of larvae, pupae and relative percentages of instars of D. plexippus
during May-September 1984 at Hazelbrook, NSW.
Date No. of Relative % of instars No. of
larvae 2nd 3rd 4th Sth pupae
26.v. * 100 100 0 0 0 0
9.vi. 90 30 70 0 0 0
23.vi. 82 0 67 33 0 0
24.vi. * 182 0 92 8 0 0
T.vii. 130 0 81 19 0 0
21.vii. 64 0 20 51 29 1
4.viii. 32 0 0 31 69 6
18.viii. 12 0 0 17 83 15
1.ix. 7 0 0 0 100 22
15.ix. 1 0 0 0 100 23
29.ix. (0) 0 landi 0 0 0 25
* Denotes introduction of 100 second or third instar larvae.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 85
Observations indicated that larvae were most vulnerable when ecdysis
coincided with cold, windy conditions, and invariably died.
Temperatures during the period of study ranged from 1-19°C and daily
maxima and minima averaged 12.6 and 6.2°C respectively (Table 2). July
was the coldest and most overcast month, while June and August were
characterised by similar temperatures and mainly sunny skies. Strong winds
were common during July and August but June was mainly calm (Table 2).
Table 2. Climate data for Hazelbrook NSW, June-August 1984. Days were recorded
as “sunny” if there were more than 4 hours of sunshine; days were recorded as windy
if winds exceeded 20 km/h for more than 1 hour.
Temperature °C No. of No.of
Maximum Minimum sunny windy
Range Daily mean Range Daily mean days days
(+SE) (+SE)
June 9.5-17.5 13.5 (2.2) 4.5-11.0 6.9 (1.4) 22 2
July 6.0-13.5 10.5 (1.8) 1.0-8.0 4.9 (1.6 17 16
August 10.0-19.0 13.9 (2.5) 3.0-10.0 6.8 (1.8) 25 22
June- 6.0-19.0 12.6 (2.7) 1.0-11.0 6.2 (1.8) 64 40
August
Discussion
Overwintering in the Blue Mountains poses considerable problems for the
survival of larvae of the monarch butterfly. Whilst cold-cool (0-12°C)
conditions (e.g. June) alone do not appear to drastically threaten survival and
development of larvae, their occurrence in combination with prolonged
exposure to strong winds (e.g. August) produces substantial mortalities. This
mortality may have been caused by a wind chill effect, and/or an inability by
larvae to recolonise host plants after being blown to the ground. Despite cool
conditions, calm and sunny weather in June produced good larval
development and excellent survival. An estimated one third of the
population progressed from second to fourth instar. This was most likely
facilitated by the predominance of sunny days which enabled larvae to
elevate body temperatures substantially, thus accelerating development.
Winter monarch larvae exposed to sunshine under calm conditions can
achieve body temperatures 10-22°C higher than ambient (James 1986).
However, even light winds drastically reduce solar heat gains (May 1979).
The sustained windy conditions during August produced devastating
mortalities and development of survivors was minimal. Even larvae that
pupated successfully in late August-September eventually died, indicating
that irreversible physiological damage was suffered by the larvae.
86 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
The southerly aspect of the garden, despite a certain amount of protection
provided by the nearby mature bushland, undoubtedly contributed towards its
unsuitability as an overwintering site for D. plexippus larvae. It seems likely
that reduction of the chill factor by adequate buffering from strong winds
would allow good overwintering survival of monarch larvae in the Blue
Mountains, provided abundant sunshine was available. Due to air circulation
from lower elevations and tree cover, many lower-mid elevation localities in
the Blue Mountains are relatively frost-free, allowing survival of the frost-
sensitive G. fruticosus. In the Sydney basin, the most successful winter
breeding populations of D. plexippus invariably occur on north facing slopes
(James, unpub. obs.) and such situations would offer the best opportunity for
survival of overwintering larvae in the Blue Mountains.
References
JAMES, D.G. 1979. Observations on two overwintering clusters of Danaus plexippus (L.)
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) in the Sydney area during 1978. Australian Entomological
Magazine 5: 81-85.
JAMES, D.G. 1981. Studies on a winter breeding population of Danaus plexippus (L.)
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) at Spencer, New South Wales. General and Applied Entomology
13: 47-53.
JAMES, D.G. 1986. Thermoregulation in Danaus plexippus (L.) (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae):
Two cool climate adaptations. General and Applied Entomology 18: 43-47.
MAY, M.L. 1979. Insect thermoregulation. Annual Review of Entomology 24: 313-349.
RAWLINS, J.E. and LEDERHOUSE, R.C. 1981. Developmental influences of thermal
behaviour on Monarch caterpillars (Danaus plexippus): an adaptation for migration
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae: Danainae). Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society 54:
387-408.
SMITHERS, C.N. 1965. A note on overwintering in Danaus plexippus (Linnaeus)
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) in Australia. Australian Zoologist 13: 135-136.
SMITHERS, C.N. 1977. Seasonal distribution and breeding status of Danaus plexippus (L.)
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) in Australia. Journal of the Australian Entomological Society 16:
175-184.
ZALUCKI, M.P. 1982. Temperature and rate of development in Danaus plexippus and
D. chrysippus (Nymphalidae). Journal of the Australian Entomological Society 21: 241-246.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 87-90 87
PARASITISM OF ACACICOLA ORPHANA (ERICHSON)
(COLEOPTERA: CHRYSOMELIDAE) IN TASMANIA
Tara L. Simmul' and Anthony R. Clarke?
! Cooperative Research Centre for Sustainable Production Forestry and University of
Tasmania, GPO Box 252-12, Hobart, Tas 7001
? Australian School of Environmental Studies, Nathan Campus, Griffith University, Brisbane,
Qld 4111
Abstract
Parasitism of late-instar Acacicola orphana larvae was assessed at six locations throughout
Tasmania in October 1997. Overall rates of parasitism were very low and only one parasitoid
was collected, a species of Lixophaga Townsend (Diptera: Tachinidae). Only 17 tachinid
pupae were reared from 600 larvae (2.83% parasitism), but the number of larvae initially
observed bearing tachinid eggs was higher (32 larvae, 5.3% parasitism). The emergence rate of
adult tachinids was low, with only four of the 17 pupae (23%) yielding flies. The number of
larvae bearing tachinid eggs between sites ranged from 0-17 and was positively and
significantly correlated with tree damage estimates made at the collection sites during the
previous season.
Introduction
The fireblight beetle, Acacicola (= Pyrgoides) orphana (Erichson), defoliates
the temperate bipinnate acacias Acacia dealbata Link. and A. mearnsii de
Wild (French 1911, Froggatt 1923, McKeown 1942). Defoliation is more
apparent in spring when the winter-developing larvae are in the fourth (final)
instar. Severely affected trees can lose all foliage and larvae chew green bark
from the stems, effectively ring-barking the trees. Repeated severe
defoliation may result in tree death. Although A. dealbata and A. mearnsii
have been identified as having potential for pulp and paper making (Clark et
al. 1994), there is a reluctance to grow these species because of the severe
defoliation caused by A. orphana (D. de Little, pers. comm.).
An understanding of the natural enemies of A. orphana is needed if IPM
systems are to be developed for this insect. Elliott (1978) observed only very
low numbers (6 specimens from ‘a number of collections ... containing
several hundred individuals per collection’) of two tachinid parasitoids,
Deltomyza australiensis (Malloch) and a species of Lixophaga Townsend in
A. orphana populations in the Florentine Valley, south-central Tasmania.
Elliott (1978) noted that A. orphana larvae develop throughout the colder
months of the year and he hypothesised that conditions in his study area were
unfavourable for many predators and parasitoids. In 1997 we conducted a
more extensive Tasmanian survey of A. orphana larval populations, with the
aim of identifying additional parasitoid species and spatial variance in
parasitism rates.
Materials and methods
No parasitism of eggs, first or second instar larvae of A. tria has been
observed (Elliott 1978, T. Simmul, pers. obs.). Therefore, for this study only
88 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
third and fourth instar larvae were collected from six Tasmanian sites on one
occasion each in mid-October, 1997. Site locations were: Lake Leake
(147°38'S, 41°58'E), Buckland 1 (147°44'S 42°39'E), Buckland 2 (147°36'S
42°38'E), Conara (147°27'S 41°50'E), Dromedary (147°06'S 42°46'E) and
Perth (147°09'S 41°35'E). At all sites A. dealbata was the predominant
Acacia species. During October 1996 (the previous season), all sites except
Dromedary were assessed for A. orphana defoliation using a visual scoring
system based on 10 trees per site. To obtain the site score, 10 trees were
scored visually with values ranging from zero, representing no damage, to
five, for complete foliage removal and some bark chewed. The values were
then averaged across the 10 trees and rounded to the nearest whole number.
When cultures were first established, each larva was examined individually
and records made of any tachinid eggs present on the body. One hundred
larvae from each site were maintained in ventilated containers under constant
conditions (17°C + 5°C; 8L, 16D, -66% R.H.). Cultures were cleaned and
fresh foliage was provided three times weakly. At these times any dead
larvae were counted and the apparent cause of death noted. Final counts
were made of the number of adult beetles, number of parasitoid pupae and
the number of adult parasitoids emerging.
The relationship between the number of larvae carrying tachinid eggs and the
defoliation score during the previous season was examined using linear
regression (Excel 6.0).
Results
Only 5.3% of collected A. orphana larvae bore tachinid eggs, with one to
three eggs found per individual. A few tachinids (0.5%) developed in larvae
with no eggs on the cuticle, implying that the eggs had been dislodged after
the tachinid larva eclosed or that the parent fly had oviposited on an earlier
instar host. The tachinid was a larval endoparasitoid, killing the host late in
the final larval or prepupal stage, when the puparium protruded from a split
in the host’s cuticle. Adult flies, identified as Lixophaga sp., emerged after
approximately 10 days. Only one tachinid developed in each host larva.
Parasitised A. orphana larvae did not appear to behave differently from non-
parasitised larvae.
The highest amount of parasitism was at Conara (17% of larvae carrying
eggs), while the lowest was 1% at Perth and Buckland 2. At Perth, no egg
was observed on the larva; however a single tachinid puparium was
observed. No flies were reared from either of these locations (Table 1).
Unidentified mortality in the cultures caused losses of 18-27% (average
24%), some of which may have been caused by parasitoids which
subsequently failed to emerge. From all collections only 17 tachinid pupae
were recorded, from which only four adult flies emerged. No
hyperparasitoids were observed.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 89
A positive relationship (r = 0.96) existed between the site defoliation scores
made in the season prior to the collections and the number of eggs found on
the larvae in 1997.
Table 1. Tree defoliation scores and Acacicola orphana larval parasitism records for
six sites in Tasmania. Initial sample size from each site = 100 larvae. Defoliation
score range: 0 = none; 5 = total defoliation.
Site Site No. of larvae No. of larvae No. of adult
defoliation carrying with a tachinid flies emerging
score tachinid eggs pupa from pupae
Lake Leake 2 2 3 2
Conara 5 17 6 2
Buckland 1 3 8 2 0
Buckland 2 1 1 0 0
Perth 0 0 1 0
Dromedary - 4 5 0
Discussion
In a collection of 600 larvae from six sites, larval parasitism (based on the
presence of tachinid eggs) of A. orphana in Tasmania, averaged across all
sites, was only 5%. Direct mortality attributable to parasitism was around
3%. This parasitism rate seems similar to that obtained by Elliott (1978),
although a direct comparison is difficult because of the way his results are
presented. Unlike Elliott, only one parasitoid species, Lixophaga sp., was
obtained. Although other authors have recorded very low parasitism rates of
paropsine chrysomelids (the group to which A. orphana belongs), tachinid
parasitism rates of species such as Chrysophtharta bimaculata (Olivier) and
Paropsis atomaria Olivier are normally 2-7 fold higher than that recorded for
A. orphana (Tanton and Khan 1978, de Little 1982, Tanton and Epila 1984,
de Little et al. 1990). The reason for the low parasitism obtained may be due
to the winter cycle of A. orphana larvae, as suggested by Elliott (1978), but
this is difficult to test directly. Alternatively, a greater temporal sampling of
larvae may show seasonal cycles in parasitism rates, of which we have only
recorded the low period. Seasonality of tachinid parasitism rates has been
demonstrated for P. atomaria (Tanton and Khan 1978, Tanton and Epila
1984).
If the level of tree defoliation is related to A. orphana population levels, this
may imply delayed density dependence between beetle numbers and parasite
numbers. Obviously the sample size is very low and this needs to be
repeated.
The low parasitism rate, coupled with the low number of adult flies
successfully developing and emerging from A. orphana larvae, suggests that
90 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
this species may be a relatively poor host for Lixophaga sp. More studies on
field parasitism are required to quantify the effect of this parasitoid on
populations of A. orphana.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Mr S. Paterson for technical assistance and
Dr B. Cantrell for identification of the tachinid. Dr D. de Little provided
unpublished information. This work was supported by an Australian
Postgraduate Award (Industry) scholarship partnered by the Tasmania Forest
Research Council, the Australian Research Council and the Cooperative
Research Centre for Sustainable Production Forestry.
References
CLARK, N.B., BALODIS, V., GUIGAN, F. and WANG, J.X. 1994. Pulpwood potential of
Acacias. Pp 196-202, in BROWN, A.G. (ed.), Australian tree species research in China.
ACIAR, Canberra; 226 pp.
de LITTLE, D.W. 1982. Field parasitization of larval populations of the Eucalyptus-defoliating
leaf-beetle, Chrysophtharta bimaculata (Olivier) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). General and
Applied Entomology 14: 3-6.
de LITTLE, D.W., ELLIOTT, H.J., MADDEN, J.L. and BASHFORD, R. 1990. Stage-specific
mortality in two field populations of immature Chrysophtharta bimaculata (Olivier)
(Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). Journal of the Australian Entomological Society 29: 51-55.
ELLIOTT, H.J. 1978. Studies on the fireblight beetle, Pyrgoides orphana (Erichson)
(Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) and its effect on the growth of silver wattle in Tasmania.
Australian Forestry 41: 160-166.
FRENCH, C. 1911. Handbook of the destructive insects of Victoria. Part V. Government
Printer, Melbourne; 169 pp.
FROGGATT, W.W. 1923. Forest insects of Australia. Government Printer, Sydney; 171 pp.
McKEOWN, K.C. 1942. Australian insects. Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales,
Sydney; 304 pp.
TANTON, M.T. and EPILA, J.S.O. 1984. Parasitization of larvae of Paropsis atomaria Ol.
(Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) in the Australian Capital Territory. Australian Journal of
Zoology 32: 251-259.
TANTON, M.T. and KHAN, S.M. 1978. Aspects of the biology of the eucalyptus-defoliating
chrysomelid beetle Paropsis atomaria Ol. in the Australian Capital Territory. Australian
Journal of Zoology 26: 113-120.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3): 91-95 91
A NEW GENUS AND SPECIES OF HAWK MOTH (LEPIDOPTERA:
SPHINGIDAE) FROM PAPUA NEW GUINEA
R.B. LACHLAN
Entomology Department, Australian Museum, 6 College Street, Sydney, NSW 2000
Abstract
Altijuba oktediensis gen. et sp. nov. is described from a single female from Tabubil, Western
Province, Papua New Guinea.
Introduction
An undescribed genus and species of hawk moth was collected at Tabubil in
the mountains of Western Province, Papua New Guinea, in May 1993. This
new taxon is distinct from all genera previously recorded from Papua New
Guinea and West Irian.
Altijuba gen. nov.
(Figs 1-3)
Type species. Altijuba oktediensis sp. nov.
Description. Antenna short, filiform except for terminal segments which
gradually taper; weakly hooked. Eyes small in relation to overall size. Palps
not large but erect, closely appressed to head. Head and thorax with distinct
medial scale crest. Abdomen very short and stout, tapering abruptly.
Middle tibia with one pair and hind tibia with two pairs of small spurs. Hind
legs short. Coxae densely covered with long hair scales. Fore femur covered
by shorter, flattened scales. Hind femur with distinctive thin crest of long
scales on ventral surface. Distal half of tibia with triangular shaped crest of
long scales on dorsal surface. All legs narrow and of thread-like appearance.
Forewing costa straight with apex of wing falcate; termen almost straight
from R, to M,, serrate and angled inwards from M, to tornus; distal edge of
inner margin at tornus bluntly tooth-like; two prominent cream stigmata
visible on upperside at end of discal cell, one above the other; only one
prominent stigmata visible on underside. Hindwing with apex rounded to Rs
vein; termen slanting inwards but almost straight from Rs to M,, then serrate
to 1A+2A; tornus with tooth-like projection.
Etymology. The generic name Altijuba is derived from the Latin words
‘altus’ meaning high and ‘juba’ meaning mane or crest.
Altijuba oktediensis sp. nov.
(Figs 1-3)
Type. Holotype 9, PAPUA NEW GUINEA: Tabubil, Western Province,
5°15'S 141°13'E, 650 m, 11.v.1993, R.B. Lachlan. Holotype in Australian
National Insect Collection, CSIRO, Canberra.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
92
Figs 1-2. Altijuba oktediensis gen. et sp. nov., holotype female. ( 1) upperside, legs
reset for examination; (2) underside.
Description. Female (Figs 1-3). Forewing length 41 mm. Antenna light
brown and filiform. Palpi grey-brown above, contrasting orange-brown
below. Small cream spot below and slightly forward of each eye. Head,
thorax and abdomen uniform grey-brown on upper surface. Head and thorax
with dark brown, longitudinal, medial crest. Underside of thorax with dense,
orange-brown pilosity. Single, dark brown, transverse line on posterior edge
of upperside of third abdominal segment. Proximal end of all tibiae with
cream spot on dorsal surface. Underside of abdomen orange-brown with
distinct sheen and three thin, disconnected, brown longitudinal medial lines;
each segment with mauve and brown posterior edge.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 93
Fig. 3. Altijuba oktediensis gen. et sp. nov., holotype female at rest.
Forewing upperside pattern as in Fig. 1; ground colour dark brown with
lighter markings. Dark brown apical band. Thin, dark brown, postmedian
line pointed outwards along veins R, to M, and 1A+2A. Two dark brown
lines beginning at submedian and postmedian areas of costa, curving inwards
and joining at inner margin one third of length from base and enclosing a
dark, triangular patch. Two prominent cream stigmata, one above the other,
at end of discal cell. Three simple brown fasciae between subbasal and
submedian areas. Underside with single, strongly visible stigma. Basal and
subcostal areas grey-brown. Postmedian area lighter brown. Single thin
brown median band from R, curving inwardly to CuA,. Single serrate, thin
brown postmedian line from R, to CuA,. Subapical area dark brown with
diffuse black and orange scaling. Light mauve subterminal band, straight to
M,, inner edge of band serrate proximally above veins CuA,, CuA, and
1A+2A.
Hindwing upperside with dark brown ground colour. Thin, orange-brown
apical and terminal band to M,. Dark, pink-brown band with thin black
anterior and posterior lines from just above vein CuA, to inner margin above
tornus distally. Underside with ground colour orange-brown, pink basally.
Dark grey along costa, lighter grey in anal area tending light brown towards
tornus. Small faint stigma at end of cell. One straight, thin, dark brown
transverse median line from vein Sc+R, to CuA,. Two thin, faint, serrate,
parallel postmedian lines terminating above tornus. Broad mauve terminal
band from apex to vein CuA,, serrate proximally between veins M, and
CuA..
94 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
Male. Unknown.
Distribution. Western Province, Papua New Guinea.
Etymology. The specific name oktediensis is derived from the Ok Tedi river,
which flows past the mining town of Tabubil, the only known locality for the
species.
Discussion i
As the only known specimen is a female, the genitalia have not been
examined. External characters have been used to characterize the genus and
to determine where it probably belongs. When males become available the
genitalia will provide further clues as to its placement. Neither Mackey
(1975) nor D’Abrera [1987] illustrated any species that closely resemble this
specimen. It was first noted as an unidentified species by Moulds and
Lachlan (1998). The forewing shape resembles Eurypteryx Felder and
Gehlenia Bryk but is more serrate. The hindwing shape also has some
resemblance to E. falcata Gehlen but is also more serrate. The two stigmata
on the forewing upperside of A. oktediensis are a prominent feature and are
also found, to a lesser degree, on E. shelfordi Rothschild & Jordan.
However, no species of Eurypteryx has the orange-brown underside to the
hindwings and abdomen seen on the new species. Also, Altijuba has very
small eyes and short palps which do not project as they do in Eurypteryx and
Acosmeryx Boisduval.
Dr Ian Kitching (personal communication) has examined photographs of the
holotype and is of the opinion that the new genus is probably closely related
to Eurypteryx and may well be somewhat sexually dimorphic, with the male
being more uniform in colour and with smaller stigmata. A distinctive
feature of this new species is the unusually short, stout abdomen, similar to
the African sphingid Dovania poecila Rothschild & Jordan. The vast
majority of world Sphingidae have a much longer abdomen in both sexes.
The crest on the head and thorax of Altijuba is similar to that in Gehlenia.
The orange-brown underside of the hindwing is also common to some
Acosmeryx species but Altijuba differs from these in the shape of both wings.
The leg scaling is another distinctive feature of Altijuba.
This new species has a number of characters found in several different genera
as well as its own distinctive features. It cannot be placed in a currently
described genus and is therefore placed in a new genus on its own.
Despite over three years of comprehensive collecting between 1991-93 and
in March-April 1994, at several sites in and around the Tabubil region, only a
single specimen of this species was collected. During this time thousands of
specimens, covering 66 species and 20 genera, were either sighted, examined
or collected (Moulds and Lachlan 1998). Dr Kitching has suggested that if
Altijuba is related to Eurypteryx this may explain its rarity as it is well known
that Eurypteryx species do not readily come to light.
Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3) 95
Acknowledgments
For advice and helpful comments on the manuscript I sincerely thank Mr Ted
Edwards (Australian National Insect Collection, CSIRO, Canberra) and Dr
Ian Kitching (The Natural History Museum, London). I am most grateful to
Ok Tedi Mining Ltd for their field support, especially to former managers of
the environment section, Murray Eagle and Ian Wood, and to Robert
Murphy, Chief Geologist. Without their support and permission to access
collecting sites this work would not have been possible. I would also like to
thank my wife, Deborah Lachlan, for typing the manuscript.
References
D’ABRERA, B. [1987]. Sphingidae Mundi, hawk moths of the world. Based on a checklist by
Alan Hayes and the collection he curated in the British Museum (Natural History). E.W.
Classey, Faringdon; ix+226 pp.
MACKEY, A.P. 1975. Hawk moths of Port Moresby. Occasional Papers of the Biology
Department, University of Papua New Guinea 4: 1-20.
MOULDS, M.S. and LACHLAN, R.B. 1998. An annotated list of the hawk moths
(Lepidoptera: Sphingidae) of Western Province, Papua New Guinea. Australian Entomologist
25(2): 45-60.
96 Australian Entomologist, 1999, 26 (3)
BACK ISSUES OF AUSTRALIAN ENTOMOLOGIST.
AUS$3 per volume or AUS$1 per issue, incl. postage. Stocks of some issues
are in short supply. Parts in parenthisis comprise one issue. * includes beetle
fascicle. Orders to Grég Daniels, Dept of Zoology & Entomology, University
of Quensland, Brisbane, Qld, 4072. 07 3365 7084. g.daniels @ento.uq.edu.au
ara
CI
ZEEE]
E]
EECH
C
ENTOMOLOGICAL NOTICES
Items for insertion should be sent to the editor who reserves the right to alter, reject or
charge for notices.
FOR SALE: Butterflies from all parts of the world. Papua New Guinea,
Peru, Indonesia, Thailand, China, Africa, Brazil, Colombia, etc.
Papilionidae inc. Parnassius, Delias, Charaxes etc. Free catalogue. David
Hall, 6 Rule St, Cambridge Park, N.S.W., 2747. Ph. 02 4731 2410.
ENTOMOLOGICAL BOOKS. Pemberley Books are specialist suppliers of
entomological literature across the world. Send for our free catalogue
which lists a wide range of antiquarian, second-hand and new natural
history titles. Pemberley Books, Ian Johnson, 34 Melrose Close, Hayes,
Middlesex, UB4 0AZ, England. Tel/Fax: +44 181 561 5494. E-mail:
ij@pembooks.demon.co.uk
WANTED. Any information regarding Rhytiphora macleayi (Coleoptera:
Cerambycidae), particularly from private collections. Mark Hura, 111
Oleander Drive, Parafield Gardens, S.A., 5107.
NOTES FOR AUTHORS
Manuscripts submitted for publication should, preferably, be type-written, double spaced and
in triplicate. Refer to recent issues for layout and style.
All papers will be forwarded to two referees and the editor reserves the right to reject any
paper considered unsuitable.
Papers longer than eight printed journal pages will normally not be accepted.
Papers will be accepted only if a minimum of 100 reprints is purchased. Manuscripts
occupying less than one printed page may be accepted without charge if no reprints are
required. Charges are as follows: cost per printed page $25 for 100 copies. Page charges
may be reduced at the discretion of the Publications Committee.
Illustrations: Both colour and B & W photographs must be submitted at the size they are to
appear in the journal. Line drawings should be about twice their required size.
Address papers to: The Editor
The Australian Entomologist
P.O. Box 537,
Indooroopilly, Queensland, 4068
Printed by Hans Quality Print, 20 Lyons Terrace, Windsor, Qld, 4030
THE AUSTRALIAN
Entomologist
Volume 26, Part 3, 10 December 1999
CONTENTS
AUSTIN, A.D.
Use of Odonata as prey by sand wasps, Bembix spp. (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae).
JAMES, D.G.
A note on unsuccessful overwintering of larvae of Danaus plexippus (L.)
(Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) in the Blue Mountains, New South Wales.
LACHLAN, R.B.
A new genus and species of hawk moth (Lepidoptera: Sphingidae) from Papua
New Guinea.
MULLER, CJ.
A new species of Leuciacria Rothschild & Jordan (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) from
montane New Ireland, Papua New Guinea.
ORR, AG.
Possible postcopulatory mate guarding in Ornithoptera euphorion (Gray)
(Lepidoptera: Papilionidae).
SIMMUL, T..L. and CLARKE, A.R.
Parasitism of Acacicola orphana (Erichson) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) in
Tasmania
77
83
91
65
87
ENTOMOLOGICAL NOTICES Inside back cover.
ISSN 1320 6133
COR