11
Biodiversity
www.biodiversityjournaI.com
journal
ISSN 2039-0394 (Print Edition)
ISSN 2039-0408 (Online Edition)
JUNE 2013, 4 (2): 261-384
with the support of
o o
FOR NATURALISTIC RESEARCH
y
AND ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES
Alcides privitera Vinciguerra, 2006 - So rong, Indonesia
The genus Alcides Hlibner, [ 1 822 1 (Lepidoptera Uraniidae). The Family Uraniidae contains some of the most beautiful moths known to
lepidoptcrists. It includes four subfamilies (Auzcinac, Epipleminae, Microniinae and Uraniinac), some ninety genera and about seven hundred species.
This is a tropical family which is found in Africa, the Americas, and the Indo-Australian region. Diurnal and nocturnal species are found within this
family and the day-flying ones are usually vibrantly colored and covered with iridescent scales and tails which have led many to mistake them for
butterflies. Several species are known to be migratory, but very little is known about the details of these migrations. One of these species was once
considered by the French lepidopterist Jean Baptiste Antoine Dechauffor de Boisduval (1799-1879) as the most beautiful of the creation.” The
subfamily Uraniinae contains seven genera. Three of them include species of moderate size and with resemblance to those in the Microniinae, while the
other four include large and strongly tailed species. Their hosts include plants belonging to the Euphorbiaceae and it appears that some of these moths
are models for certain species of some butterfly families. Among the Uraniinae we find the swallow tail moths of the genus Alcides Hubner, which are
brightly colored and probably distasteful to birds and other potential predators. Alcides is distributed in the Indo-Australian region and contains ten
species. Most fly by day but some have also been reported with crepuscular activity. Their larvae feed on leaves of plants in the genera Endospermum
and Omphalea which carry certain poisons that appear to protect the caterpillars, and eventually the adults, from predation. The caterpillars pupate in a
sparse cocoon in crevices or between dead leaves. The imagoes are characterized by front wings of triangular shape with a large, curved band that starts
in the Costal margin, crosses the discal area, and ends in the anal angle. A second, parallel, thinner band, is also observed in the apical angle of the wing
and starts also in the costal margin (without touching it), and goes to the anal angle, but vanishes before reaching it. The colors in both bands are always
iridescent green or blue. The hind wings have a wide band in the discal area, and when the wings are spread it looks like a continuation of the large band
in the forewing. This band also presents iridescent colors. All species in the genus present short tails in the hind wings. The current systematic
knowledge and taxonomy of the genus is incomplete and the status of some taxa remains uncertain. Even though ten species have been described so far,
the systematics of the group is still somehow uncertain. They are knowm from localities in Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, and the Moluccas, New'
Hebrides and Salomon Islands. However, the only exception to this distribution, the species Alcides met a unis (Hopffer) [=A. zodiaca (Butler)], is
endemic of Queensland, Northern Australia. The illustrated specimen is the Holotype of Alcides privitera Vincigucrra, This is a beautiful species
somehow similar to A. metaums but has been found in Sarong, Irian Jaya, Indonesia.
Jorge M. Gonzalez, California State University, Fresno, Department of Plant Sciences, Fresno, CA 93740-8033 (Research Associate, McGuire Center
for Lepidoptera & Biodiversity), USA; e-mail: gonzalez.jorge.m@gmail.com
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 263-268
Description of a new species of Amphidromus Albers, 1 850
from Sumba, Indonesia (Gastropoda Pulmonata Camaenidae)
David P. Cilia
29, Triq il-Palazz 1-Ahmar, Santa Venera, Malta; e-mail: (dpcilia@gmail.com)
ABSTRACT The camaenid Amphidromus ( Syndromus ) iunior n. sp. from an isolated forest in the east
of Sumba island in the Indonesian archipelago is described. Its closest named relative is
Amphidromus (, Syndromus ) abbasi Chan et Tan, 2010, and some conchological features are
common for both species. However, the new species is smaller, with consistent differences
in shell thickness, pattern and pigmentation.
KEY WORDS Camaenidae; Amphidromus iunior n. sp.; Sumba; Indonesia.
Received 16.01.2013; accepted 14.04.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
The polyphyletic family Camaenidae Pilsbry,
1895 (Scott, 1996) is distributed in three distinct
clades (Wade et al., 2007), geographically separated
mainly by the Pacific Ocean. Synapomorphies
amongst the members of the different clades are ab-
sent, and the family is characterized by the absence of
vaginal accessory organs found in other members of
the otherwise monophyletic Helicoidea Rafinesque,
1815 (Wade at al., 2006). According to molecular
techniques employed by Wade et al. (2007), the Aus-
tralasian fraction of this family was found to be syn-
onymous with Bradybaenidae Pilsbry, 1934.
Amongst the most speciose genera in this Aus-
tralasian clade is the arboreal Amphidromus Albers,
1850. Extending over a wide geographical area
from India to Australia (Laidlaw & Solem, 1961;
Solem, 1983), it is divided into two or three sub-
genera historically differentiated mostly through
conchological characteristics. Of these, the sub-
genus Syndromus Pilsbry, 1900 (comprising the
newly described species discussed herein) consists
of animals with small shells (20-40 mm high, 10-
25 mm wide) and a short epiphallic caecum, which
according to Lok & Tan (2008) includes one dex-
tral, one enantiomorphic, and 44 sinistral taxa. New
species have recently been assigned to this subgenus
by Sevems (2006), Dharma (2007) and Chan & Tan
(2010), though Scucharit & Panha (2006) shed doubt
on the taxon’s monophyly. A new species of Syndro-
mus collected on east Sumba is described herein.
ABBREVIATIONS. Depositories: BP = collec-
tion of Bama Pall-Gergely, Mosonmagyarovar, Hun-
gary; DC = collection of David P. Cilia, Santa
Venera, Malta; FMNH = Field Museum of Natural
History, Chicago, Illinois; HUJ = Hebrew University
of Jerusalem, Israel; JA = collection of John Abbas,
Jakarta, Indonesia; MNHN = Museum National
d'histoire Naturelle, Paris, France; NHMUK = Natu-
ral History Museum, Fondon, United Kingdom;
NMNH = National Museum of Natural History,
Mdina, Malta; TAU = Zoological Department of Tel
Aviv University, Israel. Morphology and anatomy:
D = diameter; H = height; H/D = height to diameter
ratio; min. = minimum value; med. = median value;
max. = maximum value.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The mean value of two readings for height (in-
264
David P. Cilia
eluding the reflected peristome), width (including the
reflected peristome) and oblique apertural height for
a random selection of 2 1 adult specimens was taken
using a dial caliper of a resolution of 50 jam. Results
were rounded off to the nearest 0. 1mm. Whorls were
counted, including the nucleus. Statistical data was
formulated and used together with peculiar morpho-
logical characteristics to differentiate the new species
from similar ones, most significant of which is the
geographically and phylogenetically close A abbasi
Chan et Tan, 2010. Topotypical adult shells of the lat-
ter were similarly measured and morphometrically
compared to those of the new species. Systematics
in the present paper follow Bouchet & Rocroi (2005).
SYSTEMATICS
Superfamily Helicoidea Rafmesque, 1815
Family Camaenidae Pilsbry, 1895
Subfamily Camaeninae Pilsbry, 1895
Genus Amphidromus Albers, 1850
Subgenus Syndromus Pilsbry, 1900
Type species Helix contraria Muller, 1774
Amphidromus ( Syndromus ) iunior n. sp.
Examined material. Holotype: small forest
close to Mangili village, east part of Sumba Island,
East Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia (-10°05'32"N,
120°42'08"E), at an altitude of about 560 m above
sea level, leg. JA: MNHN 23265. Paratypes (20
specimens): same data as holotype: DC RG217 (3);
HUJ 53490 (2); JA unreg. (3); MNHN 23266 (2);
FMNH 328102 (2); TAU 75175 (1); NHMUK
20120044 (3); NMNH unreg. (2); BP unreg. (2).
Description of holotype (Figs. 1-6). Sinistral,
conical, thin, smooth, glossy and translucent shell,
14 mm wide and 28 mm tall. Dull yellow base
colour intensifying towards the ultimate whorl, with
brown markings in the form of two well-defined
subperipheral spiral striae, faint subordinate ones,
and blurred spaced vertical columns featuring a re-
duction in their colour intensity and frequency to-
wards the final whorl. These columns are
interrupted halfway through by a perpendicularly
crossing spiral band lacking in pigment, another of
which is present just beneath the suture. Nucleus
dark purple-brown, its colour descending and fad-
ing out along the apical whorl just above the suture,
appearing in top view as a dark spiral over the pale
base. The number of the moderately convex whorls
is between six and seven, the final of which is
smoothly rounded. Aperture is vertically elongated
and teardrop-shaped, its height constituting about
40% of the shell’s total. Peristome fragile and ex-
panded, only thickened and reflected at its columel-
lar side. The reflected segment is not completely
fused to the base of the ultimate whorl, in most
cases leaving an obliquely oriented pinhole um-
bilicus. Internal aspect glossy, with the brown mark-
ings showing through.
Variability. The width varies from 1 3 to 1 6 mm
and the height from 23 to 34 mm (Figs. 8-22; Table
1). Whereas the subperipheral spiral striae are al-
ways present, very brief interruptions occasionally
occur. Additional spiral striae may unusually take
the form of parallel brown dashes that also coincide
in a perpendicular direction, forming columns.
Etymology. The species is named for the
youngest son of John Abbas, who encountered this
hitherto unrecorded species during one of his
expeditions. Another species of Amphidromus
named for John, A. (S.) abbasi, is closely related to
this species, but is significantly larger, amongst
other differences. The meaning of iunior therefore
takes on another meaning, referring to the relative
size of the snail (iunior is the comparative form of
iuvenis, meaning young in Latin).
Distribution. Only known from the type locality.
Comparative notes. Two Syndromus (sensu
lato) lineages are represented on the volcanic is-
land of Sumba (Laidlaw & Solem, 1961; Chan &
Tan, 2008, 2010). One lineage is represented by
the A (S.) latestrigatus Schepman, 1892 complex,
including A. (S.) latestrigatus sumbaensis Fulton,
1896 and A. (S.) floresianus Fulton, 1897. The
other lineage has only recently been discovered,
with the first species described being A. (S.) ab-
basi (see Chan & Tan, 2008: p. 9, figs. 1.1 -1.6;
2010: p. 247, figs. 1A-C). The new species, a sec-
ond addition to this latter lineage, is currently only
known from a patch of forest close to Mangili in
eastern Sumba which lies on a Pleistocene lime-
stone platform, and as such it is reproductively
separated from A abbasi, which is located at Lan-
ggaliru, about 122km in a northwesterly direction,
in another isolated forest patch, here on a late Cre-
taceous formation of sedimentary and volcanic
origin (Lytwyn et al., 2001).
Description of a new species of Amphidromus from Sumba, Indonesia (Gastropoda Pulmonata Camaenidae) 265
Figures 1-6. Shells of Amphidromus iunior n. sp., small forest close to Mangili village, east part of Sumba island, East Nusa
Tenggara, Indonesia - holotype. Figure 7. Map of Sumba showing the type localities of A. iunior n. sp. (Mangili, marked
with a white square) and of A. abbasi (Langgaliru, marked with a white circle). Inset map shows the Indonesian archipelago.
266
David P. Cilia
Figures 8-22. Shells of Amphidromus iunior n. sp., small forest close to Mangili village, east part of Sumba island, East Nusa
Tenggara, Indonesia. Figs. 8-12: paratype (FMNH 328102). Figs. 13-17: paratype (NHMUK 20120044). Figs. 18-22: paratype
(DCRG217).
Description of a new species of Amphidromus from Sumba, Indonesia (Gastropoda Pulmonata Camaenidae) 267
Figures 23-32. Shells of Amphidromus abbasi, forest in Langgalira, southwest part of Sumba island, East Nusa Tenggara, Indo-
nesia (-09°45'44"N, 119°38'33"E) (DC RGA698).
H (mm)
D (mm)
H/D
mean
min.
med.
max.
mean
min.
med.
max.
A. iunior n. sp. holotype
27.65
NA
NA
NA
14.25
NA
NA
NA
1.94
A. iunior n. sp. type series
27.70
23.30
27.65
33.80
14.31
12.65
14.25
15.75
1.93
A. abbasi topotype
37.78
35.60
38.00
39.50
18.86
18.00
18.95
19.65
2.01
Table 1. Condensed data for shell measurements of the type series of A. iuniorn. sp. (21 specimens) and a topotypical sample
of A. abbasi (6 specimens - DC R.GA698) for comparison. All measurements are in mm.
268
David P. Cilia
A number of morphological characteristics are
valuable in differentiating between the two species.
A. abbasi is larger, with its smallest specimens
exceeding by about 2mm in width and in height the
largest A. innior n. sp. specimens encountered (Table
1). The degree of conchological intraspecific vari-
ability in A. abbasi significantly exceeds that of the
A. iunior n. sp. population. It is also thicker-shelled,
reaching a degree of opacity lacking in A. iunior n.
sp. (Figs. 23-32). The two subperipheral brown spiral
bands may be extremely faint or absent in A. abbasi ,
and considerable variation in base colour occurs in
the topotypic population, with a spectrum ranging
from pink to yellow-brown, whereas this is never the
case for A. iunior n. sp. The columnar markings in the
former are frequently resolved to a series of dashes,
in the latter they are generally fused and continuous,
apart from the one main perpendicular interruption
through which the yellowish base colour appears. The
peristome of A. abbasi is more strongly reinforced
and its degree of fusion at the columellar side is rarely
incomplete; in A. iunior n. sp., the umbilical zone is
always narrowly perforated (closed in A. abbasi ). Pig-
mentation of the nucleus, a feature of significant di-
agnostic value amongst Nusa Tenggara Syndromus,
according to Goldberg & Sevems (1997), is always
restricted to a spot in A. abbasi, varying between
pinkish and brown, while in A. iunior n. sp. it is
always dark, descending and diminishing gradually
along the first whorl in proximity of the suture.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author would like to thank John Abbas
(Jakarta, Indonesia), for making the specimens
available for study, Fred Naggs and Jonathan Ablett
(NHMUK), Jochen Gerber (FMNH), Philippe Bou-
chet and Virginie Heros (MNHN), John J. Borg
(NMHM), and Henk Mienis (HUJ) for technical
assistance, Fabio Liberto and Salvatore Giglio
(Cefalu, Italy) for photography and plate layout,
and anonymous reviewers for their suggestions.
REFERENCES
Bouchet P. & Rocroi J.-P., 2005. Classification and nomen-
clator of gastropod families. Malacologia, 47: 1-397.
Chan S.Y. & Tan S.K., 2008. On a new species of Am-
phidromus {Syndromus) (Gastropoda: Pulmonata:
Camaenidae) from Sumba Island, Indonesia. Occa-
sional Molluscan Papers, 1: 6-10.
Chan S.Y. & Tan S.K., 2010. On two new species of Am-
phidromus (Gastropoda: Camaenidae) from the Les-
ser Sunda Islands, Indonesia. The Raffles Bullettin of
Zoology, 58: 245-249.
Dharma B., 2007. Report on fossil Amphidromus and de-
scription of new species and subspecies of recent and
fossil Amphidromus from Indonesia (Gastropoda,
Pulmonata: Camaenidae). Schriften zur Malakozoo-
logie, 23: 45-78 + pis. 9-14.
Goldberg R.L. & Severns M., 1997. Isolation and evolu-
tion of the Amphidromus in Nusa Tenggara. Ameri-
can Conchologist, 25: 3-7.
Laidlaw F.F. & Solem A., 1961. The land snail genus Am-
phidromus-. a synoptic catalogue. Fieldiana (Zo-
ology), 41: 507-677.
Lok A.F.S.L. & Tan S.K., 2008. A review of the Singa-
pore status of the green tree snail, Amphidromus atri-
callosus perakensis Fulton, 1901 and its biology.
Nature in Singapore, 1: 225-230.
Lytwyn J., Rutherford E., Burke K. & Xia C. 2001. The
geochemistry of volcanic, plutonic and turbiditic
rocks from Sumba, Indonesia. Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, 19: 481-500.
Scott B., 1996. Phylogenetic relationships of the Camae-
nidae (Pulmonata: Stylommatophora: Helicoidea).
Journal of Molluscan Studies, 62: 65-74.
Severns M., 2006. A new species and a new subspecies
of Amphidromus from Atauro Island, East Timor
(Gastropoda, Pulmonata, Camaenidae). Basteria, 70:
23-28.
Solem A., 1983. First record of Amphidromus from Aus-
tralia, with anatomical notes on several species (Mol-
lusca: Pulmonata: Camaenidae). Records of the
Australian Museum, 35: 153-166.
Sutcharit C. & Panha S., 2006. Taxonomic review of the
tree snail Amphidromus Albers, 1850 (Pulmonata:
Camaenidae) in Thailand and adjacent areas: Sub-
genus Amphidromus. Journal of Molluscan Studies,
72: 1-30.
Wade C.M., Hudelot C., Davison A., Naggs F. & Mordan
P.B., 2007. Molecular phylogeny of the helicoid land
snails (Pulmonata: Stylommatophora: Helicoidea),
with special emphasis on the Camaenidae. Journal of
Molluscan Studies, 73: 411-415.
Wade C.M., Mordan PB. & Naggs F., 2006. Evolutionary
relationships among the Pulmonate land snails and
slugs (Pulmonata, Stylommatophora). Biological
Journal of the Linnean Society, 87: 593-610.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 269-274
Reproductive cycle of the European anchovy Engraulis encra-
sicolus (Linnaeus, 1 758) (Clupeiformes Engraulidae) in the gulf
of Skikda (Algerian East coasts)
L/amine Mezedjri 1 *, Ahmed Kerfouf 2 &AliTahar 3
'Departement SNV, Faculte des sciences, Universite du 20 aout 55, Skikda 21000, Algerie; email: mezedjri.lyamine@gmail.com
2 Laboratoire d’ecodeveloppement des espaces, departement des sciences de l’environnement, faculte des sciences, universite Djillali
Liabes, Sidi Bel-Abbes 22000, Algerie; email: kerfoufalnned@yahoo.fr
3 Laboratoire de biologie vegetale et environnement, departement de biologie, Faculte des sciences, Universite Badji Mokhtar, An-
naba 23000, Algerie; email: prjahar _ali@hotmail.com
’Corresponding author
ABSTRACT A study on the sexual cycle of the European anchovy, the pelagic fish Engraulis encrasicolus
(Linnaeus, 1758) (Clupeiformes Engraulidae), was carried out in Algerian East coasts over
a year (July 2008-June 2009). Annual sex-ratio (SR) showed that females dominate with an
average male sex-ratio of 39.35%. The European anchovy spawning period ranges from April
to October with peaks in the warmest months, strictly dependent on temperature. The go-
nado-somatic index was updated monthly which allowed us to divide the entire cycle into
four successive phases: (i) a phase of slow maturation which occurs between the end of winter
and the beginning of spring; (ii) a phase of significant sexual activity; (iii) a phase of emission
of the sexual products which corresponds to the warmest months; and, finally, (iv) a phase of
sexual rest occurring in the coldest months. Monthly variation of either hepato-somatic index
or mesenteric fat reserves informed us about the origin of the energetic deposits, particularly
important for the development of the gonads. In both sexes, the first sexual maturity is reached
at a fish total length (Lt) of 12.5 cm.
KEY WORDS Algerian East-coasts; Engraulis encrasicolus', reproduction; sex-ratio; first sexual maturity.
Received 16.02.2013; accepted 14.05.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Reproduction and sexual behaviour of the Euro-
pean anchovy Engraulis encrasicolus (Linnaeus,
1758) (Clupeiformes Engraulidae) were the subject
of many studies focusing on the connection between
these items and food behaviour, plumpness of fishes
and ecological factors in natural populations of this
species (Fage, 1911, 1920; Dorel, 1986; Hemida,
1987; Whitehead et al., 1988; Djabali & Hamida,
1989; Pertierra, 1992; Prouzet & Metuzals-Sebedio,
1994; E.R.H., 1996; Kara, 2001; Mezedjri & Tahar,
2005, 2006; Kada et al., 2009). This work brings new
information on the reproduction of E. encrasicolus
in the Gulf of Stora, Skikda (Algerian East coasts).
Sex-ratio, gonado-somatic and hepato-somatic in-
dexes, adiposity and size at first sexual maturity were
studied. Obtained results were compared with those
reported in literature for several Mediterranean areas.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was carried out on fishes caught by
means of sliding seines in the Gulf of Stora (Alge-
270
L. Mezedjri.A. Kerfouf & A.Tahar
ria) during one year, from July 2008 to June 2009.
Just with the unloading, a sample of 1 kg at mini-
mum was taken at the port of Stora, monthly. On
each fish a series of measures were made (Table
1) including length, by using an ichthyio-meter
with meadows millimetre; total and eviscerated
weights, by means of a balance with an accuracy
of 0.01 g; and gonadic and hepatic weights to the
nearest 0.0001 g.
Determination of maturity stages was carried
out according to the method recommended by the
ERJJ team (E.R.H., 1996), in particular, by taking
into account the degree of fattening of each spec-
imen according to an empirical four degree-scale
which is a derivative of the scale of Nikolsky
(1963). In literature there is a divergence on the for-
mula for the sex-ratio. In our work we used the for-
mula which gives sex-ratio as a percentage of males
by the following relation: SR= (Males Number/Total
Number)xl00. Then, the chi-squared (x 2 ) test was
used to evaluate the variation of the observed values
of the sex-ratio compared to the theoretical propor-
tion of 50% (Dagnelie, 2006). We supposed as hy-
pothesis H 0 : sex-ratio = 50% and tested this
hypothesis by calculating the value of x 2 obs by the
formula:
X 2 = (nr / F) + (f~ / F ) - n
where, m: number of males; f: number of fe-
males; n = m + f; F = n/2. When x 2 0 b s > T\-a at ^
degree of freedom we rejected the hypothesis H 0 at
the level a = 0.05. Please note that this test is valid
only for number of males or females higher than 5
(Dagnelie, 2006). The gonado-somatic index (GSI)
N°
CODE
DESCRIPTION
1
Lt
Total length
2
Wt
Total Weight
3
We
Eviscerated Weight
4
Wgon
Gonadic Weight
5
Whep
Hepatic Weight
6
Adip
Adiposity
7
Sex
Identification of sex and stage of ma-
turity
Table 1 . Measures made on fishes for the reproduction survey.
is an index expressed in percentage. It is calculated
starting from the relationship between the weight
of the gonads (Wgon) and the eviscerated weight of
fish (We). We preferred to use the weight of emp-
tied specimens in the place of the total weight to
eliminate the variations due to the repletion state of
the stomach. The GSI is calculated for each indi-
vidual according to the following formula (Kara,
1997): GSI=(Wgon/We) x 100. GSI values reflect
changes in gonads weight during the reproductive
cycle, thus making us possible to monitor their
maturation (Barnabe, 1976). The hepato-somatic
index (HSI) is expressed in percentage as well. This
relationship links the hepatic weight (Whep) and
the eviscerated weight (We) according to the follow-
ing formula (Kara, 1997): HSI= (Whep/We) x 100.
Its changes are connected to the variations of he-
patic weight during the reproductive cycle. Monthly
variations of adiposity (Adip), i.e. the mesenteric
fat, were followed during the entire period (July
2008-June 2009). All the specimens caught during
the reproduction period (from April to October)
were distributed, according to their size, in classes
of sizes with an interval of 0.5 cm. Then, we took
in consideration the frequency of the mature indi-
viduals in relation to the total number of specimens
belonging to each class. Size at first sexual maturity
is determined as the size of 50% of the mature in-
dividuals (Barnabe, 1976; Kara, 1997). This para-
meter is calculated separately for each sex, and then
the two sexes are compared. All calculations have
been executed with the software MINITAB for
analysis and statistical treatment of the data, version
16 for Windows (2010).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Sex-ratio
On a whole of 803 examined individuals, we ob-
served 316 males and 487 females with an average
male sex-ratio of 39.35% (x 2 = 36.41; P<0.001).
Monthly variations of sex-ratio are shown in Table
2. Broadly speaking, the sex-ratio was always in
favour of females (with a male SR ranging from
18.42% to 35.62%, 0<P<0.05) except during Sep-
tember, when we noted a value of sex-ratio in favour
of males (SR=7 1 .96%, P<0.001). SR values assessed
in October 2008 and March 2009 (56.30% and 40%,
Reproductive cycle of the European anchovy Engraulis encrasicolus in the gulf of Skikda (Algerian East coasts) 271
respectively) were not statistically significant. Fe-
males remained dominant for 7 months, particularly
during the warmest ones (from April to August),
when the anchovies come closer to the Algerian co-
asts, where they are captured easily. This leads us to
say that the Gulf of Stora may be considered as a
zone of spawning of the European anchovy.
Month
No. of
males
No. of
females
Sex-ratio
X2 obs
Jul-08
14
62
18.4211
30.31579 ***
Aug
50
100
33.3333
16.66667 ***
Sep
77
30
71.9626
20.64486 ***
Oct
67
52
56.3025
1.89076 ns
Nov
-
-
-
-
Dec
-
-
-
-
Jan-09
12
26
31.5789
5.15789 *
Feb
25
86
22.5225
33.52252 ***
Mar
32
48
40
3.2 ns
Apr
26
47
35.6164
6.04109 *
May
9
30
23.0769
11.30769 ***
Jun
4
6
40
0.4 ns
Total
316
487
39.3524
36.41469 ***
Table 2. Monthly variations of male sex-ratio for Engraulis
encrasicolus from the gulf of Stora between July 2008 and
June 2009. p > a = 0,05: (ns) not significant, p < a = 0,05:
(*) significant, p < a = 0,001 : (***) very highly significant.
Gonado-somatic index
Graphically, monthly fluctuations of gonado-so-
matic index (GSI) values of E. encrasicolus are
shown in figure 1. For females, GSI showed the high-
est values in summer with a maximum in August
(GSI=4.31%), decreased at the beginning of au-
tumn, the lowest values being recorded in winter
with a minimum in February (0.65%), and then
gradually and notably increased in spring. Males
ex-hibited more or less a similar trend, with the ma-
ximum value recorded in September (3.39%) and
the least in January (0.86%). Noteworthy, the in-
crease in GSI values through the spring period
(March- June) was less marked than in females.
Monthly variations of the gonado-somatic index re-
vealed that the reproduction period of the anchovy
in our area spreads between April and October. This
is in line with Whitehead et al. (1988) who affirm
that the peak of spawning generally coincides with
the warmest months, the limits of the spawning sea-
son being dependent on the temperature. Plotting
the evolution of GSI values showed that the repro-
ductive cycle of E. encrasicolus is characterized by
four successive phases: (i) a phase of slow matura-
tion which starts in March and continues until June;
(ii) a phase of significant and intense sexual activity
which occurs during the warm-est months (from
June to September); (iii) a phase of decline starting
in September during which the testicles and the
ovaries gradually loose their mass; and finally (iv)
a phase of rest, coinciding with the coldest months
(from December to Feb-ruary), when fishes become
sexually inactive.
These findings once again support the hypothe-
sis that temperature exerts a strong influence on the
sexual cycle of the European anchovy, with high
temperatures leading to spawning and low temper-
atures preventing sexual activity (Whitehead et al.,
1988; Djabali & Hamida, 1989).
Hepato-somatic index
For the hepato-somatic index (Fig. 2) we ob-
served, in females, a maximum in July
(HSI=1 .58%) and, then, a clear reduction up to Oc-
tober (0.85%), with the lowest values in January
(0.53%) when it dramatically increased to reach a
maximum in February (1.17%). After that, HSI
gradually decreased up to June (0.64%). In males
we observed the same trend, although absolute val-
ues were slightly lower than in females. HSI, com-
pared with GSI, was less marked. During the
reproduction period HSI values decreased probably
due to the consumption of fat deposits, reaching a
peak in winter (at the end of February) which sug-
gests a possible storage of reserves in the liver dur-
ing the sexual rest, followed by the reduction of HSI
from March on, when sexual maturity begins. It is
interesting to note that, especially for females, HSI
and GSI values did not always show complemen-
tary trends, thus suggesting that energy reserves
used to allow the development of the gonads may
not be accumulated exclusively in the liver.
272
L. Mezedjri.A. Kerfouf & A.Tahar
1
5
Djabali & Hamida (1989) during a study on the
European anchovy, carried out between 1983 and
1984, concluded that the liver didn’t have any role
in the maturation process of the sexual products;
this implies that the two parameters (GSI and HSI)
should be studied together.
Adiposity
Changes in mesenteric deposits in E. encrasi-
2
4
Figure 1. Monthly variations of GSI in Engraulis encrasi-
colus from the gulf of Stora.
Figure 2. Monthly variations of the HSI for E. encrasicolus
from the gulf of Stora.
Figure 3. Monthly variations of adiposity for E. encrasico-
lus from the gulf of Stora.
Figure 4. Size at first sexual maturity in females of E. en-
crasicolus from the gulf of Stora.
Figure 5. Size at first sexual maturity in males off. encra-
sicolus from the gulf of Stora.
colus are shown in figure 3. The maximum values
were recorded in September (males) and January
(females) while, in both sexes, the lowest ones
were in April.
Taking into account that the highest values were
observed in winter (during the sexual rest) and the
lowest ones in the warmest months, these findings
confirm the hypothesis, maintained by Djabali &
Hamida (1989), that gonadic reserves may origin
mainly from mesenteric fat deposits.
Year 2008 2009
3
Calss of size
Reproductive cycle of the European anchovy Engraulis encrasicolus in the gulf of Skikda (Algerian East coasts) 273
Size at first sexual maturity
The size at the first sexual maturity (Lt) is roughly
the same for both sexes and corresponds to 12.5
cm (Figs. 4, 5). As can be seen, our data are in line
with most of the Lt values available for E. encra-
sicolus populations in the Mediterranean (Table 3),
suggesting that, in the areas analysed, there are not
big differences in environmental factors, particu-
larly water temperatures, population density and
food availability, while Lt = 6.5 cm reported for
the lagoon of Nador (Morocco) might be possibily
due to disturbing issues including high fishing
pressures.
In conclusion, the present study not only gave
information on any biological aspects of Engraulis
encrasicolus from the guld of Skikda (Algerian
East-coasts), which up to now were deficient, but
also contributed to provide a preliminary base for
monitoring the changes in biological indexes con-
nected to the reproduction cycle of this species in
order to ensure its sustainable management in the
Mediterranean area.
Lt (cm)
Sex
Locality
Author
13.0
Males
Golf of Biscay
Dorel, 1986
13.0
Females
Golf of Biscay
Dorel, 1986
11.2
Males
Bay of Algiers
Djabali &
Hamida, 1989
11.6
Females
Bay of Algiers
Djabali &
Hamida, 1989
11.5
Indefinite
Coast of
Catalonia
Pertierra, 1992
12.5
Both sexes
Golf of Stora
(Skikda)
Mezedjri &
Tahar, 2005; 2006
12.5
Both sexes
Golf of Stora
(Skikda)
present paper
06.5
Both sexes
the lagoon of
Nador (Morocco)
Kada et al., 2009
Table 3. Size at first sexual maturity of Engraulis encrasi-
colus in some regions of the Mediterranean Sea.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Authors wish to thank two anonymous referees
for the their suggestions which significantly im-
proved the manuscript.
REFERENCES
Bamabe G., 1976. Contribution a la connaissance de la bio-
logie du loup Dicentrarchus labrax (L.) (Poisson Se-
raranide) de la region de Sete. These d’etat, Universite
des Sciences et Techniques du, Montpellier, 426 pp.
Dagnelie P., 2006. Statistique theorique et appliquee.
Tome 2: Inferences statistique a une et a deux dimen-
sions. De Boeck, Bruxelles, 659 pp.
Djabali F. & Hamida F., 1989. Reproduction de l'anchois
( Engraulis encrasicolus, Linne 1758) de la region d' Al-
ger. Bulletin de Pinstitut des sciences de la mer et de
l’amenagement du littoral ISMAL. Pelagos, 7: 11-14.
Dorel D., 1986. Poissons de l'Atlantique nord-est rela-
tions taille-poids. Institut Franqais de Recherche pour
l'Exploitation de la Mer. IFREMER, Nantes, 165 pp.
E.R.H., 1996. Evaluation de la ressource halieutique. Mi-
nistere des peches et des ressources halieutiques.
Rapp. Campagne, 40 pp.
Fage L., 1911. Recherches sur la biologie de l’anchois
(Engraulis encrasicolus Linne): races-age-migra-
tions. Annales de l'lnstitut oceanographique Monaco,
2: 1-40.
Fage L., 1920. Engraulidae, Clupeidae. Report on the
Danish Oceanographical Expeditions 1908-1919 to
the Mediterranean and adjacent seas, Vol. 2, 140 pp.
Hemida F., 1987. Contribution a l’etude de l’anchois En-
graulis encrasicolus (Linne, 1758) dans la region
d’ Alger. Biologie et exploitation. These de magistere,
USTHB.
Kada O., Abdellaoui S., Ramdani M. & Nachit D., 2009.
Contribution a 1’ identification et a la caracterisation
biologique et dynamique de l’anchois de la lagune de
Nador (Maroc). Bulletin de l’lnstitut Scientifique,
Rabat, section Sciences de la Vie, 31: 91-98.
Kara M.H., 1997. Cycle sexuel et fecondite du loup Di-
centrarchus labrax (poisson Moronide) du golfe
d’Annaba. Cahiers de Biologie Marine, 38: 161-168.
Kara M.H., 2001. Biologie, dynamique et evaluation des
ressources halieutiques coheres du littoral Est-alge-
rien. Projet de recherche: Ministere de l’Enseigne-
ment Superieur et de la Recherche scientifique.
Mezedjri L. & Tahar A., 2005. Reproduction de l’an-
chois Europeen dans le golfe de Skikda, Algerie :
Actes du Sixieme Congres Maghrebin des Sciences
de la Mer Monastir, Tunisie (18-22 decembre 2005).
Abstract book.
Mezedjri L. & Tahar A., 2006. Reproduction de l’anchois
Europeen Engraulis encrasicolus dans le golfe de
Stora, Skikda. 8eme conference internationale des
limnologues d’expression franqaise « CILEF 2006 ».
Hammamet, Tunisie. Abstract book.
Minitab 16 Statistical Software (2010). [Computer soft-
ware]. State College, PA: Minitab, Inc. (www.mini-
tab.com).
274
L. Mezedjri.A. Kerfouf & A.Tahar
Nikolsky G.V., 1963. The ecology of fishes. Academic
Press. London, 352 pp.
Pertierra J.P., 1992. Fisheries biology of the anchovy (En-
graulis encrasicolus ) in the Catalan coast. Ph.D. The-
sis, Universitat Politeenica de Catalunya, Spain.
Prouzet P. & Metuzals-Sebedio K.I., 1994. Population
structure and reproductive biology. Stock discrimi-
nation studies using morphometric and genetic data.
In: Cendrero O. (Ed.), Improvement of Stock Asses-
sment by direct Methods, Its Application to the An-
chovy ( Engraulis encrasicolus ) in the Bay of Biscay.
Final Report. Projet DG XIV EU, ref MA. 2. 495.
Whitehead P.J.P., Nelson G.J. & Wongratana T., 1988.
FAO species catalogue Vol. 7. Clupeoid fishes of the
world. An annotated and illustrated catalogue of the
herrings, sardines, pilchards, sprats, shads, anchovies
and wolf-herrings. Part 2. Engraulididae. FAO Fishe-
ries Synopsis, 7: 305-579.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 275-280
Amauta hodeei (Oberthur, 1881) and its subspecies (Lepi-
doptera Castniidae), with comments on the life and times of
Brother Apolinar Maria
Jorge M. Gonzalez 1 *, Roberto Vinciguerra 2 & Sergio D. Rios 3
'California State University, Fresno, Department of Plant Sciences, Fresno, CA 93740-8033 (Research Associate, McGuire Center
for Lepidoptera & Biodiversity), USA; e-mail: gonzalez.jorge.m@gmail.com
2 Via XX Settembre, 64, 1-90141 Palermo, Italy
’Museo Nacional de Historia Natural de Paraguay, Sucursal 1 Campus, Central XI, San Lorenzo, Departamento de Biologia, Fa-
cultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad Nacional de Asuncion, Paraguay. E-mail: sergiord40@gmail.com
*Corresponding author
ABSTRACT In 1948, a fired destroyed the La Salle Museum in Bogota, Colombia, which was built with
a great effort by the La Salle religious teaching congregation, but with the particular and de-
cisive input of Brother Apolinar Maria. He became a champion of the study of the natural
history of Colombia and through the museum, he established numerous connections with
scientists and naturalists worldwide. Some rare Castniidae were among the numerous speci-
mens of the fauna he traded with museums around the world. General information about
Brother Apolinar Maria, the La Salle Museum, and the subspecies of Amauta hodeei (Cast-
niidae) are provided here in an attempt to improve and stimulate the interest in such a re-
markable naturalist and some rare and almost unknown species of the South American Fauna.
One of these ssp. (A. hodeei kruegeri ) is reported from Ecuador, thus increasing knowledge
about its geographical distribution.
KEY WORDS Museo La Salle Bogota; Castniidae; Amauta hodeei hodeei', Amauta hodeei kruegeri.
Received 22.02.2013; accepted 08.04.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Massive riots followed the assassination of po-
litical leader and presidential candidate Jorge Elie-
cer Gaitan (1903-1948) in Bogota, Colombia, on
April 9, 1948. The 10 hour riot resulted in a fire that
left thousands of dead and injured, and much of
downtown Bogota was destroyed by the effects of
a widespread fire (Alape, 1994). The Museum of
Natural History La Salle was among those buildings
that disappeared because of the fire (Figs. 2, 3). It
originally contained samples of over 73,000 speci-
mens of several groups, and by 1930, some 37,706
of those specimens were insects (Salazar, 1999).
The success of this museum was mainly the product
of the efforts of Nicolas Seiller (1867-1949), better
known as Brother Apolinar Maria (Figs. 1, 4)
(Velez & Salazar, 1991; Salazar, 1999; Diaz Meza
et al., 2006). The museum and its annex library
were consumed by the fire and, as a result, Apolinar
Maria entered a deep state of depression and died
in December, 1949 (Salazar, 1999).
Seiller was born in Alsace, France, in 1867.
Some time later, he went to Reims, where he
eventually joined the religious Brotherhood of La
Salle.
276
J.M. GonzAlez, R.Vinciguerra & S.D. Rios
As customary in the brotherhood, he changed
his name to Apolinar Maria and was then sent to
Colombia, where he arrived in 1904 (Lamas, 1979).
Thanks to his interest in the natural sciences, he
founded the Natural History Society of La Salle In-
stitute in Bogota, in 1912 (Lamas, 1979). With the
help of other brothers and local amateur naturalists,
he also built the museum that would eventually con-
tain the largest collection of Lepidoptera in Colom-
bia (Lamas, 1979; Salazar, 1999). Most importantly,
he emphasized the need of knowing and sharing in-
formation with scientists around the world, and with
this vision, he sent countless Colombian specimens
to several institutions and private American and
European collections in an effort to trade, but also
obtain the appropriate identification of his adopted
country’s fauna and flora (Lamas, 1979; Rodriguez,
2002; Freile & Cordova, 2008). Together, with col-
leagues and pupils, he published numerous papers
on Lepidoptera, described many new taxa, and
made observations on Colombian natural history
(Lamas, 1979, 2013).
Figure 1. Brother Apolinar Maria examining specimens inside the Natural History Museum, La Salle, Bogota (Picture borro-
wed from Diaz Meza et al. 2006). Figure 2. La Salle Museum being devoured by the flames, 1948. Figure 3. La Salle Museum
after the flames were controlled, 1948. Figure 4. Nicollas Seiller, best known as Brother Apolinar Maria (1867-1949).
Amauta hodeei and its subspecies (Lepidoptera Castniidae), with comments on the life and times of Brother Apolinar Maria 277
Through the Museum he established communi-
cations with scientists and naturalists around the
world, including renowned entomologists such as
Charles Oberthiir (1845-1924), Paul Dognin (1856-
1931), Eugene Louis Bouvier (1856-1944), Harri-
son Gray Dyar jr. (1866-1929), Anton H. Fassl
(1876-1922), William Schaus (1858-1942), Johan-
nes Karl Rober (1861-1942), Arnold Schiiltze
(1875-1948), and Romualdo Ferreira D’ Almeida
(1891-1969) (Lamas 1979; Salazar, 1999; Velez &
Salazar, 1991; Julian Salazar, pers. comm.).
Apolinar Maria is considered one of the most re-
levant and recognized Colombian naturalists and
the precursor of the studies of Lepidoptera in the
country (Salazar 1999; Rodriguez, 2002). Aside
from the collecting he and other brothers from his
congregation did while travelling to different Co-
lombian locations, he hired people to collect fauna
and flora specimens, mainly from Muzo, Boyaca,
along the forests that border Rio Magdalena and
other effluents, like Rio Carare, as well as Villavi-
cencio, Meta (Apolinar Maria, 1915; Julian Salazar,
pers. comm., 2012).
He published some of his findings, including the
descriptions of several new species, in various jour-
nals and newsletters (Lamas, 1979; 2013). In Lepi-
doptera, he mainly published about butterflies,
however he also wrote several papers or notes with
information about moths (Salazar, 1999; Lamas,
2013). Among those works, he wrote about some
Castniidae found in Colombia (Apolinar Maria,
1915, 1945). Brother Apolinar Maria recognized
and made brief comments about ten species and se-
veral subspecies in the Castniidae collected in Co-
lombia and deposited at Bogota’s La Salle Museum
(Apolinar Maria, 1915, 1945; Salazar, 1999).
Among the over 3 1 taxa belonging to 2 1 species
of Castniidae found in Colombia (Hernandez-Baz
et al., 2012), some belong to the genus Amauta
Houlbert, 1918. According to Lamas (1995) it con-
tains four species: A. ambatensis (Houlbert, 1918),
A. cacica (Herrich- Schaffer, [1854]), A. hodeei
(Oberthiir, 1881), and A. papilionaris (Walker,
[1865]). They are all species of medium to large
dimensions, with triangular forewings, commonly
dark brown to black, with some white/cream and
orange markings in both wings and they are se-
xually dimorphic (Miller, 1986). The genus is dis-
tributed from Guatemala, through Central America
and down to South America, where specimens have
been found in Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, Bolivia
and Brazil (Miller, 1986, 1995; Lamas, 1995). Un-
fortunately, the known information on the several
species in the genus is still fragmentary and scarce,
and data found in several insect Museums is far
from adequate (Miller, 1986; Miller & Sourakov,
2009).
Even though we have been able to study Castnii-
dae specimens from many museums worldwide, we
could locate only few of Amauta hodeei. Among the
known specimens of both subspecies (A. hodeei ho-
deei and A. hodeei kruegeri), including those men-
tioned in the literature, a few were collected by
Brother Apolinar Maria (or his group of collectors).
Both subspecies are known to occur in Colombia;
however, a specimen of A. hodeei kruegeri collec-
ted in Ecuador is reported herein, thus expanding
its known distribution.
Specimens examined are in the following col-
lections: AMNH = American Museum of Natural
History, New York, USA; MGCLB = McGuire
Center for Lepidoptera & Biodiversity, (Allyn Mu-
seum Collection), Gainesville, Florida, USA;
MHN-UC = Natural History Museum, University
of Caldas, Manizales, Colombia; MffNP = Natural
History Museum, Paris, France; NMNH-SI = Na-
tional Museum of Natural Histoiy, Smithsonian In-
stitution, Washington D.C., USA; GPC = G. Penati
Collection, Milan, Italy; RVC = Roberto Vinci-
guerra Collection, Palermo, Italy.
COMMENTS ON THE TWO KNOWN SSP.
OF AMAUTA HODEEI (OBERTHUR, 1881)
Amauta hodeei hodeei (Oberthiir, 1881)
This subspecies was originally described (as
Castnia hodeei ) by Oberthiir (1881) from material
collected in the Colombian region along Santa Rosa
and the Carare river. Years later, Schaus (1896) de-
scribed Castnia corrupta from Colombia, while
Oberthiir (1925) illustrates a species he names C.
apollinaris [nomem nudum (Lamas, 1995)] based
on a male specimen collected in Colombia, and
compares and discusses similarities and differences
with the species C. corrupta. That same year, Knop
(1925) describes C. amazona from Bogota, Colom-
bia. Those species have been established as syno-
nyms of hodeei hodeei (Lamas, 1995).
278
J.M. GonzAlez, R.Vinciguerra& S.D. Rios
Unfortunately, this is a rare taxon and almost no-
thing is known about its biology and ecology. In
fact, very few specimens are known from insect col-
lections worldwide. Joicey & Talbot (1925) men-
tioned that they received three specimens (two
males and a female) sent by Brother Apolinar Maria
which were originally collected in Muzo and Villa-
vicencio. Gonzalez & Salazar (2003) also reported
a male and a female from Guamoco and Cauca Val-
ley (Caucaval).
Examined material (with notes). COLOMBIA:
1 male, 1 female, Bogota, 1931, Coll. Fre. Apoli-
naire Marie (MHNP) [even though the labels (Fig.
10) clearly state that this material was collected in
Bogota, they were most certainly collected in the
Muzo region where Brother Apolinar Maria had
peasants hired to collect specimens. Since the La
Salle Museum was located in Bogota, most Institu-
tions that received material from Apolinar Maria,
commonly assumed that “Bogota” was the collec-
Figure 5. Amauta hodeei hodeei, male, Bogota, Colombia (MHNP). Figure 6, Idem, male, Guamoco Colombia (AMNH).
Figure 7. Idem, female, Cauca Valley, Colombia (AMNH). Figure 8. A. hodeei kruegeri, Esmeraldas, Ecuador (RVC). Figure
9. Idem, Rio Calima, Colombia (MGCLB). Figure 10. Labels of two A. hodeei hodeei specimens collected or sent by
Brother Apolinar Maria (MHNP). Scale (for figures 5-9): 10 mm.
Amauta hodeei and its subspecies (Lepidoptera Castniidae), with comments on the life and times of Brother Apolinar Maria 279
ting locality]; 1 male?, Muzo, Boyaca, [the occiden-
tal sector with influence of the middle area of the
Magdalena River], Coll. Apolinar Maria [reported
in Apolinar Maria (1945). This specimen was surely
lost in the Museum’s fire]; 1 male, Campo Santo,
Bogota, 1922, Coll. L. Pfeiffer (NMNH-SI) [this is
the type specimen of Castnia corrupta described by
Schaus (1896) and now considered a synonym of A.
hodeei hodeei (Lamas, 1995)]; 1 female, Colombia,
Boyaca, Coll. ? (NMNH-SI); 1 male, Guamoco,
Coll. F. Johnson (AMNH); 1 female, Caucaval
[Cauca Valley], Coll. F. Johnson (AMNH); 1 male,
Santa Rosa-Carare, Coll. Oberthiir [mentioned in
Oberthiir (1881) and Houlbert (1918)].
Amauta hodeei kruegeri (Niepelt, 1927)
Only males are known of this rare subspecies,
and they differ from the nominate subspecies be-
cause of its darker, blackish, background color, and
also because of the very distinctive white and
orange markings in the hind wings (Figs. 5-9).
Niepelt (1927) described it (as Castnia kriigeri )
based on a male collected in “West Colombia.” We
have been able to examine four specimens, all
males, from four different collections. The fore-
wings are devoid of any markings except for a small
light amber band in the sub-apical region. They are
larger than the sub-apical creamy spot observed in
males of the nominate subspecies (Figs. 5, 6, 8, 9).
A large, creamy-white spot can be observed in the
tormal region of the hind wing. The spot turns
orange at the edge of the wing. Such markings are
clearly noticeable, better defined, and larger in the
four studied specimens than in the similar (but
smaller and faddier) markings found in males of the
nominate species (Figs. 5, 6, 8, 9).
Examined material. COLOMBIA: 1 male, Rio
Dagua, W. Colombia, ex coll. H. Gerstner (GPC);
1 male, Rio Calima, VII, [19] 84, Allyn Museum
Ace. 1991-13, Allyn Museum Photo No. 850827-
15/16, Slide No. M-7132, male append. Jacqueline
Y. Miller (MGCLB); 1 male, Valle, Queremal -
Km 55, 9-IV-85, Leg. J.A Salazar (MJJN-UC).
ECUADOR: 2 males, Esmeraldas, (RVC).
All specimens known to us (and listed above) of
A. hodeei hodeei were collected east of the Western
Cordillera while those of A. hodeei kruegeri were
collected on the western slope of the Western Cor-
dillera in Colombia, and closer to the coast and west
01 "O'CTW 00'fftrW 79XrtrW 78 WW 7T‘UCrW 76WW 75 , 0 , 0"W 74'0 r (rW 73*0 - 0"W
— I 1 i i I I I I I
8 1WW &0 a cnrw 79*ff(TW 70WW 77 e CrO“W 76 WW 75 WW 74 1 <WW 73WW
Figure 1 1 . Map showing localities and ecological regions
where specimens of Amauta hodeei ssp. have been collected
in Colombia and Ecuador. A. hodeei hodeei: A1 : Magdalena,
Guamoco; A2: Magdalena, Santa Rosa and Carare; A3:
Magdalena, Muzo; D4: Paramo, Bogota; A. hodeei kruegeri :
B6: Choco, Rio Dagua; C5: Cauca, Rio Calima; E7: East
Ecuador, Durango; F: Napo.
of the Ecuadorian Western Cordillera (Fig. 11). The
Western Cordillera of Colombia continues along the
Western Cordillera of Ecuador and they seem to be
a geographic barrier that clearly separates the po-
pulations of both subspecies. The populations of
both ssp. appear to be highly dispersed along their
geographic range, but the low number of specimens
known and the lack of knowledge about their bio-
logy and ecology prevent us from providing any in-
formation about their conservation status.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are greatly indebted to curators and persons
in charge of the revised insect collections mentio-
ned herein. We appreciate the kindness and help of
Ronald Erwin Rengifo and the personnel in charge
of the photographic register of the La Salle Mu-
seum, Bogota, Colombia, who provided us with
pictures of Brother Apolinar Maria (Figs. 1, 4). Also
thanks to Julian Salazar who provided us with pic-
tures of the La Salle Museum while burning and
after the fire was extinguished (Figs. 2, 3). Thanks
280
J.M. GonzAlez, R.Vinciguerra& S.D. Rios
to Joan Sharma and Martin Valencia (California
State University, Fresno, USA) for their help to
assemble the plates and to Andrea C. Gonzalez and
William Hale for proof reading the manuscript.
Our friend and colleague Roberto Vinciguerra
passed away shortly after this manuscript was
submitted to BJ for consideration. We (JMG &
SDR) will like to dedicate this work to his memory.
REFERENCES
Alape A., 1994. El Bogotazo: memorias del Olvido. Abril
9 de 1948. Planeta, Colombia, 653 pp.
Apolinar Maria, 1915. Miscelanea. Capturas interesantes.
Boletin de la Sociedad de Ciencias Naturales del Ins-
titute La Salle, 3: 141-144.
Apolinar Maria, 1945. Miscelanea entomologica. I-Algo
sobre castnidos colombianos. Revista de la Academia
Colombiana de Ciencias Experimentales, Fisicas &
Naturales, 6: 322.
Diaz Meza C.J., Jimenez J.R. & Turriago D., 2006. His-
toricidad, Saber y Pedagogia, Una Mirada al Modelo
Pedagogico Lasallista en Colombia 1915-1935. Uni-
versidad de La Salle, Bogota, Colombia. 170 pp.
Freile J.F. & Cordoba S., 2008. Historia de la omitologia
en la region andina: el ejemplo de Colombia y Ecua-
dor. Omitologia Neotropical, 19 (suppl.): 381-389.
Gonzalez J.M. & Salazar J.A., 2003. Adicion a la lista de
castnidos (Lepidoptera: Castniidae: Castniinae) co-
nocidos de Colombia. Boletin Cientifico del Museo
de Historia Natural, Universidad de Caldas, Maniza-
les, 7: 47-56.
Houlbert C., 1918. Revision monographique de la sous-
famille des Castniinae. Etudes de Lepidopterologie
Comparee,15: 1-730.
Joicey J.J. & Talbot G., 1925. Notes on some Lepidop-
tera, with descriptions of new forms. Annals and Ma-
gazine of Natural History, (9)16 (96): 633-653.
Knop T., 1925. Castnia amazona nov. spec, und Papilio
androgeus (Cr.) nov. var .fassli. Entomologische Zeit-
schrift, 39: 42-43.
Lamas G., 1979. Brother Apolinar Maria (1867-1949)
and his contributions to Colombian lepidopterology.
Journal of the Lepidopterists Society, 33: 65-67.
Lamas G., 1995. A critical review of J. Y. Miller’s chec-
klist of the Neotropical Castniidae (Lepidoptera). Re-
vista Pemana de Entomologia, 37: 73-87.
Lamas G., 2013. Bibliography of Butterflies. An Anno-
tated Bibliography of the Neotropical Butterflies and
Skippers (Lepidoptera: Papilionoidea and Hesperioi-
dea). Revised Electronic edition, 672 pp.
Miller J.Y., 1986. The Taxonomy, Phylogeny, and Zoogeo-
graphy of the Neotropical Castniinae (Lepidoptera:
Castnioidea: Castniidae). Ph.D. Thesis. University of
Florida, Gainesville, 571 pp.
Miller J.Y., 1995. Castniidae. In: Heppner J.B. (Ed.).
Checklist: Part 2. Hyblaeoidea-Pyraloidea-Tortricoi-
dea. Atlas of Neotropical Lepidoptera, 3: 133-137,
176-177. Association for Tropical Lepidoptera/Scien-
tific Publishers, Gainesville.
Miller J.Y. & Sourakov A., 2009. Some observations on
Amauta cacica procera (Boisduval) (Castniidae:
Castniinae) in Costa Rica. Tropical Lepidoptera Re-
search, 19: 113-114.
Niepelt W., 1927. Neue Falter von Columbien. Interna-
tionale Entomologische Zeitchrift, 21: 239-241.
Oberthur C., 1881. II. Lepidopteres d’Amerique. Etudes
d’Entomologie, 6:xxv - xxvi, 27-38.
Oberthur C., 1925. Lepidopteres de l’Amerique du Sud.
Eudes de Lepidopterologie. Comparee, 9: 63-64.
Rodriguez G., 2002. El naturalista Antoine Rouhaire
(Hermano Niceforo Maria) y el desarrollo de la Zoo-
logia sistematica en Colombia. Revista de la Acade-
mia Colombiana de Ciencias, 26: 229-237.
Salazar J.A., 1999. Notas biograficas a una historia de la
Lepidopterologia en Colombia durante el siglo XX.
Boletin Cientifico del Museo de Historia Natural,
Universidad de Caldas, Manizales, 3: 71-102.
Schaus W., 1896. New species of Heterocera from tropi-
cal America. Journal of the New York Entomological
Society, 4: 147-154.
Velez J.H. & Salazar J.A., 1991. Mariposas de Colombia.
Villegas Eds., Bogota, Colombia, 167 pp.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 281-284
Further records of two uncommon Crustaceans in Italian
seas: Maja goltziana D'Oliveira, 1 888 (Decapoda Brachyura
Majidae) and Xaiva biguttata (Risso, 1816) (Decapoda Bra-
chyura Portunidae)
Joachim Langeneck 1 * & Davide Di Franco 2
'Via Derna 13B, 56126 Pisa, Italy; email: jo.langeneck@gmail.com
2 Via S. Maria dei Monti 38/D, 95030, Gravina, Catania, Italy; email: davide_di_franco@hotmail.it
* Corresponding author
ABSTRACT The presence of Maja goltziana D'Oliveira, 1888 (Decapoda Brachyura Majidae) is confirmed
in the central Tyrrhenian Sea and in the Tuscan Archipelago. Xaiva biguttata (Risso, 1816)
(Decapoda Brachyura Portunidae) is first recorded from the Western Sardinian coast and the
Eastern Sicilian coast. The presence and spread of M. goltziana are considered a consequence
of climatic changes. The presence of A. biguttata in Italian seas was probably underestimated,
and its supposed rarity should be reassessed.
KEY WORDS Maja goltziana ; Xaiva biguttata', Mediterranean Sea; new record; climatic changes.
Received 3.04.2013; accepted 9.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Maja goltziana D'Oliveira, 1888 (Decapoda
Brachyura Majidae) and Xaiva biguttata (Risso,
1816) (Decapoda Brachyura Portunidae) are two
Crustaceans generally considered rare in the Italian
seas. In this paper are reported some further records
of these species, and their current status in the Ital-
ian seas is discussed.
ABBREVIATIONS. CC = F. Crocetta collec-
tion, Napoli, Italy; CD = D. Di Franco collection,
Gravina, Catania, Italy; CF = J. Fangeneck collec-
tion, Pisa, Italy.
Maja goltziana D’Oliveira, 1888
Examined material. One male specimen (Figs.
1 , 2) (carapace length 49 mm; carapace width 42
mm, including rostral and longest lateral spines)
found in a gillnet set near the coast of Elba Island
(Figurian Sea) at a depth of 40-50 m, May 2008
(CF). One male specimen (carapace length 98 mm;
carapace width 76 mm, including rostral and lon-
gest lateral spines) trawled on deep circalittoral bot-
toms at Fa Maddalena Island, October 2010 (CC).
Remarks. The first specimen is a subadult
male; the similar M. squinado (Herbst, 1788) is
fairly common in the collecting area. While adult
specimens of each species can be easily distin-
guished, the difference between subadult specimens
is thinner. A visible difference between the speci-
men of M. goltziana and a subadult of M. squinado
is the central series of five large spines, which inM
squinado are much smaller and shaped as tubercles.
However, a remarkable affinity with M. squinado
consists in the absence of the strong antero-dorsal
spine on the meri of the pereiopods, as it is de-
282
Joachim Langeneck & Davide Di Franco
scribed by Holthuis & Gottlieb (1958). A compari-
son between the second right pereiopod of both
species shows that the legs of M. squinado (Fig. 3)
and of sub-adult specimen of M. goltziana (Fig. 4)
are, in fact, more similar than the legs of this last
one compared to the adult of M. goltziana (Fig. 5).
The absence of the spine on the meri in young spec-
imens has been confirmed by further observations
on eastern Mediterranean specimens (Galil, pers.
comm.), but this characteristic was not highlighted
in literature so far; it is remarkable that the larger
specimen, caught at La Maddalena Island, shows
well developed spines on the pereiopods.
Xaiva biguttata (Risso, 1816)
Examined material. One male specimen (Fig.
6) (carapace length 8 mm; carapace width 7 mm)
found stranded on the Is Arenas beach (Cuglieri,
Western Sardinia) (CL) (August 2008). One male
specimen (Fig. 7) (carapace length 9 mm; carapace
width 9 mm) collected alive on shell grit at a depth
of 1.7 m (Cannizzaro, Catania, July 2008, Eastern
Sicily) (CD).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
M. goltziana is a widespread species, and it is
considered quite common in the Eastern Atlantic
Ocean (Manning & Holthuis, 1981; D'Udelcem
DAcoz, 1999; Henriksen, 2009) and in the Eastern
Mediterranean Sea (Holthuis & Gottlieb, 1958;
Artiiz, 2006; Lelli et al., 2008; Ate§ et al., 2010).
The first record of the species in the Mediterranean
Sea dates back to the late 50's off the Israel coast
(Holthuis & Gottlieb, 1958); in the Italian seas the
species has been recorded first in the Ionian Sea
(Pastore, 1983) and in the Sicilian Straight (Pipitone
& Arculeo, 2003), while just recently it was recor-
ded in the Adriatic Sea (Pallaoro & Dulcic, 2004),
in the Tyrrhenian Sea (Soppelsa et al., 2005; Cro-
cetta, 2007) and in the Ligurian Sea (Vignoli et al.,
2004). Therefore, the new records do not widen the
known distribution of the species; however, they
confirm the presence of M. goltziana in the Western
Tyrrhenian Sea and in the Ligurian Sea (Fig. 8).
M. goltziana is an eurybathic species with sub-
tropical affinity, and has been first recorded in the
warmest Mediterranean sectors; its spread in central
and Northern Mediterranean Sea is considered as a
consequence of climatic changes (Vignoli et al.,
2004; Soppelsa et al., 2005). The species seems to
have spread either geographically (in the Adriatic
and Tyrrhenian Sea) and numerically (Lelli et
al., 2007, recorded more than 50 specimens in
Lebanese waters, whereas every previous record
concerned at most two or three specimens). There-
fore, the hypothesis of the climatic changes conse-
quence appears to be persuasive.
X biguttata is known in the Eastern Atlantic
Ocean (Manning & Holthuis, 1981; D'Udelcem
D'Acoz, 1999; Vieira & Morato, 2001) and in the
Mediterranean Sea, where it was recorded along
the Spanish coast (Garcia Raso & Jimenez Millan,
1981), in the Eastern Mediterranean Sea (Lewin-
sohn & Holthuis, 1986; Ate§ et al., 2010) and
along the Italian coasts (Pastore, 1977; Pipitone
& Arculeo, 2003; Bedini, 2004). The Italian
records refer to the southern Tyrrhenian Sea, (Pi-
pitone & Arculeo, 2003) and the Ionian Sea (Pa-
store, 1977); recently Bedini recorded one
subadult female (carapace length 7 mm; carapace
width 6 mm) on the Tuscan coast on Posidonia
meadow (Bedini, 2004 and pers. comm.). The
species has never been officially reported from
the western Sardinian coast before. The record
from Cannizzaro (Catania) confirms the presence
of the species in the Ionian Sea (Fig. 9). X bigut-
tata has been recorded throughout the Mediter-
ranean Sea (Lewinsohn & Holthuis, 1986), but
with quite a few specimens for each record; there-
fore, the species is generally considered rare in
the Mediterranean Sea (Garcia Raso & Jimenez
Millan, 1981; Bedini, 2004), while it is consid-
ered more common in the Atlantic Ocean (Vieira
& Morato, 2001). In the Mediterranean Sea the
abundance of X biguttata is probably higher than
what is commonly considered; however, it is hard
to find this species as fishing by-catch because of
its littoral habitat and small size.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We wish to thank Prof. R. Bedini, Dr. V. Vi-
gnoli for providing data, and especially Dr. F. Cro-
cetta for data and suggestions.
Further records of two uncommon Crustaceans in Italian seas: Maja goltziana and Xaiva biguttata
283
Figure 1. Maja goltziana, Rio Marina, Elba Island (Ligurian Sea). Figure 2. Idem, particular of the dorsal spines. Figure 3.
Second right pereiopod of subadult M. squinado. Figure 4. Second right pereiopod of subadult M. goltziana. Figure 5. Second
right pereiopod of M. goltziana (photo by courtesy of Dr. V. Vignoli). Figure 6. Xaiva biguttata, ecdysis from Western Sardinia,
in frontal and ventral view. Figure 7. X biguttata, specimen from Cannizzaro (Eastern Sicily), in frontal and ventral view.
284
Joachim Langeneck & Davide Di Franco
!z X
4
r\ C LT" ' • v S
r ' C ,j\ x
\ &
ji \
fS-M '■— * J
\ J A P — ;
\ r\
k'd
<
W
ITALY
" N&A
ITALY
.. ' \
Ligurian
N
Ligurian
Sea
Adriatic
r
Sea Adriatic
★
Sea
• Sea
0
•K
3
0
■ » - - ' - A,
2 V
■*-
\ a
•*
eP\ AN
s-t V.
Sardinia gj
Sardinia Tyrrhenian
a. Tyrrhenian
Sea
Sea
•
Ionian
4 Ionian
Sicily
Sea
Sicily ^ Sea
L £
•
o
i ; N
5
i L . ■
Figure 8. Map showing the
known records of Maja
goltziana in the Italian seas.
The current record are repre-
sented by stars. 2: two speci-
mens (Vignoli et al., 2003). 3:
three specimens (Pallaoro &
Dulcic, 2004).
Figure 9. Map showing the
known records of Xaiva bi-
guttata in Italian seas. The
current records are represen-
ted by stars.
REFERENCES
Boccone Artuz M.L., 2006. First record of Maja
goltziana Oliveira, 1888 in Saros Bay, north Ageis.
Zoonatantia, 33-34.
Ate§ A.S., Kocata§ A. & Ozcan T., 2010. An updated list
of decapod crustaceans on the Turkish coast with a
new record of the Mediterranean shrimp, Processa
acutirostris Nouvel and Holthuis 1957 (Caridea,
Processidae). North-Western Journal of Zoology, 6:
209-217.
Bedini R., 2004. Gli animali delle praterie a Posidonia
oceanica : dai macroinvertebrati ai pesci. Bandecchi
& Vivaldi, Pontedera, 543 pp.
Crocetta F., 2007. First record of Maja goltziana D’Oli-
veira, 1888 (Decapoda, Brachyura, Majidae) in the
western Tyrrhenian Sea. Crustaceana, 80: 631-633.
D’Udekem D’Acoz C., 1999. Inventaire et distribution
des crustaces decapodes de TAtlantique nord-orien-
tale, de la Mediterranee et des eaux continentales
adjacentes au nord de 25°N. Museum National d’Hi-
stoire Naturelle, Collection Patrimoine Naturels 40,
Paris, 383 pp.
Garcia Raso J.E. & Jimenez Millan F., 1981. Algunas
species de decapodos (Crust.) del litoral malagueno.
Boletin de la Asociacion Espanola de Entomologia,
4: 19-24.
Henriksen C.S., 2009. Investigation of crustacean from
shelf areas in the Gulf of Guinea, with special em-
phasis on Brachyura. Master thesis, University of
Bergen, Norway, 71 pp.
Holthuis L.B. & Gottlieb E., 1958. An annotated list of
the decapod Crustacea of the Mediterranean coast of
Israel, with an appendix listing the Decapoda of the
eastern Mediterranean. Bulletin of Research Council
of Israel, 7B: 1-126.
Lewinsohn Ch. & Holthuis L.B., 1986. The Crustacea
Decapoda of Cyprus. Zoologische Verhandelingen,
230: 1-64.
Lelli S., Carpentieri P,, Colloca F. & Ardizzone G.D., 2008.
The spiny spider crab Maja goltziana (Crustacea:
Majidae) in south Lebanese waters. Marine Biodiver-
sity Records, 1, e83 doi: 10. 10 17/S 1755267207008676.
Manning R.B. & Holthuis L.B., 1981. West African bra-
chyuran crabs. (Crustacea: Decapoda). Smithson
Contributions to Zoology, 306: 1-379.
Pallaoro A. & Dulcic J., 2004. On the occurrence of the
spider crab Maja goltziana (Crustacea: Majidae) an
alien species in the Adriatic Sea. Journal of the Ma-
rine Biological Association of the United Kingdom,
84: 1007-1008.
Pastore M., 1977. Presenza di Thia scutellata (Fabricius)
e Xaiva biguttata (Risso) nel Golfo di Taranto (Mar
Jonio). Thalassia Salentina, 7: 83-90.
Pastore M., 1983. An Oxyrhynch crab new to the Ionian
Sea: Maja goltziana D’Oliveira, 1888 (Decapoda:
Brachyura). Crustaceana, 45: 232-237.
Pipitone C. & Arculeo M., 2003. The marine Crustacea
Decapoda of Sicily (central Mediterranean Sea): a
checklist with remarks on their distribution. Italian
Journal of Zoology, 70: 69-78.
Soppelsa O., Crocetta F. & Pipitone C., 2005. Maja gol-
tziana D’Oliveira, 1888 (Decapoda: Brachyura,
Majidae) in the Southern Tyrrhenian Sea. Crusta-
ceana, 78: 121-124.
Vieira C.M. & Morato T., 2001. First record of the crabs
Pirimela denticulata (Montagu 1808) and Xaiva
biguttata (Risso, 1816) (Crustacea: Decapoda) from
the Azores. Life and Marine Sciences, 18 A: 89-91.
Vignoli V., Caruso T. & Falciai L., 2004. Decapoda
Brachyura from Monte Argentario (Mediterranean
Sea, central Tyrrhenian). Crustaceana, 77: 177-186.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 285-300
No end in sight? Further new records of amphibians and rep-
tiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh
Province, Vietnam
Vinh Quang Luu 1,5,6 , Truong Quang Nguyen 2,6 , CuongThe Pham 2 , Kien Ngoc Dang 3 , Thanh NgocVu 4 , Sladjana
Miskovic 5 , Michael Bonkowski 6 & Thomas Ziegler 5,6 *
'Department of Wildlife, Faculty of Natural Resource and Environmental Management, Vietnam Forestry University, Xuan Mai,
Chuong My, Fla Noi, Vietnam; e-mail: qvinhfuv@yahoo.com.au
institute of Ecology and Biological Resources, Vietnam Academy of Science and Technology, 18 Hoang Quoc Viet, Hanoi, Viet-
nam; e-mail: nqt2@yahoo.com
Thong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Bo Trach District, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam
4 Faculty of Biology, Vietnam National University, Hanoi, University of Science, Department of Vertebrate Zoology, Zoological
Museum, 334 Nguyen Trai Str., Thanh Xuan, Hanoi, Vietnam; e-mail: thanhdouc@gmail.com
5 AG Zoologischer Garten Koln, Riehler Strasse 173, D-50735 Cologne, Germany; e-mail: ziegler@koelnerzoo.de
"Zoological Institute, University of Cologne, Ziilpicher Strasse 47b, D-50674 Cologne, Germany
’Corresponding author
ABSTRACT We report 1 1 new records of amphibian and reptile species and subspecies on the basis of
newly collected specimens from the UNESCO World Heritage Site Phong Nha - Ke Bang
National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam: Ingerophrynus macrotis, Limnonectes
gyldenstolpei, Babina chapaensis, Theloderma corticate, T. stellatum, Scincella rufocaudata,
Oligodon cinereus pallidocinctus, Parahelicops annamensis, Rhynchophis boulengeri,
Sinomicrurus macclellandii and Protobothrops mucrosquamatus. The record of T. corticate
from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park is the southernmost record generally known, that
of T. stellatum the northernmost record within Vietnam, and, most remarkably, the finding
of Limnonectes gyldenstolpei represents the first country record for Vietnam. In addition,
we report the second known specimen and the first adult male of Sphenomorphus tetradacty-
lus, a species recently described based on a single female only. At time, 151 species of am-
phibians and reptiles are known from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, including 50
species of amphibians, 12 species of turtles, 31 species of lizards, and 58 species of snakes.
In addition, an updated list of the local herpetofauna is provided, including recent taxonomic
or nomenclatural changes.
KEY WORDS herpetofauna; taxonomy; distribution; limestone habitat; Truong Son Mountain Range.
Received 7.04.2013; accepted 24.05.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park in the
Truong Son Mountain Range in central Vietnam is
known as one of the country’s most famous pro-
tected areas in terms of herpetofaunal diversity. Zie-
gler & Herrmann (2000) published a first,
preliminary list of the karst forest area's herpetodi-
versity, based on own fieldwork, collection-based
research and first Vietnamese reports, comprising
96 amphibian and reptile species. Four years later,
the total number of amphibian and reptilian species
known from the area as a result of further field work
was increased to 128 species (Ziegler et al., 2004).
286
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
In a third updated herpetofaunal list for the area,
Ziegler et al. (2006) reported of 140 amphibian and
reptilian species, demonstrating a still ongoing in-
crease in new species records. Ziegler et al. (2007)
published a comprehensive review of the snake di-
versity of Phong Nha - Ke Bang including nine for-
merly not yet recorded species, thus increasing the
total number of snakes known from Phong Nha -
Ke Bang to 59 species. Hendrix et al. (2008) pro-
vided an updated anuran list comprising 47 taxa
recorded for the Phong Nha - Ke Bang National
Park, in which five species were recorded for the
first time from that karst forest area. Recently, Zie-
gler & Vu (2009) published an updated checklist of
the amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke
Bang National Park with a total of 138 species, in-
cluding 45 species of amphibians and 93 species of
reptiles. The total number of recorded amphibians
and reptiles has decreased in this overview, because
several doubtful or unconfirmed records, e.g., men-
tioned in Ziegler et al. (2007) and Hendrix et al.
(2008), were removed from the list provided by Zie-
gler & Vu (2009), viz. Bombina maxima (Boulen-
ger, 1905), Eutropis chapaensis (Bourret, 1937),
Scincella rupicola (Smith, 1916), Sphenomorphus
buenloicus (Darevslcy et Nguyen, 1983), and Ma-
layemys subtrijuga (Schlegel et Muller, 1844). In
the years 2010 and 2011, additional herpetological
field surveys were conducted in Phong Nha - Ke
Bang National Park and extension area which re-
vealed the existence of a number of so far not re-
ported amphibian and reptile species. In addition to
the eleven new herpetofaunal records for Phong
Nha - Ke Bang National Park we provide an up-
dated list of amphibians and reptiles occurring in
this area.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Field surveys were conducted in the Phong Nha
- Ke Bang National Park area by Thomas Ziegler,
Thanh Ngoc Vu, KienNgoc Dang, and Sladjana Mi-
skovic (TZ and others) from June to July 2010, as
well as from 12th July to 2nd August, and from 12th
September to 1st October 2011 by Truong Quang
Nguyen, Cuong The Pham, Dai Van Nguyen, Hang
Thi An, and Kien Ngoc Dang (TQN and others)
(Figs. 1, 2). After taking photographs, specimens
were anaesthetized, fixed in 40-70% ethanol (am-
Figure 1. Map showing the location of Phong Nha - Ke
Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam.
phibians) or 80-85% ethanol (reptiles) and subse-
quently stored in 70% ethanol. Measurements were
taken with a digital calliper to the nearest 0.1 mm.
ABBREVIATIONS, a.s.l. = above sea level; SVL
(snout- vent length) = from tip of snout to anterior
margin of cloacal; TaL = tail length, from posterior
margin of cloacal to tip of tail; tenninology of mor-
phological characters followed Nguyen et al. (2012)
for amphibians and anuran webbing formula followed
Glaw & Vences (2007) (except for forearm length,
FAL = from axilla to elbow and hand length, HAL =
from base of outer palmar tubercle to tip of finger III),
Phung & Ziegler (2011) for lizards, and David et al.
(2012) for snakes. Specimens were deposited in the
collections of the Institute of Ecology and Biological
Resources (IEBR), Vietnam Academy of Science and
Technology Hanoi, Vietnam, Phong Nha - Ke Bang
National Park (PNKB), Quang Binh Province, Viet-
nam, and the Zoologisches Forschungsmuseum
Alexander Koenig (ZFMK), Bonn, Germany.
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 287
RESULTS
BUFONIDAE
Ingerophrynus macrotis (Boulenger, 1887)
Big-eyed Toad / Coe tai to (Fig. 3)
Examined material. One juvenile ZFMK
94263 collected by TZ and others during night time
in June 2010 in the leaf litter of karst forest near
Tam Co Cave, Tan Trach Commune, Bo Trach Dis-
trict and one adult female IEBR A.2013.7 (SVL:
58.7 mm) collected on 15 July 2011 by TQN and
others in Da Lat forest, Thuong Hoa Commune,
MinhHoa District (17°40.124’N, 105°55.031’E, at
an elevation of 3 12 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL of adult fe-
male 58.7 mm; head wider than long (HW 20.3 mm,
HL 18.7 mm); snout truncate, protruding, longer
than horizontal diameter of eye (SL 6.6 mm, ED 5.9
mm); canthus rostralis rounded, loreal region con-
cave; interorbital distance wider than intemarial dis-
tance (IOD 4.7 mm, IND 4.1 mm); nostril closer to
the tip of snout than to the eye (SN 1.7 mm; EN 3.6
mm); pupil rounded; tympanum distinct (TD 3.2
mm); parotoid gland 11.1 mm; vomerine teeth ab-
sent; tongue rounded posteriorly. Forelimbs: FAL
15.4 mm, HAL 30.1 mm; fingers free of webbing,
relative length of fingers: II<I V <I<III ; tips of fingers
rounded, without discs; dermal fringe along outer
finger absent; palmar tubercles distinct. Hindlimbs:
femur longer than tibia and foot length (FML 26.0
mm, TBL 24.4 mm, FTL 23.2 mm); toes long and
thin, relative length of toes: I<II<V<III<IV; tips of
toes rounded; webbing basal; tarsal fold absent, der-
mal fringe along outer toe absent; subarticular tu-
bercles present; inner metatarsal tubercle present
(IMT 2.4 mm), outer metatarsal tubercle small
(OMT 1.8 mm). Dorsal skin of body covered with
tubercles or warts in different sizes, those on head
smallest, few enlarged tubercles around vent.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal skin greyish
brown with some symmetrical darker markings on
snout and interorbital region; a V-shaped conversely
mark in front of shoulder and dark spots near mid-
dle of back; dorsal tubercles on body, limbs grey to
yellow; tympanum dark grey; upper lip with yellow
and grey flecks. Ventral skin and concealed parts of
limbs dirty greyish-yellow (determination after
Inger et al., 1999).
Distribution. In Vietnam, /. macrotis has been
recorded from Thanh Hoa, Ha Tinh, Thua Thien-
Hue, Da Nang, Quang Nam, Dak Lak, Lam Dong,
and Dong Nai provinces. Our finding represents the
first record for Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park
and for Quang Binh Province. Elsewhere, this
species is known from northeastern India, Myan-
mar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, and Malaysia
(Nguyen et al., 2009; Frost, 2013).
DICROGLOSSIDAE
Limnonectes gyldenstolpei (Andersson, 1916)
Gyldenstolpe’s Frog / Ech gin-den-x-ton-pi (Fig. 4)
Examined material. One adult male IEBR
A. 20 13. 8 collected on 14 September 2011 in the
evergreen forest, Hoa Son Commune, Minh Hoa
District (17°42.166’N, 105°47.957’E, at an eleva-
tion of 449 m a.s.l.)
Morphological characters. SVL 69.6 mm;
head longer than wide (HL 35.2 mm, HW 34.4
mm); snout longer than horizontal diameter of eye
(SL 12.7 mm; ED 7.2 mm); canthus rostralis
rounded; nostril directed laterally; loreal region
concave; interorbital distance broader than intemar-
ial distance (IOD 8.5 mm, IND 7.3 mm); nostril
closer to the tip of snout than to the eye (EN 7.1
mm; SN 4.7 mm); tympanum rounded, longer than
tympanum-eye distance (TD 7.4 mm, TEY 6.4
mm); vomerine teeth present; tongue notched pos-
teriorly; vocal sac indistinct in males. Forelimbs:
FAL 13 mm, HAL 32 mm; fingers free of webbing,
relative length of fingers: II<IV<I<III; tips of fin-
gers rounded, without discs; dermal fringe along
outer finger absent; palmar tubercles present; nup-
tial pad present in males. Hindlimbs: femur shorter
than tibia and foot length (FML 32.7 mm, TBL 36.7
mm, FTL 34.7 mm); toes long and thin, relative
length of toes: I<II<V<III<IV; tips of toes rounded;
webbing formula: Io(0)-(l)iIIo(0)-(l)iIIIo(l/2)-
(l)iIVo(2)-(0) iV; dermal fringe along outer toe ab-
sent; subarticular tubercles present; inner metatarsal
tubercle present (IMT 4.3 mm), outer metatarsal tu-
bercle indistinct. Dorsal skin of head smooth with
a swollen flap (10.6 mm length and 10.2 mm
width); dorsal surface of forelimbs, thigh and tarsus
smooth; supratympanic fold distinct, from eye to
shoulder; ventral surface smooth.
288
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
Coloration in preservative: head grey with a
cream broad stripe between eyes; dorsum brown;
dark dorsolateral spots; dark bars present on upper
surface of forelimbs, tibia and thigh; venter cream
with dark spots on throat (determination after Tay-
lor, 1962; Ohler & Dubois, 1999).
Distribution. The specimen from Phong Nha -
Ke Bang National Park represents the first country
record of Limnonectes gyldenstolpei for Vietnam.
Elsewhere, this species is known from Laos, Cam-
bodia, and Thailand (Frost, 2013).
Remarks. The male specimen differs from the
juvenile female in the description of Ohler & Du-
bois (1999) by having the tibia longer than femur
(TBL 36.7 mm, FML 32.7 mm versus TBL 11.6
mm, FML 11.7 mm).
RANIDAE
Babina chapaensis (Bourret, 1937)
Chapa Frog / Chang sa pa (Fig. 5)
Examined material. Two adult males IEBR
A.2013.9 and ZFMK 94258, one adult female
IEBR A.2013.10 collected on 14 September 2011
and one adult male ZFMK 94259 collected by
TQN and others on 16 September 2011 in the forest
near Cha Lo Village, Hoa Son Commune, Minh
Hoa District (17°42.213’N, 105°47.748’E, at an
elevation of 570 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL 43.0-46.0
mm in males (mean ± SE 44.2 ± 1.6, N = 3), 56.9
mm in the female; head longer than wide (HL 17.3-
20.4 mm, HW 14.9-18.0 mm); snout longer than
horizontal diameter of eye (SL 6. 9-7. 8 mm; ED 4.7-
5.6 mm); canthus rostralis rounded; nostril directed
laterally; loreal region concave; interorbital distance
narrower than internarial distance (IOD 3. 3-4. 5
mm, IND 5. 1-6.3 mm); nostril closer to the eye than
to the tip of snout (EN 2. 9-4.0 mm; SN 3. 5-4. 2
mm); tympanum rounded, longer than tympanum-
eye distance (TD 3. 9-4. 2 mm, TEY 0.3- 1.4 mm);
vomerine teeth present; tongue notched posteriorly;
vocal sac present in males. Forelimbs: FAL 8.8-10.3
mm, HAL 20.2-23.7 mm; fingers free of webbing,
relative length of fingers: II<I=IV<III; tips of fin-
gers rounded, without discs; dermal fringe along
outer finger absent; palmar tubercles distinct; nup-
tial pad present in males. Hindlimbs: femur shorter
than tibia and foot length (FML 21.4-25.2 mm, TBL
24.5-29.5 mm, FTL 24.1-29.2 mm); toes long and
thin, relative length of toes: I<H<V<III<IV; tips of toes
rounded; webbing formula: Io(l)-(l)iIIo(l/2)-
(2)iIIIo(l)-(2)iIVo(2)-(l/2)iV; dermal fringe along
outer toe absent; subarticular tubercles present;
inner metatarsal tubercle present (IMT 2. 2-2. 5 mm),
outer metatarsal tubercle indistinct.
Dorsal surface of head and dorsum smooth; dor-
solateral fold distinct; lateral sides smooth; a small
fold present along arm; ventral surface smooth. Col-
oration in preservative: head and dorsum light
brown with a cream vertebral stripe, edged in dark
brown, running from behind the eye to vent; poste-
rior part of dorsum with some dark spots; upper jaw
with a cream stripe, from below the nostril to axilla;
dorsolateral fold yellowish brown, edged in black
laterally; upper surface of tibia and thigh with some
dark bars; venter cream (determination after Bourret,
1942; Chuaynkem et al., 2010).
Distribution. In Vietnam, B. chapaensis has been
recorded from Lao Cai, Bac Giang, Ha Tinh, Kon
Turn, Gia Lai, and Dak Lak provinces (Nguyen et al.,
2009). This is the first record of this species from
Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park as well as from
Quang Binh Province. Elsewhere, this species is
known from Laos and Thailand (Nguyen et al., 2009).
RHACOPHORIDAE
Theloderma corticale (Boulenger, 1903)
Tonkin Bug-eyed Frog / Ech cay san bac bo (Fig. 6)
Examined material. Three adult males IEBR
A.2013.11, ZFMK 94262 collected on 2 1 July 2011
by TQN and others in Da Lat forest, Thuong Hoa
Commune, Minh Hoa District (17°39.032’N,
105°54.774’E, at an elevation of 516 m a.s.l.) and
PN-KB 2011.204 collected by TQN and others on
28 July 2011 in Cha Noi forest, Xuan Trach Com-
mune, Bo Trach District (17°37.758’N,
106°05.893’E, at an elevation of 470 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL of males
61.3-69.7 mm; head wider than long (HL 24.1-27.5
mm, HW 26.3-28.6 mm); snout longer than hori-
zontal diameter of eye (SL 9.0-10.0 mm; ED 6.2
mm); canthus rostralis rounded; loreal region con-
cave; interorbital distance wider than internarial dis-
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 289
Figure 2. Karst forest in Thung Hoa Commune, extension area of Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park. Figure 3. Big-eyed
Toad, lngerophynus macrotis. Figure 4. Gyldenstolpe’s Frog, Limnonectes gyldenstolpei. Figure 5. Chapa Frog Babina
chapaensis. Figure 6. Tonkin Bug-eyed Frog, Theloderma corticale. Figure 7. Taylor’s Bug-eyed Frog, Theloderma stel-
latum. Photos: T. Q. Nguyen & T. Ziegler.
290
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
tance (IOD 6. 1-6.5 mm, IND 3. 7-4. 4 mm); nostril
closer to tip of snout than to eye (SN 2.5 mm; EN
7. 1-8.3 mm); vocal sac absent; tympanum oval,
greater than tympanum-eye distance (TD 4. 0-4. 9
mm, TEY 3. 3-3. 9 mm); vomerine teeth present;
tongue notched posteriorly. Forelimbs: FAL 12.2-
14.8 mm, HAL 33.2-34.7 mm; relative length of fin-
gers: I<II<IV<III; tips of fingers and toes enlarged
into round discs; webbing present at base of fingers
III and IV; dermal fringe along outer finger present;
palmar tubercles distinct; nuptial pad present.
Hindlimbs: tibia longer than femur and foot length
(TBL 31.8-34.0 mm, FML 25.5-32.2 mm, FTL
27.8-30.5 mm); relative length of toes:
I<II<III<V<I V; webbing formula: Io(0)-(0)iIIo(0)-
(0)iIIIo(0)-(l)iIVo(l)-(0)iV; dermal fringe along
outer toe absent; subarticular tubercles present;
inner metatarsal tubercle present (IMT 3. 1-4.9
mm); outer metatarsal tubercle absent.
Dorsal surface of body covered with tubercles
or warts of different sizes, those on head and back
biggest; ventral skin with small tubercles. Col-
oration in preservative: dorsal colour olive-green
marbled with red-brown spots; dark brown bars
present on upper surface of fore and hind limbs;
ventral surface greyish yellow (determination after
Inger et al., 1999; Orlov et al., 2006).
Distribution. I corticale is currently known
only from northern Vietnam: Ha Giang, Tuyen
Quang, Cao Bang, Lang Son, Vinh Phuc, and Son
La provinces (Nguyen et al., 2009; Frost, 2013).
This is a new record for Phong Nha - Ke Bang Na-
tional Park and for Quang Binh Province as well as
the southernmost known record of the species.
Theloderma stellatum Taylor, 1962
Taylor’s Bug-eyed Frog / Ech cay san tay-lo (Fig. 7)
Examined material. One adult female ZFMK
94261 collected by TZ and others during night time
on a tree trunk nearby a forest stream and one adult
male IEBR A.20 1 3 . 1 2 collected by TQN and others
on 28 July 2011 in Cha Noi forest, Xuan Trach
Commune, Bo Trach District (17°37.649’N,
106°05.806’E, at an elevation of 517 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL 32.7-35.0
mm; head as long as wide (HL 13.5-13.9 mm, HW
13.6-14.0 mm); snout longer than horizontal diame-
ter of eye (SL 5. 3-5. 4 mm; ED 4. 5-4. 7 mm); can-
thus rostralis rounded; loreal region concave;
interorbital distance wider than intemarial distance
(IOD 3. 6-3. 9 mm, IND 2.0-2. 1 mm); nostril closer
to tip of snout than to eye (SN 1.6- 1.7 mm; EN 3.2-
4.0 mm); tympanum rounded, greater than tympa-
num-eye distance (TD 2. 2-2. 9 mm, TEY 1.0 mm);
vomerine teeth present; tongue notched posteriorly.
Forelimbs: FAL 7. 9-8.4 mm, HAL 17.5-17.9 mm;
relative length of fingers: I<II<IV<III; tip of fingers
and toes enlarged into large discs; webbing basal;
dermal fringe along outer finger absent; palmar tu-
bercles indistinct; nuptial pad present. Hindlimbs:
tibia longer than femur and foot length (TBL 17.6-
18.3 mm, FML 16.6-16.9 mm, FTL 15.6-16.0 mm);
relative length of toes: I<II<III=V<IV; webbing for-
mula: Io( 1 )-( 1 )iIIo( 1 /2)-(2)iIIIo( 1 )-(2)iI Vo(2)-( 1/2)
iV; dermal fringe along outer toe absent; subarticu-
lar tubercles present; inner metatarsal tubercle
present (IMT 1.3- 1.5 mm).
Dorsal skin of head and body, upper surface of
fore-arm, tibia, and tarsus, with tubercles covered
in whitish granular asperities; ventral s kin smooth.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head and body
brownish with cream speckles; black spots present
on snout and black marking present between shoul-
ders; upper surface of thigh, tibia, tarsus, and foot
with transverse dark bars; discs pinkish; chin and
venter dark brown with light flecks (determination
after Taylor, 1962; Inger et al., 1999; Orlov et al.,
2006; Nguyen & Nguyen, 2008).
Distribution. In Vietnam, T. stellatum has been
recorded from Kon Turn, Gia Lai, Dak Lak, Dong
Nai, and Kien Giang provinces (Nguyen et al.,
2009). This is the first record of the species from
Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park as well as from
Quang Binh Province, which at the same time is
the northernmost country record. Elsewhere, this
species is known from Thailand, southern Laos and
Cambodia (Nguyen et al., 2009).
SCINCIDAE
Scincella rufocaudata (Darevsky et Nguyen, 1983)
Red-tailed ground skink / Than lan phe-no duoi do
(Fig. 8)
Examined material. One adult male IEBR
A.20 13. 13 collected on 21 July 2011 by TQN and
others in Da Lat forest, Thuong Hoa Commune,
MinhHoa District (17°39.665’N, 105°55.800’E, at
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 291
an elevation of 448 m a.s.l.), 2 adult females IEBR
A. 20 13. 14 collected on 29 July 2011 by TQN and
others in Khe Ma forest, Thuong Hoa Commune,
MinhHoa District (17°3 9. 41 0’N, 106°03.592’E, at
an elevation of 300 m a.s.l.), and ZFMK 94256 col-
lected on 20 July 2011 by TQN and others in Hoa
Son Commune, Minh Hoa District (17°39.120’N,
105°59.678’E, at an elevation of 250 m a.s.l.) and
one juvenile ZFMK 94257 collected on 18 July
20 1 1 by TQN and others in Thuong Hoa Commune,
Minh Hoa District (17°40.057’N, 105°56.049’E, at
an elevation of 513 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL 45.5 mm in
the male, 45.9-47.2 mm in females; TaL 51.0 mm
in one female, regenerated or lost in others; snout
obtuse; rostral wider than long, nostril in the nasal;
frontonasal large; prefrontals separated from each
other; frontal longer than frontoparietal; parietals
large, in contact posteriorly; nuchals absent; supraoc-
ulars 4; supraciliaries 8; loreals 2; supralabials 7;
temporals 2 + 2, upper overlapped by lower one; in-
fralabials 6; ear-opening oval; lower eyelid with a
transparent window; midbody scales in 30-34 rows,
smooth; paravertebral scales 67-69; ventral scales
61-66; enlarged precloacals 2; limbs pentadactyl;
subdigital lamellae under fourth toe 15-20.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head and body
brown with a row of dark vertebral spots, a black
stripe present on upper part of the side; upper sur-
face of tail reddish; venter cream (determination
after Stuart & Emmett, 2006; Nguyen et al., 2011a).
Distribution. In Vietnam, S. rufocaudata is
known from Thua Thien - Hue, Quang Nam, Kon
Turn, Gia Lai, Dak Lak, and Ba Ria - Vung Tau prov-
inces (Nguyen et al., 2009). Records of this species
in northern Vietnam (Bac Kan, Thai Nguyen and
Vinh Phuc provinces) were reidentified as S. tonki-
nensis by Nguyen et al. (2011a). Elsewhere, this
species is recorded from Laos and Cambodia
(Nguyen et al., 2009).
Remarks. The red-tailed ground skink was trans-
ferred from the genus Sphenomorphus to Scincella
by Nguyen et al. (2011a).
Sphenomorphus tetradactylus (Darevsky et
Orlov, 2005)
Four-fingered skink / Than lan phe-no bon ngon
(Fig. 9)
Examined material. One adult male IEBR
A.2013.15 collected on 17 July 2011 by TQN and
others in Thuong Hoa Commune, Minh Hoa Dis-
trict (17°40.057’N, 105°56.049’E, at an elevation
of 513 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. Size small, SVL
36 mm, TaL 49.9 mm, tail tip lost; rostral wider than
high, in contact with frontonasal; frontonasal broa-
der than long; prefrontals small, separated from
frontal; supraoculars 4/4, first two in contact with
frontal on each side; loreal single; lower eyelid
scaly; external ear openings hidden with slightly re-
cessed auricular depression; supraciliaries 7/7, first
in contact with frontal; supralabials 6/6, third to fifth
8
9
Figure 8. Red-tailed Ground Skink Scincella rufocaudata. Figure 9. Four-fingered Skink Sphenomorphus tetradactylus.
Photos: K. N. Dang & T. Q. Nguyen.
292
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
below the eye; infralabials 7/7; nuchals 2/3; mid-
body scale rows 20; paravertebral scales 48; ventral
scales 51; enlarged precloacals 2; limbs very short,
forelimb tetradactyl, first shortest; hind limbs pen-
tadactyl; subdigital lamellae under fourth toe 9/10.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head and body
brown with longitudinal dark shapes along dorsum;
venter cream with brown spots; legs dark above with
indistinct black marks; free margins of upper and
lower eyelids not edged in white (determination after
Darevsky & Orlov, 2005; Nguyen et al., 2011a).
Distribution. S. tetradactylus is currently
known only from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National
Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam (Nguyen et
al., 2011a).
Remarks. S. tetradactylus was originally de-
scribed by Darevsky & Orlov (2005) as a member
of the genus Leptoseps based on the holotype
collected from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park.
However, Nguyen et al. (2011a) removed this spe-
cies from the genus Leptoseps to the genus Sphe-
nomorphus. This is the second known specimen and
the first reported adult male of the species.
COFUBRIDAE
Oligodon cinereus pallidocinctus (Bourret, 1934)
Guenther’s Kukri Snake / Ran khiem xam (Fig. 10)
Examined material. One male, PNKB S.0154,
collected by K.D. Ngoc in 2009.
Morphological characters. SVL 495 mm;
TaL 90 mm; maxillary teeth 16/16; loreal 1/1;
supralabials 8/8, fourth and fifth entering orbit;
infralabials 8/8; preoculars 2; postoculars 2; temporals
1/2+2; dorsal scale rows 17:17:15, smooth; cloacal
entire; ventral scales 3 + 167, subcaudals 42, divided.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head with a
grey chevron; dorsal surface of body yellowish
brown with 38 grey, black-edged bands on body, 6
bands on tail; ventral surface cream with dark spots
(identification after Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943).
Distribution. In Vietnam, this subspecies is
known from Thua Thien - Hue, Ba Ria - Vung Tau,
and Ho Chi Minh City (“Form IV” in Smith, 1943).
This is the first record of O. cinereus pallidocinctus
from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang
Binh Province.
Remarks. The male specimen differs from the
description of Smith (1943) in having more light
bands on body (38 versus 27-34) and more bands
on tail (6 versus 3-4).
Parahelicops annamensis Bourret, 1934
Annam Keelback / Ran binh mui trung bo (Fig. 11)
Examined material. Two males IEBR
A.20 1 3 . 1 6- A.20 13.17 collected on 23 July 20 1 1 by
TQN and others in Hoa Son Commune, Minh Hoa
District (17°42.612’N, 105°52.571’E, at an eleva-
tion of 537 m a.s.l.) and one female ZFMK 94255
collected on 16 September 2011 in Hoa Son Com-
mune, Minh Hoa District (17°42.208’N,
105°46.970’E, at an elevation of 641 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVF 358-430
mm in males, 455 mm in the female; TaF 165-177
mm in males, 102 mm in the female; head distinct
from neck; maxillary teeth 21/21; rostral flat,
broader than high; nostril in the nasal; intemasals
narrowed anteriorly; prefrontals 2/2, slightly
broader than long; frontal narrowed posteriorly,
about half the length of the parietals; loreal single,
elongated; preoculars 2/2, upper larger; postoculars
2/2; temporals 1 + 1; supralabials 8 or 9; fourth to
sixth (in one male) or fifth and sixth bordering orbit;
infralabials 10, first to fifth in contact with first chin
shield; first pair of chin shield shorter than second
pair, second pair divided by an elongated scale pos-
teriorly; body scales rows 19:17:17, median rows
strongly keeled posteriorly; dorsal scales on tail
strongly keeled, eight longitudinal keel rows at
base, decreasing to four rows distally; ventrals 167-
169; cloacal divided; subcaudals divided, 95 and
121 in two males, 51 in the female.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head with ir-
regular brown markings; a yellow stripe present
from posterior margin of eye to neck, continuing
onto body as broken dorsolateral stripe, being less
distinct posteriorly; tail iridescent yellowish-brown;
ventral and subcaudal surface cream, outer margin
of ventrals dark brown (determination after Bourret,
1936; Stuart, 2006; Ziegler et al., 2007).
Distribution. In Vietnam, the species is only
known from Da Nang and Kon Turn provinces (see
Stuart, 2006; Nguyen et al., 2009). This is the first
record from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park as
well as from Quang Binh Province. Elsewhere, this
species is reported from Faos (Xe Kong) (Nguyen
et al., 2009).
Remarks. P. annamensis was previously listed
as Amphiesma sp. by Ziegler & Vu (2009).
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 293
Rhynchophis boulengeri Mocquard, 1897
Rhinoceros snake / Ran voi (Fig. 12)
Examined material. Two males deposited in
PNKB.
Morphological characters. SVL 940-950
mm; TaL 350-360 mm; presence of a long pointed
nasal appendage covered with small scales; inter-
nasals much smaller than the prefrontals; frontal
narrowed posteriorly; loreal single, longer than
wide; preocular single; postoculars 2; temporals
2+3; supralabials 8 or 10, fourth to fifth or fifth to
seventh in contact with the eye; infralabials 11;
midbody scale rows 19, slightly keeled dorsally;
ventral scales 1 + 211 or 1 + 208; subcaudal scales
122 or 126, divided; cloacal plate divided.
Coloration in preservative: dorsum green, venter
paler; thin black stripe behind eye; interstitial skin
on the sides of the body bluish-black and white;
light stripes on subcaudal fold (determination after
Smith, 1943; Nguyen et al., 2011b).
Distribution. In Vietnam, R. boulengeri has
been recorded from the provinces of Son La, Thai
Nguyen, Vinh Phuc, Ha Noi, Quang Ninh, Hai
Phong, and Ha Tinh (Nguyen et al., 2009; Nguyen
et al., 2011b). This is a new record for Phong Nha -
Ke Bang National Park as well as for Quang Binh
Province. Elsewhere, this species is known only
from China (Nguyen et al., 2009).
ELAPIDAE
Sinomicrurus macclellandii (Reinhardt, 1844)
MacClelland’s Coral Snake/ Ran la kho thuong
(Figs. 13-14)
Morphological characters. Morphological
characters based on photographic record: vertebral
scales not larger than adjacent scales; subcaudals
divided; dorsal surface reddish brown with 3 1 black
cross-bands from behind head to tip of tail; head black
with a wide, white cross-band behind eyes; ventral
surface cream with black bands and black squarish
marks (determination after Ziegler et al., 2007).
Distribution. In Vietnam, this species is
known from Lao Cai and Cao Bang provinces in
the North southwards to Lam Dong and Dong Nai
provinces (Nguyen et al., 2009). This is the first
confirmed record for Phong Nha - Ke Bang Na-
tional Park. Elsewhere, this species is reported
from India, Nepal, Myanmar, Thailand, China,
Japan, Taiwan (Nguyen et al., 2009).
Remarks. S. macclellandii was mentioned as
unconfirmed record for Phong Nha - Ke Bang by
Ziegler et al. (2007) and thus was subsequently
removed from the herpetofaunal list of Phong Nha
-Ke Bang by Ziegler & Vu (2009).
VIPERIDAE
Protobothrops mucrosquamatus (Cantor, 1839)
Chinese Habu / Ran luc cuom (Fig. 15)
Examined material. One specimen was found
at night of 27 October 2009 by TZ and others in the
vegetation nearby a forest path in the Cha Noi
region and one male IEBR A.2013.18 (PN-KB
2011.51), collected on 16 July 2011 by TQN and
others in Thuong Hoa Commune, Minh Hoa Dis-
trict (17°40.405’N, 105°56.656’E, at an elevation
of 260 m a.s.l.).
Morphological characters. SVL 950 mm;
TaL 225 mm; head long, narrow; singe loreal pit;
supralabials 10; gular scales smooth; mental bor-
dering infralabial posteriorly; elongated subocular
scales, divided from supralabials; dorsal scales
strongly keeled, midbody scale rows 27; ventral
scales 3 + 216; subcaudals 98; cloacal undivided.
Coloration in preservative: dorsal head brown,
paler below; dorsum greyish brown, with a series
of large brown, dark-edged spots; ventral surface
cream, with light brown, light areas appearing as
squarish spots; dorsal tail light brown, with a series
of conspicuous black spots (determination after
Smith, 1943; Ziegler et al., 2007; Nguyen et al.,
2011b).
Distribution. In Vietnam, P. mucrosquamatus
has been recorded from Lao Cai, Ha Giang, Cao
Bang, Bac Kan, Lang Son, Thai Nguyen, Vinh
Phuc, Quang Ninh, Hai Phong, Hai Duong, Ha Noi,
Ninh Binh, Nghe An, Ha Tinh, Quang Tri, Thua
Thien-Hue, Kon Turn, and Gia Lai provinces
(Nguyen et al., 2009). This is the first record of the
species for Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park and
for Quang Binh Province. Elsewhere, this species
is known from India, Bangladesh, China, Taiwan,
and Myanmar (Nguyen et al., 2009).
Remarks. The male specimen differs from the
description of Smith (1943) in having more subcau-
dals (98 versus 76-91).
294
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
Figure 10. Guenther’s Kukri Snake, Oligodon cinereus pallidocinctus. Figure 11. Annam Keelback, Parahelicops anna-
mensis. Photos: K. N. Dang & T. Q. Nguyen. Figure 12. Rhinoceros Snake, Rhynchophis boulengeri. Figures 13-14. Mac-
Clelland’s Coral Snake, Sinomicrurus macclellandii. Figure 15. Chinese Habu, Protobothrops macros quamatus . Photos:
K. N. Dang, T. Q. Nguyen & T. Ziegler.
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 295
Check-list of amphibians and reptiles recorded
from Phong Nha - Ke Bang
Current check-list of amphibians and reptiles recorded
from Phong Nha - Ke Bang after Ziegler & Vu
(2009), including the herein listed new records (*),
additions (**) according to Ziegler et al. (2010),
Nguyen et al. (2011a), Hoang et al. (2012), and tax-
onomic reassignments (***) according to Blanck et
al. (2006), Stuart & Fritz (2008), Fritz et al. (2008,
2010), Inger & Stuart (2010), McLeod (2010), Yu
et al. (2010), David et al. (2011), Nguyen et al.
(2011b, ), Ohler et al. (2011), Rosier et al. (2011),
Kuraishi et al. (2012), Uetz (2013), Frost (2013),
Siler et al. (2013), and Patrick David (pers. comm,
to replace Amphiesma khasiense in central Vietnam
with A. boulengeri ); snake species which have been
previously listed but could not be confirmed as oc-
curring in Phong Nha - Ke Bang by Ziegler et al.
(2007) are excluded from the list: Typhlops diardi
Schlegel, 1839, Calamaria pavimentata Dumeril,
Bibron et Dumeril, 1854, C. septentrioncdis Bou-
lenger, 1890, Dendrelaphis pictns (Gmelin, 1789),
Lycodon septentrionalis (Gunther, 1875), Orthrio-
phis moellendorffi (Boettger, 1886), and Sibynophis
collaris (Gray, 1853).
AMPHIBIA
ANURA
MEGOPHRYIDAE
Brachytarsophrys intermedia (Smith, 1921)
Leptobrachium chapaense (Bourret, 1937)
Leptolalax aereus Rowley, Stuart, Richards, Phim-
machak et Sivongxay, 2010(***)
Ophryophryne hansi Ohler, 2003
Xenophrys major (Boulenger, 1908)
BUFONIDAE
Duttaphrynus melanostictus (Schneider, 1799)
Ingerophrynus galeatus (Gunther, 1864)
Ingerophrynus macrotis (Boulenger, 1887) (*)
HYLIDAE
Hyla simplex Boettger, 1901
MICROHYLIDAE
Kalophrynus interlineatus (Blyth, 1854)
Kaloula pulchra Gray, 1831
Microhyla berdmorei (Blyth, 1856)
Microhyla butleri Boulenger, 1900
Microhyla fissipes Boulenger, 1884
Microhyla heymonsi Vogt, 1911
Microhyla inornata (Boulenger, 1 890)
Microhyla marmorata Bain et Nguyen, 2004
Microhyla pulchra (Hallo well, 1861)
DICROGLOSSIDAE
Fejervarya limnocharis (Gravenhorst, 1829)
Hoplobatrachus rugulosus (Wiegmann, 1834) (***)
Limnonectes bannaensis Je, Fei et Jiang, 2007 (***)
Limnonectes gyldenstolpei (Andersson, 1916) (*)
Limnonectes limborgi (Sclater, 1892) (***)
Limnonectes poilani (Bourret, 1942)
Occidozyga lima (Gravenhorst, 1 829)
Occidozyga martensii (Peters, 1 867)
RANIDAE
Amolops cremnobatus Inger et Kottelat, 1998
Babina chapaensis (Bourret, 1937) (*)
Hylarana attigua (Inger, Orlov et Darevsky, 1999)
Hylarana guentheri (Boulenger, 1882)
Hylarana maosonensis Bourret, 1937
Hylarana nigrovittata (Blyth, 1856)
O dorr ana chloronota (Gunther, 1876)
Odorrana tiannanensis (Yang et Li, 1980)
Rana johnsi Smith, 1921
RHACOPHORIDAE
Chiromantis vittatus (Boulenger, 1887)
Gracixalus quyeti (Nguyen, Hendrix, Bohme, Vu,
et Ziegler, 2008)
Kurixalus banaensis (Bourret, 1939)
Kurixalus bisacculus (Taylor, 1962) (***)
Polypedates megacephalus Hallowell, 1861(***)
Polypedates mutus (Smith, 1940)
Rhacophorus annamensis Smith, 1924
Rhacophorus dennysi Blanford, 1881
Rhacophorus exechopygus Inger, Orlov et Darev-
sky, 1999
Rhacophorus kio Ohler et Delorme, 2006
Rhacophorus orlovi Ziegler et Kohler, 2001
Rhacophorus rhodopus Liu et Hu, 1960
Theloderma asperum (Boulenger, 1886)
Theloderma corticale (Boulenger, 1903) (*)
Theloderma stellatum Taylor, 1962 (*)
296
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
REPTILIA
TESTUDINES
PLATYSTERNIDAE
Platysternon megacephalum Gray, 1831
GEOEMYDIDAE
Cuora cyclornata Blanck, McCord et Le, 2006 (***)
Cuora galbinifrons Bourret, 1939
Cuora mouhotii (Gray, 1862)
Cydemys oldhamii Gray, 1863 (***)
Heosemys grandis (Gray, 1860)
Mauremys mutica (Cantor, 1842)
Ocadia sinensis (Gray, 1834)
Sacalia quadrioceUata (Siebenrock, 1903)
TESTUDINIDAE
Manouria impressa (Gunther, 1882)
TRIONYCHIDAE
Palea steindachneri (Siebenrock, 1906)
Pelodiscus cf. parviformis Tang, 1997 (***)
SQUAMATA: SAURIA
GEKKONIDAE
Cyrtodactylus cryptus Heidrich, Rosier, Vu, Bohme
et Ziegler, 2007
Cyrtodactylus phongnhakebangensis Ziegler, Ro-
sier, Herrmann et Vu, 2003
Cyrtodactylus roesleri Ziegler, Nazarov, Orlov,
Nguyen, Vu, Dang, Dinh et Schmitz, 2010 (**)
Gehyra mutilata (Wiegmann, 1834)
Gekko palmatus Boulenger, 1907
Gekko reevesii Gray, 1831 (***)
Gekko scientiadventura Rosier, Ziegler, Vu, Herrmann
et Bohme, 2004
Hemidactylus frenatus Dumerilet Bibron, 1836
Ptychozoon lionotum Annandale, 1905 (**)
AGAM1DAE
Acanthosaura lepidogaster (Cuvier, 1 829)
Calotes emma Gray, 1 845
Calotes versicolor (Daudin, 1802)
Physignathus cocincinus Cuvier, 1 829
ANGUIDAE
Dopasia gracilis G ray, 1845 (**)
VARANIDAE
Varanus salvator (Laurenti, 1768)
LACERT1DAE
Takydromus hani Chou, Nguyen et Pauwels, 2001
Takydromus kuehnei van Denburgh, 1909
Takydromus sexlineatus Daudin, 1 802
SCINCIDAE
Eutropis longicaudata (Hallowed, 1856)
Eutropis macularia (Blyth, 1853)
Eutropis multifasciata (Kuhl, 1 820)
Lygosoma boehmei Ziegler, Schmitz, Heidrich, Vu
et Nguyen, 2007
Lygosoma quadrupes (Linnaeus, 1766)
Plestiodon elegans (Boulenger, 1887)
Plestiodon quadrilineatus Blyth, 1853
Scincella melanosticta (Boulenger, 1887)
Scincella rufocaudata (Darevsky et Nguyen, 1983) (*)
Sphenomorphus indicus (Gray, 1853)
Sphenomorphus tetradactylus (Darevsky et Orlov,
2005) (***)
Tropidophorus cocincinensis Dumeril et Bibron, 1839
Tropidophorus noggei Ziegler, Vu et Bui, 2005
SQUAMATA: SERPENTES
TYPHLOPIDAE
Ramphotyphlops braminus (Daudin, 1803)
XENOPELTIDAE
Xenopeltis hainanensis Hu et Zhao, 1972
Xenopeltis unicolor Boie, 1 827
BOIDAE
Broghammerus reticulatus (Schneider, 1801) (***)
Python molurus (Linnaeus, 1758)
XENODERMATIDAE
Fimbrios smithi Ziegler, David, Miralles, Doan et
Nguyen, 2008
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 297
COLUBRIDAE
Ahaetulla prasina (Boie, 1827)
Amphiesma andreae Ziegler et Le, 2006
Amphiesma boulengeri (Gressitt, 1937) (***)
Amphiesma leucomystax David, Bain, Nguyen,
Orlov, Vogel, Vu et Ziegler, 2007
Amphiesma stolatum (Linnaeus, 1758)
Boiga bourreti Tillack, Ziegler et Le, 2004
Boiga guangxiensis Wen, 1998
Boiga multomaculata (Boie, 1827)
Calamaria thanhi Ziegler & Le, 2005
Chrysopelea ornata (Shaw, 1802)
Coelognathus radiatus (Boie, 1827)
Cyclophiops major (Gunther, 1858)
Cyclophiops multicinctus (Roux, 1907)
Dendrelaphis ngansonensis (Bourret, 1935)
Dryocalamus davisonii (Blanford, 1878)
Enhydris plumbea (Boie, 1827)
Liopeltis frenatus (Gunther, 1858)
Lycodon fasciatus (Anderson, 1897
Lycodon futsingensis (Pope, 1928)
Lycodon paucifasciatus Rendahl, 1 943
Lycodon cf. rufozonatum Cantor, 1842 (***)
Lycodon ruhstrati (Lischer, 1886)
Oligodon chinensis (Gunther, 1888)
Oligodon cinereus pallidocinctus (Bourret, 1934) (*)
Oreocryptophis porphyraceus (Cantor, 1839)
Orthriophis taeniurus Cope, 1861
Parahelicops annamensis Bourret, 1934 (*)
P areas carinatus Wagler, 1830
Pareas hamptoni (Boulenger, 1905)
Pareas macularius Blyth, 1868
Pareas margaritophorus (Jan, 1 866)
Psammodynastes pulverulentus (Boie, 1 827)
Pseudoxenodon macrops (Blyth, 1854)
Ptyas korros (Schlegel, 1837)
Ptyas mucosa (Linnaeus, 1758)
Rhabdophis chrysargos (Schlegel, 1837)
Rhabdophis subminiatus (Schlegel, 1837)
Rhadinophis prasinus (Blyth, 1854) (***)
Rhynchophis boulengeri Mocquard, 1897 (*)
Sinonatrix percarinata (Boulenger, 1899)
Xenochrophis flavipunctatus (Hallowed, 1860)
ELAPIDAE
Bungarus candidus (Linnaeus, 1758)
Bungarus fasciatus (Schneider, 1801)
Naja cf. atra Cantor, 1 842
Ophiophagus hannah (Cantor, 1836)
Sinomicrurus macclellandii (Reinhardt, 1844) (*)
VIPER1DAE
Protobothrops cornutus (Smith, 1930)
Protobothrops mucrosquamatus (Cantor, 1839) (*)
Protobothrops sieversorum (Ziegler, Herrmann,
David, Orlov et Pauwels, 2000)
Trimeresurus albolabris (Gray, 1842) (***)
Trimeresurus truongsonensis (Orlov, Ryabov, Bui
et Ho, 2004) (***)
Trimeresurus vogeli (David, Vidal et Pauwels,
2001 ) (***)
DISCUSSION
This study brings the confirmed species number
of amphibians and reptiles recorded from Phong
Nha - Ke Bang National Park to 151, including 50
species of amphibians (5 Megophryidae, 3 Bu-
fonidae, 1 Hylidae, 9 Microhylidae, 8 Dicroglossi-
dae, 9 Ranidae, 15 Rhacophoridae), 12 species of
turtles (1 Platysternidae, 8 Geoemydidae, 1 Testu-
dinidae, 2 Trionychidae), 31 species of lizards (9
Gekkonidae, 4 Agamidae, 1 Anguidae, 1 Varanidae,
3 Lacertidae, 13 Scincidae), and 58 species of snakes
(1 Typhlopidae, 2 Xenopeltidae, 2 Boidae, 1 Xeno-
dermatidae, 41 Colubridae, 5 Elapidae, 6 Viperi-
dae), see also fig. 16. An updated list, including
recent taxonomic/nomenclatural changes since the
last review by Ziegler & Vu (2009), is provided.
The research history of the herpetofauna of Phong
Nha - Ke Bang clearly shows that even after more
than a decade of very intensive herpetological sur-
veys, additional species can be recorded or even
discovered as new to science. Since the description
of the first herpetological discovery from Phong
Nha - Ke Bang, Cyrtodactylus phongnhakebangen-
sis by Ziegler et al. (2002), a series of new species
descriptions took place to date, amongst others
eight snake and four gecko taxa, to mention only
the most outstanding examples (see overview in
Ziegler & Vu, 2009). And we are aware of further
new discoveries to be described from the region in
the near future. This does not only underline the
importance of Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park
in a regional scale and the Truong Son Mountain
Range along the border between Vietnam and Laos
298
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
•^VVVVVV 0
Figure 16. Species richness of amphibian and reptile families from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park (new records are
marked by open rectangles).
in a wider geographical scale as centres of biodi-
versity and endemism, but also shows that longterm
biodiversity research is crucial for covering the
total species richness in tropical environment,
which is prerequisite for appropriate evaluation of
the conservation status and application of adequate
protection measures.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to the directorates of Phong Nha
- Ke Bang National Park for the support of our field
work and issuing relevant permits. We thank H. T.
An and D. V. Nguyen (Hanoi) and H. V. Nguyen
(Quang Binh) for their assistance in the field. Field
surveys in Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park and
extension area was supported by the Nature Con-
servation and Sustainable Natural Resource Man-
agement in Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park
Region Project with funding from the Vietnam-Ger-
many Development Cooperation. We also acknowl-
edge the World Association of Zoos and Aquariums
(WAZA) for the support of biodiversity research
and conservation in Phong Nha - Ke Bang National
Park (WAZA branded project 07011). Research of
V. Q. Luu in Germany is funded by the Ministry of
Education and Training of Vietnam (MOET, Project
322) and the German Academic Exchange Service
(DAAD). Research of T. Q. Nguyen in Germany is
funded by the Alexander von Humboldt
Stiftung/Foundation (VIE 114344). For discussions
about the taxonomic status of some snake taxa we
are grateful to Patrick David (Paris). Thanks also
to Anna Rauhaus (Cologne Zoo) for preparing the
plates.
REFERENCES
Blanck T., McCord W. P. & Le M., 2006. On the vari-
ability of Cuora trifasciata (Bell, 1825), the redisco-
very of the type specimen, with descriptions of a new
Cuora species and subspecies, and remarks on the
distribution, habitat and vulnerability of these spe-
cies. Chimaira, Frankfurt am Main.
Bourret R., 1936. Les serpents de Flndochine, II, Cata-
logue systematique descriptif. H. Basuyau, Toulouse.
Bourret R., 1942. Les Batraciens de Flndochine [Hanoi]:
Institut Oceanographique de Flndochine.
Chuaynkern Y., Ohler A., Inthara C., Duengkae P.,
Makchai S. & Salangsingha N., 2010. A revision
of species in the subgenus Nidirana Dubois, 1992,
with special attention to the identity of specimens al-
located to Rana adenopleura Boulenger, 1909, and
Rana chapaensis (Bourret, 1937) (Amphibia: Anura:
Ranidae) from Thailand and Laos. Raffles Bulletin
of Zoology, 58: 291-310.
Darevsky I.S. & Orlov N. L., 2005. New species of limb-
reduced lygosomine skink genus Leptoseps Greer,
Further new records of amphibians and reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 299
1997 (Sauria, Scincidae) from Vietnam. Russian
Journal of Herpetology, 12: 65-68.
David P., Nguyen T.Q., Nguyen T.T., Jiang K., Chen T.
B., Teynie A. & Ziegler T., 2012. A new species of
the genus Oligodon Fitzinger, 1826 (Squamata:
Colubridae) from northern Vietnam, southern China
and central Laos. Zootaxa, 3498: 45-62.
David P., Vogel G. & Dubois A., 2011. On the need to
follow rigorously the Rules of the Code for the sub-
sequent designation of a nucleospecies (type species)
for a nominal genus which lacked one: the case of the
r \
nominal genus Trimeresurus Lacepede, 1804 (Rep-
tilia: Squamata: Viperidae). Zootaxa, 2992: 1-51.
Fritz U., Gong S., Auer M., Kuchling G., Schneeweifi N.
& Hunsdorfer A. K., 2010. The word’s economically
most important chelonians represent a diverse species
complex (Testudines: Trionychidae: Pelodiscus). Or-
ganisms Diversity & Evolution, 10: 227-242.
Fritz U., Guicking D., Auer M., Sommer R.S., Wink M.
& Hundsdorfer A.K., 2008. Diversity of the South-
east Asian leaf turtle genus Cyclemys : how many
leaves on its tree of life? Zoologica Scripta, 37: 367-
390.
Frost, D.R., 2013. Amphibian Species of the World: an On-
line Reference. Version 5.6 (9 January 2013). Electronic
Database accessible at http://research.amnh.org/herpe-
tology/amphibia/index.html. American Museum of Na-
tural History, New York, USA.
Glaw F. & Vences M., 2007. A field guide to the amphi-
bians and reptiles of Madagascar. Third Edition,
Frosch Verlag, Cologne, 496 pp.
Hendrix R., Nguyen T.Q., Bohme W. & Ziegler T., 2008.
New anuran records from Phong Nha - Ke Bang Na-
tional Park, Truong Son, central Vietnam. Herpetol-
ogy Notes, 1: 23-31.
Hoang N.T., Ho A.T. & Hoang Q.D., 2012. New record
of Ptvchozoon lionotum Amiandale, 1905 (Squamata:
Sauria: Gekkonidae) in Phong Nha - Ke Bang Na-
tional Park, Quang Binh Province. Pp. 255-259 (in
Vietnamese). In: Hoang X.Q. et al. (Eds.), Proceed-
ings of the second National Scientific Workshop on
Amphibia and Reptilia in Vietnam. Vinh University
Press.
Inger R.F. & Stuart B. L., 2010. Systematics of Lim-
nonectes (Taylorana) Dubois. Current Herpetology,
29: 51-68.
Inger R.F., Orlov N.L. & Darevsky I.S., 1999. Frogs of
Vietnam: A report on new collections. Fieldiana:
Zoology, New Series, 92: 1-46.
Kuraishi N., Matsui M., Hamidy A., Belabut D. M.,
Ahmad N., Panha S., Sudin A., Yong H.S.Y., Jiang
J.-P, Ota H., Thong H.T. & Nishikawa K., 2012. Phy-
logenetic and taxonomic relationships of the Polype-
dates leucomystax complex (Amphibia). Zoologica
Scripta, doi:10.1111/j.l463-6409.2012.00562.x
McLeod D.S., 2010. Of least concern? Systematics of a
cryptic species complex: Limnonectes kuhlii (Am-
phibia: Anura: Dicroglossidae). Molecular Phyloge-
netics and Evolution, 56: 991-1000.
Nguyen Q.T. & Nguyen V.K., 2008. First record of The-
loderma stellatum Taylor, 1962 from Phu Quoc Is-
land, Kien Giang Province, southern Vietnam.
Herpetology Notes 1: 61-62.
Nguyen Q.T., Bohme W., Nguyen T.T., Le K.Q., Pahl
K.R., Haus T. & Ziegler T., 2011a. Review of the
genus Dopasia Gray, 1853 (Squamata: Anguidae) in
the Indochina subregion. Zootaxa 2894: 58-68.
Nguyen V.S., Ho T. C. & Nguyen Q. T., 2009. Herpeto-
fauna of Vietnam. Edition Chimaira, Frankfurt am
Main, 768 pp.
Nguyen Q.T., Le D. M., Pham T.C., Nguyen T.T., Bon-
kowski M. & Ziegler T., 2012. Anew species of Gra-
cixalus (Amphibia, Anura, Rhacophoridae) from
northern Vietnam. Organisms Diversity and Evolu-
tion, doi: 10. 1007/s 13 127-0 12-0 11 6-0.
Nguyen Q.T., Schmitz A., Nguyen T.T., Orlov N.L., Bohme
W. & Ziegler T., 2011b. A review of the genus Sphe-
normorphus Fitzinger, 1843 (Squamata: Sauria: Scin-
cidae) in Vietnam, with description of a new species
from northern Vietnam and Hainan Island, southern
China and the first record of S. mimicus Taylor, 1962
from Vietnam. Journal of Herpetology, 45: 145-154.
Nguyen Q. T., Stenke R., Nguyen H.X. & Ziegler T.,
2011c. The terrestrial reptilian fauna of the Biosphere
Reserve Cat Ba Archipelago, Hai Phong, Vietnam.
In: Schuchmann, K-L. (Ed.), Tropical Vertebrates in
a Changing World. Bonner zoologische Monogra-
phien, 57: 99-115.
Ohler A. & Dubois A., 1999. The identity of Elachy-
glossa gyldenstolpei Andersson, 1916 (Amphibia,
Ranidae), with comments on some aspects of statisti-
cal support to taxonomy. Zoologica Scripta, 28: 269-
279.
Ohler A., Wollenberg K.C., Grosjean S., Hendrix R.,
Vences M., Ziegler T. & Dubois A., 2011. Sorting out
Lalos: description of new species and additional
taxonomic data on megophryid frogs from northern
Indochina (genus Leptolalax, Megophryidae, Anura).
Zootaxa, 3147: 1-83.
Orlov N.L., Dutta S.K., Ghate H.V. & Kent Y., 2006.
New species of Theloderma from Kon Turn Province
(Vietnam) and Nagaland State (India) (Anura: Rha-
cophoridae). Russian Journal of Herpetology 13:
165-175.
Phung M.T. & Ziegler T., 2011. Another new Gekko
species (Squamata: Gekkonidae) from southern Viet-
nam. Zootaxa, 3129: 51-61.
Rosier H., Bauer A.M., Heinicke M.P., Greenbaum E.,
Jackman T., Nguyen Q.T. & Ziegler T., 2011. Phy-
logeny, taxonomy, and zoogeography of the genus
300
Vinh Quang Luu etalii
Gekko Laurenti, 1768 with the revalidation of G. ree-
ves ii Gray, 1831 (Sauria: Gekkonidae). Zootaxa,
2989: 1-50.
Siler C.D., Oliveros C.H., Santanen A. & Browne R.M.,
2013. Multilocus phylogeny reveals unexpected di-
versification patterns in Asian wolf snakes (genus Ly-
codon). Zoologica Scripta, doi: 1 0. 1 1 1 1/zsc. 12007.
Smith M.A., 1943. The fauna of British India, Ceylon and
Burma, including the whole of the Indo-Chinese sub-
region. Vol. 3-Serpentes. Taylor and Francis, London.
Stuart B.L., 2006. A second specimen of Parahelicops
annamensis Bourret, 1934 (Serpentes: Colubridae:
Natricinae). Hamadryad, 30: 167-171.
Stuart B.L. & Emmett D.A., 2006. A collection of am-
phibians and reptiles from the Cardamom Mountains,
southwestern Cambodia. Fieldiana: Zoology, 109: 1-
27.
Stuart B.L. & Fritz U., 2008. Historical DNA from mu-
seum type specimens clarifies diversity of Asian leaf
turtles ( Cyclemys ). Biological Journal of the Linnean
Society, 94: 131-141.
Taylor E.H., 1962. The amphibian fauna of Thailand.
University of Kansas Science Bulletin, 63: 265-599.
Uetz P., 2013. The Reptile Database, http://www.reptile-
database.org, accessed 31 January, 2013.
Yu G.-H., Zhang M.-W. & Yang J.-X., 2010. A species
boundary within the Chinese Kurixalus odontotarsus
species group (Anura: Rhacophoridae): new insights
from molecular evidence. Molecular Phylogenetics
and Evolution, 56: 942-950.
Ziegler T., Hendrix R., Vu N.T., Vogt M., Forster B. &
Dang N.K., 2007. The diversity of a snake commu-
nity in a karst forest ecosystem in the central Truong
Son, Vietnam, with an identification key. Zootaxa,
1493: i_40.
Ziegler T. & Herrmann H.-W., 2000. Preliminary list of
the herpetofauna of the Phong Nha - Ke Bang area in
Quang Binh province, Vietnam. Biogeographica, 76:
49-62.
Ziegler T., Herrmann H.-W., Vu N.T., Le K.Q., Nguyen
T.H., Cao X.C., Luu M.T. & Dinh H.T., 2004. The
amphibians and reptiles of the Phong Nha - Ke Bang
National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam. Ha-
madryad, Tamil Nadu, 28: 19-42.
Ziegler T., Nazarov R., Orlov N., Nguyen Q.T., Vu N.T.,
Dang N.K., Dinh H.T. & Schmitz A., 2010. A third
new Cyrtodactylus (Squamata: Gekkonidae) from
Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, Truong Son,
Vietnam. Zootaxa, 2413: 20-36.
Ziegler T., Ohler A., Vu N.T., Le K.Q., Nguyen X.T.,
Dinh H.T. & Bui N.T., 2006. Review of the am-
phibian and reptile diversity of Phong Nha - Ke
Bang National Park and adjacent areas, central
Truong Son, Vietnam. In: Vences, M., Kohler, J.,
Ziegler, T. & W. Bohme (Eds.): Herpetologia Bon-
nensis II: 247-262. Proceedings of the 13th Ordinary
General Meeting of the Societas Europaea Herpeto-
logica, Bonn.
Ziegler T., Rosier H., Herrmann H.-W. & Vu N.T., 2002.
Cyrtodactylus phongnhakebangensis sp. n., a new
bent-toed gecko from the Annamitic karst forest mas-
sif, Vietnam. Herpetofauna, 24: 11-25.
Ziegler T. & Vu N.T., 2009. Ten years of herpetodiversity
research in Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, cen-
tral Vietnam. In: In: Vo V. T., Nguyen D. T., Dang K.
N. & Pham Y. H. T. (Eds.). Phong Nha - Ke Bang
National Park and Cologne Zoo, 10 years of coope-
ration: 103-124.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 301-326
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Pro-
vince, central Vietnam
Liza Nemes 1 , Randall Babb 2 , Wa/ne Van Devender 2 , Khoi Vu Nguyen 2 , Quyet Khac Le 3 , Thanh NgocVu 4 ,
Anna Rauhaus 1 , Truong Quang Nguyen 5,6 &Thomas Ziegler 1,6 *
'AG Zoologischer Garten Koln, Riehler Strasse 173, D-50735 Cologne
2 Wildlife At Risk, 202/10 Nguyen Xi Street, Ward 26, Binh Thanh District, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
’Department of Anthropology, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309 USA
4 Faculty of Biology, University of Science, Vietnam National University, 334 Nguyen Trai Str., Thanh Xuan, Hanoi, Vietnam,
institute of Ecology and Biological Resources, Vietnam Academy of Science and Technology, 18 Hoang Quoc Viet, Hanoi, Vietnam.
6 Zoological Institute, University of Cologne, Ztilpicher Strasse 47b, D-50674 Cologne, Germany; e-mail: ziegler@koelnerzoo.de
‘Corresponding author
ABSTRACT Based on recent field surveys, we provide a first preliminary list of reptiles from Quang
Ngai Province, central Vietnam, comprising 35 recorded species, including 16 species of
lizards (Agamidae: 6, Gekkonidae: 2, Lacertidae: 1, Scincidae: 6, Anguidae: 1), 18 species
of snakes (Xenodermatidae: 1, Colubridae: 14, Viperidae: 3), and 1 species of turtle (Geoe-
mydidae: 1). The taxonomic status of Fimbrios cf. klossi from Quang Ngai needs further
examination.
KEY WORDS herpetofauna; taxonomy; distribution; Kon Turn Plateau.
Received 20.04.2013; accepted 08.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
According to the checklist of Nguyen et al.
(2009) 368 species of reptiles are known to occur
in Vietnam. In the following year 16 species were
added to the country’s reptile fauna (see overview
in Ziegler & Nguyen, 2010), thus increasing the
number of Vietnamese reptile species to 384. Since
then new country records and new species descrip-
tions of reptiles were regularly published from Viet-
nam (e.g., Nguyen et al., 2011a, b; David et al.,
2012; Nazarov et al., 2012; Luu et al., 2013), show-
ing that the Vietnamese reptile fauna is still little
understood. One of the most poorly studied regions
in terms of herpetodiversity is Quang Ngai Province
at the south central coast of Vietnam (Fig. 1). Only
recently, a first preliminary list of amphibians oc-
curring in this province has been published by Tran
et al. (2010) comprising 16 species of anurans.
Nguyen et al. (2009) listed only two terrestrial
reptile species with definite records from Quang
Ngai Province, i.e., the lizard Leiolepis guenther-
petersi, and the snake Oligodon ocellatus. We
herein provide a first preliminary reptile inventory
for Quang Ngai Province, based on recent field re-
search in particular in the evergreen forest in a tran-
sitional area between the Kon Turn Plateau and the
lowlands.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Preliminary field work was conducted by Quyet
Khac Le (QKL) and Khoi Le Vu (KLV) in the ever-
302
Liza Nemes et alii
green forest in the vicinity of Mo Nit Village, Son
Ky Town, Son Ha District, Quang Ngai Province,
Vietnam (14°51’N, 108°31’E, elevation 800 m
a.s.l.), from 12 to 21 July 2008 (Fig. 2). The survey
site is located in a transitional area between the
Kon Turn Plateau and the lowlands.
Additional surveys were conducted by Klioi Vu
Nguyen, Paul Moler, Randall Babb, Ab Abercrom-
bie, Chris Hope, and Wayne Van Devender
(hereafter KVN and others) in Ba To District, dur-
ing May and June 2011 (camp site 14°39’36.7”N,
108 o 36’27.0”E, elevation 750 m), in March 2012
(camp site 14°37 , 10.2 ,, N, 108°35’04.2”E, elevation
920 m), and from May to June 2012 (camp site
14°37’05.9 ,, N, 108°30’10.6”E, elevation 1,025 m).
The only specimens which were not collected at
the camps in the highlands are Hemidactylus fre-
natus (derive from human environment in low-
lands), Leiolepis guentherpetersi and Lygosoma
bowringii (collected at the beach east of Quang
Ngai), as well as Enhydris subtaeniata (fished in
lowlands). Specimens were photographed in the
field. A few individuals were collected by hand for
subsequent proper identification. Collected speci-
mens were anaesthetised and euthanized with ethyl
acetate, fixed in 80-90% ethanol and subsequently
stored in 70% ethanol. Specimens were deposited
in the following collections: Institute of Ecology
and Biological Resources (IEBR), Hanoi, Vietnam;
Zoological Museum, Vietnam National University
(VNUH), Hanoi, Vietnam; Zoologisches Forschun-
gsmuseum Alexander Koenig (ZFMK), Bonn, Ger-
many.
Taxonomic determination followed Pope
(1935), Smith (1935, 1943), Bourret (1936, 2009),
Gressit (1937), Taylor (1963), Musters (1983), Da-
revsky & Kupriyanova (1993), Murphy & Voris
(1994), Manthey & Grossmann (1997), Ziegler &
Vogel (1999), David et al. (2001, 2007), Ziegler
(2002), Leviton et al. (2003), Orlov et al. (2006),
Vogel & David (2006), Ziegler et al. (2006, 2007,
2010), Fritz et al. (2008), Rosier et al. (2008), Green
(2010), Grismer & Grismer (2010), Kams et al.
(2010), Nguyen et al. (2009, 2010, 2011a, b), and
Hartmann et al. (2013). Morphological characters
were given based on the recorded specimens, de-
viations from literature or in between literature
records were presented under remarks. Sex was
identified by examination of external characters
such as hemipenis swellings or through dissection
Figure 1. Map showing the survey site in Quang Ngai
Province, central Vietnam.
(inspection of gonads, retracted copulatory organs).
Scientific and common names (in English and Viet-
namese) as well as distribution records (except
otherwise noticed) followed Nguyen et al. (2009)
and David et al. (2011).
Measurements were taken with callipers to the
nearest 0. 1 mm. Dorsal scale row formula is given as
dorsal scales around body at one head length behind
head : at midbody : one head length before cloaca.
ABBREVIATIONS. HD = head depth at the
pari-etal region; HL = head length (from the pos-
terior edge of the comer of jaw to the snout tip);
HW = head width at the level of tympanum; O = di-
ameter of the orbit; SnL = snout length (from the
anterior edge of the orbital cavity to the snout tip);
SVL (snout-vent length) = distance between tip of
snout and vent; T = tympanum diameter; TAL = tail
length (measured from posterior margin of cloaca
to tip of tail; + = tail reduced or regenerated).
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
303
RESULTS
SQUAMATA SAURIA
AGAMIDAE
Acanthosaura lepidogaster (Cuvier, 1829)
Scale-bellied tree lizard; O ro vay
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2). One adult male collected by QKL and KLV
(ZFMK 94265), SVL: 74.1 mm, TAL: 119.6 mm);
one adult female coll, by KVN and others (IEBR
3277, SVL: 75.7 mm, TAL: 108.7 mm) (Fig. 3).
Morphological characters. Body laterally
compressed; head about 1 .5 times longer than wide;
snout shorter than orbit; frontal region deeply con-
cave; scales on upper head unequal, obtusely
keeled, much smaller in size in posterior region;
canthus rostralis and supraciliary edge strongly pro-
jecting; a spine present at the end of the super-
cilium; another one on the nape, mid- way between
the tympanum and the nuchal crest, with enlarged
scales at the base; ear opening distinct, visible;
supralabials 10-12; infralabials 11 or 12; gular sac
absent, gular scales strongly keeled, smaller than
ventrals; a strong oblique fold present in front of the
shoulder, almost extending across the throat; nuchal
crest composed of long, narrow, compressed spines,
with two rows of shorter ones at the base; dorsal
crest not continuous with the nuchal crest, forming
a prominent ridge, composed of broad, triangular
scales; dorsal scales very small, keeled, intermixed
with much larger, strongly keeled ones, upper scales
pointing upwards, lateral scales pointing backwards
and upwards, sometimes downwards; hind-limbs
reaching or almost reaching to snout tip; third and
fourth fingers equal or nearly so, fourth toe dis-
tinctly longer than third; femoral pores absent; tail
feebly compressed, subtriangular at the base, cov-
ered with equally keeled scales above, strongly
keeled and elongated scales below; ventrals as large
as the largest dorsal, strongly keeled (determination
after Smith, 1935; Ziegler, 2002; Bourret, 2009).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
olive grey or reddish brown, with light and dark lat-
eral marbling; a large dark diamond- shaped patch
on the neck, the rest of the head being light brown;
tail alternately barred with light and dark; belly
whitish, uniform, or spotted with black; for coloura-
tion in life see figure 3.
Distribution. Vietnam: from the Chinese
border southwards to Lam Dong, Binh Phuoc, and
Dong Nai provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
South China (Guangdong, Guangxi, Yunnan,
Fujian, Hainan Island), southern Myanmar, Laos,
Thailand, Cambodia.
Remarks. There are some discrepancies re-
garding morphological characters given in the lit-
erature. According to Smith (1935) the head is
shorter (less than one and a half time its width),
whereas Bourret (2009) mentioned the head being
1 % longer than broad. Smith (1935) stated that the
dorsal crest forming a prominent ridge, whereas
such feature is absent in the description of Bourret
(2009). Whether this is due to imprecise descrip-
tions, individual variation or points to cryptic taxa
within A. lepidogaster (e.g., Wood et al., 2010)
must be dealt with in detail elsewhere.
Natural history notes. The testicles of the
male measured 7.3 x 4.7 mm (left side) and 7.5 x
4.9 mm (right side).
Acanthosaura nataliae Orlov, Nguyen et
Nguyen, 2006
Natalia's tree lizard; O ro na-ta-li-a
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
3). One adult female collected by QKL and KLV
(ZFMK 94266, SVL: 120.1 mm, TAL: 212.1 mm);
one adult male collected by QKL and KLV (ZFMK
94267, SVL: 148.4 mm, TAL: 276.5 mm); one
adult male coll, by KVN and others (IEBR 3276,
SVL: 120.5 mm, TAL: 234.6 mm) (Figs. 4, 5).
Morphological characters. A large-sized
Acanthosaura , postorbital spine present; spine on
occiput between tympanum and nuchal crest absent;
both sexes with well-developed gular pouch; lateral
and dorsal surface of body with large keeled scales
intermixed with small scales; hindlimbs with het-
erogeneous imbricate scales intermixed with larger
scales; 2 or 3 distinct rows of papillary scales
present on the midline of belly (determination after
Orlov et al., 2006).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
brownish grey, reddish brown, or bluish; upper head
light or dark brown; orbital region blackish brown,
a dark stripe extending from behind the eye to the
tympanum; labial region lighter; tail with broad, al-
304
Liza Nemes et alii
temating dark and light bands; belly yellowish
white; for colouration in life see figures 4, 5.
Distribution. Vietnam: Thanh Hoa, Nghe An,
Quang Tri, Thua Thien-Hue, Da Nang, Quang Nam,
Kon Turn, and Gia Lai provinces (this is the first
record of the species from Quang Ngai Province);
elsewhere: southern Laos (Saravane and Xe Kong
provinces).
Remarks. Enlarged scales in the cloacal region
as described by Orlov et al. (2006) were not seen in
the specimens from Quang Ngai.
Natural history notes. A total of 8 small and
1 0 larger oocytes were found in the female (ZFMK
94266), of which the larger eggs measured 6. 5 -7. 9
mm (left side) and 6.6-8 mm (right side). Testicle
sizes in the male (ZFMK 94267) were 14.2 x 9.5
mm (left side) and 16.8 x 8.3 mm (right side).
Calotes mystaceus Dumeril etBibron, 1837
Blue-crested lizard; Nhong xam
Examined material. Specimens examined (n
2). One adult was photographed by RB (Fig. 6);
another adult female, collected by KVN and
others (IEBR 3278, SVF: 82.7 mm, TAF: 206 mm;
see Fig. 7).
Morphological characters. Body com-
pressed; head more than 1.5 times longer than wide
(ratio HF/HW=1 .8); snout distinctly longer than the
orbit (10.9 versus 8 mm); frontal region feebly con-
cave; upper head-scales unequal, smooth or keeled;
canthus rostralis and supraciliary edge sharp; postor-
bital spine absent; two short, separated spines present
on each side of the nape, the lower one separated
from the tympanum by 4 or 5 scales; a row of 3 or 4
enlarged scales between the eye and the tympanum;
tympanum diameter about half of the orbit (ratio
T/O=0.4); supralabials 1 1 ; infr alabials 10 or 11; gular
pouch small, gular scales strongly keeled, mucronate,
larger than ventrals; an oblique fold present in front
of the shoulder, covered with small granular scales;
dorsal scales strongly keeled, pointing backwards
and upwards, nearly twice as large as ventrals; scales
around midbody 54; limbs moderate; third and fourth
fingers nearly equal; fourth toe distinctly longer than
third toe; hind-limb reaching to the posterior comer
of orbit; tail feebly compressed, covered with sube-
qual, keeled scales; ventrals strongly keeled (deter-
mination followed Smith, 1935, compared with
Hartmann et al., 2013).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
greyish blue on body with six large chocolate-
coloured spots along the vertebral line; head brow-
nish, with thin dark lines radiating from the eye;
fold in front of the shoulder black; an eponymous
whitish stripe on upper lip extends from between
nostril and eye to the neck; tail pale blue; dirty
whitish below; for colouration in life see figures 6, 7.
Distribution. Vietnam: from Son Fa, Fang
Son, and Nghe An provinces in the North south-
wards to Kien Giang Province (this is the first
record of the species from Quang Ngai Province);
elsewhere: India, China, Myanmar, Faos, Thailand,
and Cambodia.
Draco indochinensis Smith, 1928
Indochinese flying lizard; Than lan bay dong duong
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1). One adult female collected by QKF and KLV
(ZFMK 94268, SVF: 110.7 mm, TAF: 205.5 mm)
(Figs. 8, 9).
Morphological characters. Body large; pata-
gial ribs 5; head moderate (HF/SVF 0.21 and
HD/HF 0.44); snout length 0.44 times of the head
length; snout longer than the diameter of the orbit;
nostrils directed almost straight upwards; ear
opening distinct; upper head-shields unequal,
strongly keeled, compressed and more or less
erected over the canthus rostralis; supralabials 10
or 11; two median teeth present on upper jaw; no
thornlike scale on the supraciliary edge, but a
rounded tubercle; gular appendage 0.76 times of the
head length, with enlarged scales; dorsal scales
173, unequal, smooth or faintly keeled, smaller than
the ventral scales; ventrals strongly keeled; a series
of enlarged scales present on the border between
body and patagium, widely separated from each
other, strongly keeled; subdigital lamellae under the
fourth finger 28 or 29, keeled, under the fourth toe
33-35; hindlimbs 0.5 times of the snout-vent length;
fore-limb reaching to beyond the snout, hindlimb
nearly reaching to the axilla; fringelike scales
present on posterior edge of thigh and on base of tail;
tail length 1.86 times the snout- vent length; ventrals
144, keeled, larger than dorsals (determination after
Smith, 1935; Musters, 1983; Bourret, 2009).
The colouration of the presereved specimen is
greyish or bronze and bluish above, with numerous
small black spots; wing-membranes reddish-brown
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
305
Figure 2. Primary forest in Quang Ngai Province, photo. Q.K. Le. Figure 3. Acanthosaura lepidogaster, adult female, photo
R. Babb. Figure 4. Acanthosaura nataliae, adult male, photo R. Babb. Figure 5. Acanthosaura nataliae, portrait of adult
male, photo Q.K. Le. Figure 6. Calotes mystaceus, uncollected adult, photo R. Babb.
306
Liza Nemes et alii
above, with four distinct, light-bordered, curved
transverse black bands which bifurcate as they
approach the body; ventral surface of patagium
with a black stripe along the outer margin; chin
spotted with black; throat blue, with a broad, black,
transverse bar extending to the inner sides of the
wattles; belly yellowish grey; for colouration in life
see figures 8, 9.
Distribution. Vietnam: Khanh Hoa, Kon Turn,
Lam Dong, Dong Nai, and Tay Ninh provinces (this
is the first record of the species from Quang Ngai
Province); elsewhere: Cambodia.
Remarks. The specimen from Quang Ngai
differs from the description provided by Musters
(1983) in some aspects: 10 or 11 instead of 8-10 su-
pralabials, 28 or 29 instead of 25 or 26 subdigital
lamellae under fourth finger, 33-35 instead of 29-
32 subdigital lamellae under fourth toe, 144 instead
of 123-129 ventrals, and 173 instead of 189-210
dorsals; however, it must be taken into account that
the description of D. blanfordii indochinensis in
Musters (1983) was based on only two specimens.
Natural history notes. The female contained
one egg on the left side (15.8 mm) and two eggs on
the right side (14.8-15.7 mm).
Leiolepis guentherpetersi Darevsky et Kupriya-
nova, 1993
Peter’s butterfly lizard; Nhong cat soc
Examined material. Specimen photographed (n
= 1): one adult was photographed by RB (Fig. 10).
Morphological characters. Identification of
the photographed specimen is based on character-
istic body shape and colour pattern (determination
after Darevsky & Kupriyanova, 1993; Nguyen et
al., 2009; Grismer & Grismer, 2010).
Distribution. Vietnam: Thua Thien-Hue, Da
Nang, Quang Nam, and Quang Ngai provinces;
elsewhere: this species is currently known only
from central Vietnam.
Physignathus cocincinus Cuvier, 1829
Indochinese water dragon / Rong dat
Examined material. Specimens photographed
(n = 2): two subadult to adult specimens were pho-
tographed by QKL and RB (Fig. 11).
Morphological characters. Identification of
the photographed specimens is based on character-
istic body shape and colour pattern, such as dorsal
scales small; distinctly enlarged scale row present
below infralabials; some scattered enlarged scales
present behind mandible; transverse skin fold
present in posterior gular region; nuchal, dorsal and
tail crests well developed; tail laterally com-
pressed; toes without distinct lobes (determination
after Ziegler, 2002).
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country (how-
ever, this is the first documented record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
Southern China, Myanmar, Laos, southeastern
Thailand, and Cambodia.
GEKKONIDAE
Cyrtodactylus pseudoquadrivirgatus Rosier,
Vu, Nguyen, Ngo et Ziegler, 2008
Pretended four-striped forest gecko; Thach sung
ngon gia bon vach
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
3): two adult males (IEBR 3270, SVL: 67.4 mm,
TAL: 54.7 mm; IEBR 3272, SVL: 65.4 mm, TAL:
6.5+ mm); one adult female collected by KVN and
others (IEBR 3271, SVL: 57.4 mm, TAL: 61.3 mm).
Morphological characters. A medium-sized
Cyrtodactylus ; lateral fold narrow, with enlarged
lateral tubercles; interorbital scales 34-45; tubercles
present on dorsum of head, body, limbs and tail;
dorsal tubercles in 18 to 20 rows; lamellae under
first finger 11-13, lamellae under first toe 11-13,
lamellae under fourth toe 18-23; ventral scales at
midbody in 39-46 longitudinal rows; precloacal
pores 7 or 8, in angular series in males, absent in
adult female; enlarged precloacal scales 8-11,
behind angular pore series; enlarged femoral scales
absent; femoral pores and a precloacal groove
absent; transversely enlarged subcaudals absent (de-
termination after Rosier et al., 2008).
Colouration of the preserved specimens: dorsal
surface brown, mottled in dark brown; neck band
medially interrupted; tail with dark and light bands;
for colouration in life (uncollected specimens from
Quang Ngai Province) see figure 12.
Distribution. Vietnam: Quang Tri, Thua Thien-
Hue, Da Nang, and Kon Turn (this is the first record
of the species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
this species is currently known only from Vietnam.
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
307
9
10
11
12
Figure 7. Calotes mystaceus, female, photo R. Babb. Figure 8. Draco indochinensis, adult female in dorsal view, photo Q.K. Le.
Figure 9. Draco indochinensis, adult female in ventral view, photo Q.K. Le. Figure 10. Leiolepis guentherpetersi, photo R. Babb.
Figure 11. Physignathus cocincinus, photo R. Babb. Figure 12. Cyrtoclactylus pseudoquadrivirgatus, photo Q.K. Le.
308
Liza Nemes et alii
Hemidactylus frenatus Schlegel, 1836
Common house gecko; Thach sung duoi san
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2): two adult males collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94660, SVL: 49.6 mm, TAL: 56 mm;
ZFMK 94661, SVF: 44.8 mm, TAF: 9.1+ mm).
Morphological characters. Head large;
snout obtusely pointed, longer than the distance
between eye and ear-opening; snout with large
scales, posterior part of head covered with small
granules; dorsum with small granules intermixed
with scattered, rounded tubercles; nostril sur-
rounded by rostral, first labial, and three or four
small scales; rostral distinctly broader than high,
quadrangular, with median groove; supralabials 1 1
or 12; infralabials 9; ear-opening oval, oblique, less
than half of the eye diameter; mental large, sub-
triangular; postmentals two pairs, well-developed,
outer pair slightly smaller than the inner; gular re-
gion with small granular scales; fingers and toes
free of webbing; lamellae medially forked, 4 or 5
(some missing) under the first toe, 10 under the
fourth toe; hind-limb not reaching to the axilla; tail
feebly depressed, oval in section, verticillate, dor-
sal surface covered with small scales and series of
six enlarged pointed tubercles; ventrolateral skin
fold absent; belly with smooth, rounded, imbricate
scales; ventrals in 35 and 37 rows; males with 28-
32 precloacal-femoral pores, in continuous series;
postcloacal tubercles 2; ventral tail with a median
series of transversely enlarged scales (determina-
tion after Smith, 1935; Manthey & Grossmann,
1997; Ziegler, 2002; Bourret, 2009).
The colouration of the preserved specimens
is greyish-brown above, with indistinct darker
markings; a bright line along the side of the head;
yellowish white below.
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country; elsewhere:
worldwide in tropical and subtropical regions.
Remarks. The examined specimens differ from
the description by Manthey & Grossmann (1997) in
the number of ventral scales (35-37 versus 28-36).
FACERTIDAE
Takydromus sexlineatus Daudin, 1802
Asian grass lizard; Fiu diu chi
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94659, SVF: 63.5 mm, TAF: 253.7 mm).
Morphological characters. Head narrow and
elongate, pointed anteriorly; nasals just touching
each other behind the rostral; fronto-nasal single, as
long as wide; prefrontals in contact with each other;
supraoculars 3, in contact with the supraciliaries, the
first two the largest, anterior in contact with poste-
rior loreal; supraciliaries 3; interparietal about half
the size of fronto-parietals, larger than the occipital;
anterior loreal smaller than the posterior; temporal
scales strongly keeled, upper ones bordered with
parietal, enlarged; fifth supralabial in contact with
subocular; chin shields 3 pairs, the first pair in con-
tact, third pair largest in size; collar indistinct; gular
scales 23, in a line between chin shield and collar,
scales on the anterior half of the gular region more
elongate and considerably smaller than those on the
posterior half; dorsal plates truncate and shortly
mucronate behind, in 6 rows across the nape, in 4
across the back; lateral scales small, more or less
granular, bordered above and below by larger ones,
10 in a vertical series between the dorsal and ventral
plates; tail very long; caudal scales as large as dorsal
plates, strongly keeled and mucronate; ventral scales
strongly keeled and mucronate, in 12 longitudinal
series; scales between collar and groin 29; a single
femoral pore present on each side; precloacal scale
single (determination after Smith, 1935; Manthey &
Grossmann, 1997; Bourret, 2009).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
brown to bluish-brown above, with metallic gloss;
a light, dorso-lateral stripe starting from above the
eye and extending on to the base of the tail, edged
above with black spots, below with a black line;
flanks with a series of white black-edged ocelli;
brown colour terminated half way down the flank
and bordered by a thin black stripe, starting from the
nostril to above the ear; upper head and tail brown;
venter and upper lip yellowish and bluish- white.
Distribution. Vietnam: from the Chinese bor-
der southwards to Dong Nai, Tay Ninh and Binh
Duong provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
India, southern China, Taiwan, Myanmar, Faos,
Thailand, Cambodia, Malaysia, and Indonesia.
Remarks. The specimen matches the description
of Smith (1935) except for only one pair of temporal
scales bordering the parietal being larger than the
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
309
others; also only the first pair of chin shields is in
contact in the examined specimen instead of the first
two pairs, as was mentioned by Smith (1935).
SCINCIDAE
Eutropis longicaudatus (Hallowell, 1856)
Long-tailed mabuya; Than lan bong duoi dai
Examined material. Specimen photographed
(n = 1): one individual was photographed by RB
(Fig. 13).
Morphological characters. Identification
of the photographed specimen is based on charac-
teristic body shape and colour pattern, such as
dorsal scales with two weakly developed longitu-
dinal keels; well developed limbs with five
fingers and toes each overlapping when laterally
adpressed to the body; ear opening immersed,
visible; supranasals present, touching each other;
postnasal present on each side (determination
after Ziegler, 2002).
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country; else-
where: Southern China, Taiwan, Laos, Thailand,
Cambodia, and Malaysia.
Eutropis multifasciatus (Kuhl, 1820)
Many-lined sun skink; Than lan bong hoa
Examined material. Specimen examined (n = 1):
one juvenile specimen collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94662, SVL: 39.5 mm, TAL: 33.1+ mm).
Morphological characters. Supranasals just
touching each other; fronto-nasal broader than long;
postnasal 1; anterior loreal as large as posterior
loreal; supraoculars 4, large; parietals divided by a
large interparietal; lower eyelid scaly, without disc;
supralabials 7, the fifth below the eye; infralabials
7; temporal scales smooth or feebly keeled; ear-
opening visible, moderately large, subcircular,
sunken, with small, pointed lobules anteriorly; nu-
chals in 1 pair; dorsal scales with 3, more or less
strongly keeled, lateral scales feebly keeled; scales
around the midbody 30; vertebrals between pari-
etals and tail base 45; digits moderately long, with
smooth lamellae, 19 beneath the fourth toe; limbs
well developed, hind-limb reaching to elbow when
adpresses along body; precloacals not enlarged (de-
termination after Smith, 1935; Manthey & Gros-
smann, 1997; Ziegler, 2002; Bourret, 2009).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
uniform olive -brown above; upper parts of flanks
dark brown with white spots; light dorso-lateral
stripe present.
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country; else-
where: India, China, Taiwan, Myamnar, Laos, Thai-
land, Cambodia, Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines,
and New Guinea.
Lygosoma bowringii (Guenther, 1864)
Bowring’s supple skink; Than lan chan ngan bao-ring
Examined material. Specimen photographed
(n = 1): one individual was photographed by RB
(Fig. 14).
Morphological characters. Identification of
the photographed specimen is based on characteristic
body shape and colour pattern, such as ground
colouration being brown above; each dorsal scale
generally with a darker spot forming more or less
continuous longitudinal lines; dark brown or black
dorsolateral stripe of variable thickness, edged in light
above; sides of neck and body usually thickly spotted
with black and white; white longitudinal stripe across
supralabials until ear opening; yellow below; sides of
neck, body and tail often red in life; fifth supralabial
longest, below the eye; ear opening subcircular, about
half as large as the eye, with one very small projecting
lobule anteriorly (determination after Smith, 1935;
Manthey & Grossmann, 1997).
Distribution. Vietnam: from Hai Duong Prov-
ince in the North to Kien Giang Province in the
South (this is the first record of the species from
Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: India, China,
Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, Malaysia,
and Philippines.
Scincella melanosticta (Boulenger, 1887)
Black-spotted smooth skink; Than lan co dom den
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2): one adult female collected by QKL and KLV
(ZFMK 94391 , SVL: 5 1 .3 mm); one adult male col-
lected by KVN and others (IEBR 3274, SVL 37.4
mm, Fig. 15).
Morphological characters. Size small, tail
regenerated in both specimens; prefrontals in contact
310
Liza Nemes et alii
with each other; supraoculars 4; nuchals absent;
supralabials 7; infralabials 6; primary temporals 2;
secondary temporals 2, lower one overlapped by
upper one; external ear opening present, without lob-
les on anterior margin; tympanum deeply sunken;
midbody scales in 34 rows; dorsal scales smooth, in
8 rows across the dorsum; paravertebral scales 67,
not widened; subdigital lamellae under fourth toe 14-
15 (determination after Smith, 1935; Taylor, 1963).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
bronze brown on back and dorsal tail base with a
row of large black spots; a dark stripe running from
snout to anterior comer of eye and from posterior
corner of eye to shoulder; upper lateral zone with
large black spots from axilla to tail base; chin with
some dark dots, throat and belly cream.
Distribution. Vietnam: Quang Binh, Lam Dong,
and Ba Ria-Vung Tau provinces (this is the first re-
cord of the species from Quang Ngai Province); else-
where: Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, and Cambodia.
Remarks. Specimens from Quang Ngai also
resemble S. rupicola, however, they were assigned
to S. melanosticta by having a higher number of
midbody scale rows (34 vs. 30) and vertebral row
of dark spots unpaired anteriorly (see Taylor, 1963).
Sphenomorphus indicus (Gray, 1853)
Indian forest skink; Than lan phe-no an do
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
3): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94663, SVL: 65.4 mm, TAL: 125.1 mm,
Fig. 16); one adult female collected by QKF & KLV
(ZFMK 94269, SVF: 75.6 mm, TAF: 56 + mm); one
subadult collected by QKF & KLV (ZFMK 94393,
SVF: 43.4 mm).
Morphological characters. Size large; nostril
in a big nasal; supranasals absent; prefrontals sepa-
rated from each other; supraoculars 4; loreals 2;
supraciliaries 8 or 9; lower eyelid scaly; primary
temporals 2; supralabials 7 or 8; external ear
present, with 2 or 3 small lobules on anterior margin;
tympanum deeply sunken; nuchals absent; midbody
scales smooth, in 30-34 rows; paravertebral scales
69, not widened; limbs pentadactyl; lamellae under
fourth toe 16-19 (determination after Smith, 1935;
Taylor, 1963; Ziegler, 2002; Nguyen et al., 2011b).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
bronze-brown above with irregular black dots; light
dorsolateral stripe present on neck and shoulder;
upper lateral zone with a dark stripe from behind eye
to tail base; lower lateral zone with light bars; ventral
surface cream; for colouration in life see figure 16.
Distribution. Vietnam: from Fao Cai, Cao Bang,
and Bac Kan provinces in the North southwards to
Dong Nai Province (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
India, Bhutan, China, Taiwan, Myanmar, Faos, Thai-
land, Cambodia, Malaysia, and Indonesia.
Natural history notes. The adult female con-
tained 17 oocytes, 0.5 -1.8 mm in size.
Tropidophorus cocincinensis Dumeril et Bi-
bron, 1839
Cochinchinese water skink; Than lan tai nam bo
Examined material. Specimens examined (n
= 3): three adult specimens collected by QKF and
TNV (ZFMK 94270, SVF: 87.5 mm, TAF: 81.6+
mm; ZFMK 94271, SVF: 76.3 mm, TAF: 73.3+
mm; ZFMK 94272, SVF: 73.4 mm, TAF: 1 14 mm),
see figure 17.
Morphological characters. Upper head-
shields strongly striated; frontonasal undivided;
prefrontals in broad contact, touching each other or
with a small azygous shield in between loreals 2
(posterior loreal fused with frontonasal on right side
in one specimen), separated from supralabials by a
series of small scales; superciliaries 7, superciliary
row not completed along the entire length of lateral
edge of supraoculars; supralabials 7 (8 in one
specimen), fifth largest, below the eye; infralabials
6-8; postmental undivided; nuchals in 3 or 4 pairs;
dorsals strongly keeled; paravertebral scales 41-44;
midbody scales in 30 or 32 rows; ventrals in 46 or
47 transverse rows; enlarged precloacal shields 2;
scale rows at position of tenth subcaudal on tail 14
or 15; dorsal keels on the tail forming strong ridges;
two series of moderately elevated spines along
middle of tail dorsum, continuous with those on
back; subdigital lamellae under fourth toe 18-20
(determination after Nguyen et al., 2010).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
reddish-brown above with indistinct black spots or
transverse markings on back; large white spots
starting behind the head, extending over the flanks,
paler on the tail, arranged in 1 or 2 longitudinal
rows; belly brownish- white.
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
311
Figure 13. Eutropis longicaudata, photo R. Babb. Figure 14. Lygosoma bowringii, photo R. Babb. Figure 15. Scincella me-
lanosticta, photo R. Babb. Figure 16. Sphenomorphus indicus, photo R. Babb. Figure 17. Tropidophorus cocincinensis,
photo Q.K. Le. Figure 18. Dopasia gracilis, photo Q.K. Le.
312
Liza Nemes et alii
Distribution. Vietnam: Quang Binh, Quang
Tri, Thua Thien-Hue, Da Nang, Quang Nam, and
Kon Turn provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
Laos, Cambodia, and Thailand (see also Nguyen
et al., 2010).
Remarks. One specimen from Quang Ngai
shows 8 instead of 7 supralabials. Compared with
the diagnosis of T. cocincinensis in Nguyen et al.
(2010), the Quang Ngai specimens have 3 to 4 pairs
of nuchals (versus 1-3), and the number of scale
rows at position of tenth subcaudal on tail is 14 or
15 (versus 13 or 14).
Natural history notes. The females (ZFMK
94270-94271) contained about 10-20 follicles of up
to 2.1 cm in size on the left side and about 13-20
follicles of up to 2.6 cm in size on the right side,
respectively.
ANGUIDAE
Dopasia gracilis Gray, 1845
Asian glass lizard; Than lan ran
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2): one subadult male collected by QKL and KLV
(VNUH 2008.7.10, SVL: 105.0 mm, TAL: 212.0
mm) (Fig. 18).
Morphological characters. Body cylindrical,
without limbs; ear opening 2 times greater than
nostril; nasal separated from frontonasal by 3 scales;
supraoculars 5; supraciliaries 6; supralabials 10, first
and second bordering nostril; infralabials 9; dorsal
scales strongly keeled; longitudinal scale rows
between lateral folds 18; number of scales along la-
teral fold 81-87; ventral scales in 10 longitudinal
rows; vertebrae from atlas to remnants of hind limb
bones 47 (determination after Nguyen et al., 2011a).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
brown or grey brown dorsally with longitudinal
series of small brown spots on anterior part of back;
two dark stripes present on each side of body:
dorsolateral stripe from one head-length behind ear
opening to tail tip, progressively broader poste-
riorly; ventrolateral stripe narrower but more
distinct than dorsolateral stripe, from angle of jaw
to vent, changing to a series of small spots on tail;
for colouration in life see figure 18.
Distribution. Vietnam: Cao Bang, Ha Giang,
Yen Bai, Quang Binh, and Quang Ngai provinces
(see Nguyen et al., 2011a); elsewhere: India, China,
Myanmar, Laos, and Thailand.
SQUAMATA SERPENTES
XENODERMATIDAE
Fimbrios cf. klossi Smith, 1921
Kloss' snake; Ran ma
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(IEBR 3275, SVL: 203.1 mm, TAL: 51.3 mm; Fig.
19), ratio TAL/TL: 0.25.
Morphological characters. Nostril in the
anterior part of a large concave nasal; rostral trian-
gular, not visible from above; suture between inter-
nasals shorter than that between prefrontals;
intemasals separated from rostral by a horizontal
skin fold; frontal broadly tmncate in front, broader
than long, as long as its distance from the tip of
snout, much shorter than parietals, about three times
as broad as the supraoculars; preocular small, just
touching the frontal; large quadrangular loreal in
contact with eye; postoculars 3; subocular 1; tem-
porals 5; supralabials 9 or 10, first 5 very small with
strongly raised edges, the last one more elongated;
infralabials 1 1 , first 7 very small with raised edges
like supralabials; mental absent; a pair of large chin
shields, in contact with the first ventral; dorsal scales
in 28 or 29 rows at anterior part of body; dorsal
scale rows: 28 or 29 : 30 : 31; interstitial skin partly
visible between anterior scales, scales feebly imbri-
cate posteriorly; ventrals 161; cloacal scale undi-
vided; subcaudals 62, unpaired (determination after
Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Ziegler et al., 2008).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
black above, brighter ventrally; edges of ventrals
and of subcaudals tinged with dark grey.
Distribution. Vietnam: Quang Tri, Thua Thien-
Hue, Kon Turn, Gia Lai, Dak Lak, and Lam Dong
provinces (this is the first record of the species from
Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: Cambodia.
Remarks. The collected individual differs from
previous descriptions (Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943;
Ziegler et al., 2008) by a lower number of infralabials
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
313
(11 versus 12), a higher number of temporals (5
versus 2-3) and subcaudals (62 versus 43-60), a less
developed scale imbrication, no mental shield, and a
different TAL/TL ratio (0.25 versus 0.126 to 0.2).
COLUBRIDAE
Ahaetulla prasina (Boie, 1827)
Oriental whip snake; Ran roi thuong
Examined material. Specimen examined (n = 1):
one specimen collected by KVN and others (ZFMK
94664, SVL: 584.3 mm, TAL: 319.2 mm; Fig. 20).
Morphological characters. Head shields
large; pupil horizontal; snout pointed, projecting,
without dermal appendage, snout more than twice
as long as eye diameter; canthus rostralis sharp;
nostrils lateral, not valvular; nasal in contact with
the labials; loreals 3, small; frontal followed by two
symmetric parietals of size equal to frontal;
preocular 1, in contact with frontal; postoculars 2;
temporals 1 or 2 + 2; supralabials 9, fourth to sixth
touching the eye, entire; infralabials 8, first 4 in
contact with anterior chin shields, shorter than the
posterior; mental groove present; dorsals smooth,
slightly keeled in the sacral region; dorsal scale
rows at midbody 15; ventrals 196; cloacal scale di-
vided; subcaudals 168, divided (determination after
Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Manthey & Gros-
smann, 1997; Ziegler, 2002).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
bluish-green above, with a yellowish-white line on
both sides of the ventral part; interstitial skin in the
neck region black and white.
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country; else-
where: India, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, Myanmar,
Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, Malaysia, Singapore,
Bmnei Damssalam, Indonesia, and Philippines.
Amphiesma boulengeri (Gressitt, 1937)
Boulenger's keelback; Ran sai bau-len-go
Examined material. Specimens examined (n
= 2): one subadult specimen collected by KVN
and others (ZFMK 94665, SVL: 107.2 mm, TAL:
46.6 mm; see Fig. 21); one adult male collected by
QKL and KLV (ZFMK 94273, SVL: 370 mm,
TAL: 179 mm).
Morphological characters. Nostrils lateral;
intemasals truncated; preocular 1; postoculars 2;
temporals 1+2, anterior at least twice as long as
posterior; supralabials 9, fourth to sixth touching the
eye, seventh to ninth very large; infralabials 9 or 1 0,
first five in contact with anterior chin shields; ante-
rior chin shields two-thirds as long as posterior pair;
outermost dorsal scale row smooth, remainder finely
keeled; dorsal scale rows 19 : 19 : 17; ventrals 140-
145; subcaudals 89-98, divided (determination after
Gressit, 1937; David et al., 2007).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
black dorsally; head brown above; anterior supral-
abials white, posterior black with a median elon-
gated cream colored streak, forming a postocular
stripe extending on the neck, followed by white
dorsolateral spots extending to the anterior part of
the tail; venter white.
Distribution. Vietnam: Vinh Phuc, Thua Thien-
Hue, Dak Lak, and Lam Dong provinces (this is the
first record of the species from Quang Ngai Prov-
ince); elsewhere: China.
Remarks. Both specimens differ from the
original description by Gressit (1937) in the number
of posterior temporals (2 instead of 1). The adult
specimen moreover shows a slightly lower number
of ventrals (140 vs. 143-147).
Boiga guangxiensis Wen, 1998
Guangxi cat snake; Ran rao quang Tay
Examined material. Specimen photographed
(n = 1): one adult specimen was photographed by
KVN (Fig. 22).
Morphological characters. Identification of
the photographed specimen is based on character-
istic body shape and colour pattern; single loreal;
postoculars 2; temporals 3 + 3; supralabials 8, third
to fifth touching the eye; dorsal scales smooth (de-
termination after Ziegler et al., 2006, 2010).
Distribution. Vietnam: from Lao Cai, Cao
Bang and Lang Son in the north southwards to
Dong Nai Province (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
southern China, Laos.
Calamaria pavimentata Dumeril, Bibron et Du-
meril, 1854
Collared reed snake; Ran mai gam lat
314
Liza Nemes et alii
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult female collected by KVN and others
(IEBR 3292, SVL: 231.1 mm, TAL: 18.6 mm;
Fig. 23).
Morphological characters. Head covered
with large shields; pupil round; nostrils lateral, not
valvular; rostral wider than high, partly visible from
above, 0.6 times as long as interprefrontal suture;
supranasals absent; frontal longer than broad,
shorter than parietals, 2 times wider than supraocu-
lars, followed by two symmetrical parietals; loreal
absent; preocular 1 ; postocular 1 ; temporal absent;
supralabials 4, second and third touching the eye,
second and fourth largest; first pair of infralabials
in contact with each other behind the mental;
mental groove present; chin shields in 2 pairs, in
contact with each other, anterior longer than poste-
rior; middorsal scale rows 13, smooth; tail pointed;
ventrals 151, more than twice as broad as adjacent
dorsals; ventrals and subcaudals without notches;
cloacal scale entire; subcaudals 20, divided (deter-
mination after Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Ziegler,
2002; Ziegler et al., 2007).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
reddish-brown above, with six dark dorsolateral lines
and three paler ones, consisting of small spots; neck
dark brown; belly yellowish; tail ventrally yellowish,
with a dark line medially across the subcaudals.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Lao Cai and Son
La in the West eastwards to Quang Ninh and south-
wards to Quang Nam, and Lam Dong provinces (this
is the first record of the species from Quang Ngai
Province); elsewhere: China, Myanmar, Laos, Cam-
bodia, Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Japan.
Dendrelaphis ngansonensis (Bourret, 1935)
Nganson bronzeback; Ram leo cay ngan son
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(IEBR 3287, SVL: 728.5 mm, TAL: 392.2 mm; Fig.
24), ratio TAL/TL: 0.35.
Morphological characters. Eye as long as
its distance from the nostrils; pupil round; nostrils
lateral, not valvular; rostral much broader than
high, visible from above; intemasals a little shorter
than prefrontals; frontal 1.4 times longer than
broad, as long as its distance from the tip of snout,
shorter than symmetrical parietals; loreal elon-
gated; preocular 1; postoculars 2; temporals 2 + 2;
supralabials 9, fourth to sixth touching the eye; first
five infralabials in contact with anterior chin
shields, anterior chin shields shorter than the pos-
terior; dorsals smooth, dorsal scale rows 15:15:
1 1 ; vertebral scales enlarged, variable in width, not
broader than the outermost scale row at midbody,
posterior margin rounded; ventrals 177, keeled;
cloacal scale divided; subcaudals 148, divided (de-
termination after Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Zie-
gler & Vogel, 1999; Ziegler, 2002).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
bluish and bronze-brown above; interstitial skin
black and white; dorsal head bronze brown; a black
stripe present along the side of the head, strongly
marked on the temple and extending to the neck;
supralabials yellow; cream below; for colouration
in life see figures 24, 25.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Ha Giang and
Cao Bang provinces in the North southwards to
Quang Nam Province (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
Laos (Xieng Khouang Province).
Enhydris subtaeniata (Bourret, 1934)
Mekong mud snake; Ran bong me-kong
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult collected by KVN and others (IEBR
3289, SVL: 300 mm, TAL: 56.6 mm; Fig. 26), ratio
TAL/TL: 0.16.
Morphological characters. Body stout;
snout blunt, squarish; nasals contiguous; intemasal
2 times wider than long, in contact with triangular
loreal (loreal divided on left side); preocular 1;
postoculars 2; temporals 1+2; supralabials 8,
fourth in contact with eye; infralabials 3, in contact
with anterior chin shields; posterior pair of chin
shields longer than anterior pair, separated from
each other by small scales; dorsal scale rows 2 1 :
21 : 21; ventrals 143; subcaudals 45, divided (de-
termination after Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Mur-
phy & Voris, 1994; Kams et al., 2010).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
olive-grey above, with indistinct blackish spots;
ventrals and 3 outer scale rows yellowish; outer
margins of the ventrals and adjacent scale-rows
heavily margined with dark grey; a series of dark
spots forming a median ventral line at the posterior
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
315
19
20
21 22
23
24
Figure 19. Fimbrios cf. klossi, photo R. Babb. Figure 20. Ahaetulla prasina, photo R. Babb. Figure 21 . Amphiesma boulen-
geri, juvenile, photo R. Babb. Figure 22. Boiga guangxiensis, adult, photo K.V. Nguyen. Figure 23. Calamaria pavimentata,
photo R. Babb. Figure 24. Dendrelaphis ngansonensis, photo R. Babb.
316
Liza Nemes et alii
part of the body; a darker, continuous line medially
across the subcaudals.
Distribution. Vietnam: Kon Turn, Tay Ninh,
Ho Chi Minh City, Soc Trang, Kien Giang, and Ca
Mau provinces (this is the first record of the species
from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: Laos, Thai-
land, and Cambodia.
Remarks. Murphy (2007) revalidated Enhydris
subtaeniata, which was originally described as a
subspecies of E. enhydris (Bourret, 1934) and sub-
sequently synonymized with E. jagorii by Smith
(1943). According to Nguyen et al. (2009),
previous records of E. jagorii from Vietnam and
neighbouring countries should be assigned to E.
subtaeniata.
Oligodon chinensis (Gunther, 1888)
Chinese kukri snake; Ran khiem trung quoc
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2): one adult male collected by QKL and KLV
(ZFMK 94274, SVL: 514.2 mm, TAL: 115.7 mm);
one adult male collected by KVN and others (ZFMK
94672, SVF: 557.6 mm, TAF: 126.2 mm, Fig. 27).
Morphological characters. Nasal divided;
internasals 2; rostral partly visible from above, as
long as its distance from frontal; suture of inter-
nasals shorter than sutures of prefrontals; frontal
longer than its distance to the tip of snout, as long
as parietals; loreal somewhat longer than broad;
preocular 1; postoculars 2; subocular 1, temporals
1+2; supralabials 7 or 8, fourth and fifth touching
the eye; infralabials 8 or 9, fourth in contact with
anterior chin shields; anterior pair of chin shields
longer than posterior ones; dorsal scale rows 17 :
17 : 15; ventrals 170 or 172; cloacal scale undi-
vided; subcaudals 58 or 59 (determination after Bour-
ret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Ziegler, 2002; Green, 2010).
The colouration of the preserved specimens is
reddish-brown dorsally; with dark, rounded
blotches; blotches on the back with dark margins,
occupying about 3 to 4 scale rows along the
vertebral line, descending laterally; several similar
spots on the tail; the darker edges of the scales
between these spots forming less visible equidi-
stant fasciatures in each section; head olive brown
with a dark brown stripe across the eyes, edged in
black, running upwards to the posterior end of the
rostral and the upper lip; a long arrowhead-shaped
dark brown spot, edged in black, tip of arrow at
the posterior third of the frontal, the two rear ends
extending to the side of the neck, almost up to the
ventrals; temporal bars absent; ventral surface
white, with a longitudinal row of quadrangular
black blotches forming along each side, disappear-
ing gradually at the tail base.
Distribution. Vietnam: Fao Cai, Bac Kan,
Fang Son, Vinh Phuc, Quang Ninh, Hai Phong, Hai
Duong, Nghe An, Ha Tinh, Quang Binh, and Gia
Fai provinces (this is the first record of the species
from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: China.
P areas hamptoni (Boulenger, 1905)
Hampton's slug snake; Ran ho may ham-ton
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94666, SVF: 317.2 mm, TAF: 110.1 mm;
Fig. 28), ratio TAF/TF: 0.26.
Morphological characters. Body elongated,
strongly compressed; pupil vertical; snout short;
rostral wider than high, visible from above; intema-
sals about 0.6 times as long as prefrontals; prefron-
tals touching the eye; frontal somewhat longer than
broad, longer than its distance from the snout tip;
supraocular about half as wide as frontal; nasal
complete; loreal small, higher than long, separated
from the eye by 1 or 2 small preoculars; postocular
1, small; subocular 1, long and slender, separating
the eye from the labials; temporals 2 + 3, anterior
larger than posterior ones; supralabials 7, fourth and
fifth below the eye, seventh very long; mental
groove absent; chin shields in 3 pairs, large, anterior
ones longer than wide; dorsal scales smooth, 15
rows at midbody; ventrals 189, more than 2 times as
broad as adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale undivided;
subcaudals 78, divided (determination after Bourret,
1936; Smith, 1943; Ziegler, 2002).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
light brown dorsally, with dorsolateral rows of
alternating spots, forming a zigzag line, spots absent
at the margin of the ventrals, not more than 2 scales
in length; two parallel brown lines, starting from the
posterior part of the supraoculars, bordering the
head and ending at the nape; two other bands from
behind the parietals forming a X on the neck; a few
larger spots forming a stripe from the eye to the oral
commissure.
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
317
Distribution. Vietnam: Lao Cai, Ha Giang, Bac
Kan, Thai Nguyen, Vinh Phuc, Hai Duong, Ha Tinh
southwards to Lam Dong and Dong Nai provinces
(this is the first record of the species from Quang
Ngai Province); elsewhere: China, Myanmar, Laos,
and Cambodia.
Remarks. In contrast to Bourret (1936) and
Smith (1943), the vertebral scales of the examined
specimen are not enlarged.
P areas margaritophorus (Jan, 1866)
White-spotted slug snake; Ran ho may ngoc
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(IEBR 3294, SVL: 219.9 mm, TAL: 60 mm; Fig.
29), ratio TAL/TL: 0.21.
Morphological characters. Eye moderate,
diameter equal to its distance from the mouth;
preocular 1, triangular; postocular 1; subocular 1,
long, crescentic, united with postocular on left side;
temporals 2 or 3 + 1 , elongated; supralabials 7, not
touching the eye, fourth and fifth below the eye;
infralabials 7; chin shields in 4 pairs, large; dorsal
scale rows 15 at midbody, smooth, equal; vertebrals
not enlarged; ventrals 144, more than twice as broad
as adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale undivided;
subcaudals 55, divided (determination after Bour-
ret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Manthey & Grossmann,
1997; Ziegler, 2002).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
dark grey above with irregular transverse rows of
black and white blotches, the scales white ante-
riorly and posteriorly; a white nuchal collar
present; ventral surface yellowish white, densely
spotted with black.
Remarks. In contrast to the description of Bour-
ret (1936), the specimen shows only 1 + 1 tempo-
rals on one side instead of 2 + 3, 4 pairs of chin
shields instead of 3 pairs.
Distribution. Vietnam: Vinh Phuc, Hai Duong,
Hoa Binh, Ha Tay, Ninh Binh, Ha Tinh, Quang
Binh, Quang Tri, Gia Lai, Lam Dong, Tay Ninh, Ho
Chi Minh City, and Kien Giang provinces (this is
the first record of the species from Quang Ngai
Province); elsewhere: China, Myanmar, Laos, Thai-
land, Cambodia, and Malaysia.
Pseudoxenodon macrops (Blyth, 1854)
Big-eyed bamboo snake; Ran ho xien mat to
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(IEBR 3300, SVL mm: 587, TAL: 127.1 mm;
Fig. 30).
Morphological characters. Nostril large,
between two nasals; rostral slightly visible from
above; suture between internasals half as long as
suture between prefrontals; frontal 1.3 times longer
than broad, shorter than its distance from the snout
tip, shorter than parietals; loreal large, longer than
high; preocular 1, not touching the frontal; pos-
toculars 3; temporals 2 + 2 or 3; supralabials 8,
fourth and fifth in contact with the eye, seventh
highest; infralabials 9, first five in contact with
anterior chin shields; first pair of chin shields a little
shorter than the posterior; dorsal scales strongly
keeled except the outermost row, scale rows 19:17
: 15; ventrals 151; cloacal scale divided; subcaudals
63, divided (determination after Bourret, 1936;
Smith, 1943; Manthey & Grossmann, 1997).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
greyish-brown and reddish-brown above, with a
vertebral series of large, pale-orange spots, edged
in black, extending over the whole body and tail;
neck with a yellowish white, chevron-shaped mark,
the tip pointing forward; ventral surface yellowish-
white, with large, blackish-brown, quadrangular
blotches anteriorly, blotches paler posteriorly.
Distribution. Vietnam: Lai Chau, Lao Cai,
Vinh Phuc, Nghe An, Ha Tinh, Quang Binh, Da
Nang, Kon Turn, and Lam Dong provinces (this is
the first record of the species from Quang Ngai
Province); elsewhere: India, Nepal, China, Myan-
mar, Laos, Thailand, and Malaysia.
Rhabdophis subminiatus (Schlegel, 1837)
Red-necked keelback; Ran hoa co nho
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult female collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94667, SVL: 494.9 mm, TAL: 48.6 mm;
Fig. 31), TAL/TL: 0.1.
Morphological characters. Body rather
stout; eye large; pupil round; nostrils lateral, not
valvular; mental groove present; rostral 2 times as
wide as high, visible from above; intemasals con-
joint, a little broader than long, truncated at the
318
Liza Nemes et alii
front, shorter than prefrontals; frontal 1.4 times
longer than wide, longer than its distance from the
snout tip, shorter than parietals; loreal as high as
long; preocular 1; postoculars 3; temporals 2 + 3;
supralabials 8, third to fifth touching the eye, se-
venth largest; infralabials 10, first 5 in contact with
anterior chin shields, anterior chin shields a little
shorter than posterior; dorsal scales in 19 rows at
midbody, strongly keeled, the outermost row
smooth; ventrals 161, more than twice as broad as
adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale divided; subcaudals
23 (tail tip lost), divided (determination after Bour-
ret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Manthey & Grossmann,
1997; Ziegler, 2002; Ziegler et al., 2007).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
bluish above, head and neck greenish; body with
white, transverse spots; a black oblique bar radiated
from below the eye; venter yellowish anteriorly,
strongly spotted posteriorly.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Cao Bang Prov-
ince in the North westwards to Lao Cai and Son
La provinces, eastwards to Quang Ninh and south-
wards to Tay Ninh, Ho Chi Minh City, and Kien
Giang provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
India, Bangladesh, Nepal, Bhutan, China, Myan-
mar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, Malaysia, Singa-
pore, and Indonesia.
Sibynophis collaris (Gray, 1853)
Common black-headed snake; Ran rong co den
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one male specimen collected by KVN and
others (ZFMK 94668, SVL: 360 mm, TAL: 72
mm, Fig. 32).
Morphological characters. Preocular single,
postoculars 2; loreal 1; fourth to sixth supralabials
entering orbit, eighth very large, in contact with
anterior temporal; temporals 1+2, lower posterior
one divided vertically; parietal touching upper
postocular only; dorsal scales smooth, in 17 rows
at midbody; cloacal undivided (determination after
Pope, 1935; Smith, 1943; Ziegler et al., 2007).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
greyish brown dorsally; venter whitish cream with
a black dot on the edge of each ventral; head olive
grey with dark markings in the snout region and two
black transverse bars (one behind the eyes and an-
other across the occiput); a distinct dark neck band
followed by a white transverse band; a black edged
white horizontal line present along the supralabials.
Distribution. Vietnam: from Dien Bien, Son La
and Ninh Binh southwards to Lam Dong and Dong
Nai provinces (this is the first record of the species
for Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: India, Nepal,
China, Taiwan, Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambo-
dia, and Malaysia.
Remarks. The specimen was damaged so that
only the above mentioned scale counts could be
taken.
Sinonatrix percarinata (Boulenger, 1899)
Mountain water snake; Ran hoa can van den
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one juvenile specimen collected by KVN and
others (ZFMK 94671, SVL: 198.9 mm, TAL: 68.4
mm; Fig. 33), ratio TAL/TL: 0.26.
Morphological characters. Body stout; eye
moderate; pupil round; nostrils directed slightly
upwards, not valvular; rostral 2 times wider than
high; nasal completely divided; internasals longer
than wide, distinctly narrowed anteriorly, longer
than the prefrontals; loreal as long as high; pre-
ocular 1; pos-toculars 3; suboculars 2; temporals 2
or 3 + 3; supralabials 9, fourth and fifth touching
the eye; dorsal scale rows: 19 : 17 : 17, keeled,
except outermost row; ventrals 136, more than
twice as broad as adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale di-
vided; subcaudals 76, paired (determination after
Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Ziegler, 2002).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
greyish brown above with 28 vertical black bars
on each side, not symmetrical, getting wider
towards the back, where all are confluent, dark
bars in anterior part of body ending in the middle
of ventrals, forming broken rings in width of 2 or
3 scale rows; upper head dark olive brown, supral-
abials white posteriorly; chin and venter white,
except for the black rings.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Lao Cai, Ha
Giang, and Cao Bang in the North, southwards to
Kon Turn, Gia Lai, and Dong Nai provinces (this is
the first record of the species for Quang Ngai
Province); elsewhere: India, China, Taiwan, Myan-
mar, Laos, and Thailand.
Remarks. The colouration of the specimen is
typical for young individuals (see Smith, 1943). Ac-
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
319
27
28
29
30
Figure 25. Uncollected Dendrelaphis ngansonensis, 23.VI.2009, feeding on Polypedates sp., photo T. Geismann. Figure 26.
Preserved Enhydris subtaeniata (IEBR 3289), photo R. Babb. Figure 27. Oligodon chinensis, photo R. Babb. Figure 28. Pareas
hamptoni, photo R. Babb. Figure 29. P. margaritophorus , photo R. Babb. Figure 30. Pseudoxenodon macrops, photo R. Babb.
320
Liza Nemes et alii
cording to the key of Ziegler et al. (2007), two
supralabials entering the eye are typical for Sino-
natrix percarinata, as well as vertical or Y-shaped
black bars on the body sides, whereas the number
of these dark body marks (fewer than 30) is typi-
cal for Sinonatrix aequifasciata (which, however,
in contrast normally has not more than one supral-
abial entering the eye, and which has broad, roun-
ded X-shaped dark marks on sides of body
instead).
Xenochrophis flavipunctatus (Hallowell, 1861)
Yellow- spotted keelback; Ran nuoc dom vang
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one adult male collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94669, SVL: 370 mm, TAL: 172.8 mm;
Fig. 34), ratio TAF/TF: 0.32.
Morphological characters. Body stout;
pupil round; eye shorter than its distance from the
nostril; nostril slightly directed upwards, not
valvular; rostral visible from above; contiguous in-
temasals strongly narrowed towards the front, sub-
triangular, with the anterior angle truncated, nearly
as long as prefrontals; frontal constricted in the
middle, 2.3 times as long as broad, longer than its
distance from the snout tip, a little shorter than
pari-etals; loreal as long as high; preocular 1;
postoculars 3; temporals 2 + 2 ; supralabials 9,
third to fourth or to fifth touching the eye; infral-
abials 5, in contact with anterior chin shields; men-
tal groove present; dorsal scales in 19 rows at
midbody, more or less strongly keeled, 3 outermost
rows smooth; ventrals 128, more than twice as broad
as adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale divided; subcau-
dals 83, divided (determination after Bourret, 1936;
Smith, 1943; Ziegler, 2002; Vogel & David, 2006).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
pale olive above, with black spots, spots larger
laterally; a pale, dark V-shaped marking on nape;
two well-defined subocular streaks present on
neck, posterior one extending from the eye to the
corner of the mouth; ventral surface yellow,
ventral and subcaudal scales with entire, broad,
dark margins.
Distribution. Vietnam: entire country; else-
where: Bangladesh, China, Myanmar, Faos, Thai-
land, Cambodia, Malaysia, and Indonesia.
VIPERIDAE
Protobothrops mucrosquamatus (Cantor, 1839)
Brown-spotted pitviper / Ran luc cuom
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
1): one subadult specimen collected by KVN and
others (ZFMK 94673, SVF: 437.3 mm, TAF: 90.6
mm; see Fig. 35), ratio TAF/TF: 0.17.
Morphological characters. Head elongate;
upper head scales unequal, extremely small, granu-
lar, smooth; snout 2.75 times as long as eye diam-
eter; rostral slightly broader than high; supraoculars
long and narrow, entire; intemasals separated from
each other by 3 small scales, separated from
supra-oculars by two enlarged scales; scales
between the supraoculars 15; postoculars 4, small;
subocular 1 , separated from the labials by 2 scale
rows; temporal scales 2 or 3 rows, enlarged, smooth;
supralabials 10, the first completely separated from
the nasal, the second forming the anterior margin of
the loreal pit, the third largest; dorsal scales keeled;
dorsal scale rows 31 : 28-30 : 24; ventrals 232;
cloacal scale undivided; subcaudals 96, divided (de-
termination after Bourret, 1936; Smith, 1943; Fe-
viton et al., 2003).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
pale brown above, with a series of large, dark-
brown blotches; lower lateral with a series of
smaller blotches, all edged in black; a dark brown
line from the eye to the angle of the mouth, edged in
black; ventral surface brownish with white blotches.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Fao Cai, Ha
Giang, and Cao Bang provinces in the North east-
wards to Quang Ninh and southwards to Kon Turn,
and Gia Fai provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere:
India, Bangladesh, China, Taiwan, and Myanmar.
Remarks. In contrast to the descriptions of Smith
(1943) and Feviton et al. (2003) all the head scales of
the specimen are smooth. The number of dorsal scale
rows, ventrals, and subcaudals is somewhat higher
than in the previous descriptions. The ratio TAF/TF
is smaller than in Smith's description (1943). The
intemasals are only 2 times, not 5 to 10 times longer
than the adjacent scales (see Feviton et al., 2003).
Trimeresurus albolabris Gray, 1842
White-lipped pitviper / Ran luc mep trang
Examined material. Specimen examined (n =
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
321
Figure 31. Rhabdophis subminiatus, photo R. Babb. Figure 32. Sibynophis collaris, photo T. Ziegler. Figure 33. Sinonatrix
percarinata, photo R. Babb. Figure 34. Preserved Xenochrophis flavipunctatus (IEBR 3297), photo R. Babb. Figure 35.
Protbothrops mucrosquamatus , photo R. Babb. Figure 36. Trimeresurus albolabris , photo R. Babb.
322
Liza Nemes et alii
1) : one adult male collected by KVN and others
(ZFMK 94670, SVL: 485.2 mm, TAL: 135.9 mm;
see Fig. 36), ratio TAL/TL: 0.22.
Morphological characters. Pupil vertical;
snout 2.4 times as long as eye diameter; loreal pit
between nostril and eye; canthus rostralis sharp,
rostral wider than high; scales on top of head small,
smooth, subequal, subimbricate; scales between
supraoculars 12; intemasals about 3 times larger
than adjacent scales, in contact with each other;
preoculars 3; postoculars 2, small; subocular 1, in
contact with third labial; scale rows between sub-
ocular and labials 1-3; temporal scales feebly
keeled; supralabials 9-10, not in contact with the
eye, the first partially fused to the nasal, the second
bordering loreal pit, the third largest; infralabials
12-13; dorsal scales keeled; dorsal scale rows 20 :
21 : 15; ventrals 166, more than twice as broad as
the adjacent dorsals; cloacal scale entire; subcau-
dals 76, divided (determination after Bourret, 1936;
Smith, 1943; Manthey & Grossmann, 1997; Zie-
gler, 2002; Leviton et al., 2003).
The colouration of the preserved specimen is
blue above; supralabials pale blue; ventral surface
yellowish blue.
Distribution. Vietnam: From Lao Cai and Cao
Bang provinces in the North southwards to Dong
Nai, Tay Ninh, Kien Giang, and Ca Mau provinces
(this is the first record of the species from Quang
Ngai Province); elsewhere: Northeast India, China,
Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, and Cambodia.
Trimeresurus vogeli David, Vidal et Pauwels,
2001
VogeFs green pitviper; Ran luc von-gen
Examined material. Specimens examined (n =
2) : one adult female collected by QKL and KLV
(ZFMK 94275, SVL: 462 mm, TAL: 83 mm); one
adult male collected by KVN and others (IEBR
3305, SVL: 508.8 mm, TAL: 119 mm; Fig. 37), tail
average, ratio TaL/TL of 0.15 in the female.
Morphological characters. Dorsum green; a
white lateral stripe, edged in red below in males,
and a narrow yellow stripe without red in females;
a constant lack of red color in the postocular streak
in both males and females; not more than 25 % of
tail tip rusty red; tail average, with a ratio TaL/TL
of 0.15 in the female; labial region somewhat
lighter greenish than green head colouration; first
supralabial totally separated from the corresponding
nasal; intemasals separated from each other by 0-2
scales; dorsal scales 21 rows at midbody, strongly
keeled; ventrals 155-158, plus 2-3 preventrals;
cloacal entire; subcaudals paired, 60-67; hemipenis
short and strongly spinose (determination after
David et al., 2001; Ziegler et al., 2007).
Distribution. Vietnam: from Ha Tinh and
Quang Binh southwards to Dak Lak and Lam Dong
provinces (this is the first record of the species from
Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: Laos, Thailand,
Cambodia.
Remarks. The specimens differ somewhat from
the original description of David et al. (2001) by
having a lower ventral count (155-158 versus 163-
173); the head streak is not distinct; the eyes are
greenish orange instead of greenish yellow to
yellow; the internasals in the male IEBR 3305 are
not separated (usually separated by 1-3 scales), and
the dorsum bears no faint dark crossbands and no
white vertebral spots.
TESTUDINES
GEOEMYDIDAE
Cyclemys pulchristriata Fritz, Gaulke et Lehr,
1997
Striped leaf turtle; Rua dua soc
Examined material. Specimens photographed
(n = 2): two subadults were photographed by QKL
and RB (see Figs. 38-40).
Morphological characters. Identification of
the photographed specimens is based on character-
istic scalation and colour pattern, such as plastron
entirely yellow or prevalent plastral colour yellow;
femoral mid-seam shorter than cloacal mid-seam;
cloacal notch small to wide and acute-angled to
obtuse-angled; throat uniformly white coloured;
light head and neck stripes (yellow to salmon in live
specimens) wide; if black radiating pattern present
on plastron, radiating lines short and stout (deter-
mination after Fritz et al., 2008).
Distribution. Vietnam: Quang Nam, Gia Lai, and
Lam Dong provinces (this is the first record of the
species from Quang Ngai Province); elsewhere: ac-
cording to Fritz et al. (2008) easternmost Cambodia.
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
323
37
38
Figure 37. Trimeresurus vogeli. Figure 38. Cyclemys pulchristriata. Figure 39. Cyclemys pulchristriata, portrait. Figure 40.
Cyclemys pulchristriata , ventral view. Photos R. Babb.
DISCUSSION
We herein provide a list of 35 identified reptile
species (16 lizards, 18 snakes, and 1 turtle) based
on our recent field surveys in Quang Ngai Province.
Fourteen of the recorded species belong to the
family Colubridae, which is the most species-rich
reptilian family in Quang Ngai, followed by 6
agamid and 6 scincid species. Nguyen et al. (2009)
also listed Oligodon ocellatus as occurring in
Quang Ngai Province, which brings the total
reptilian number known from that province to 36.
Nguyen et al. (2009) further list the terrestrial rep-
tilian species Gekko gecko , Coelognathus radiatus,
and Enhydris plumbea as occurring in the whole
country, so that there is high probability that they
also will be recorded from Quang Ngai Province in
the future. Regardless, G. gecko from Vietnam
recently has been revised, and it has not yet been
determined whether G. gecko or G. reevesii is
involved (see Rosier et al., 201 1). A further number
of species are listed in Nguyen et al. (2009) as oc-
curring along Vietnam’s central coasts, but without
definite records for Quang Ngai Province. The data
presented herein thus serve only as a preliminary
reptilian list, which must be extended in the future
based on further field research. Also the taxonomic
status of Fimbrios cf. klossi from Quang Ngai needs
further examination. There exist clear differences
between the available specimen and known varia-
tion of F. klossi. The combination of the number of
temporals, the lack of a mental, and the longer tail
324
Liza Nemes et alii
would suggest a distinct species. However, because
only one individual is available at this time, an
anomalous specimen cannot be excluded with
certainty. Together with the 1 6 amphibian species
recorded from this area (Tran et al., 2010), the her-
petofaunal list for Quang Ngai Province currently
covers 52 amphibian and reptile species. Compared
with the herpetofaunal composition of other central
Vietnamese provinces, such as Quang Binh Prov-
ince (see Ziegler & Vu, 2009), species numbers
could easily be doubled to tripled in the near future.
Such further research also will be essential for
evaluating the conservation status of Quang Ngai
forested areas, in particular as protected areas have
not yet been established in this province until today.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Field surveys in Quang Ngai Province were
assisted by Khoi Le Vu, Tuan Thanh Nguyen, Tran
Anh Vu, Ab Abercrombie, Chris Hope, Paul Moler,
and Bill Turner. We are grateful to the directorates
of the Forest Protection Department of Quang Ngai
Province for the support of our field work and is-
suing relevant permits. For help with species iden-
tification we are indebted to Patrick David, Paris
(. Amphiesma , Fimbrios ), and Ulrich Manthey, Ber-
lin ( Calotes ). For the loan of specimens, we thank
Canh Xuan Le, Thai Huy Tran, Cuong The Pham
(IEBR, Hanoi) and Tao Tien Nguyen (VNMN,
Hanoi). Thanks to Eleanor Sterling (New York) and
Kevin Koy (Berkeley) for providing the map, and
to Thomas Geismami for providing figure 25. Field
surveys in Quang Ngai were partially supported by
the Douc Langur Foundation (DLF) and Wildlife at
Risk (WAR).
REFERENCES
Bourret R., 1936. Les serpents de FIndochine. I. Etudes
sur la faune. Henry Basuyau et Cie, Toulouse, 505 pp.
Bourret R., 2009. Les lezards de FIndochine. Edition
Chimaira, Frankfurt am Main, 624 pp.
Darevsky, I.S. & Kupriyanova L.A., 1993. Two new all-
female lizard species of the genus Leiolepis Cuvier,
1829 from Thailand and Vietnam (Squamata: Sauria:
Uromastycinae). Herpetozoa, 6: 3-20.
David P., Bain R.H., Nguyen, T.Q., Orlov N.L., Vogel G.,
Vu T.N. & Ziegler T., 2007. A new species of the
natricine snake genus Amphiesma from the Indochi-
nese Region (Squamata: Colubridae: Natricinae).
Zootaxa, 1462: 41-60.
David R, Nguyen T.Q., Nguyen T.T., Jiang K., Cchen T.,
Teynie A. & Ziegler T., 2012. A new species of the
genus Oligodon Fitzinger, 1826 (Squamata: Colubri-
dae) from northern Vietnam, southern China and
central Laos. Zootaxa, 3498: 45-62.
David P., Vidal N. & Pauwels O.S.G., 2001. A morpho-
logical study of Stejneger's pitviper Trimeresurus
stejnegeri (Serpentes, Viperidae, Crotalinae), with the
description of a new species from Thailand. Russian
Journal of Herpetology, 8: 205-222.
David P., Vogel G. & Dubois A. 201 1 . On the need to fol-
low rigorously the Rules of the Code for the subse-
quent designation of a nucleospecies (type species)
for a nominal genus which lacked one: the case of the
r \
nominal genus Trimeresurus Lacepede, 1804 (Rep-
tilia: Squamata: Viperidae). Zootaxa, 2992: 1-51.
Fritz U., Guicking D., Auer M., Sommer R.S., Wink M.
& Hundsdorfer A.K., 2008. Diversity of the South-
east Asian leaf turtle genus Cyclemys : how many
leaves on its tree of life? Zoologica Scripta, 37: 367-
390.
Green M.D., 2010. Molecular phylogeny of the snake
genus Oligodon (Serpentes: Colubridae), with an
annotated checklist and key. Master thesis, University
of Toronto, 161 pp.
Gressit J.L., 1937. Anew snake from southeastern China.
Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington,
50: 125-128.
Grismer J.L. & Grismer L.L., 2010. Who’s your
mommy? Identifying maternal ancestors of asexual
species of Leiolepis Cuvier, 1 829 and the description
of a new endemic species of asexual Leiolepis
Cuvier, 1829 from Southern Vietnam. Zootaxa, 2433:
47-61.
Hartmann T., Geissler P., Poyarkov N.A., Ihlow F., Ga-
loyan E.A., Rodder D. & Bohme W., 2013. A new
species of the genus Calotes Cuvier, 1817 (Squamata:
Agamidae) from southern Vietnam. Zootaxa, 3599:
246-260.
Kams D.R., Lukoschek V., Osterhage J., Murphy J.C. &
Voris H.K., 2010. Phylogeny and biogeography of the
Enhydris clade (Serpentes: Homalopsidae). Zootaxa,
2452: 18-30.
Leviton A.E., Wogan G.O.U., Koo M.S., Zug G.R.,
Lucas R.S. & Vindum J.V., 2003. The dangerously
venomous snakes of Myanmar. Illustrated checklist
with keys. Proceedings of the California Academy of
Sciences, ser. 4, 54: 407-460.
Luu V.Q., Nguyen T.Q., Pham C.T., Dang K.N., Vu T.N.,
Miskovic S., Bonkowski M. & Ziegler T., 2013. No
end in sight? Further new records of amphibians and
reptiles from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park,
First contribution to the reptile fauna of Quang Ngai Province, central Vietnam
325
Quang Binh Province, Vietnam. Biodiversity Journal,
4: 285-300.
Manthey U. & Grossmann W., 1997. Amphibien und
Reptilien Sudostasiens. Natur und Tier-Verlag, Mun-
ster, 512 pp.
Murphy J.C., 2007. Homalopsid snakes: evolution in the
mud. Krieger, 249 pp.
Murphy J. C. & Voris H. K., 1994. A key to the homa-
lopsine snakes. The Snake, 26: 123-133.
Musters C.J.M., 1983. Taxonomy of the genus Draco L.
(Agamidae, Lacertilia, Reptilia). Zoologische Ver-
handelingen, 199: 1-120.
Nazarov R., Poyarkov N.A., Orlov N.I., Phung T.M.,
Nguyen T.T., Hoang D. M. & Ziegler T. 2012. Two
new cryptic species of the Cyrtodactylus irregularis
complex (Squamata: Gekkonidae) from southern
Vietnam. Zootaxa, 3302: 1-24.
Nguyen S.V., Ho C.T., Nguyen T.Q., 2009. Herpetofauna
of Vietnam. Edition Chimaria, Franfkurt am Main,
768 pp.
Nguyen T.Q., Bohme W., Nguyen T.T., Le Q.K., Pahl K.
R., Haus T. & Ziegler T., 2011a. Review of the genus
Dopasia Gray, 1853 (Squamata: Anguidae) in the In-
dochina subregion. Zootaxa, 2894: 58-68.
Nguyen T.Q., Nguyen S.V., Orlov N.L., Hoang T.N.,
Bohme W. & Ziegler, T., 2010. A review of the
genus Tropidophorus (Squamata, Scincidae) from
Vietnam with new species records and additional
data on natural history. Zoosystematics and Evolu-
tion, 86: 5-19.
Nguyen T.Q., Schmitz A., Nguyen T.T., Orlov N.L.,
Bohme W. & Ziegler T., 20 1 lb. Review of the genus
Sphenomorphus Fitzinger, 1843 (Squamata: Sauria:
Scincidae) in Vietnam, with description of a new
species from northern Vietnam and southern China
and the first record of Sphenomorphus mimicus Tay-
lor, 1962 from Vietnam. Journal of Herpetology, 45:
145-154.
Orlov N.L., Truong N.Q. & Sang N.V., 2006. A new
Acanthosaura allied to A. capra Gunther, 1861 (Aga-
midae, Sauria) from central Vietnam and southern
Laos. Russian Journal of Herpetology, 13: 61-76.
Pope C.H., 1935. The reptiles of China. Turtles,
crocodilians, snakes, lizards. Natural History of cen-
tral Asia. Vol. X. American Museum of Natural Hi-
story, New York, 604 pp.
Rosier H., Bauer A.M., Heinicke M.P., Greenbaum E.,
Jackman T., Nguyen T.Q. & Ziegler T., 2011. Phy-
logeny, taxonomy, and zoogeography of the genus
Gekko Laurenti, 1768 with the revalidation of G. ree-
vesii Gray, 1831 (Sauria: Gekkonidae). Zootaxa,
2989: 1-50.
Rosier H., Vu T.N, Nguyen T.Q., Ngo T.V. & Ziegler T.,
2008. Anew Cyrtodactylus (Squamata: Gekkonidae)
from central Vietnam. Hamadryad, 33: 48-63.
Smith M. A., 1935. The fauna of British India including
Ceylon and Burma. Reptilia and Amphibia. Vol. II.
Sauria. Taylor and Francis (London), 440 pp.
Smith M.A., 1943. The fauna of British India, Ceylon
and Burma, including the whole of the Indo-Chinese
Subregion. Reptilia and Amphibia. Vol. III. Ser-
pentes. Taylor and Francis (London), 583 pp.
Taylor E.H., 1963. The lizards of Thailand. University of
Kansas Science Bulletin, 44: 687-1077.
Tran D. T. A., Le K. Q„ Le K. V., Vu T. N., Nguyen T.
Q., Bohme W. & Ziegler T., 2010. First and prelim-
inary frog records (Amphibia: Anura) from Quang
Ngai Province, Vietnam. Herpetology Notes, 3:
111-119.
Vogel G. & David P, 2006. On the taxonomy of the Xe-
nochrophis pis cat or complex (Serpentes, Natricidae).
In: Vences M., Kohler J., Ziegler T. & Bohme W.
(Eds.). Herpetologia Bonnensis II: Proceedings of the
13th Congress of the Societas Europaea Herpetolog-
ica, Bonn, pp. 241-246.
Wood P.L., Grismer L.L., Grismer J.L., Neang T., Chav
T. & Holden J., 2010. Anew cryptic species of Acan-
thosaura Gray, 1831 (Squamata: Agamidae) from
Thailand and Cambodia. Zootaxa, 2488: 22-38.
Ziegler T., 2002. Die Amphibien und Reptilien eines Tie-
flandfeuchtwald-Schutzgebietes in Vietnam. Natur &
Tier Verlag, Munster, 342 pp.
Ziegler T., David P., Miralles A., Dang K.N., Nguyen
T.Q., 2008. A new species of the snake genus Fim-
brios from Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park,
Truong Son, central Vietnam (Squamata: Xenoder-
matidae). Zootaxa, 1729: 37-48.
Ziegler T., Hendrix R., Vu T.N., Vogt M., Forster B.,
Dang K.N., 2007. The diversity of a snake commu-
nity in a karst forest ecosystem in the central Truong
Son, Vietnam, with an identification key. Zootaxa,
1493: i_40.
Ziegler T. & Nguyen T.Q., 2010. New discoveries of am-
phibians and reptiles from Vietnam. Bonn zoological
Bulletin, 57: 137-147.
Ziegler T., Ohler A., Vu T.N., Le Q. K., Nguyen T.X.,
Dinh T.H. & Bui T.N, 2006. Review of the amphib-
ian and reptile diversity of Phong Nha - Ke Bang Na-
tional Park and adjacent areas, central Truong Son,
Vietnam. In: Vences M., Kohler J., Ziegler T. &
Bohme W. (Eds.): Herpetologia Bonnensis II. Pro-
ceedings of the 13th Ordinary General Meeting of
the Societas Europaea Herpetologica, Bonn, pp. 247-
262.
Ziegler T., Orlov N.L., Giang T., Nguyen T.Q., Nguyen
T.T., Le Q.K., Nguyen K.V. & Vu T.N., 2010. New
provincial records of cat snakes, Boiga Fitzinger,
1826 (Squamata: Serpentes: Colubridae), from Viet-
nam, inclusive of an extended diagnosis of Boiga
326
Liza Nemes et alii
bourreti Tillack, Le & Ziegler, 2004. Zoosystematics
and Evolution, 86: 263-274.
Ziegler T. & Vogel G., 1999. On the knowledge and spe-
cific status of Dendrelaphis ngansonensis (Bourret,
1935) (Reptilia: Serpentes: Colubridae). Russian
Journal of Herpetology, 6: 199-208.
Ziegler T. & Vu T.N., 2009. Ten years of herpetodiversity
research in Phong Nha - Ke Bang National Park, cen-
tral Vietnam. In: Vo Van Tri, Nguyen Tien Dat, Dang
Ngoc Kien & Pham Thi Hai Yen (Eds.): Phong Nha -
Ke Bang National Park and Cologne Zoo, 10 years of
cooperation (1999-2009). Quang Binh, pp. 103-124.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 327-334
Foraging behaviour of three primate species in a Costa Rican
coastal lowland tropical wet forest
Kirsty E. Graham 1 *, Megan J. Bulloch 2 &Todd R. Lewis 3
'Quest University Canada, 3200 University Blvd, Squamish, BC, V8B 0N8, Canada; email: kirsty.graham@questu.ca
2 Quest University Canada, 3200 University Blvd, Squamish, BC, V8B 0N8, Canada; email: megan.bulloch@questu.ca
3 Estacion Biologica Cano Palma, Refugia Barra del Colorado, Tortuguero, Costa Rica; email: ecolewis@gmail.com
^Corresponding author
ABSTRACT Primates are predominantly distributed across tropical regions, many of which are threatened
by deforestation. Removal of mature trees can harm primate populations by reducing avail-
able food resources. Understanding the dietary requirements of primates at local levels can
help identify key habitats to conserve, and protect plant species on which primates rely. Little
is known about local diets of Alouatta palliata (mantled howler monkey), Ateles geoffroyi
(black-handed spider monkey), and Cebus capucinus (white-faced capuchin) in Costa Rica's
lowland tropical wet forests. Because diet and activity levels are closely connected, studies
examining one provide insight into the other. We used group scan sample methods to record
activity and diet, identifying all plant species on which the primates fed. We identified nine
families of plants eaten by Ateles geoffroyi , four families eaten by Alouatta palliata, and
two families eaten by Cebus capucinus. Activity budgets demonstrated that Alouatta palliata
was the least active species and Cebus capucinus the most active. We also found differences
in the type of plant parts consumed by the three primate species; Alouatta palliata and Ateles
geoffroyi fed mostly on fruit and new leaves, whereas Cebus capucinus fed on fruit and in-
sects. The nine families of plants identified in this study are potentially important for all
three primate species locally, and warrant conservation.
KEY WORDS Primate; Activity budget; Foraging; Lowland wet forest; Costa Rica.
Received 7.04.2013; accepted 24.05.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
New World primates have evolved to fill spe-
cific niches through variable body size, activity lev-
els, and dietary preference (Rosenberger, 1992).
However, these distinct niches may be contingent
on intact forest. Timber extraction increases inter-
species competition by narrowing the number of
preferred plant species, in addition to reducing the
total biomass of food resources. Studying basic pri-
mate natural history by recording aspects such as
diet can assist conservation land management pre-
scriptions at a local scale by identifying key habitats
and plants that primates use, and protecting them as
food resources.
In recent history, Costa Rica has suffered habitat
loss of up to 4% forest cover per annum, mostly
from expanding agriculture and human frontiers
(Myers et al., 2000; Sanchez- Azofeifa et al., 2001;
Achard et al., 2002). The country sought to redress
this issue by the formation of national parks, and
has recently expanded these to include wildlife cor-
ridors that connect reserve land to benefit primates,
among a myriad of diverse wildlife (Canet-Desanti
& Finegan, 2010). Costa Rica is biologically di-
328
K.E. Graham, M.J. Bulloch &T.R. Lewis
verse, and has four species of primates that live in
its tropical forests; Saimiri oerstedii (Reinhardt,
1872) (Central American squirrel monkey), Cebus
capucinus (Linnaeus, 1758) (white-faced capuch-
in), Alouatta palliata (Gray, 1849) (mantled howler
monkey), and Ateles geoffroyi (Kellogg et Gol-
dman, 1944) (Geoffroy's or black-handed spider
monkey). Despite their iconic status within Costa
Rica’s eco-tourism industry, surprisingly little is
known about the diet of A. palliata, Ateles geoffroyi,
and C. capucinus among these reserve lands, espe-
cially at local levels.
Group size and social structure can mitigate
intra- and inter-species competition for food re-
sources. Mantled howler monkeys form large, sta-
ble groups ranging from 2-39 individuals (Crockett
& Eisenberg, 1987). They can live in large groups
without intense food competition because their fit-
ness is limited by access to mates rather than food;
leaves are an abundant and easily accessible food
source (Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007). Species with
a higher proportion of fruit in their diet often use
grouping strategies that allow access to this widely
dispersed food source. Black-handed spider mon-
keys have a fission- fusion social structure (Di Fiore
& Campbell, 2007), and live in groups of 15-25 in-
dividuals, forming sub-groups of 3 individuals (Ro-
binson & Janson, 1987). Fission- fusion social
structures may be a way of avoiding direct compe-
tition over food resources with conspecifics, by dis-
persing in small groups to scattered fruit sources
(Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007). White-faced ca-
puchins also feed predominantly on fruit, and form
mixed-sex groups of 10-35 individuals (Robinson
& Janson, 1987; Jack, 2007). Farge group size
might be a way to increase frequency of detecting
fruit sources and defending these sources against
other groups (Janson, 1988). Capuchins’ smaller
body size means that they have to intake fewer calo-
ries, mitigating competition within each group.
This study was performed at Cano Palma Bio-
logical Station, 8 km north of the coastal village of
Tortuguero, in NE Costa Rica. Cano Palma is a
small 5,000 m 2 reserve of mixed lowland tropical
wet forest with dominant stands of Manicaria and
Raphia palms (Fewis et al., 2010). The main objec-
tive of this study was to identify plant species and
parts consumed by A. palliata, Ateles geoffroyi, and
C. capucinus. In addition, each primate species was
monitored for activity budget and food competition,
to create an ethogram to determine whether they fed
on overlapping plant species and plant parts.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study period lasted 28 survey days from 8
April to 20 May 2011. Each day, the study site was
surveyed commencing at 06:00. The first located
species of primate was followed and monitored
through the day until nightfall or until they became
inaccessible. Observational frequency of all three
primate species was adjusted in the field to ensure
equal time budgets were allocated to each species.
Namely, if one species had been followed more
often than another, but was the first to be located
during a survey, this species was immediately fol-
lowed until an encounter with a less frequently ob-
served species. For each data point, GPS coordinates
were recorded to create distributional maps of each
primate species across the site.
Activity budget data were collected using a
group scan sample method (Martin & Bateson,
1993). At two-minute intervals the activity of each
individual was recorded as one of four categories;
inactive, travelling, feeding, and social interaction
(Pavelka & Knopff, 2004). The age and sex of each
individual was also recorded. Juveniles were not di-
vided by sex, and adults of unknown sex were not
included in analysis. Infants were excluded from ac-
tivity budgets because of dependence on mothers
for food (Pavelka & Knopff, 2004). When an indi-
vidual was feeding, the species of plant and/or plant
part was recorded. The five categories of plant parts
were new leaf, mature leaf, unknown leaf, fruit, and
stalk (Pavelka & Knopff, 2004). Plant parts that
could not be identified were recorded as 'unknown'.
Unknown plant species were included in the analy-
sis of activity budget and plant parts, but discounted
in analysis of plant species. For insectivores, such
as C. capucinus, the number of insect feeding bouts
was recorded, but the species of insect was not iden-
tified due to the complexity of deciphering specific
species for each insect.
Data analyses of activity budgets and food bud-
gets were conducted using R (version 2.11.1). Food
budgets were sub-divided into separate analyses for
plant species and plant parts. Individual identifica-
tion of primates was not possible, and therefore, re-
peat sampling of some groups likely occurred. We
Foraging behaviour of three primate species in a Costa Rican coastal lowland tropical wet forest
329
attempted to control for repeat sampling by using
group scan sampling. The time budget spent for
each activity was measured as a proportion of the
time observed (Pavelka & Knopff, 2004). There-
fore, time spent by a primate on an activity, the de-
pendent variable, was measured as a percentage.
Activity budget analyses used a 3 (species) x 2
(age) x 2 (sex) three-way ANOVA on mean fre-
quency of each activity. Variation in plant parts con-
sumed was analyzed by a 2 (sex) x 2 (age) x 3
(species) three-way ANOVA on mean frequency of
type of plant part consumed.
RESULTS
The dataset comprised 28 survey days, of which
monkeys were observed on 1 7 days, for a total of
approximately 49 hours. Totals of 933 A. palliata ,
368 Ateles geoffroyi , and 156 C. capucinus obser-
vations were recorded. Individual monkeys often
provided multiple observations upon encounter.
Population and Distribution
A. palliata were found in groups of 3-4 individ-
uals, Ateles geoffroyi in groups of 3-7 individuals,
and C. capucinus in groups of 12-20 individuals.
Distribution maps for each primate species indicated
that most groups were located, and foraged, in edge
and transitional (occasionally flooded) habitat (Fig.
1). Only A. palliata were found farthest north of the
reserve among Manicaria swamp habitat (Fig. 1).
Activity Budgets
Overall activity budget for A. palliata, including
all age and sex groups, indicated they spent 77% of
time inactive, 14% moving, 7% feeding, and 2%
engaging in social behaviour. Ateles geoffroyi spent
41% of time moving, 31% inactive, 20% feeding,
and 8% engaging in social behaviour. C. capucinus
spent 76% of time moving, 10% engaging in social
behaviour, 8% feeding, and 6% inactive (Fig. 2). A
3 (species) x 2 (age) x 2 (sex) three-way ANOVA
on mean frequency of each activity produced a sta-
tistical interaction between activity and primate
species. The percentage of time spent on each activ-
ity differed significantly between primate species,
F (6, 192) = 8.2069, P = 0.001 (Fig. 2).
Diet
For time engaged in feeding, A. palliata spent
35% feeding on new leaves, 32% on fruit, 30% on
unknown leaves, 2% on stalks, and 2% on unknown
plant parts. Ateles geoffroyi spent 44% feeding on
new leaves, 28% feeding on fruit, 17% on unknown
leaves, 11% on plant stalks, and 1% on mature
leaves. C. capucinus spent 77% of the time feeding
on fruit, 15% on insects, and 8% on unknown parts
(Fig. 3). A 2 (sex) x 2 (age) x 3 (species) three-way
ANOVA on mean frequency of type of plant part
consumed produced an interaction between plant
part and primate species. Primate species ate differ-
ent plant part, F (10, 291) = 2.347, p = 0.0123, but
not different plant families (Table 1).
N ine families of plants were identified as food for
A. geoffroyi ; Anacardiaceae, Araceae, Arecaceae,
Clusiaceae, Melastomaceae, Moraceae, Myrtaceae,
Rubiaceae and Tiliaceae. A. palliata fed on four plant
families (Anacardiaceae, Araceae, Arecaceae, Clu-
siaceae), and C. capucinus fed on two plant families
(Anacardiaceae and Melastomaceae) (Table 1).
DISCUSSION
Population and Distribution
All three species of primate were observed
around Cano Palma’s reserve land without disturb-
ing normal activity. This suggested that all three
species were habituated to human presence, likely
due to the long-term presence of researchers at
Cano Palma Biological Station and regular eco-
tourism to the area.
Cano Palma Biological Station’s reserve land
features lowland tropical wet forest edge, lowland
tropical wet transitional (occasionally flooded)
forest, and Manicaria swamp forest (Lewis et al.,
2010). All three species of primates in this study
were located, and observed foraging among edge
and transitional vegetative zones within Cano Pal-
ma’s reserve land. Only A. palliata was located in
Manicaria swamp forest habitat. This is possibly
due to the higher diversity of food providing trees
and high vegetation within the transitional forest
zone (Lewis et al., 2010). The observations of group
numbers of A. palliata, Ateles geoffroyi, and C. ca-
330
K.E. Graham, M.J. Bulloch &T.R. Lewis
Population Distribution Over Time
Legend
Ecoregion
Edge Habitat
Manicaria Forest
Occasional Flooding
Primate Distribution over Time (days)
o
earliest data
mid data
latest data
0 75 150
N
Meters
Cebus capucinus
Ateles geoffroyi
Alouatta palliata
Figure 1 . Distribution of each primate species across the study site as a function of time.
pucinus concurred with known group numbers for
each species. A. palliata were found in groups of 3-
4 individuals, within the reported range of 2-39 in-
dividuals (Crockett & Eisenberg, 1987). Ateles
geoffroyi were found in small groups of 3-7 indi-
viduals that were possibly sub-groups, although
they have been observed at Cano Palma Biological
Station in larger groups (P. Grant & R. Ballard, pers.
comm.). Ateles geoffroyi are usually found in fis-
sion-fusion structured social groups of 15-25 indi-
viduals, and form sub-groups of up to three
individuals (Robinson & Janson, 1987; Di Fiore &
Campbell, 2007). These fission- fusion social struc-
tures may be a way of avoiding direct competition
over food resources with conspecifics (Di Fiore &
Campbell, 2007). C. capucinus groups ranged from
12-20 and are known to form mixed-sex groups of
10-35 individuals (Jack, 2007; Robinson & Janson,
1987). C. capucinus were only observed on 3 non-
consecutive days of 28 survey days, travelling
through the study site. It is possible that Cano Pal-
ma's reserve is only a portion of this group's range.
Foraging behaviour of three primate species in a Costa Rican coastal lowland tropical wet forest
331
Activity budget for three monkey species
100
75
■AP
D AG
°CC
s, so
25
_m
Feeding Inactive Moving
Activity
Social
Food budget
100
Q<
a
u
s
75
50
25
Plant Part
I
I
■Mantled Howler
Monkeys
0 Black-handed
Spider Monkeys
°White-faced
Capuchins
J] .0 0
Figure 2. Activity budget by species (Ateles geoffroyi -
black, Alouatta palliata - white, Cebus capucinus - grey);
percentage of total time observed performing each activity.
The percentage of time spent on each activity differed sig-
nificantly between primate species, F (6, 192) = 8.2069,
P = 0.001.
Figure 3. Food budget by species ( Ateles geoffroyi - black,
Alouatta palliata - white, Cebus capucinus - grey); percent-
age of total time observed feeding on each plant part.
Table 1. Food budget by species, age, and sex; percentage
of total time observed feeding on each plant species.
Species
Ateles geoffroyi
Alouatta palliata
Cebus
capucinus
Age
All
A
J
All
A
J
All
A
J
Sex
All
F
M
Unk
All
F
M
Unk
All
F
M
Unk
Anacardiaceae
23
15
28
50
44
41
47
50
8
14
0
0
Araceae
11
10
17
0
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Arecaceae
23
29
22
0
5
5
7
10
0
0
0
0
Clusiaceae
1
2
0
0
18
20
20
10
0
0
0
0
Melastomataceae
4
6
0
0
0
0
0
0
46
43
0
100
Moraceae
7
6
6
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Myrtaceae
1
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Rubiaceae
5
6
0
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Tiliaceae
16
15
17
20
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Unknown
9
8
11
10
32
34
27
30
31
14
100
0
Insect
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
15
29
0
0
During this study, little interspecific competition
was observed between primate species despite their
overlapping distribution. This is possibly because
each species foraging strategy led them to feed on
different plant parts and plant species. It is possible
that each primate species filled a specific niche, al-
though a year-long study would clarify this concept
and determine whether competition increases dur-
ing periods of lower food availability.
Activity Budgets and Food Choice
A. palliata , Ateles geoffroyi, and C. capucinus
exhibited different activity budgets, and fed on dif-
ferent plant parts to sustain activity. Differing activ-
ity budgets are known for all three species
(Schoener, 1971; Crockett & Eisenberg, 1987; Di
Fiore & Campbell, 2007). A. palliata was observed
to consume mostly leaves and fruit, and did not
332
K.E. Graham, M.J. Bulloch &T.R. Lewis
travel as much as Ateles geoffroyi or C. capucinus.
These findings are consistent with the hypothesis
that A. palliata exhibits a strategy of energy mini-
mization. Namely, they receive less energy from the
leaves they eat, and therefore exert less energy (Di
Fiore & Campbell, 2007). A. palliata is primarily fo-
livorous, with a diet similar to colobines and in-
driids, but without a specialized digestive tract to
efficiently digest fibre (Milton, 1979). Although
their capacious gut allows A. palliata to digest
leaves, they do not extract the same amount of nu-
trients as their old world relatives (Milton, 1979).
Across primate species, diets high in leaves correlate
to low levels of activity (Dasilva, 1992). At Cano
Palma, A. palliata exhibited a preference for young
leaves, which may be because they contain higher
protein content, and are generally lower in fibre, thus
easier to digest (Milton, 1979). A. palliata can re-
main in stable social groups sharing the same area
without intense competition because leaves are
abundant and readily available in high density (Di
Fiore & Campbell, 2007). At Cano Palma we did not
observe intraspecific competition for food resources
either within or between howler monkey groups.
Ateles geoffroyi are known to move to specific
areas to exploit seasonally ripe fruit and can spend
between 18.9% and 50.5% of their day feeding (Ro-
binson & Janson, 1987). Spider monkeys in this
study ate fruit and leaves from a wide variety of plant
species, and were more active than A. palliata. Un-
like A. palliata , Ateles geoffroyi live in fission-fusion
societies, possibly as a response to their dietary pref-
erence for ripe fruit (Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007).
Because fruit is a densely but sparsely distributed re-
source, spider monkeys often divide into sub-groups
to avoid competition while foraging (Di Fiore &
Campbell, 2007). This was evident within Cano Pal-
ma’s spider monkey groups from the low group sizes
encountered. Ateles geoffroyi maximize energy in-
take by moving quickly to sources of high-energy
foods (Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007). To gain the
energy required to travel and forage; they must eat
fruit and, synchronously to eat fruit, they must travel
to foraging areas. At Cano Palma, Ateles geoffroyi
ranged constantly in the field as was observed in their
distribution. Ateles geoffroyi do not have the capa-
cious gut of A. palliata and therefore possibly cannot
extract sufficient calories from leaves alone.
C. capucinus can spend 70-80% of their day for-
aging and move seasonally to find ripe fruit (Robin-
son & Janson, 1987). Our observations showed C.
capucinus to be more active than Ateles geoffroyi ,
eating mainly fruit, as well as occasional insects. This
diet of high energy fruit and insects could allow
higher activity levels for capuchins. According to op-
timal foraging theory, individuals should select fruit
based on caloric/nutritional profitability even when
other familiar food sources are available (Schoener,
1971). Considering this, C. capucinus should con-
sume the available fruit with the highest energy con-
tent. A study to investigate capuchin seasonal diet at
Cano Palma would confirm this aspect. Diets bet-
ween neighbouring groups of C. capucinus can vary
and such differences in diet between groups at Cano
Palma could be cultural, intraspecific, or due to food
profitability (Chapman & Fedigan, 1990).
Diet Composition
In this study, the three primate species fed on a
total of nine families of plants, some of which over-
lapped across two, or all three species. The differ-
ence in plant families consumed may be explained
by the preferred plant parts of each primate species,
and possibly by plant distribution. A. palliata has
been known to consume mostly young leaves and
fruit, and the morphology of their teeth suggests
they have a predominantly folivorous diet (Crockett
& Eisenberg, 1987; Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007).
Past studies have shown that the proportion of fruit
in the diet of A. palliata affects their activity levels,
because fruit is a higher energy source than leaves
(Pavelka & Knopff, 2004). At Cano Palma, A. pal-
liata confirmed their known ecological behaviour
trait as inactive frugivore-folivores by their selec-
tion of vegetative food (Table 1).
Our observations of Ateles geoffroyi diet con-
firm their ecological behaviour as active frugivore-
folivores that prefer ripe fruit (Robinson & Janson,
1987; Di Fiore & Campbell, 2007). At Cano Palma,
Ateles geoffroyi were seen consuming Philodendron
sp. (Araceae). Philodendron is a genus known for
its toxic properties due to the presence of calcium
oxalate crystals (Genua & Hillson, 1985). Calcium
oxalate crystals are a secondary compound that de-
fends certain plant species against herbivores (Fran-
ceschi & Horner, 1980). Other mammal species,
with ruminating or complex guts, have been known
to eat high concentrations of oxalates (Freeland &
Janzen, 1974). Humans also consume some oxalate
Foraging behaviour of three primate species in a Costa Rican coastal lowland tropical wet forest
333
rich foods such as rhubarb, spinach, nuts, and tea,
and over-consumption can lead to adverse health ef-
fects (Massey et al., 1993). Ateles geoffroyi may
possess a tolerance to oxalate crystals that allow
them to consume calcium oxalate rich plants, such
as Philodendron spp., in conjunction with other
plant foods when preferred sources are scarce
(Franceschi & Homer, 1980). This food choice
could also be an act of self-medication (Huffman,
1997). Ateles geoffroyi in certain parts of Costa Rica
have lower parasite loads due to the ingestion of fig
leaves (Glander, 1994), and it is possible that cal-
cium oxalate acts as a similar vermicide.
C. capucinus confirmed their ecological behav-
iour as very active frugivore-insectivores (Robinson
& Janson, 1987). Their diet is known to be variable,
comprising mostly seasonal fruit or insects, and they
are known to hunt small vertebrates (Jack, 2007). At
Cano Palma, C. capucinus consumed species of plant
not atypically described for the species at other sites
across Costa Rica and the neotropics (Jack, 2007).
Habitat and Conservation for Primates at
Cano Palma
Factors such as variable body size and feeding
specializations may help New world primate species
to mitigate interspecific competition. Additionally,
each species' social structure can alleviate pressure
from intraspecific competition and resource scarcity
(Rosenberger, 1992). This self-regulating behaviour
among and within species of primate highlights the
importance of protecting areas that contain preferred
food plants, especially in connected habitats like
Cano Palma that buffer national reserves.
However, despite laws to regulate selective log-
ging within the Barra del Colorado Refuge, unmoni-
tored logging still occurs (Lewis et al., 2010; R.
Ballard, pers. comm.). We recommend that any se-
lective logging should avoid plant families and com-
munities of local provenance to maintain the integrity
of food resources for primates. Notwithstanding, reg-
ulation of selective logging on the vast Barra del Col-
orado Refuge is not always pragmatic. By studying
and considering local foraging by primates, a strategy
to conserve connected areas around Cano Palma
could be realised, and is suggested. Further study of
territory and distribution combined with disseminat-
ing information, and involvement of local commu-
nities, support this recommendation.
6
Figure 4. White faced capuchin. Copyright Jamie Bowkett.
Figure 5. Mantled Howler Monkey. Copyright Michelle
Haines. Fig. 6 Black-handed Spider Monkey. Copyright
Paul Grant.
334
K.E. Graham, M.J. Bulloch &T.R. Lewis
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank the Canadian Organization for Tropi-
cal Education and Rainforest Conservation for al-
lowing use of the study site, particularly Dr.
Kymberley Snarr for her support of this project.
Ana Maria-Monge and Elena Vargas of the Mini-
sterio de Ambiente, Energia y Telecomunicaciones
permitted the study under license ACTo-GASP-
PIN-06-2011. Special thanks are extended to Ross
Ballard for plant identification and K. Julian Hoc-
kin-Grant for GIS plotting. We also thank the stu-
dents and volunteers who helped to collect data, and
the many friends involved in the editing process.
REFERENCES
Blanck Achard F., Eva H.D., Stibig H.-J., Mayaux P.,
Gallego J., Richards T. & Malingreau J.-P., 2 0 0 2 .
Determination of deforestation rates of the world’s
humid tropical forests. Science, 297: 999-1002.
Canet-Desanti L. & Finegan B., 2010. Bases de conoci-
miento para la gestion de corredores biologi-
cos en Costa Rica, Foundations of knowledge for the
management of biological corridors in Costa Rica.
Meso Americana, 14: 11-24.
Chapman C.A. & Fedigan L.M., 1990. Dietary differ-
ences between neighboring Cebus capucinus groups:
local traditions, food availability or responses to food
profitability. Folia Primatologica, 54: 177-186.
Crockett C.M. & Eisenberg J.F., 1987. Howlers: varia-
tions in group size and demography. In: Smuts B.B.,
Cheney D.L., Seyfarth R.M., Wrangham R.W. &
Struhsaker T.T. (Eds.), Primate societies. University
of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 54-68.
Dasilva G.L., 1992. The western black-and-white Colo-
bus as a low-energy strategist: activity budgets,
energy expenditure and energy intake. Journal of Ani-
mal Ecology, 61: 79-9.
Di Fiore A. & Campbell C.J., 2007. The Atelines: varia-
tion in ecology, behavior, and social organization. In:
Campbell C.J., Fuentes A., MacKinnon K.C., Panger
M. & Bearder S. K. (Eds.), Primates in perspective.
Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 155-185.
Franceschi V.R. & Homer H.T., 1980. Calcium oxalate
crystals in plants. Botanical Review, 46: 361-427.
Freeland W.J. & Janzen D.H., 1974. Strategies in her-
bivory by mammals: the role of plant secondary com-
pounds. American Naturalist, 108: 269-289.
Genua J.M. & Hillson C.J., 1985. The occurrence, type
and location of Calcium oxalate crystals in the leaves
of fourteen species of Araceae. Annals of Botany, 56:
351-361.
GlanderK.E., 1994. Nonhuman primate self-medication
with wild plant foods. In: Etkin N.L. (Ed.), Eating on
the wild side: The pharmacologic, ecologic, and so-
cial implications of using noncultigens. University of
Arizona Press, Tuscon, pp. 239-256.
Huffman M.A., 1997. Current evidence for self-medica-
tion in primates: a multidisciplinary perspective.
Yearbook of Physical Anthropology, 40: 171-200.
Jack K.M., 2007. The Cebines: toward an explanation of
variable social structure. In: Campbell C.J., Fuentes
A., MacKinnon K.C., Panger M. & Bearder S. K.
(Eds.), Primates in perspective. Oxford University
Press, Oxford, pp. 107-121.
Janson C.H., 1988. Intra- Specific Food Competition and
Primate Social Stmcture: A Synthesis. Behaviour,
105: 1-17.
Lewis T.R., Grant P.B.C., Quesada M.G., Ryall C. &
LaDuke T.C., 2010. A botanical survey of Cano
Palma Biological Station (Estacion Biologica Cano
Palma), Tortuguero, Costa Rica. Brenesia, 73-74:
73-84.
Martin P. & Bateson P., 1993. Measuring behaviour: An
introductory guide, second edition. Cambridge Uni-
versity Press, Cambridge, 176 pp.
Massey L.K., Roman-Smith H. & Sutton R.A.L., 1993.
Effect of dietary oxalate and calcium on urinary ox-
alate and risk of formation of calcium oxalate kidney
stones. Journal of the American Dietetic Association,
93: 901-906.
Milton K., 1979. Factors influencing leaf choice by
howler monkeys: a test of some hypotheses of food
selection by generalist herbivores. American Natura-
list, 114:362-378.
Myers N., Mittermeier R.A., Mittermeier C.G., da Fon-
seca G.A.B. & Kent J., 2000. Biodiversity hotspots
for conservation priorities. Nature, 40: 853-858.
Pavelka M.S.M. & Knopff K.H., 2004. Diet and activity
in black howler monkeys ( Alouatta pigm ) in southern
Belize: does degree of fmgivory influence activity
level? Primates, 45: 105-111.
Robinson J.G. & Janson C.H., 1987. Capuchins, squirrel
monkeys, and Atelines: socio-ecological convergence
with Old World primates. In: Smuts B.B., Cheney
D.L., Seyfarth R.M., Wrangham R.W. & Struhsaker
T.T., (Eds.). Primate societies. University of Chicago
Press, Chicago, pp. 69-82.
Rosenberger A.L., 1992. Evolution of feeding niches in
new world monkeys. American Journal of Physical
Anthropology, 88: 525-562.
Sanchez-Azofeifa G.A., Harriss R.C. & Skole D.L.,
200 1 . Deforestation in Costa Rica: a quantitative ana-
lysis using remote sensing imagery. Biotropica, 33:
378-384.
Schoener T.W., 1971. Theory of feeding strategies. An-
nual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 2: 369-404.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 335-342
Diversity of mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) in protected na-
tural parks from Valencian Autonomous Region (Eastern
Spain)
Alberto Bernues-Baneres* & Ricardo Jimenez-Peydro
Entomology and Pest Control Laboratory, Cavanilles Institute for Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology, University of Valencia,
Official Post 22085, 46071 Valencia, Spain
* Corresponding author, email: alberto.bernues@uv.es
ABSTRACT Several larval samplings of mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) were carried out between 2008-
2011, throughout very diverse larval biotopes located in thirteen protected natural parks from
Eastern Spain, offering new information about the faunistic diversity of mosquitoes in these
protected areas. Biodiversity was analyzed in terms of alpha, beta and gamma components,
with the aim of comparing mosquito diversity according to the typology of the natural parks
under study. A total of 15355 specimens belonging to 25 different mosquito species and 6
genera were collected and identified. Diversity analysis indicated higher diversity for Inland
Mountainous Areas (IMAs) with a low degree of interspecific dominance in these communi-
ties, while Coastal Wetlands and Marshes registered the lowest observed diversity and a high
degree of interespecific dominance. The cluster analysis revealed the relationship between
the categories (IMA, CMA, CWM), while the Principal Components Analysis proved the re-
lationship between larval abundance and the categories studied.
KEY WORDS Mosquitoes; Culicidae; biodiversity; natural parks; Eastern Spain.
Received 29.04.2013; accepted 29.05.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) are considered
one of the most relevant group of arthropods in the
public health field (Schaffner et al., 2001; Becker
et al., 2010) and, like other organisms, show a di-
rect relation to different factors such as environ-
mental and habitat heterogeneity or host
preferences (Zhong et al., 2003). Unfortunately,
since the eradication of malaria in Spain (Bueno
Mari & Jimenez Peydro, 2008), there have been
few scientific studies aimed to increase the knowl-
edge about mosquito diversity and the factors that
regulate its change and their populations in our
country. From this point of view, the comparison
of mosquito diversity (alpha diversity) and the
structure of the communities in wich they are inte-
grated (beta diversity) can provide us with a pow-
erful tool for the implementation of more effective
and efficient population control programs, accord-
ing to the structure of the landscape (Wittaker,
1972; Magurran, 1988).
We can define alpha diversity (a) as the spe-
cific richness of a community that we consider ho-
mogeneous. Beta diversity (ft) refers to the
replacement degree in the specific composition
between different communities of a landscape.
And, finally, we can define gamma diversity (y) as
the specific richness of the grouped communities
that form a landscape, resulting from both alpha
and beta diversities interaction (Magurran, 1988).
This method of biodiversity analysis is useful not
336
Alberto Bernues-Baneres & Ricardo Jimenez-Peydro
only to explore the climatic, physical or biological
influences on biodiversity, but also to study the ef-
fects of human pressure on biodiversity (Halffter,
1998; Moreno, 2001). Taking into account these
considerations, the aim of this study was to ana-
lyze the diversity of Culicidae present in the natu-
ral areas considered, as well as the differences on
the faunistic composition of mosquito species in
function of the climatic and ecological features of
each natural park.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area
To develop the study, we selected thirteen natu-
ral parks belonging to the Valencian Autonomous
Region (Spain): eight of them belonging to inland
mountainous areas, two belonging to coastal moun-
tainous areas and, finally, three belonging to coastal
wetlands and marshes (Fig. 1). Due to the climatic
variability recorded in the Valencian Autonomous
Region, it is possible to observe large differences
in the average temperatures and precipitacions reg-
istered between the different categories of the natu-
ral parks here studied. According to this, we can
define our study area as follows (GVA, 2003):
• Inland Mountainous Areas (IMA). Character-
ized by a tipical Mediterranean climate, but influ-
enced by continental climate, these are the only areas
where it is possible to find Supramediterranean
(mean temperature range between 13-8 °C) and Oro-
mediterranian (mean temperature range between 8-
4 °C) termotypes. During the study period, maximum
average temperatures of 26.5 °C and minimum aver-
age temperatures of 2.5 °C were recorded, with an
avergage precipitation of 36.7 1 (Fig. 2).
• Coastal Mountainous Areas (CMA). Very
similar to the IMA, are characterized by being
classified as Termomediterranean (mean tempera-
ture range between 19-17 °C) and Lower Me-
somediterranean (mean temperature range between
17-13 °C) termotypes, which is why the average
temperature is higher than in the previous class.
During the study period, maximum average tem-
peratures of 27.8 °C and minimum average tem-
peratures of 5.0 °C were recorded, with an avergage
precipitation of 29.2 1 (Fig. 3).
• Coastal Wetlands and Marshes (CWM). CWM
are the most common coastal environments of the
Valencian territory, registering the highest average
values of temperature (Inframediterranean termo-
type, mean temperature >19 °C). Rainfall is
strongly influenced by seasonality, characterized by
a severe drought time during the summer months.
During the study period, maximum average tem-
peratures of 29.1 °C and minimum average tem-
peratures of 5.5 °C were recorded, with an average
rainfall of 27.8 1 (Fig. 4).
Figure 1. Study area and the classification of each natural park studied by category. IMA (Inland Mountainous Areas),
CMA (Coastal Mountainous Areas) and CWM (Coastal Wetlands and Marshes).
Diversity of mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) in protected natural parks from Valencian Autonomous Region (Eastern Spain) 337
Sampling methods and taxonomic identification
A simple random sampling method was car-
ried out across the study area by selecting all suit-
able biotopes to accomodate immature forms of
mosquitoes. In this way, many different points
were sampled by using “dipping” technique (Ser-
vice, 1993) over 4 consecutive years (2008-2011).
Mosquito species were identified according to the
keys of Encinas Grandes (1982), Darsie & Sami-
nadou Voyadjoglou (1997) and Schaffner et al.
( 2001 ).
Diversity studies and statistical analysis
Diversity studies (alpha diversity) were con-
ducted separately for each natural park category
(IMA, CMA and CWM) by calculating classic di-
versity indexes like Margalef’s (D Mg = (S- 1 )/ln7V)
(Simpson, 1949; Magurran, 1988; Moreno, 2001)
and Simpson’s Indexes (2 = Zpf , where = nfN
[uf, relative abundance of the species calculated as
the proportion of individuals of a given species
against the total number of individuals of a commu-
nity, N]). Shannon diversity idex (H’ = -\L(pj •ln/; / -)])
is commonly used to characterize species diversity
in a community, accounting for both abundance and
evenness of the species present (Shannon & Wea-
ver, 1949). Species richness (5) is the number of
species present in a community while species even-
ness («/’) indicates the distribution of individuals
within the species and it’s calculated by using Pie-
lou’s Index formula ( J ’ = //77/ max , where H max =
In (5)) (Magurran, 1988; Moreno, 2001).
On the other hand, to calculate beta diversity, a
variety of similarity/dissimilarity indexes were used,
both qualitative (Jaccard’s Index, L = c/[ a+b-c]) and
quantitative (Sorensen’s Index, I s = [2 pN]/[aN+bN]),
as well as Whittaker’s (wich calculates the
species replacement according to the expression (i w
= <Sy[(2<2+Z?+c)-l]) and Complementarity Idex (C AB
= [S a + Sb-2VabV[Sa+S b -V ab ], where V AB repre-
sents the number of common species to both sites
A and B) (Magurran, 1988; Moreno, 2001).
The calculation of gamma diversity, was carried
out by using the classic proposal of Schluter and
Ricklefs (Schluter & Ricklefs, 1993) ([average a
diversity] [average (3 diversity] [sample size(7V’)]),
as well as the modification made by Lande
(1996) ([average a diversity] [/? diversity], where
Figure 2. Characteristic climogram (average maximum
and minimum temperatures and precipitations) of IMAs
natural parks for the study period (2008-2011). Figure 3.
Characteristic climogram (average maximum and mini-
mum temperatures and precipitations) of CMAs natural
parks for the study period (2008-2011). Figure 4. Charac-
teristic climogram (average maximum and minimum tem-
peratures and precipitations) of CWMs natural parks for
the study period (2008-2011).
f) = Zjqj[S r Sj |) to calculate the contribution made
by alpha and beta diversity to gamma (Moreno,
2001). Finally, to calculate the ecological distance
between different environments, a cluster (based on
338
Alberto Bernues-Baneres & Ricardo Jimenez-Peydro
IMA
Relative
abundance
CMA
Relative
abundance
CWM
Relative
abundance
Aedes
Aedes vexans
15
0.16
0
0.00
0
0.00
Aedes vittatus
0
0.00
49
1.37
0
0.00
Anopheles
Anopheles atroparvus
22
0.23
0
0.00
0
0.00
Anopheles claviger
30
0.32
0
0.00
0
0.00
Anopheles maculipennis s.s.
34
0.36
0
0.00
0
0.00
Anopheles marteri
19
0.20
0
0.00
0
0.00
Anopheles petragnani
1069
11.23
63
1.77
0
0.00
Culex
Culex hortensis hortensis
1216
12.77
7
0.20
0
0.00
Culex impudicus
697
7.32
44
1.23
0
0.00
Culex laticinctus
1265
13.29
1462
40.96
0
0.00
Culex mimeticus
583
6.12
41
1.15
0
0.00
Culex modestus
17
0.18
0
0.00
47
2.08
Culex pipiens
1935
20.32
708
19.84
1138
50.24
Culex territans
246
2.58
0
0.00
0
0.00
Culex theileri
2
0.02
0
0.00
0
0.00
Culiseta
Culiseta annulata
62
0.65
0
0.00
11
0.49
Culiseta longiareolata
2151
22.59
1195
33.48
168
7.42
Ochlerotatus
Ochlerotatus berlandi
14
0.15
0
0.00
0
0.00
Ochlerotatus caspius
0
0.00
0
0.00
658
29.05
Ochlerotatus detritus
0
0.00
0
0.00
223
9.85
Ochlerotatus echinus
93
0.98
0
0.00
0
0.00
Ochlerotatus geniculatus
33
0.35
0
0.00
0
0.00
Ochlerotatus gilcolladoi
11
0.12
0
0.00
0
0.00
Ochlerotatus pulcritarsis
7
0.07
0
0.00
0
0.00
Uranotaenia
Uranotaenia unguiculata
0
0.00
0
0.00
20
0.88
TOTAL COUNT
9521
62.00%
3569
23.24%
2265
14.75%
Table 1. Number of specimens captured for each environmental category (IMA, CMA and CWM).
Diversity of mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) in protected natural parks from Valencian Autonomous Region (Eastern Spain) 339
Jaccard’s Index) and a principal components analy-
ses (PCA) were made, offering the cophenetic cor-
relation value for the Jaccard cluster to calculate the
degree of reliability of the classification system
used. PAST software (Paleontological Statistics
Software Package) was used to carry out all calcu-
lations developed (Hammer et al., 2001).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Faunistic and systematic results
A total of 15,355 mosquito larvae were collected
from 285 sampling points, obtaining a total of 900
samples. The systematic study showed a total of 25
species belonging to 6 different genera (Table 1)
wich represents an 86.21% of the maximum spe-
cific richness calculated for the Valencian Autono-
mous Region (Bueno Mari, 2011). The complete
catalogue of species collected is listed below: Aedes
vexans (Meigen, 1830); Aedes vittatus (Bigot,
1861); Anopheles atroparvus Van Thiel, 1927; Ano-
IMA
CMA
CWM
Abundance
9521
3569
2265
Specific richness ( S)
21
8
7
Margalef index (Dy[g)
2.183
0.856
0.777
Simpson index (2)
0.149
0.320
0.353
Shannon index ( H 3
2.101
1.301
1.274
Evenness of Pielou index (J r )
0.690
0.626
0.655
Table 2. Alpha biodiversity estimators for each environ-
mental category (IMA, CMA and CWM).
1 MA-
GMA
IMA-
CWM
CMA-
CWM
Jaccard index (Ip
0.32
0.17
0.15
Sorensen index C ^Squant >
0.51
0.23
0.30
Whittaker index (fi ^ )
0.52
0.71
0.73
Complementarity (C^g%)
68.18
83.33
84.62
Table 3. Beta biodiversity estimators for each environmen-
tal category (IMA, CMA and CWM)
pheles claviger (Meigen, 1804); Anopheles maculi-
pennis s.s. Meigen, 1818; Anopheles marteri Sene-
vet et Pmnelle, 1927; Anopheles petragnani De
Vecchio, 1939; Culex hortensis hortensis Ficalbi,
1889; Culex impudicus Ficalbi, 1890; Culex laticin-
ctus Edwards, 1913; Culex mimeticus Noe, 1899;
Culex modestus Ficalbi, 1889; Culex pipiens Lin-
naeus, 1758; Culex territans Walker, 1856; Culex
theileri Theobald, 1903; Culis eta annul ata ( Schrank,
1776); Culiseta longiareolata (Macquart, 1838);
Ochlerotatus berlandi (Seguy, 1921); Ochlerotatus
caspius (Pallas, 1771); Ochlerotatus detritus (Hali-
day, 1833); Ochlerotatus echinus (Edwards, 1830);
Ochlerotatus geniculatus (Olivier, 1791); Ochlero-
tatus gilcolladoi (Sanchez-Covisa, Rodriguez et
Guillen, 1985); Ochlerotatus pulcritarsis (Rondani,
1872) and Uranotaenia unguiculata Edwards, 1913.
Mosquito species richness and evenness
According to the analysis of a biodiversity in-
dexes (Table 2), it is possible to observe that IMA en-
vironments are the most diverse (N =21; D Mg = 2.1 83),
Figure 5. Cluster analysis based on Jaccard’s distance; co-
phenetic correlation rc=0.9975.
340
Alberto Bernues-Baneres & Ricardo Jimenez-Peydro
while CWM are the least diverse (S= 7; D Mg = 0.777).
Simpson and Shannon indexes highlight that in
CWMs (2 = 0.353; H’ = 1.274) species such as Cx.
pipiens (50.24%) and O. caspius (29.05%) strongly
dominate the rest of species present in the community.
Something similar occurs in the case of CMAs (2 =
0.320; H’ = 1.301), where Cx. laticinctus (40.96%),
Cs. longiareolata (33.48%) and Cx. pipiens (19.84%)
develop a strong influence. Finally, IMAs (2 = 0.149;
// ’ = 2.101) are the category of natural park where a
greater evenness degree can be ob served, because the
most dominant species do not show such a strong in-
fluence as in the two other cases.
These observations can be explained according
to the bioclimatic characteristics of each natural
park category. The IMAs record a greater rainfall
abundance (Fig. 2) as well as a higher variety of en-
vironments that are able to be colonized by mosqui-
toes than in other categories of natural parks. That
means a greater amount of larval biotopes available
to be exploited by different communities of culicids
along the year. The CMAs, can be defined as tran-
sitional environments between IMAs and CWMs
categories since rainfall regime is more heteroge-
neous, focusing on specific periods throughout the
year (Fig. 3). This factor, in combination with times
of severe drought during the summer months, de-
termines a population dynamics feature which is re-
flected in the diversity observed in the natural parks
grouped in this category. Finally, CWMs represent
the most extreme type of environment analyzed,
being the driest (Fig. 4) and most homogeneous in
terms of water bodies typology, which acts as limit-
ing factor in the diversity observed in that category.
Similarity and dissimilarity analysis
The analysis of fi biodiversity (Table 3), indicates
that IMAs and CMAs are the closest categories in
their specific composition (7 ; - = 0.32; I Squant = 0.5 1),
showing the lower replacement degree (fiw = 0.52)
between pairs analyzed, observations also supported
by the complementarity index (C IMA -C MA =
68.18%). With the aim of representing the informa-
tion provided by the Jaccard index, a cluster analysis
based on Jaccard’s distance was carried out, cor-
roborating the same conclusions already given be-
fore (Fig. 5). The high value of Jaccard distance
cophenetic correlation (r c = 0.9975) indicates a high
correlation level between the ecological distance ob-
served in the study and the distance predicted by the
hierarchical configuration of the cluster.
As a result of the PCA, two principal compo-
nents were extracted explaning a 93.06% of the
total variability observed (PCj = 83.55%; PC 2 =
9.51%) (Fig. 6). It is worth pointing out the large
dispersion exhibited by Cx. pipiens, Cs. longiareo-
lata and Cx. laticinctus, which are the most abun-
dant and dominant species in all studied
communities. It is also interesting to mention the
close relationship existing between IMAs (the most
diverse and heterogeneous) and species such as Cx.
mimeticus, Cx. impudicus and An. petragnani, wich
define perfectly the main vector of this natural park
category. Specially significant is the case of Cx.
hortensis hortensis, which has been described as
one of the regular members of the most biodiverse
Culicidae communities in our region (Bueno Mari
& Jimenez Peydro, 2011).
In the case of CWMs, note the relationship with
typical halophilic species, being O. caspius and O.
detritus the ones that best define the axis of this cat-
egory, despite the fact that Cx. pipiens was the most
common and dominant species in CWMs.
Integrated landscape biodiversity
As mentioned above, gamma (y) diversity was
calculated following Schluter & Ricklefs (1993)
and Lande (1996) criteria. As a result, 7(s c hluter and
Ricklefs) was 25.7 1 , virtually identical to the value of
the total specific richness (S = 25) evidenced in the
study area. On the other hand, y (Lande) was 19.99
with an a contribution of 60.05% and a /> contribu-
tion of 39.95%, demonstrating that the alpha diver-
sity of the richest community (IMAs) contributes to
a greater extent of the gamma diversity (60.05 %),
which implies a low level of complementarity be-
tween categories and a high proportion of exclusive
species in each category studied.
CONCLUSIONS
Due to the limited existence of studies based on
mosquito diversity in Spain (Demba et al., 2005;
Bueno Mari, 2011; Bueno Mari & Jimenez Peydro,
2011), the results of our study represent an inter-
esting contribution to the general knowkedge about
Culicidae diversity in our country. According to
Diversity of mosquitoes (Diptera Culicidae) in protected natural parks from Valencian Autonomous Region (Eastern Spain) 341
1 . 8 -
l.J-
1 , 2 -
0,9-
0 . 6 -
's
<
0.3-
-0.3-
-0.6-
-0.9-
Ae. vittatus
CMA
Cx.laticinctus
Cs. longiareolata
IMA
Cx.mimelicus/territans
Cx, pipiens
An.petragnani 1
*Cs. annulata/subochrea
Cx. hortensis hortensis’
Cx. impudicus
An. maculipennis s.s.
CWM
Cx. modestus
-i-
-0.4
U. unguiculata
O. detritus
O, caspius
- 0.8
0.4
1.2
1.6
Axis 1
2.4
Figure 6. Principal Components Analysis (PCA) based on the larval abundance within each natural park category.
Margalef Index and specific richness, IMAs show
the highest diversity observed in the Valencian Au-
tonomous Region’s natural parks, probably due to
various factors that should be taken into account. In
first place, these are the most extensive areas, fa-
cilitating landscape heterogeneity and larval
biotopes diversity present within their limits. These
conditions favor their colonization and increase the
likelihood of the presence of suitable host on which
to feed. Another aspect to consider is the water qual-
ity sampled (low levels of eutrophy), the high level
of replacement and longer periods of stay (higher
precipitation regimes favor both aspects) (Rivas
Martinez, 2004), aspects strongly related with the
presence of species such as Cx. hortensis hortensis
and An. petragnani. CMAs recorded a lower level
of diversity, a fact that relates to their lower surface
and larger coastline influence. These conditions lead
to a decrease in turnover rate and retention of water
(high droguht times) (Rivas Martinez, 2004), favor-
ing an ecological filter toward less sensitive species
and better adapted to strong changes such as Cs. lon-
giareolata and Cx. laticinctus (Becker et al., 2010).
CWMs are the natural parks that suffer from the
stronger influence by the closeness of the sea, show-
ing a greater homogeneity of larval habitats, a lower
level of replacement and water permanence (Rivas
Martinez, 2004), promoting the presence of heavily
adapted species (such as O. caspius , O. detritus and
U. unguiculata ) or highly plastic ones (such as Cx.
pipiens). On the other hand, the concentration of
human population in coastal zones (INE, 2011) and
the higher level of anthropogenic influence has
been linked to the decline of diversity in other areas
of our territory (Bueno Mari et al., 2010). In this
case, it has been observed a pattern of loss of diver-
sity from inland areas (IMAs) toward coastal ones
(CWMs), coinciding with the assessments of Bueno
Mari & Jimenez Peydro (2011), who mantain that
a high level of anthropization does not imply a re-
duction of mosquito populations in urban environ-
ment, but rather an ecological selection filter that is
only surpassed by a few species.
Finally, it is particularly interesting to note the
high level of correlation observed between IMAS
and a small group of species (An. petragnani, Cx.
hortensis hortensis, Cx. impudicus and Cx. mimeti-
cus ), which behave as indicators of this category and,
therefore, can be related to a high degree of conser-
vation of the environment for future studies on
bioindicator species (Dorville, 1996, Montes, 2005).
To conclude, IMAs have a higher diversity of
Culicidae with a lesser degree of dominance and a
greater intraspecific evenness. On the other hand,
CWMs represent the less diverse and uniform com-
munities, with a greater degree of interspecific
dominance. These communities are composed of a
few abundant and a high number of rare species,
342
Alberto Bernues-Baneres & Ricardo Jimenez-Peydro
establishing a clear relationship between Culicidae
abundance and the prevaling climatic conditions.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to the Regional Ministry of Ge-
neralitat Valenciana (Conselleria de Medi Ambient,
Aigua, Urbanisme i Habitatge) for the grant of the
insects capture permissions in the protected enclaves.
We also want to point out that this article was par-
tially funded by Research Project CGL 2009-11364
(BOS), supported by the Ministry of Science and In-
novation of Spain (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innova-
cion del Gobierno de Espana).
REFERENCES
Becker N., Petrie D., Zgomba M., Boase C., Madon M.,
Dahl C. & Kaiser, A., 2010. Mosquitoes and their
control. Springer, London, 577 pp.
Bueno Mari R., 2011. Bioecologia, diversidad e interes
epidemiologico de los culicidos mediterraneos (Dip-
tera: Culicidae). Servei de Publicacions de la Univer-
sitat de Valencia, Valencia, 423 pp. Available online
at: http://hdl.handle.net/10803/52158.
Bueno Mari R. & Jimenez Peydro R., 2008 Malaria en
Espana: Aspectos entomologicos y perspectivas de fu-
turo. Revista Espanola de Salud Publica, 82: 161-163.
Bueno Mari R. & Jimenez Peydro R., 2011. Diferences
in mosquito (Diptera: Culicidae) biodiversity across
varying climates and land-use categories in Eastern
Spain. Entomologica Fennica, 22: 190-198.
Bueno Mari R., Corella Lopez E. & Jimenez Peydro R.,
2010. Culicidofauna (Diptera: Culicidae) presente en
los distintos enclaves hidricos de la ciudad de Valen-
cia (Espana). Revista Colombiana de Entomologia,
36: 235-241.
Darsie R.F. & Saminadou Voyadjoglou A., 1997. Keys
for the identification of the mosquitoes of Greece.
Journal of the American Mosquito Control Associa-
tion, 13: 247-254.
Demba Sy M., Remus Zamfirescu S., Thiam N. & Palanca
Soler A., 2005. Diversity of mosquitoes in a semiarid
environment from San Juan del Flumen (Los Mone-
gros, Huesca, Spain) (Diptera, Culicidae). Boletin de
la Asociacion Espanola de Entomologia, 29: 23-33.
Dorville L.F.M., 1996. Mosquitoes as bioindicators of
forest degradation in southeastern Brazil, a statistical
evaluation of published data in the literature. Studies
on Neotropical Fauna and Environment, 31: 68-78.
Generalitat Valenciana (GVA), 2003. Habitats prioritarios
de la Comunidad Valenciana. Conselleria de Territori
i Habitatge, Valencia, 222 pp.
Halffter G., 1998. A strategy for measuring landscape
biodiversity. Biology International, 36: 3-17.
Hammer 0., Harper D.A.T. & Ryan P.D., 2001. PAST:
Paleontological statistics software package for ed-
ucation and data analysis. Palaeontologia Electronica,
4: 9. Available online in: http://palaeo-electronica.
org/ 2001_l/past/ issuel_01.htm.
Instituto Nacional de Estadistica (INE), 2011. Cifras ofi-
ciales de poblacion resultantes de la revision del pa-
dron municipal (01/01/2011). Available online at:
http:// www.ine.es/iaxi/tabla.do. Accessed 3 March
2013.
Lande R., 1996. Statistics and partitioning of species di-
versity and similarity among multiple communities.
Oikos 76: 5-13.
Magurran A.E., 1988. Ecological diversity and its mea-
surement. Princeton University Press, New Jersey,
179 pp.
Montes J., 2005. Culicidae fauna of Serra da Cantareira,
Sao Paulo, Brazil. Revista de Saude Publica Sao
Paulo, 29: 578-584.
Moreno C., 2001. Metodos para medir la biodiversidad.
Manuales & Tesis de la SEA. Editorial Cyted, Orcyt-
Unesco & SEA, Zaragoza, 84 pp.
Rivas Martinez S., 2004. Centro de Investigaciones Fi-
tosociologicas. Global Bioclimatics Org. Available
online at: http://www.ucm.es/info/cif. Accessed 3
March 2013.
Schaffner F., Angel G., Geoffroy B., Hervy J.O. & Rha-
eim A., 2001. The mosquitoes of Europe/Les mousti-
ques d’ Europe [computer program], France: IRD
Editions and EID Mediterranee, Montpellier.
Schluter R.E. & Ricklefs R.E., 1994. Species diversity: an
introduction to the problem, in: Ricklefs, R.E. &
Schluter, R.E. (Eds.), Species diversity in ecological
communities: historical and geographical perspectives.
The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 1-10.
Service M.W., 1993. Mosquito Ecology. Field Sam-
pling Methods. Elsevier Science Publishers, Lon-
don, 988 pp.
Shannon C.E. & Weaver W., 1949. The Mathematical
Theory of Communication. The University of Illinois
Press, Urbana, 111, 144 pp.
Simpson E.H., 1949. Measurement of diversity. Nature,
163:688-688.
Wittaker R.H., 1972. Evolution and measurement of
species diversity. Taxon, 21: 213-251.
Zhong H., Yan Z., Jones F. & Brock C,, 2003. Ecological
analysis of mosquito light trap collections from West
Central Florida. Environmental Entomolgy, 32: 807-
815.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 343-354
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distri-
bution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni (Monterosato,
1891) (GastropodaTrochidae)
Paolo Mariottini 1 *, Andrea Di Giulio 1 , Massimo Appolloni 2 & Carlo Smriglio 1
‘D ipartim ento di Scienze, Universita degli Studi di Roma Tre, Viale Marconi 446, 00 146 Rome, Italy; e-mails:
paolo.mariottini@ unir oma3.it; andrea.digiulio@ unir oma3.it; csmriglio@ alice.it
; Museo Civico di Zoologia, Sezione Molluschi, Via Ulisse Aldrovandi, 1 8, 00 197 Rome, Italy; e-mail:
m assim o.appolloni@ com une.ro m a. it
* C orresponding author
ABSTRACT Jujubinus baudoni (M onterosato, 1891) shows highly diverse chromatic and morphological
patterns. Based on the examination of the type material and series of specimens from private
collections, and of recent findings from Sardinia, we reviewed and updated the distribution
of this species, and figured the three representative shell colour morphs which are constant
in local populations. A comparative SEM analysis did not outline significant differences
among shells with greatly different colour patterns, thus justifying their belonging to a single
specif ic entity. The survey of the material of J. baudoni did not show a strict correspondence
between Corse and Sardinian shell colour morphs and their geographical distribution, not al-
lowing to clearly state trends and relationships among island populations. On the contrary
the colour pattern of the continental shells of J. baudoni seems to be constant and different
from the ones of the island shells, indicating a well separated colour morph. This study con-
firmed that the distribution of J. baudoni is limited to the north-western Mediterranean Sea,
with its eastern range widened to the La Maddalena Archipelago (Sardinia). The record of
this species from Azores is due to a misidentification with J. pS6lldogravina6 Nordsieck, 1973,
which is also figured for comparison. A lectotype and p arale c to ty p e s of TvOChuS baudoni are
herein designated .
KEY WORDS Trochidae; JujllbinUS baudoni', Monterosato collection; colour morph; Mediterranean Sea.
Received 1 6.05.20 1 3; accepted 20.06.20 1 3; printed 30.06.20 1 3
INTRODUCTION
The genus Jujubinus Monterosato, 1 8 84 was
nominally based on TvochllS YUCltOYli Montagu, 1803
and it is represented by a small group of marine gas-
tropods living mostly in the interdital zone down to
about 80 m, invariably associated with photophilic
algal vegetation and/or marine p h an ero g am e s . The
alp h a -tax o n o m y of this genus still has to be com-
pletely solved, but it is currently accepted that sev-
eral different species occur worldwide albeit,
mainly on European waters, the exact number at the
moment amounts to 29 according to WoRMS
(World Register of Marine Species available at
http ://w w w ,m arinespecies.org/index .php ; A ppeltans
et al., 2012). In particular, 18 taxa are listed by
CLEMAM (at http:// w ww.somali. asso.fr/clem am /
index. php; Gofas & Le Renard, 2013) as European
species, most of them restricted to the Mediter-
ranean basin. Among the Mediterranean taxa be-
344
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
longing to this genus, JujubinUS baudoni (Monte-
rosato, 1891) was revaluated as bona species by Cu-
rini Galletti (1982). J. baudOYli was described under
the genus TvochuS Linnaeus, 1758 by Monterosato
(1891) with a very scanty description: “II T. Bau-
doni, H. Martin mss., e una piccola forma grosse-
sculpta, vivente in abbondanza sulle coste di
Provenza” (“The T. Baudoni, H. Martin mss., is a
small form heavily sculptured, abundant and living
along the coast of Provence”). Since the paper of
Curini Galletti (1982), only two further reports we re
recently published dealing with this species: by Sca-
pe rrotta et al. (2011), who figured shells from C orse,
and by Spanu (2011) who reported specimens from
the northwestern Sardinian coast. J. bcilidofli is
present on the infralittoral zone and is considered
locally common of the Catalan coast, Gulf of Lion,
Corse and North-Western Sardinia (Curini Galletti,
1 982; Scaperrotta et al., 2011; Spanu, 2011). The
Azores Islands cannot be considered in the J. bau-
doni distribution, since the materialexamined in the
Monterosato collection and labelled as CallioStoma
baudoni coming from these islands, tentatively iden-
tified as J. pseudogravinae N ordsieck , 1973 by Cu-
rini Galletti (1982), has been confirmed to belong to
this latter taxon. We have analyzed the type material
of Trochus baudoni m on ter os a to, 1891 and 7. bau-
doni var. incomparabilis Locard et Caziot (1901)
(reported by clem am as J. baudoni incompara-
bilis Ghisotti et Melone, 1975), and series of speci-
mens of J. baudoni from private collections. A
lectotype of J. baudoni is herein designated. We
found that this species shows a great mo rphological
variability, mainly concerning its colour pattern,
which is very constant within the different popula-
tion examined.A survey of colour mo rphs from dif-
ferent localities is here presented and, as far as to
our knowledge, this study confirmed that the distri-
bution of J. baudoni is lim ited to a restricted area of
the North-Western Mediterranean basin, being
slightly enlarged to east with the sampling of shells
from the La Maddalena Archipelago (Sardinia).
Shells from M o ntero sato ’s collection labelled as J.
baudoni and J. pseudogravinae fr o m the Azores are
figured for comparison.
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS. Carlo
Smriglio and Paolo Mariottini collections, Rome,
Italy (CS-PM); Monterosato (MTS); Museo Civico
di Zoologia, Rome, Italy (MCZR); Scanning Elec-
tron Microscopy (SEM).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Examined Material. We could examine the
type material of TvochuS baudoni in the Montero-
sato collection at the MCZR, consisting of empty
shells: 134 exx from Paulilles (France); 30 exx from
Roussillon (France); 12 exx from Departement de
l’Aude, Pyrenees Orientales (France); 20 exx J.
baudoni var. incomparabilis from Pietranera,
(Corse). A lectotype from the Paulille lot has been
designated with the number MCZR00218 and the
remaining material have been designed as paralec-
totypes M C Z R 0 0 2 1 9 /I - 1 9 5 . Furthermore, 18 exx
from Azores (Portugal) MCZR 11761, named as
Calliostoma baudoni but not related to this species,
have been examined.
Other empty shells of J. baudoni examined: 2
exx from Cadaques (Spain), collected at a depth of
4 m; 3 exx from Capo Caccia, Sardinia (Italy),
depth of 25 m. From La Maddalena Archipelago,
Sardinia (Italy) further empty materialwas gathered
among the shell grit collected handily by SCUBA
diving: 59 exx from Caprera Is., depth of 25 m; 91
exx from La Maddalena Is., depth of 25 m; 62 exx
of Spargi Is., depth of 20 m. M aterial referring to J.
pseudogravinae : 8 exx from Azores (Portugal), dea-
ler source. SEM photographs were carried out at the
Interdepartmental Laboratory of Electron Mi-
croscopy (LIME), Universita Roma Tre, Rome, Italy.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
We analysed the type m aterial of T. baudoni, in-
cluding the J. baudoni v ar. incomparabilis shells,
stored at the MCZR and we figured some shells
and original labels (Figs. 1 a - 1 2b). The shells of J.
baudoni V ar. incomparabilis w ell fit the description
given by Locard and Caziot (1901): “Nous revelon
une tres belle var. incomparabilis (M tr.), d’une
coloration verte et rouge”. A lectotype and paralec-
totypes of T. baudonihav e been herein designated.
From the examination of these shells, and the ac-
companying labels, as well as of shells from pri-
vate collections, we could confirm the systematic
status of this species and derived its distribution.
In fact, M onterosato’s material labelled as T. bau-
doni from Azores (Figs. 1 3 - 1 5 d ) resulted to be J.
pseudogravinae N ordsieck, 1 97 3 after a literature
research (Avila et al., 2004; Avila et al., 2007;
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distribution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni
345
Avila et al., 2011) and a direct comparison with
shells of this endemic species (Figs. 16a-d, 29a-n).
Most probably the bad conservation of the shells
(sent by Dautzenberg, see handwriting label ofFig.
14) has induced Monterosato to identify wrongly
these specimens, as already suggested by Curini
Galletti who examined this material (1982). As far
as we know, there are no reliable records of J. bau-
doni from A lb o ran Sea or Atlantic Ocean, in-
cluding Azores islands. On the contrary, from lit-
erature and personal sampling (Figs. 17a-24b) the
distribution of this species seems to be rather con-
fined to the north-western Mediterranean basin
(Ghisotti & Melone, 1 975; Curini Galletti, 1 982;
Scaperrotta et al., 2011; Spanu, 2011).
The distribution of J. baudoni has been slightly
enlarged to east with the shells collected by
SCUBA diving in the La Maddalena Archipelago
(Sardinia); in particular material was collected in
the infralittoral zone from three islands of the Ar-
chipelago (Caprera, La Maddalena, Spargi) (Figs.
2 2 a-2 4 b ; Table 1).
Regarding the morphological variability of this
taxon, interestingly we found different phenotypes,
being the shells (colour morph A) from the conti-
nental coast stouter, slightly more coarsely sculp-
tured, showing prosocline reddish-brown and
milky-white flam m ules, higher in number on the
basal cordlet (Figs. la-8c;17a-18c), in respect to the
specimens from Corse and Sardinia. In turn, these
latter can be divided in two different colour patterns
regarding the teleoconch coloration: 1) the typical
J. baudoni var. incomparabilis coloration (colour
morph B), which consists in an emerald green back-
ground interrupted by bright orange and/or red
flammules and milky-white prosocline stripes, with
white spots on the basal cordlet (Figs. 9a, 12b, 19a-
20b); 2) colour morph C, almost entirely brownish-
green or with prosocline faint whitish flammules
(Figs. 22a, 24b).
We recall that all J. baudoni shells invariantly
show protoconch and initial teleoconch whorls of
red colour. It is worth to mention that this feature
has induced several authors in the past to erro -
neousiy identify J. baudoni as J. exasperatus coralli-
HUS (Monterosato, 1884) (Figs. 21a-c-30a-e), as re-
called by Curini Galletti (1 982) and Spanu (2011).
Since it is possible to easily separate the three colour
patterns, as well as the continental shells from the
Corse and Sardinian ones, due to their slight dif-
ferences in the teleoconch sculpture, a comparative
SEM analysis was carried out. The examination of
the SEM photographs did not reveal any significant
protoconch and teleoconch sculpture differences
among all the shells analysed (Figs. 25a-28g), in
spite of their diverse colour patterns, thus indicating
that we are probably facing a single specific entity.
It is a matter of fact, the colour pattern of the conti-
nental shells of J. baudoni seems to be constant and
different from the ones of the island shells, indicating
a well separated phenotype. On the contrary, shells
of J. baudoni from C orse and S ardinia did not show
a strict correspondence between colour morphs and
their geographical distribution, not allowing to
clearly state trends and relationships among island
populations. In many marine gastropods a direct ge-
netic control of shell coloration has been demon-
strated, and in several cases variation in shell colour
has been considered to be an adaptive value related
to environmental variables such as climate, diet,
habitat choice, insolation, salinity, visual predation
and wave exposure (Terreni, 1981; Byers, 1989; So-
kolova & Berger, 2000 and references therein; Miura
et al., 2007). Shell colour may have three functions:
communication, crypsis and thermoregulation, and
it has been suggested that correlation between indi-
vidual physiology and shell colour polym orphism is
a result of pleiotropic effects of genes responsible for
the shell colour or a linkage between them and genes
determining certain physiological features (Sokolova
& Berger, 2000 and references therein; Miura et al.,
2007). The factors that maintain the color polymor-
phism, and those that contribute to among-site varia-
tion in color frequencies, re m a in unknow n. A lthough
the color polym orphism may have an underlying ge-
netic component, the regional-scale variation in color
frequency observed in J. baudoni could be ecologi-
cally controlled.
Interestingly, another member of the genus Ju-
jubinus, J. geographicus Poppe, Tagaro et D ekker,
20 0 6 shows a parallel shell colour variability (Figs.
31a, 32), including one very similar to the morph
B (red-green pattern, Figs. 3 1 a-c ) and one entirely
red (Fig. 32). In particular, green is a rare colour
occurring in marine shell coloration and the occur-
rence of this colour in two different species so dis-
tantly geographically separated (Mediterranean and
Philippines) could be due to a common genetic
background the phenotype of which is selected by
similar ecological constrains.
346
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
Figure 1 . Tvochus bciudoni. MTS collection, lectotype MCZR00218, H = 6.5 x D = 5.2 mm, Pa u lilies (France). Figures 2 -
4. MTS collection, original labels. Figure 5. T. bciudoili. MTS collection, 6.3 x 5.0 mm, Roussillons (France). Fig u res 6,7.
MTS collection, original labels. Figure 8. T. baudoni. MTS collection, 5.7 x 4.7 mm, Department de l’Aude (France).
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distribution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni
347
Figure 9. JlljllbinUS baudoni var. incomparabilis. MTS collection, H = 6.0 X D = 4.9 mm, Pietranera (Corse). Figure 10.
MTS collection, original label. Fig u re 11./. baudoni var. inCOfnpCirClbilis . MTS collection, 6.1 x 5.0 mm, Pietranera (Corse).
Figure 12. J. baudoni v ar. incomparcibilis. MTS collection, 5.4 x 4.8 mm, Pietranera (Corse). Figure 13. MTS collection,
original label. Figure 14. J. pS € U d()g m villClC. MTS collection, 2.8 x 2.6 mm, Azores Islands.
348
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
Figure 15. JujubinUS pseudo gravinae. MTS collection, H = 2.7 X D = 2.6 mm, Azores Islands, MTS collection. Figure 16.
J. pseudogravinae. CS-PM collection, 6.9 X 4.8 mm, Cais da Ribeirinha, S. Miguel Is. (Azores Islands), on stones, 10 m
depth. Figure 17. JujubinUS baudoni. CS-PM collection, 5.5 x 4.4 mm, Cadaques (Spain), 4 m depth. Figure 18. J. Baudoili.
CS-PM collection, 3.9 x 3.1 mm, Cadaques (Spain), 5 m depth.
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distribution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni
349
Figure 19. JujubinUS baudoni w ar. incomp ar abilis . CS-PM collection, H = 5.9 mm X D = 4.6 mm, Capo Caccia (Sardinia),
15 m depth. Figure 20. idem, 4.1 mm x 3.7 mm . Figure 21.7. CXClSpCVCltUS COTallinUS . CS-PM collection, 6.2 x 4.9 mm. La
Maddalena Is. (Sardinia), 25 m depth. Figure 22. J. bcilldoni. CS-PM collection, 7.1 x 4.8 mm, La Maddalena Is., Sardinia,
25 m depth. Figure 23. idem, 7.1 x 4.9 mm, Caprera Is. (Sardinia), 30 m depth. Figure 24. idem, 6.0 x 4.2 mm.
350
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
Figure 25. Tvochus baudoYli. MTS collection, H = 4.7 x D = 4.2 mm, Paulilles (France). Figure 26. JujubifflAS baudoni v ar.
incomparabilis. MTS collection, 6.1 X 4.8 mm, Pietranera (Corse). Figure. 27. J. bciudoili { Monterosato, 189 1); specimen
of figure 2 2. Figure 28. J. baudoni. CS-PM collection, 4.6 x 3.4 mm. Cap re r a Is. (Sardinia), 30 m depth.
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distribution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni
35 1
Figure 29. Jujubinus pseudogravinae N ordsieck, 1 973. CS-PM collection, H = 4.5 x D = 3.0 mm, Cais da Ribeirinha, S.
Miguel Is. (Azores Islands), on stones, 10 m depth. Figure 30. J. CXCLSpemtUS COValUnUS. CS-PM collection, 6.8 x 4.6 mm,
Bosa Marina (Sardinia), 30 m depth.
352
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
Figure 3 1. JlijubinUS geOgVOphicilS. Flolotype, FI = 4.9 x D = 3.9 mm, Punta Engano, Mactan Island (Philippines), 80-150
m d ep th . Fig u re 3 2. J. geOgraphicUS . Topotype, 4.8 x 3.3 mm, Punta Engano, Mac tan Island (Philippines), 80-150 m depth.
Fig . 3 3. J. baudofli. MorphotypesA-C distribution.
Phenotypic diversity, taxonomic remarks and updated distribution of the Mediterranean Jujubinus baudoni
353
COAST
LOCALITY
REFERENCES
SPAIN
La Escala, Girona, Palamos
Curini Galletti, 1 982; G ian n u z zi-S a v elli
et al., 1994
Port Lligat, Cadaques
Spanu, 2011; this work
FRANCE
Pa u lilies, Roussillon; Dupott de l’Aude,
Pyrenees Orientales
M onterosato, 1891
Lerin Islands, Provence
Spanu, 2011
CORSE
P ietran era
M onterosato, 1891
Ajaccio; Ile-Rousse; Barcaggio; B astia
Locard & Caziot, 1901
R e v ellata
Scaperrotta et al., 2011
SARDINIA
Capo C accia, A lghero (S assari); A sinara
Island, Punta Aguada (Sassari); Costa
Paradiso, Trinita d’Agultu (O lbia-Tem pio)
Spanu, 2011; this work
La M addalena Archipelago (Olbia-Tempio)
This w o rk
Table 1. Records o f JujuhinUS baudoni fro m the North-Western Mediterranean area (from literature and this work).
CONCLUSIONS
Type materialof TrochuS baudoni and Jujubinus
baudoni var. incomp arabilis, together with other
shells of this species have been analysed and fig-
ured in the present work. A lectotype and paralec-
to types of T. baudoni have been designated. J.
baudoni resulted to be represented by highly di-
verse chromatic shells, and three distinct colour
morphs (A-C) have been recognized and figured,
but comparative SEM analyses demonstrated that
there are no significant differences in the shell
sculpture, suggesting that they belong to a single
specific entity. Since members of genus Jujubinus
graze on a variety of micro-algal food sources, such
as diatoms and green algal epiphytes (Peduzzi,
1987), we can infer that the different colour patterns
observed in J. baudoni are influenced by diverse
environmental factors. This could explain the oc-
currence of the same colour pattern in disjointed
populations of the same geographical area, like the
case of the colour morph B of Pietranera (Corse)
and Capo Caccia (Sardinia), which are separated by
the colour morph C (Fig. 33 and Tablel). However,
we cannot rule out a different scenario, where those
phenotypes correspond to a mosaic of sibling
species. In the present study, we prefer to be con-
servative in non-assigning a taxonomic status to
these different chromatic patterns. Genetic analyses
are required to verify our current interpretation and
further studies are necessary to reveal mechanisms
maintaining shell colour polymorphism among
populations of J. baudoni and understand if there is
a physiological selection as a driving force shaping
the p h e n o -(g e n o - ) ty p ic structure of these popu-
lations along the continental and island coasts. As
far as we know, the distribution of J. baudoni is lim-
ited to the North-Western Mediterranean Sea, with
its eastern range widened to the La M addalena Ar-
chipelago (Sardinia) (Fig. 33). On the contrary, this
species does not occur in the Azores, having been
m isidentified with J. pSCudogravinae.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
W e are indebted to M arco C urini G alletti (D ipar-
timento di Scienze della Natura e del Territorio, U ni-
versita di Sassari, Italy), Franco Rapetti (Societa
Toscana di Scienze Naturali, Pisa; Italy) and Bruno
Amati (Rome, Italy) who kindly provided bibliogra-
phy related to the Jujubinus genus. Sincere thanks
are due to Sergio Bartolini (Firenze, Italy), and to
Guido and Stefano Poppe (Lapu Lapu City, Cebu,
354
P. Mariottini, A. Di Giulio, M.Appolloni & C. Smriglio
Philippines) for the permission to use a J. baudoni
and J. geOgraphicUS photographs, respectively.
REFERENCES
Appeltans W., Bouchet P., Boxshall G.A., De Broyer C
de Voogd N.J., Gordon D.P.. Hoeksema B.W., Horton
T., Kennedy M., Mees J., Poore G.C.B., Read G.,
Stohr S., Walter T.C . & Costello M .J., 2012.
World Register of Marine Species. Available at
http://www.marinespecies.org (accessed 8 May 2013).
Avila S.P.. Cardigos F. & Santos R.S., 2004. D. Joao de
Castro Bank, a shallow water hydrothermal-vent in
the Azores: checklist of the marine molluscs. Arqui-
pelago. Life and Marine Sciences, 21A: 75-80.
Avila S.P., Cardigos F. & Santos R.S., 2007. Comparison
of the community structure of the marine molluscs
of the “Banco D. Joao de Castro” seamount (Azores,
Portugal) with that of typical inshore habitats on the
Azores archipelago. Helgol Marine Research, 61:
43 -5 3.
Avila S.P.. Borges J.P. & De Frias Martins A.M., 2011.
The littoral Trochoidea (M ollusca: Gastropoda) of the
Azores. Journal of Conchology, 40: 408-427.
Byers B.A., 1989. Habitat-choice polymorphism asso-
ciated with cryptic shell-color polymorphism in the
lim pet Lottici digitalis. T he Veliger, 32: 394-402.
Cur ini Galletti M., 1982. Note ai Trochidae, VI. Jlljllbi-
flUS Bcilldoni H . Martin in Monterosato, 189 1. A tti
della Societa Toscana di Scienze Naturali, Memorie,
serie B , 8 9: 75 -85.
Giannuzzi-Savelli R., Pusateri F., PalmeriA. & Ebreo C.,
1 994. Atlas of the Mediterranean Sea Shells. “La
Conchiglia” Ed., Roma, 125 pp.
Ghisotti F. & M clone G., 1975. Catalogo il lustra to delle
conchiglie marine del M ed iterran e o , 5. Conchiglie,
1 1 , suppl. 5 : 1 47-208.
Go fas S. & Le Renard J., 2013. CLEMAM: Check List
of European Marine Mollusca. Available at
http://www.som ali.asso.fr/clem am /index.clem am .htm 1
(accessed 8 May 2012).
Locat'd A. & Caziot E., 1901. Les coquilles marines des
cotes de Corse. Annales de la Societe Linneenne de
Lyon. 47: 158-294.
M iura O., N ishi S. & Chiba S., 2007. Tern peratu re-related
diversity of shell colour in the intertidal gastropod Bci-
tillaria. Journal of M oil u scan Studies, 73: 235-240.
Monterosato T. di Maria di, 1891. Molluschi fossili qua-
ternari di S. Flavia. II N aturalista sic ilia no, 10: 96-104.
Peduzzi P.. 1 987. Dietary preferences and carbon absorp-
tion by two grazing gastropods Gibblllci IWlbiUcClris
(Linne") and JujllbhlUS StvidtUS. Marine Ecology, 8:
359-3 70.
Scaperrotta M., Bartolini S. & Bogi C., 2011. Stages
of growth of marine molluscs of the Mediterrranean
Sea. Vol. III. L’lnform atore Pice no Ed., Ancona,
184 pp.
Sokolova I.M . & Berger V.Ja., 2000. Physiological vari-
ation related to shell colour polymorphism in White
Sea Littorina scixatilis. Journal of Experim ental Ma-
rine Biology and Ecology, 245: 1 -23.
Spanu M .T., 2011. Prim a segnalazione di JujubinilS bcill-
dOTli ( Monterosato, 189 1 ex H. Martin ms) (Gastro-
poda: Trochidae) per la Sardegna e le acque italiane.
Bollettino Malacologico,47: 1 35-1 37.
Terreni G., 1981. Molluschi conchiferi del mare anti-
stante la costa toscana (Gastropoda, Scaphopoda,
Amphineura, Bivalvia, Cephalopoda). Livorno,
10 6 p p .
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 355-358
New and poorly-known harvestmen (Opiliones) from Sardinia
(Italy). Part I: Lacinius horridus (Panzer, 1 794), new to Sardinia
(Phalangiidae Oligolophinae)
Salvatore Canu 1 & Lars Friman 2
'Via Uri 6, 1-07049 Usini, Sassari, Italy; e-mail: SalvatoreCanul@tin.it
2 Larchenweg 28, D- 14806 Bad Belzig, Germany; e-mail: LF0107@t-online.de
"■Corresponding author
ABSTRACT The first occurrence of Lacinius horridus (Panzer, 1794) (Phalangiidae Oligolophinae) on
Sardinia is decribed and the general biogeographical distribution of Opiliones in Italy is
discussed.
KEY WORDS Opiliones; Sardinia; Lacinius horridus ; biogeography.
Received 16.05.2013; accepted 22.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Lacinius horridus (Panzer, 1794) (Phalangiidae
Oligolophinae) is a well-known species found in
nearly all areas of Southern, Central and Northern
Europe (Martens, 1978; Blick & Komposch, 2004)
with the exception of Spain (Prieto, 2008), the
Netherlands (Wijnhoven, 2009) and Norway (Stol,
2007). In Italy L. horridus has been found on the
mainland and also in Sicily (Stoch, 2003), but not
undisputedly in Sardinia.
ABBREVIATIONS. S-Fri = Sardinian specimen;
G-Fri = german specimen; Fe = femur; Pt = patella;
Ti = tibia; Mt = metatarsus; Ta = tarsus;
Lacinius horridus (Panzer, 1794) from Sardinia
Examined material. Coordinates in WGS84.
Usini, Sassari, 31.04.2012, subadult female,
40°39'49" / 08°29'49", 78 m a.s.l., legit S. Canu (S-
Fri 01-099 Rif 71/8). Usini, Sassari, 05.04 2012,
subadult female, 40°39'46" / 08°32'41", 206 m a.s.l.
legit S. Canu (S-Fri 02-010 Rif 81/2). Usini, Sas-
sari, 29.04.2012, juvenile female, 40°39'44" /
08°32'44", 206 m a.s.l., legit S. Canu (coll. “Schon-
hofer”). Usini, Sassari, 04.06.2012, subadult fe-
male, 40°39'46" / 08°32'43", 206 m a.s.l., legit S.
Canu (coll. “Schonhofer”) (Fig. 1).
Remarks. For this first reliable record of the
thermophile L. horridus all specimens were col-
lected by hand. The localities where L. horridus was
found, can be described as typical “mediterran
semi-natural dry open grasslands”, mostly on cal-
careous substrates (Fig.l; Martens 1978:325; Kom-
posch & Gruber, 2004: 516). Two of the specimens
(Nr. Rif7 1/8, = Fri 01-099 and Nr. Rif 81/2, = Fri
02-010) were selected for further examination and
have been retained as voucher specimens in collec-
tions of Department of Agriculture, Plant Pathology
and Entomology Section, University of Sassari
(Italy). In Table 1 (measurements) we have added
4 reference-specimens, 3 from Germany/Branden-
burg (G) and 1 from Martens (1978, lit.).
Without any evidence other than the ominous ci-
tation in Costa (1 885: 1 1 , but as Acantholophus hor-
356
Salvatore Canu & Lars Friman
Specimens-nrs.
body length/breadth(l/b)
leg II (Fe, Pt, Ti, Mt, Ta)
Fe I / Fe II / Fe III / Fe IV
S-Fri 01-099 Rif 71/8
2.8/ 2.0 Fb = 1.4
1.6 / 0.5 / 1.6 / 0.8 / 3.5 = 7.4
0.5 / 1.7 / 0.5 / 1.3
S-Fri 02-010 Rif 81/2
2.8/ 1.9 1/b = 1.5
1.4 / 0.5 / 1.2 / 0.7 / 2.2 = 6.0
0.4 / 1.4 / 0.4 / 1.2
G-Fri 03-030
2.0/ 1.5 1/b = 1.3
1.3 / 0.5 / 1.2 / 0.5 / 2.0 = 5.5
0.3 / 1.3 / 0.3 / 1.2
G-Fri 03-031
5.5/ 3.5 1/b = 1.6
4.5 / 1.0 / 3.7 / 1.9 / 5.8 = 16.9
1.5/ 4.5 / 1.4 / 2.9
G-Fri 03-053
6.0/ 4.6 1/b = 1.3
4.8/ 1.0/ 3.7/ 2.4/ 6.0= 17.9
1.7/ 4.8 / 1.9 / 3.7
Martens (1978) ad. females
6.0/ 3.5 1/b = 1.7
5.2/1.5/4.1/3.1/7.3 = 21.2
- / 5.2 / - / -
Table 1. Measurements of specimens in mm. G-Fri 03-030, BadBelzig, 03.09.2010, juvenile female, 52°13'21" 12°34'57",
98 m a.s.l. G-Fri 03-031, Bad Belzig, 29.10.2012, subadult female, 52°13'25" 12°34'57", 98 msm. G-Fri 03-053, Bad
Belzig, 21.08.2009, adult females, 52°13'22" 12°35'03", 98 msm.
ridus Bose, not Panzer, 1794), Marcellino (e.g.
1973: Tab. 1. as “sistema sardo-corso”, p. 7,
1975:163 and 1980: 337, Tab. 1) includes the
species Lacinius horridus as known for Sardinia
(contra Roewer, 1924, 1957 and Trossarelli, 1943;
Stoch 2003). Consequently, this unverified state-
ment by Marcellino (e.g. 1980:337: “Non ho tro-
vato specifiche menzioni per la Sardegna, salvo
Tunica citazione di Costa ...”) was not followed by
Chemini (1995) or Stoch (2003).
It is nonetheless worth mentioning that Sardinia
plays an important role in the biogeographical
distribution of Opiliones in Italy. Chemini (1996)
already observed that Italy can be divided into five
faunal territorial regions: northern, middle, and
southern peninsula; Sicily and Sardinia. Further-
more (Chemini, 1996) there is a strong latitudinal
effect (North-South-Island) that can be seen in the
increasing number of Mediterranean species from
11% (Northern Italy) to 63% in Sardinia and the
decreasing number of European species from 59%
(Northern Italy) to 0% in Sardinia. A similar
tendency can be observed in the increasing number
of endemic species from the north (25%) to 41% in
Sicily (Chemini, 1996).
In contrast, the so-called widespread species
(Chemini, 1996, but not Marcellino, 1973: “geone-
mia europea”), which include L. horridus , Mitopus
morio (Fabricius, 1799), Trogidus nepaeformis
(Scopoli, 1763 ), Phalangium opilio Linnaeus, 1761
and Odiellus spinosus (Bose, 1792) are also wide-
spread in Italy and make up about 4-5% of all
opilionid species in all regions of Italy.
Marcellino (1980: 325, Tab. 1) listed 29 species
of Opiliones for Sardinia, of which 16 species were
recognized as valid by Stoch (2003). Now with the
new species L. horridus and the long "overseen"
Mitostoma sabbadinii (Tedeschi et Sciaky, 1997,
indicated with *) the number of Opiliones on Sar-
dinia increases to 18.
Family SIRONIDAE
Parasiro minor Juberthie, 1958
Family TRAVUNIIDAE
Buemarinoa patrizii Roewer, 1956
Family PHALANGODIDAE
Ptychosoma vitellinum Soerensen, 1873
Scotolemon terricola Simon, 1872
Family NEMASTOMATIDAE
Histricostoma argenteolunulatum (Canestrini, 1875)
Mitostoma patrizii Roewer, 1953
Mitostoma sabbadinii Tedeschi et Scia, 1997 *
Family DICRANOLASMATIDAE
Dicranolasma soerenseni Thorell, 1876
New and poorly-known harvestmen (Opiliones) from Sardinia (Italy). Part I: Lacinius horridus, new to Sardinia 357
Figure 1. Lacinius hor-
ridus (coll. “Schonho-
fer”, subadult female;
Usini,: 04.06.2012) and
its habitat (Photo S.
Canu).
Family TROGULIDAE
Anelasmocephalus brignolii Martens et Chemini, 1988
Family ISCHYROPSALIDIDAE
Ischyropsalis adamii Canestrini, 1873
Family PH ALAN GIID AE
Metaphalangium propinquum (Lucas, 1847)
Dasylobus argentatus argentatus (Canestrini, 1871)
Dasylobus gestroi (Thorell, 1876)
Phalangium opilio Linnaeus, 1758
Phalangium targionii (Canestrini, 1871)
Lacinius horridus (Panzer, 1794)
Family SCLEROSOMATIDAE
Metasclerosoma sardurn (Thorell, 1876)
Nelima doriae (Canestrini, 1871)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We like to thank Prof. Dr. A. Kury (Rio de
Janeiro, Brazil) and Dr. C. Komposch (Graz,
358
Salvatore Canu & Lars Friman
Germany) for reading the manuscript and Prof. Dr.
R. Pantaleoni (Sassari, Italy) for his help and for the
Costa-papers. The English text was corrected by
Kevin Pfeiffer (Berlin, Germany).
REFERENCES
Barnabe Blick T. & Komposch C., 2004. Checkliste der
Weberknechte Mittel- und nord-europas (Checklist
of the harvestmen of Central and Northern Europe).
Arachnida: Opiliones. Version 27. http://www.ara-
ges.de/checklist/checklist04 opiliones.html
Chemini C., 1995. Arachnida, Scorpiones, Palpigradi,
Solifugae, Opiliones, Fascicolo 21. In: Minelli, A.,
Ruffo, S. et La Posta, S. (Ed.). Checklist delle Specie
della Fauna Italiana. Ministero dell'Ambiente e Co-
mitato Scientifico per la Fauna d'ltalia, pp. 1-8.
Chemini C., 1996. Biogeographic patterns in the opil-
ionids of Italy. (Arachnida: Opiliones). Bollettino del
MUseo Civico di Storia Naturale di Verona, 30:531-
538.
Costa A., 1885. Notizie ed osservazioni sulla Geo-Fauna
sarda. Memoria Quinta. Risultamento delle ricerche
fatte nel mese di maggio. Rendiconti della Reale Ac-
cademia delle Scienze Fisiche e Matematiche di Na-
poli, Vol. 1, Ser. 2,1-31.
Komposch C. & Gruber J., 2004. Weberknechte oster-
reichs. Denisia 12 (Neue Serie), 14: 485-534.
Marcellino I., 1973. Opilioni (Arachnida) delle Isole
Eolie ed Egadi. Lavori della Societa Italiana di Bio-
geographia; Nuova Serie, 3: 329-339.
Marcellino I., 1975. Opilioni Italiani del gener eLacinius
THORELL, 1876, (Arachnida, Opiliones, Phalangii-
dae). Fragmenta entomologica, 11: 149-168.
Marcellino I., 1980. Opilioni di Sardegna (Arachnida,
Opiliones). Lavori della Societa Italiana di Biogeo-
grafia, Nuova Serie, 8: 323-345.
Martens J., 1978. Die Tierwelt Deutschlands 64. Teil,
Weberknechte, Opiliones. VEB Gustav Fischer
Verlag, Jena, 464 pp.
Prieto C. E., 2008. Updating the checklist of the Iberian
opiliofauna: corrections, suppressions and additions.
Revista Iberica de Aracnologia, 16: 49-65.
Roewer F., 1924. Opilioniden von der Insel Rhodos, Ita-
lien und Sardinien sowie der Cyrenaica. Bollettino
dei Musei di Zoologia e di Anatomia Comparata della
Reale Universita di Torino, 39: 1-7.
Roewer C.F., 1957. Uber Oligolophinae, Caddoinae,
Sclerosomatinae, Leiobuninae, Neopilioninae und
Leptobuninae (Phalangiidae, Opiliones Palpatores).
(Weitere Weberknechte XX). Senckenbergiana bio-
logica, 38: 323-358.
Trossarelli F., 1943. Contributo alio studio degli Oplio-
nidi Italiani. Bollettino della Societa Entomologica
Italiana, 5: 49-54.
Stoch F., 2003. In: Zuklat P., (Ed.), Checklist of the spe-
cies of the Italian fauna. Italian Ministry of Environ-
ment - Direction for Nature Protection (online
version 2.0). http://www.faunaitalia.it/checklist/intro-
duction.html
Stol I., 2007. Checklist of Nordic Opiliones. Norwegian
Journal of Entomology, 54: 23-26.
Wijnhoven H., 2009. De Nederlandse hooiwagens
(Opiliones). Entomologische Tabellen, Nr. 23.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 359-364
The potentially invasive opisthobranch Polycera hedgpeth Er.
Marcus, 1 964 (Gastropoda Nudibranchia), introduced in a Me-
diterranean coastal lagoon
Salvatore Giacobbe 1 ' & Sergio De Matteo 2
'Department of Biological and Environmental Sciences, Viale Ferdinando Stagno d’Alcontres 31, 98166 S. Agata-Messina, Italy;
email: sgiacobbe@unime.it
2 Mare Nostrum Italia, Via A. Sforza compl. Poker, pal. G. 1-98125 Messina, Italy
* Corresponding author
ABSTRACT The non-native opisthobranch Polycera hedgpethi Er. Marcus, 1964 is reported from the
coastal lagoon of Capo Peloro (Central Mediterranean Sea) with notes on its habitat typology
and feeding behavior. The recently published opinion that P. hedgpethi established in the
Mediterranean Sea is disputed, since records of adult specimens and egg laying were not
accompanied by the presence of juveniles and/or larvae. Mussels imported from Atlantic and
North- Adriatic lagoons are hypothesized to be the source of incoming populations in the
Peloro Lagoon.
KEY WORDS Opisthobranchs; Alien species; Sicily; Biopollution; Transitional waters.
Received 27.05.2013; accepted 26.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
Human activities are responsible of increasing
introductions of non-indigenous species (NIS)
worldwide. The rate of NIS introductions is notably
high in the Mediterranean Sea due to the strong
anthropogenic pressure, but also favoured by the
marked longitudinal and latitudinal gradients in
physical factors, and highly diversified habitat
typologies. Since investigation efforts are mainly
focused on those organisms having a potential
impact on the human economy, taxa with indirect
or weak interaction with anthropogenic activities
are less known. The opisthobranchs, as highly
diversified taxa including both generalist and
specialized species, which may display invasive
behaviors, constitute an ideal model to study colo-
nization processes. Some examples are Aplysia
dactilomela (Rang, 1 828), Bursatella leachii leachii
(Blainville, 1817), and Melibe viridis (Kelaart, 1858)
, whose spread throughout the Mediterranean was
carefully monitored (Cinar et al., 2006; Daskos &
Zenetos, 2007; Borg et al., 2009).
Polycera hedgpethi is a small sized nudi-
branch, which has been considered an invasive
species because of its worldwide distribution
(Wilson, 2006). This species, that is known from
the Mediterranean since 1988, has recently colo-
nized transitional and coastal environments in the
northern Adriatic (Keppel et al., 2012) and south
Tyrrhenian Sea.
In this note, the occurrence of P. hedgpethi in
the Lago Faro, coastal lagoon of Capo Peloro,
Sicily, is reported. The aim of this paper is to con-
tribute to the knowledge of the spread of P.
hedgpethi in the Mediterranean, as an example of
a species that could potentially become invasive.
360
Salvatore Giacobbe & Sergio De Matteo
METHODS
Study area
The Lago Faro (38 o 16’07”N, 15 0 38’13”E),
north-eastern Sicily, is a temperate body of water
(average temperature of shallow waters 20.4°C)
characterized by a meromictic regime which deter-
mines anoxic conditions below 10 m depth. Faro
is a mesotrophic lagoon (Sacca et ah, 2008) with
high levels of microbial productivity (Leonardi et
ah, 2009). A moderate anthropogenic contamina-
tion was attributed to the extensive shoreline ur-
banization (Giacalone et al., 2004; Minutoli et al.,
2008), but the impact of molluscan farms has not
been evaluated to date.
Molluscan assemblages have been scarcely in-
vestigated in the past (Spada, 1969; Parenzan,
1979), but recent data suggest the anthropogenic
introduction of some extra-Mediterranean species,
together with the progressive rarefaction of en-
demic taxa (Giacobbe, 2012). Alien molluscs, crus-
taceans and annelids from the Faro Lagoon were
also reported by Cosentino et al. (2011), Cosentino
& Giacobbe (2011), Crocetta (2012) and Gian-
grande et al. (2012).
Sampling
This research has been carried out in the
framework of the PRA 2008/2009 program: “Set-
tlement dynamics and colonization of allochthonous
assemblages in the Capo Peloro lagoon”. Quali-
tative surveys were carried out monthly since
March 2009, along the oxygenated shallower
lake-floors (0-4 m depth). Quantitative samples
were collected in 16 stations in Spring 2012, and
replicated in Autumn 2012 and Spring 2013. Each
station, covering a 100 m 2 surface, was explored
by means of a 5x5 m grid (four replicates). The
most easily recognizable opisthobranchs were
identified in situ, photographed and counted.
Some specimens were also collected to confirm
their identification, and preserved in ethanol 95%,
or formaldehyde 4%, or frozen at -24°C, accord-
ing to the different analytical requirements. Col-
lected specimens are currently deposited at the
Department of Biological and Environmental
Sciences, Messina, Italy.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A total of eight P. hedgpethi specimens were
found between April 2012 and May 2013 inside the
Faro Lagoon and adjacent channels. The specimens
were recorded in the stations shown in figure 1 , and
the data are summarized in table 1 . Four specimens
were found along the channel that connects the
Messina Strait with the lagoon (stations K14, K15,
K16). A mussel farm is located close to the inner
mouth. Mussel fanning is currently practiced in the
proximity of the K4 station, whereas stations K5
and K3 are not located near aquaculture farms.
All specimens were recorded on fouled hard
substrata, less than 1 m depth, except for the first
specimen, found at 1.5 m depth and the fourth
specimen, which was sampled on floating green
algae, Ulva rigida C. Agardh 1823 (Fig. 2). All the
specimens were found in association with bry-
ozoans, Bugula neritina (L., 1758), 3 specimens,
and Zoobotryon verticillatum (Delle Chiaje, 1822),
5 specimens. All the specimens, whose size was
comprised between 15 mm and 35 mm, showed the
characteristic chromatic pattern consisting in a
whitish background color, largely covered by dense
grey dots, with yellow-orange bands on propodial,
tentacles, rhinophores, branchial plumes and related
lateral processes, as accurately described by Keppel
et al. (2012) for Mediterranean specimens. A de-
scription of anatomical features was provided by
Cervera et al. (1988), who comprehensively con-
firmed previous records, except for some details in
the reproductive system.
Wilson (2006) indicated that P. hedgpethi is
native to California, where it is widely distributed
and common, and it was also recorded in several
localities both in Pacific and Atlantic oceans. The
species, that might be cryptogenic in the Caribbean,
was introduced to South Africa (Gosliner, 1982),
Australia (Wilson, 2006), New Zealand (Miller,
2001), Japan (Keiu, 2000), the Atlantic coasts of the
Iberian Peninsula (Caballer & Ortea, 2002), and the
Mediterranean Sea, where it was first reported from
the Fusaro Lake, south Tyrrhenian Sea (Cervera et
al., 1988). Subsequently, the species was found in
the coastal lagoon of Thau, Southern France
(http://www.seaslugfomm.net/fmd.cfin?id= 10791),
and more recently, in the North-Western Adriatic
Sea and the Venice Lagoon (Keppel et al., 2012),
the northernmost limit of its range.
The potentially invasive opisthobranch Polycera hedgpethi, introduced in a Mediterranean coastal lagoon
361
P. hedgpethi has a planktotrophic development
which favours natural dispersal (Goddard, 2004).
However, natural larval fluxes between the small
and sparsely situated Italian lagoons are difficult,
whilst human-mediated connections are frequent.
Because of the disjunct distribution of this species,
ship fouling was suggested as the most probable
vector (Ryland et al. 201 1) as its favourite prey, the
bryozoan Bugula neritina and other congeneric
species (McDonald & Nybakken, 1978; Gosliner,
Venice Lagoon
' N 4
Marina di Ravenna
Rimini
1 •'£&. v _ :,
1 VT?: V
-
; . -
Adriatic
Sea
Fusaro Lake
Tyrrenian
Sea
Sicily
Faro Lake
Ionian
Sea
at*.
1
2
3
Figure 1 . Distribution of P. hedgpethi in Italian waters. Faro Lake location and related sampling stations are reported. Figure
2. On-field photo of P. hedgpethi on floating green algae. Figure 3. On-field photo of P. hedgpethi preying upon Bugula ne-
ritina, with egg ribs.
362
Salvatore Giacobbe & Sergio De Matteo
1982) often grow on ship hulls. Nevertheless, P.
hedgpethi has been never reported from commercial
harbors in Mediterranean, while it occurs in moder-
ately polluted water bodies whose common trait is
the presence of mussel and oyster farms (Sacchi &
Renzoni, 1962; Ceccherelli & Barboni, 1983;
Malet et al., 2012; Giacobbe, 2012). (Fig. 1). The
regular occurrence in the Faro Lagoon of B. neritina
on mussels and oysters imported from both Atlantic
and Adriatic Sea, together with the Adriatic record
of P hedgpethi “on a mussel bed” (Keppel et al.,
2012), support the hypothesis of a mussel-mediated
spreading in the Mediterranean lagoons.
Spawning is documented in Spring (May 2012)
for the Faro Lagoon (Fig. 3), whilst in the Venice
Lagoon, Keppel et al. (2012) found egg masses in
Autumn, as reported by Gosliner, (1982) for South
hemisphere. Keppel et al. (2012) also found a juve-
nile specimen “which did not survive” and docu-
mented egg laying in the laboratory, followed by
larval hatch seven days later. Nevertheless, egg
laying is a common stress-induced response in opi-
sthobranchs, which does not necessarily involve
reproductive success. The low number of specimens
recorded in the Faro Lagoon confirms that P. hedg-
pethi introductions do not result in dense popula-
tions outside its native range (Cervera et al., 1988;
Caballer & Ortea, 2002; Cervera et al., 2010),
contrary to typical invasive behavior. Moreover, P.
hedgpethi was recently considered as casual in the
Mediterranean (Gofas & Zenetos, 2003; Zenetos et
al., 2010; Cervera et al., 2010; Occhipinti-Ambrogi
et al., 2011; Crocetta, 2012) until the recent records
from the Venice Lagoon, that were considered
consistent to an established population (Keppel et
al., 2012). Keppel et al. (2012) opinion was accep-
ted in the most recent revision by Crocetta et al.
(2013), because of the increased frequency of
specimens and egg depositions in different areas of
the Mediterranean, despite the fact that it was not
supported by the detection of a planktonic larvae
supply for self-sustaining populations. For a species
to be considered established, it is necessary to pro-
vide evidence of “self-maintaining and self-perpet-
uating populations” (European Commission, 2004).
In the case of P. hedgpethi such evidence is lacking
since no generation replacement has been observed.
On the contrary, the hypothesis of recurrent
pseudo-populations supported by external supplies
appears to agree with both the spatial-temporal dis-
continuity of records and disappearance of the species
from early-colonized areas (Villani, pers. comm.).
CONCLUSIONS
The present record of P hedgpethi increases the
number of NIS that have recorded in the Faro La-
goon, which might be considered a Mediterranean
hotspot for species introductions, similarly to the
larger and better known Venice Lagoon (Keppel et
al., 2012). The Mediterranean range of P hedgpethi
Specimen
n° 1
n° 2
n° 3
n° 4
n° 5
n° 6
n° 7
n° 8
Date
04/12/2012
05/16/2012
05/24/2012
05/24/2012
05/24/2012
05/24/2012
02/09/2013
05/15/2013
Station
K5
K13
K14
K14
K15
K16
K4
K16
Lat. N
38°16'12.2"
38°16’15"
38°15'59.78"
38°15'59.78"
38°15'57.40"
38°15'54.39"
30°16'9.4"
38°15'54.39"
Long. E
15°38'2.9"
15°38'10"
15°38'22.24"
15°38'22.24"
15°38'28.04"
15°38'35.01"
15°38'2.1"
15°38'35.01"
Depth
1.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
0.5 m
Substratum
iron
builders
beton
green algae
builders
builders
builders
green algae
Association
Zoo. vert.
Zoo. vert.
Bug. nerit.
Zoo. vert.
Zoo. vert.
Bug. nerit.
Bug. nerit.
Zoo. vert.
Table 1. Sampling data for the eight collected specimens. The associated preys, Zoobothryon verticillatum {Zoo. vert.)
and Bugula neritina {Bug. ner.), are indicated.
The potentially invasive opisthobranch Polycera hedgpethi, introduced in a Mediterranean coastal lagoon
363
suggests that its introduction in the Faro Lagoon
might be mediated by mussel and oyster fouling,
confirming the role of aquaculture as an important
pathway for introduction and/or secondary spread
into Mediterranean semi-enclosed water bodies.
Similarly to other non- indigenous and introduced
species, P hedgpethi needs to be carefully monitored
for a better management and spread prevention.
Nevertheless, this species does not appear to show
invasive characteristics despite its rapid worldwide
spread. P. hedgpethi might be recently established in
the Venice Lagoon, but this needs to be confirmed
with further evidence of the existence of self-main-
taining and self-perpetuating populations. The Venice
Lagoon might be the source of incoming populations
in the Faro Lagoon by mussel trade, but a direct in-
troduction from Atlantic farms cannot be discarded.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We tanks A. Valdes for manuscript critical review,
G. Villani for its suggestions and unpublished no-
tices, the “Provincia Regionale di Messina” and the
“Farau” mussel farm for permissions and facilities.
REFERENCES
Borg J.A., Evans J. & Schembri P.J., 2009. Occurrence
of the alien nudibranch Melibe viridis (Kelaart, 1858)
(Opisthobranchia,Tethydidae), in the Maltese Islands.
Mediterranean Marine Science, 10: 131-136.
Caballer M. & Ortea J.A., 2002. Primera cita de Polycera
hedgpethi Marcus, 1964 (Mollusca: Opisthobranchia)
para la Peninsula Iberica. Noticiario SEM, 37: 55-56.
Ceccherelli V.U. & Barboni A., 1983. Growth, survival
and yield of Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamk. on fixed
suspended culture in a bay of the Po River Delta.
Aquaculture, 34: 101-114.
Cervera J.L., Garcia-Gomez J.C., Toscano F. & Garcia
F.J., 1988. Polycera hedgpethi Marcus, 1964 (Gastro-
poda: Nudibranchia), an Indo-Pacific species dis-
covered in the Mediterranean Sea. Iberus, 8: 225-231.
Cervera J.L., Tamsouri N., Moukrim A. & Villani G.,
2010. New records of two alien opisthobranch
molluscs from the north-eastern Atlantic: Polycera
hedgpeti and Godiva quadricolor. Marine Biodiver-
sity Records, 3; e51: 4 pp.
Cinar M.E., Bilecenoglu M., Oztiirk B. & Can A., 2006.
New records of alien species on the Levantine coast
of Turkey. Aquatic Invasions, 1: 84-90.
Cosentino A., Giacobbe S. & Potoschi A., 2011. The CSI
of the Faro Lake (Messina): a natural observatory for
the incoming of marine alien species. Biologia Ma-
rina Mediterranea, 16: 132-133.
Cosentino A. & Giacobbe S., 20 1 1 . The new potential in-
vader Linopherus canariensis (Polychaeta: Amphino-
midae) in a Mediterranean coastal lake: Colonization
dynamics and morphological remarks. Marine Pollu-
tion Bulletin, 62: 236-245.
Crocetta F., 2012. Marine alien Mollusca in Italy: a
critical review and state of the knowledge. Journal of
the Marine Biological Association, 92: 1357-1365.
Crocetta F., Macali A., Furfaro G., Cooke S., Villani G.
& Valdes A., 2013. Alien molluscan established
along the italian shores: an update, with discussions
on some Mediterranean “alien species” categories.
ZooKeys, 277: 91-108.
Daskos A. & Zenetos A., 2007. Additions to the knowl-
edge of alien Opisthobranchia of Greece. Aquatic
Invasions, 2: 258-260.
European Commission, 2004. Environment Directorate-
General LIFE Focus I Alien species and nature con-
servation in the EU. The role of the LIFE program.
Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the
European Communities, 55 pp.
Giacalone A., GianguzzaA., Mannino M.R., Orecchio S.
& Piazzese D., 2004. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocar-
bons in sediments of marine coastal lagoons in Mes-
sina, Italy: extraction and GC/MS analysis,
distribution and sources. Polycyclic Aromatic
Compounds, 24: 135-149.
Giacobbe S., 2012. Biodiversity loss in Sicilian transi-
tional waters: the molluscs of Faro Lake. Biodiversity
Journal, 3: 501-510.
Giangrande A., Cosentino A., Lo Presti C. & Licciano
M., 2012. Sabellidae (Annelida) from the Faro
coastal lake (Messina, Ionian Sea), with the first
record of the invasive species Branchiomma bairdi
along the Italian coasts. Mediterranean Marine
Science, 13: 283-293.
Goddard J.H.R., 2004. Develpmental mode in benthic
opisthobranch molluscs from the northeast Pacific
Ocean: feeding in a sea of plenty. Canadian Journal
of Zoology, 82: 1954-1968.
Gofas S. & Zenetos A., 2003. Exotic molluscs in the
Mediterranean basin: current status and perspectives.
Oceanography and Marine Biology: an Annual
Review, 41: 237-277.
Gosliner T.M., 1982. A new record of the nudibranch
gastropod Polycera hedgpethi Marcus, from the
Indian Ocean of South Africa. Journal of Molluscan
Studies, 48: 30-35.
Keppel E., Sigovini M. & Tagliapietra D., 2012. Anew
geographical record of Polycera hedgpethi Er. Mar-
cus, 1964 (Nudibranchia: Polyceridae) and evidence
364
Salvatore Giacobbe & Sergio De Matteo
of its established presence in the Mediterranean Sea,
with a review of its geographical distribution. Marine
Biology Research, 8: 969-981.
Keiu S., 2000. Opisthobranchs of Izu Peninsula, TBS-
Britannica Co., Ltd, Tokyo. 184 pp.
Leonardi M., Azzaro F., Azzaro M., Caruso G., Mancuso
M., Monticelli L.S., Maimone G., La Ferla R., Raffa
F. & Zaccone R., 2009. A multidisciplinary study of
Cape Peloro brackish area (Messina, Italy): charac-
terizzation of tropic conditions, microbial abundances
and activities. Marine Ecology, 30: 32-42.
Malet N., Pastoureaud A., Vaquer A., Quere C. & Du-
broca L., 2012. Marine diatoms sustain growth of
bivalves in a Mediterranean lagoon. Journal of Sea
Research, 68: 20-32.
McDonald G.R., & Nybakken J.W., 1978. Additional
notes on the food of some California nudibranchs
with a summery of known food habits of California
species. Veliger, 21:110-118.
Miller M.C., 2001. Descriptions of the dorid nudibranchs
Polycerci hedgpethi Marcus, 1964 and P.fujitai Baba,
1937 in New Zealand. Journal of Molluscan Studies,
67: 491-499.
Minutoli R., Fossi M.C., Zagami G., Granata A. & Gu-
glielmo L., 2008. First application of biomarkers
approach in the zooplanktonic copepod Acartia lati-
setosa for the early management and conservation of
transitional waters ecosystem. Transitional Water
Bulletin, 1: 45-52.
Occhipinti-Ambrogi A., Marchini A., Cantone G., Castelli
A., Chimenz C., Cormaci M., Froglia C., Furnari G.,
Gambi M.C., Giaccone G., Giangrande A., Gravilli
C., Mastrototaro F., Mazziotti C., Orsi-Relini L. & Pi-
raino S., 2011. Alien species along the Italian coasts:
An overview. Biological Invasions, 13: 215-237.
Parenzan P., 1979. Fauna malacologica dei laghi di
Ganzirri e del Faro (Messina). Thalassia Salentina,
9: 67-78.
Ryland J.S., Bishop J.D.D., De Blauwe H., El Nagar A.,
MinchinD., Wood C. A. &Yunnie A.L.E., 2011. Alien
species of Bugula (Bryozoa) along the Atlantic coasts
of Europe. Aquatic Invasions, 6: 17-31.
Sacca A., Guglielmo L. & Bruni, V., 2008. Vertical and
temporal microbial community patterns in a meromic-
tic coastal lake influenced by the Straits of Messina
upwelling system. Hydrobiologia, 600: 89-104.
Sacchi C.F. & Renzoni A., 1962. L'ecologie de Mytilus
galloprovincialis (Lam.) dans Te tang littoral du Fu-
saro et les rythmes annuels et nyctemeraux des
facteurs environnants. Pubblicazioni della Stazione
Zoologica di Napoli, 32 (Suppl.): 255-293.
Spada A., 1969. Breve esplorazione malacologica del
lago di Ganzirri e del Pantano di Torre del Faro
presso Messina. Conchiglie, 5: 60-65.
Terrence M.G., 1982. Anew record of the nudibranch ga-
stropod Polycerci hedgpethi Marcus, from the Indian
Ocean of South Africa. Journal of Molluscan Studies,
48: 30-35.
Wilson N., 2006. New record of the nudibranch Poly-
cera hedgpethi Er. Marcus, 1964, in South Australia,
with a discussion on its occurrence in Australia. Re-
cords of the Western Australian Museum, Suppl.
69:137-140.
Zenetos A., Gofas S., Verlaque M., £inar M.E., Garcia-
Raso J.E., Bianchi C.N., Morri C., Azzurro E., Bile-
cenoglu M., Froglia C., Siokou I., Violanti D., Sfriso
A., San Martin G., Giangrande A., Katagan T., Bal-
lesteros E., Ramos-Espla A., Mastrototaro F., Ocana
0. , Zingone A., Gambi M.C. & Streftaris N., 2010.
Alien species in the Mediterranean by 2010. A
contribution to the application of European Union’s
Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD). Part
1. Spatial distribution. Mediterranean Marine Science,
11: 381-493.
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 365-378
Fossil starfishes (EchinodermataAsteriidae) and paleontolo-
gical analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region
(NW Italy)
Giovanni Repetto 1 & Erica Bicchi 2
'Museo civico «Federico Eusebio», via Vittorio Emanuele II n. 19 - 12051 Alba, Cuneo, Italy; e-mail: gianrepetto@yahoo.it
2 Pole Sciences de l'environnement, Groupe Esaip, St Barthelemy d' Anjou Cedex, France; e-mail: ebicchi@esaip.org
■"Corresponding author
ABSTRACT The remarkable discovery of two fossil starfishes in the Pliocene clay of Cherasco (NW
Italy), allowed to analyze in detail the sediment and paleontological material associated
(malacofauna and foraminifers assemblages), aiming at reconstructing paleoenvironmental
conditions in which these organisms lived. Furthermore biostratigraphic analysis based on
planktonic foraminiferal assemblages, allowed the recognition of the MP12 biozone of lower
Pliocene.
KEY WORDS Astropecten; malacofauna; Foraminifera; paleoenvironmental reconstruction; Pliocene.
Received 02.06.2013; accepted 22.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
The structure of starfish bodies is maintained by
soft tissues that rapidly disaggregate after death and
the discovery of remains relies on exceptional con-
ditions of preservation. In the Pliocene clay of Che-
rasco (Cuneo, Piedmont region, NW Italy), these
exceptional conditions allowed the discoveiy of two
fossil starfishes, attributed to Asteroidea. The fossil
record of starfishes is very sparse in Piedmont re-
gion. In the literature only two other discoveries of
Asteroidea are known in the area albese-braidese:
Astropecten bispinosus (Otto, 1823), reported by
Sacco (1893) for the Pliocene of Bra, and a print,
unfortunately devoid of significant details, illus-
trated by Cavallo et al. (1986), found in the Torto-
nian marls at Alba.
The remarkable discovery allowed to be analyzed
in detail the sediment and paleontological material
associated. The analysis focused first on the paleon-
tological study of fossil starfish, and in a second step
on malacofauna and foraminiferal assemblages in
order to characterize these clays of Cherasco from
paleocologic and biostratigraphic points of view, for
which no specific data exist in the literature.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Cherasco (Cuneo, Piedmont region, NW Italy)
(Fig. 1) is located in a plain extending towards the
South West, bordered in the North West by the
Stura of Demonte river and in the East by the Ta-
naro river. In the western part of Cherasco, the
plain is strongly incised by “Rii di San Giovanni”
(30-40 meters depth). The fossil starfishes have
been discovered on the left side of the Rio Crosio,
one of the “Rii di San Giovanni” (3.5 km long).
The outcrop (20 m long) is located at 240 m a.s.l.
(44°38’48” N; 7°51’7” E), and it is composed of
grey-blue muddy clays which are continuous and
homogenous, 15 m thick (Figs. 2, 3). The Pliocene
366
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
Figure 1. Location of Pliocene outcrop near Cherasco (Piedmont region, NW Italy). Figures 2, 3. Outcrop view of the
Pliocene clays.
muddy clays are outcropped by quaternary allu-
vions (see geological map of Italy, foglio 80
Cuneo).
The two fossils were found in the upper meter
of the outcrop. The oral ventral sides of the two
specimens were visible and in discrete preserva-
tion. The better preserved specimen has a diameter
of 60 mm (Fig. 4), while the other one is 55 mm
(Fig. 5). The muddy clay matrix, including speci-
mens, was disaggregated and observed under a mi-
croscope to analyze the malacofauna and
foraminiferal assemblages. For the malacofauna,
3 liters of sediment were observed after being
water sieved.
For foraminiferal assemblages, a sample of 300
g was previously disaggregated in hydrogen perox-
ide (120% by volume), for about 1 hour. Later it
was divided into four size fractions: >315 pm, 1 50-
315 pm, 125-150 pm, 63-125 pm. For the >315
pm, 150-315 pm, 125-150 pm fractions, a quanti-
tative study was performed on a volume of residue
after drying, split with an Otto microsplitter (Scott
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 367
et al., 1980) in order to obtain a representative quan-
tity of the particle size fraction. This allowed to be
evaluated the abundance of the residue, the state of
preservation of tests of foraminifera and the pres-
ence of any other organogenic and inorganic com-
ponents. The foraminiferal assemblages were
subsequently the subject of specific determination
and quantitative analysis. For the fraction 63-125
pm, which consists almost exclusively of biogenic
fragments and minute foraminifera shells, that only
in rare cases allow attribution of precise species
(Schonfeld et al., 2012 ), specific determinations
were not performed.
RESULTS
ECHINODERMATA ASTERIIDAE
Astropecten cf. irregularis pentacanthus
(Delle Chiaje, 1825)
The starfish, belonging to the same species,
were attributed without doubt to the genus Astro-
pecten Gray, 1 840; this systematic group currently
includes, worldwide, more than a hundred species
living in muddy and sandy bottoms of the littoral
system, with the exception of some species which
are bathyfile (Tortonese, 1965).
The comparison, as far as possible, with the
species of Astropecten currently present in the
Mediterranean, is particularly difficult in the ab-
sence of the clear visibility of anatomical structures
useful for this puipose. Nevertheless the Astropecten
analyzed can be attributed to the species A. irregu-
laris (Pennant, 1777) and more precisely to the sub-
species A. irregularis pentacanthus (Delle Chiaje,
1825). Fossil specimens from Cherasco, in addition
to the general morphological characteristics, showed
strong similarities with the subspecies mentioned
in: a) the apices of the arms, more or less rounded;
b) the size of the individuals close to the dimension
of individuals currently living in the Mediterranean,
which generally have a diameter of 80-120 mm; c)
the ratio R/r 4.4 to 4.7 which seems consistent with
their stage of growth, considering that it tends to be
greater in the larger specimens (Borghi & Bajo
Campos, 2008); and finally, d) because this subspe-
cies, which in the Mediterranean appears to be the
most frequent Asteroidea, is present on the muddy
or sandy-clay seabed at depths from 2 to 200 m
(Riedl, 1991). The brick-red color of the fossil spec-
imens is probably due to the processes of oxidation
of organic tissues.
Unfortunately, the clay investigated did not re-
turn ossicles of Asteroidea which, if present, could
possibly provide additional information for a more
exact specific determination.
Figure 4. Astropecten cf. irregularis pentacanthus, D 60 mm, from Cherasco, ventral side. Figure 5. Other specimen of A.
cf irregularis pentacanthus, D 55 mm, from Cherasco, ventral side.
368
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
MALACOFAUNA
Given the extreme fragility of the shells, it was
hardly possible to isolate whole shells: even the
species of a few millimeters not resisted to the usual
treatments of water clay filtration, so it can be re-
trieved only in fragments. In association with bi-
valve fragments, have been found carbon wood,
parts of claws and fragments of crustaceans de-
capods arts and a dozen calcareous tubes of Ditrupa
sp. A list in systematic order of the species is found
below (Figs. 6-19)
Turritella spirata (Brocchi, 1814)
Examined material. 1 specimen (teleoconch al-
most complete) (Fig. 14).
Remarks. Although it is sometimes present in
shallower environments and not in pelitic facies,
generally outcrops where the species is found indi-
cate a muddy circalittoral-bathyal environment
(Borghi & Vecchi, 2005). This species, in fact, is
characteristic of shale and marl facies of the Mio-
cene and Pliocene (Malatesta, 1974).
Aporrhais uttingerianus peraraneosus (Sacco,
1893)
Examined material. 2 specimens (fragments).
Remarks. The fragments of Aporrhais Da Costa,
1778 found, show long and thin digits, which allow
to assign them to the subspecies peraraneosus. The
presence of this subspecies in the Rio Crosio is al-
ready mentioned by Charrier (1953). Probably the
long and thin digits are an adaptive character that
promotes the activities of these animals in the
particular seabed in which they live. In fact, the large
surface area between the coil and the digits tips line,
and the thinness of digits in proportion to their very
low weight, allows the bivalve, during their repta-
tion (movements), to "float" more smoothly on the
soft mud of seabed (Damarco, 1994). The ecological
niche of A. uttingerianus peraraneosus is now oc-
cupied by A. serresianus (Michaud, 1828), species
originating from the Atlantic Ocean and which oc-
casionally penetrated into the Mediterranean during
the Pliocene (Forli, 1989). This species developed
and proliferated later in the Quaternary (Ruggieri,
1971), and it is currently living in the mud-detritic
bottoms of the circalittoral zone also deep (Terreni,
1981; Brunetti & Forli, 2013).
Euspira sp.
Examined material. 1 specimen, in poor preser-
vation.
Remarks. The specimen found was too deterio-
rated and specific determination was impossible.
Phalium saburon (Bruguiere, 1792)
Examined material. 1 specimen (protoconch
more than 3 whorls of teleoconch).
Remarks. It is a euribate species, being corre-
lated to the deep muddy bottoms, in the circalittoral
and in the bathyal zones (settings) (Peres & Picard,
1964). In fact it lives in the Mediterranean Sea on
sandy muddy bottoms of the circalittoral zone
(Chirli, 2008).
Nassarius elatus (Gould, 1845)
Examined material. 2 specimens (1 juvenile)
(Figs. 6, 7). In the protoconch of the figure 7, the
slight rib characterizes the first whorls of teleoconch.
Remarks. The species has been reported by
Adam & Glibert (1975) for a dozen Italian fossil lo-
calities, both of the Lower and Upper Pliocene and
it can be confused with N. semistriatus (Brocchi,
1814). It still lives in the Mediterranean sandy-
muddy infra-circalittoral seabed.
Bela nitida Pavia, 1976
Examined material. 2 specimens (1 juvenile)
(Fig. 8).
Remarks. According to Pavia (1976) this species
is present in the lower and middle Pliocene of the
Piedmont (Monteu Roero, Valle Botto-Asti) and of
the Liguria (Rio Torsero-Ceriale).
Raphitoma leufroyi (Michaud, 1828)
Examined material. 2 specimens (1 juvenile).
(Figs. 9, 10). In figure 10 is illustrated planktotrophic
multispiral with 3 whorls, the first decorated by mi-
crogranules arranged in spirals, while the subsequent
whorls show sculpture canceled trending sigmoidal.
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 369
Figure 6. Nassarius elatus, h 1 1 .2 mm. Figure 7. Protoconch of N. elatus, magnification 9x. Figure 8. Bela nitida, h 3 mm, predation
hole on the penultimate whorl. Figure 9. Raphitoma leufroyi, h 2.3 mm. Figure 10. Protoconch of R. leufroyi, magnification 37x.
Figure 11. Odostomia conoidea, h 1.4, Figure 12. Idem, h 1.8 mm. Figure 13. Protoconch of O. conoidea, magnification 29x.
Figure 14. Turritella spirata, h 23 mm. Figure 15. Korobkovia oblonga, right valve, D 24.6 mm. Figure 16. Myrtea spinifera, D
6.9 mm, external and internal view of left valve, with predation hole. Figure 1 7. Neopycnodonte navicularis, external view of left
valve D 62.8 mm. Figure 18. Idem, right valve D 45.4 mm. Figure 19. Corbula gibba, D 4.4 mm, external view of right valve.
370
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
Remarks. The specimen sampled, with two
whorls of teleoconch, is rather young, but its
preservation is excellent. This species lives on all
types of bottoms, from a few meters to about 150
m in depth (Poppe & Goto, 1991).
Odostomia conoidea (Brocchi, 1814)
Examined material. 2 specimens (Figs. 11-13).
The protoconch of the figure 13 consists of 2 whorls,
the first of which is wound in a spiral with the axis
approximately at right angles to the axis of the shell,
well represents the protoconch of “type A”, accord-
ing to van Aartsen (1987).
Remarks. According to Scaperrotta et al. (2011)
and Chirli & Micali (2011), this species lives in the
Mediterranean sea on the muddy-sandy bottoms of
the infra-circalittoral zone.
Philine cf. scabra (Muller O.F., 1784)
Examined material. 1 specimen (fragments).
Remarks. Fiving on sandy and mud-sandy bot-
toms at lower depths (Thompson, 1976).
Roxania utriculus (Brocchi, 1814)
Examined material. 1 specimen (juvenile).
Remarks. Fiving on the mud bottoms of the cir-
calittoral zone (150 m depth) (Ardovini & Cossi-
gnani, 1999).
Yoldia nitida (Brocchi, 1814)
Examined material. 1 specimen: fragments of
the right valve.
Remarks. The genus Yoldia is found on the
muddy-sandy bottoms of the infralittoral zone.
Aequipecten angelonii (De Stefani et Pantanelli,
1878)
Examined material. 1 specimen: fragments of
the left valve.
Remarks. It seems that this species was found
exclusively in clay-marl outcrops attributed to the
Pliocene: in the “turquoise clays“ of Colle Melame-
renda of coralligenous area (De Stefani & Panta-
nelli, 1878); in clays of Castelnuovo d'Asti, in
Fomaci di Savona and in Piacenza area (Sacco,
1897); in the marl of Rio Torsero in Savona (Andri
et al., 2005).
Flabellipecten bosniasckii (De Stefani et Pan-
tanelli, 1880)
Examined material. 1 specimen: fragments of
left and right valves.
Remarks. The Flabellipecten Sacco, 1897 con-
stitute a group adapted to live on soft bottoms,
therefore characterize all sandy-clayey facies of the
Upper Miocene and Pliocene (Malatesta, 1974).
Mimachlamys cf. varia (Linnaeus, 1758)
Examined material. 3 partials valves, 1 right.
Remarks. The species is ubiquitous: it lives on
rocky-gravelly-muddy bottoms, often with fine
bissus attached to the sponges (Malatesta, 1974).
Some authors (Tebble, 1966; Poppe & Goto,
1993), referring especially to the Atlantic Ocean,
reported M. varia at 83 m maximum depth, and
Terreni (1981) reported this species in Mediter-
ranean area living on the muddy-sandy bottoms in
the infra-circalittoral zone. Parenzan (1974) re-
ports it from 1350 m deep, but adds that the nor-
mal environment does not exceed perhaps a
hundred meters.
Korobkovia oblonga (Philippi, 1844)
Examined material. 1 specimen: right valve
(Fig. 15).
Remarks. This species is restricted to the silts
and fine-grained calcarenites of the base of the
Pliocene (Jimenez et al., 2009).
Neopycnodonte navicularis (Brocchi, 1814)
Examined material. 7 right valves (3 partials
and 1 juvenile) and 2 left valves (only 1 with um-
bonal area) (Figs. 17, 18).
Remarks. It seems certain, as reported by Ma-
latesta (1974), that the actual N. cochlear (Poli,
1795) result from a genetic mutation of Neopycno-
donte navicularis extinct in the late Pliocene;
regarding N. cochlear , Parenzan (1974) and Terreni
(1981) reported that it lives from a hundred feet to
over 1 000 m depth, on the muddy-debris bottoms
of the deep circalittoral zone.
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 371
Myrtea spinifera (Montagu, 1803)
Examined material. 1 specimen: left valve
(Fig. 16).
Remarks. In the Mediterranean it has been found
in the biocenosis of unstable bottom sediments (Ma-
latesta, 1974); in the British Islands it has been found
to a maximum depth of 1 1 0 m (Tebble, 1 966), on the
Tuscan coast (Italy); it lives in the detritic mud-bot-
tom of infra-circalittoral zone (Terreni, 1981).
Clausinella fasciata (Da Costa, 1778)
Examined material. 1 specimen: fragments of
the left valve.
Remarks. The species lives burrowing into the
gravelly, gravelly-stony, stony or sandy-muddy sed-
iment, up to about 110 m depth (Tebble, 1966).
According to Scaperrotta et al. (2009), it prefers wa-
ters with coarse gravel or gravel and mud, from a
few meters to over 1 00 m in depth.
Timoclea ovata (Pennant, 1777)
Examined material. 3 valves (partials)
Remarks. Euribathyal species, reported for the
Mediterranean from a few meters up to 700 meters
depth, on the muddy-debris bottoms (Malatesta,
1974).
Corbula gibba (Olivi, 1792)
Examined material. 1 right valve (partial) e 3
left (juveniles and partial). The external view of
right valve (Fig. 1 9) is characterized by a large ventral
rib concentric sculpture.
Remarks. In the Mediterranean it is found in the
biocenosis of the seabed debris (80-130 m) of the
infralittoral zone; with the polychaete Ditrupa arie-
tina (O.F. Muller, 1776) this species is characteristic
of the biocenosis of instable bottoms (Malatesta,
1974). This species seems to prefer muddy or
sandy-muddy bottoms (Scaperrotta et al., 2009).
The polychaete Ditrupa sp., of which we found
a dozen specimens, also lives in sandy-muddy bot-
toms and constitutes an indicator of the depth range
of substrate. It is a genus characteristic of biocoeno-
sis of unstable bottom which Peres & Picard (1964)
placed at depths between 35 to just over 100 m.
FORAMINIFERA
The residue of the sample is quantitatively
scarce. For the three fractions considered, the inor-
ganic materials are predominantly made up of abun-
dant particles of iron oxides, frequent angular
particles of quartz and lamellae of muscovite, some
rare granule mineralized with pyrite and glauconite.
The percentage of the inorganic fraction constitutes
60% of the residue for the >315 pm fraction, it
tends to decrease to about 40% in the 150-315 pm
fraction, to increase up to 80% of the residue in the
125-150 pm fraction. This increase is marked by an
abundance of muscovite flakes lamellae that be-
come prevalent.
The organogenic residue consists mainly of
abundant fragments of pyritized and partially oxi-
dized plant frustules, frequent fragments of echino-
derm spines and prevailing benthic foraminifera,
generally very well preserved. Sometimes there are
rare individuals mineralized with pyrite and glau-
conite. The planktonic foraminifera, in all fractions
analyzed, were extremely rare.
Benthic foraminifera
The benthic foraminiferal assemblages (44
species, Table 1) were represented principally by
hyaline species. Only two agglutinated species were
present, but rare ( Bigenerina nodosaria and Textu-
laria sp.). The porcellanaceous species were absent.
Species more abundant than 4% of the assemblage
of at least one station were described and consid-
ered as dominant: Bolivina anaeriensis, B. pun-
ctata :, Bulimina aculeata, B. lappa , B. inflata,
Stainforthia complanata, Uvigerina peregrina and
Valvulineria bradyana (Figs. 20-35; Fig. 36). In the
coarser fraction (>315 pm) Uvigerina peregrina
(-34%) and Valvulineria bradyana (-20%) pre-
vailed. Bulimina aculeata was almost frequent
( — 11%), while the species of genus Bolivina d'Or-
bigny, 1839 and Stainforthia complanata were rare
(<3%) (Fig. 36). In the 150-315 pm fraction the
percentage of Uvigerina peregrina was similar to
the coarser fraction, while the percentage of Valvu-
lineria bradyana decreased considerably (-13.5%).
The species of genus Bulimina d'Orbigny, 1826
showed a variable trend. Bulimina aculeata de-
creased (5%), while Bulimina lappa increased
strongly (-8%). Lenticulina calcar, absent in the
372
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
Benthic foraminifera
>315p
150-315p
125-150p
>315p
150-315p
125-150p
Split
.1/2
.1/8
.1/8
%
%
%
Hyaline species
Ammonia tepicla (Cushman, 1926)
1
0.0
0.0
0.4
Amphicoryna scalaris (Batsch, 1791)
2
0.0
0.7
0.0
Asterigerinata mammilla (Williamson, 1848)
1
0.0
0.0
0.4
Bolivina punctata d'Orbigny, 1839 (Fig. 22)
8
27
6
2.9
9.7
2.3
Bolivina albatrossi Cushman, 1922 (Fig. 21)
6
0.0
0.0
2.3
Bolivina alata (Seguenza, 1862)
9
0.0
0.0
3.4
Bolivina anaeriensis (Costa, 1856) (Fig. 23)
4
8
11
1.4
2.9
4.1
Bolivina dil alata Reuss, 1850
7
0.0
0.0
2.6
Bolivina spathulata (Williamson, 1858) (Fig. 24)
1
2
7
0.4
0.7
2.6
Bulimina aculeata d'Orbigny, 1826 (Fig. 25)
30
15
4
10.8
5.4
1.5
Bulimina lappa Cushman et Parker, 1937 (Fig. 20)
4
23
20
1.4
8.2
7.5
Bulimina inflata Seguenza, 1862 (Fig. 26)
13
11
14
4.7
3.9
5.3
Cassidulina carinata Silvestri, 1 896
1
0.0
0.0
0.4
Chilostomella oolina Schwager, 1878
3
1.1
0.0
0.0
Cibicides kullenbergi Parker, 1953
7
2.5
0.0
0.0
Cibicides sp.
1
9
0.4
0.0
3.4
Dentalina leguminiformis (Batsch, 1791)
1
1
0.4
0.0
0.4
Florilus boueanum (d'Orbigny, 1 846)
1
3
1
0.4
1.1
0.4
Globobulimina affinis (d'Orbigny, 1839)
4
1
1.4
0.4
0.0
Gyroidina altiformis (R.E. et K.C. Stewart, 1930)
1
0.4
0.0
0.0
Gyroidinoides umbonatus (Silvestri, 1898)
5
8
0.0
1.8
3.0
Heterolepa floridana (Cushman, 1922)
5
1.8
0.0
0.0
Lenticulina calcar (Linnaeus, 1767) (Fig. 28)
1
19
2
0.4
6.8
0.8
Marginulina hirsuta d'Orbigny, 1826 (Fig. 31)
3
0.0
1.1
0.0
Marginulina costata (Batsch, 1791) (Fig. 32)
6
2.2
0.0
0.0
Melonis padanum (Perconig, 1952) (Fig. 29)
8
2.9
0.0
0.0
Oridorsalis umbonatus (Reuss, 1851)
4
4
3
1.4
1.4
1.1
Pandaglandulina dinapolii Loeblich et Tappan, 1955
2
0.7
0.0
0.0
Planularia sp.
1
0.0
0.0
0.4
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 373
Pullenia bulloides (d'Orbigny, 1846)
5
6
3
1.8
2.2
1.1
Rectuvigerina bononiensis (Fomasini, 1888)
1
0.4
0.0
0.0
Rectuvigerina siphogenerinoides (Lipparini, 1932)
1
1
0.0
0.4
0.4
Saracenaria italica Defrance, 1824
1
0.0
0.4
0.0
Sphaeroidina bulloides d'Orbigny, 1826
4
1.4
0.0
0.0
Stainforthia complanata (Egger, 1893) (Fig. 27)
1
3
13
0.4
1.1
4.9
Stilostomella advena (Cushman et Laiming, 1931)
6
5
2
2.2
1.8
0.8
Stilostomella sp.
1
0.4
0.0
0.0
Trifarina angulosa (Williamson, 1858)
1
0.0
0.0
0.4
Uvigerina auberiana d'Orbigny, 1839
1
3
0.0
0.4
1.1
Uvigerina peregrina Cushman, 1923 (Fig. 33)
95
98
27
34.3
35.1
10.2
Valvulineria bradyana/ complanata (Fig. 30)
58
38
104
20.9
13.6
39.1
Agglutinated species
Bigenerina nodosaria d'Orbigny, 1 826
2
0.0
0.7
0.0
Textularia sp.
2
1
0.7
0.4
0.0
Total number of specimens
277
279
266
100.0
100.0
100.0
Table 1. Benthic foraminifera from Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy).
Planktonic foraminifera
>315p
150-315p
125-150p
Split
.1/2
.1/8
.1/8
Globigerina bulloides d'Orbigny, 1826
2
2
2
Globigerina falconensis Blow, 1959
2
2
2
Globigerina glutinata (Egger, 1 893)
1
Globigerinoides obliquus extremus Bolli et Bermudez, 1965 (Fig. 35)
2
Globigerinoides elongatus (d'Orbigny, 1826)
1
Globorotalia cf. magaritae (Bolli et Bermudez, 1965)
1
Neogloboquadrina acostaensis Blow, 1959
1
1
Orbulina universa d'Orbigny, 1839 (Fig. 34)
3
1
Sphaeroidinellopsis dehiscens (Parker et Jones, 1865)
3
1
Total number of specimens
12
8
7
Table 2. Planktonic fora min ifera from Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy).
374
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
Figure 20. Bulimina lappa. Figure 2F Bolivina albatrossi. Figure 22. Bolivina punctata. Figure 23. Bolivina anaeriensis.
Figure 24. Bolivina spathulata. Figure 25. Bulimina aculeata. Figure 26. Bulimina inflata. Figure 27. Stainforthia com-
planata. Figure 28. Lenticulina calcar. Figure 29. Melonis padanum. Figure 30. Valvulineria bradyana. Figure 3F Mar-
ginulina hirsuta. Figure 32. Marginulina costata. Figure 33. Uvigerina peregrina. Figure 34. Orbulina universa. Figure
35. Globigerinoides obliquus extremus. Each scale bar represents 100 |im.
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 375
coarser fraction, was present with a value of ~5%.
The percentage of Bulimina inflata was constant in
the three fractions considered (4-5%) (Fig. 37). In
the 125-150 pm fraction Uvigerina peregrina de-
creased with a minimum of 10%, while Valvuline-
ria bradyana increased with a maximum of 39%.
Bulimina aculeata decreased strongly (~1%); Bu-
limina lappa , on the contrary, increased (5%). Len-
ticulina calcar was still present, but with an
extremely low percentage (-0.5%). The genus Bo-
livina and Stainforthia, due to their natural small
dimensions, were more frequent in the finer frac-
tion (Fig. 37).
In the thanathocenosis the species allochthounous
were rare. Among these Ammonia tepida, Asteri-
gerinata mammilla have been recognized and in-
dividuals belonging to the genus Cibicides de
Montfort, 1808, typical of infralittoral zone. It
showed clearly signs of transport, highlighted by
the poor preservation of the shell. The autochthonous
fauna was represented by species typical of an
outer continental shelf and an upper continental
slope. For example the agglutinated Bigenerina
nodosaria, Uvigerina peregrina, Valvulineria
bradyana, Bulimina spp., Lenticulina and Boli-
vina spp. Uvigerina peregrina, a shallow infaunal
species living close to the sediment-water inter-
face, is characteristic of mesotrophic to eutrophic
continental slope settings (Lutze & Coulbourn,
1984; Corliss, 1985, 1991; Lutze, 1986; Corliss &
Emerson, 1990; Mackensen et al., 1995; Schmiedl
& Mackensen, 1997; Jannik et al., 1998; Kuhnt et
al., 1999; De Rijk et al., 2000; Schmiedl et al.,
2000; Morigi et al., 2001; Huang et al., 2002; Fon-
tanier et al., 2003).
Valvulineria bradyana is a typical species of
pelitic-sandy bottoms, characterized by low oxygen
content and rich in organic matter (Bergamin et al.,
1999). B. aculeata is generally also considered as a
eutrophic species, typical of low-oxygen environ-
ments (Murray, 1991). The Bolivina species (ex. B.
aenariensis and B. punctata), infaunals, are charac-
teristics of muddy bottoms and they are particularly
tolerant to reduced oxygenation levels, in environ-
ments such as meso-eutrophic (Blanc-Vemet, 1969;
di Napoli Alliata et al., 1970; Van der Zwaan, 1983;
Murray, 1991; Barmawidjaja et al., 1992; Sen
Gupta & Machain-Castillo, 1993).
Planktonic foraminifera
Planktonic foraminiferal assemblages were ex-
tremely poor in the three fractions considered (9
species, Table 2). Individuals, sometimes strongly
pyritizided or glauconitized of Orbulina universa
were found in association with rare Globigerina bul-
loides, G. falconensis and G. glutinata, as well as rare
Globigerinoides obliquus extremus, G. elongatus e
Sphaeroidine- llopsis dehischens. Only one specimen
of Globorotalia cf. margaritae was found in the
coarser fraction. The genus Neogloboquadrina
Frerichs et Vincent, 1 967 was also extremely rare. In-
deed only two specimens of N. acostaensis were iden-
tified. Globigerinoides obliquus extremus and Or-
bulina universa are represented in the figures 34, 35.
Figure 36. Total percentage of benthic fora min iferal dominant
species.
Figure 37. Percentage of benthic foraminifera dominant species
for all studied fraction (>315 pm, 150-315 pm, 125-150 pm).
376
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
In an outcrop of Pliocene clays near Rio Crosio
(Cherasco, Piemonte, NW Italy) two specimens of
fossil starfish were found, attributed to Astropecten
irregularis pentacanthus (Delle Chiaje, 1825).
The analysis of the malacofauna and the benthic
foraminiferal assemblages has provided paleoeco-
logical and paleoenvironmental data indicating a
circalittoral deep environment, little more than 100
m depth and characterized by a muddy bottom; the
trophic conditions were from meso to eutrophic,
with a rather low level of oxygenation, which thus
enabled the survival of upper and intermediate in-
faunals tolerant species, such as Uvigerina pere-
grina, Valvulineria bradyana, various species of the
genus Bulimina and genus Bolivina. On the base of
planktonic foraminiferal assemblages ( Globigeri -
noides obliquus extremus, G. elongatus, genus
Sphaeroidinellopsis Banner et Blow, 1959 and Glo-
borotalia margaritae ), the samples are attributed to
biozone MP12 of lower Pliocene (Zanclean) which,
according to Violanti (2012) in the NW Italy, corre-
spond to 5.08 and 4.52 Ma. The absence of species
such as Globorotalia inflata and Bulimina margi-
nata, very frequent in the upper Pliocene (Lentini,
1969), allows to confirm this datation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are sincerely grateful to B. Tibaldi and G.
Grisotto, for providing the samples for this study
and the data about outcrop; R. Brancato, L. Lacroce
and E. Borghi for the useful data provided. We also
thanks E. Ferrero Mortara for promoting the collab-
oration of authors and for your helpful suggestions
and advice; A. Pagano and S. O’Brien for revision
of the english version and S. Cavagna for the fora-
miniferal SEM photos.
REFERENCES
Aartsen J.J. van, 1987. European Pyramidellidae: III.
Odostomia and Ondina. Bollettino Malacologico, 23:
1-33.
Adam W. & Glibert M., 1975. Contribution a la connais-
sance de Nassarius semistriatus (Brocchi, 1814)
(Mollusca: Gastropoda). Bulletin de l’lnstitut Royal
des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, 50: 1-78.
Andri E., Tagliamacco A., Testa M. & Marchini A., 2005.
Le malacofaune fossili del Rio Torsero. Regione Li-
guria, Catalogo dei beni naturali, 5 . Nuova Editrice
Genovese, Ceriale, 286 pp.
Ardovini R. & Cossignani T., 1999. Atlante delle conchi-
glie di profondita del Mediterraneo. L’lnformatore
Piceno Ed., Ancona, 111 pp.
Barmawidjaja D.M., Jorissen F.J., Puskaric S. & Van der
Zwaan G.J., 1992. Microhabitat selection by benthic
foraminifera in the northern Adriatic sea. Journal of
Foraminiferal Research, 22: 297-317.
Bergamin L., Di Bella L. & Carboni M.G.,1999. Valvu-
lineria bradyana (Fornasini) in organig matter-en-
riched environment (Ombrone river mouth, Central
Italy). II Quaternario, Italian Journal of Quaternary
Sciences, 12: 51-56.
Blanc- Vernet L., 1969. Contribution a E etude de forami-
niferes de Mediterranee. Recueil des Travaux de la-
Station Marine d'Endoume, 64: 1-315.
Borghi E. & Bajo Campos I., 2008. Asteroidei fossili del-
l’Emilia. Notiziario della Societa Reggiana di
Scienze Naturali, 13-29.
Borghi M. & Vecchi G., 2005. La malacofauna plio-plei-
stocenica del torrente Stirone (PR). Cerithiidae - Tur-
ritellidae. Parva Naturalia, 7: 3-46.
Brunetti M.M. & Forli M., 2013. The genus Aporrhais
Da Costa, 1778 (Gastropoda Aporrhaidae) in the kal-
ian Plio-Pleistocene. Biodiversity Journal, 4: 183-
208.
Cavallo O., Macagno M. & Pavia G., 1986. Fossili del-
l'Albese: aspetti geologici, e paleontologici delle Lan-
ghe e del Roero. Famija Albeisa, Alba, 223 pp.
Charrier G., 1953. Brevi note sulle forme del gen. Apor-
rhais ( Chenopus ) della fauna pliocenica di San Gau-
denzio (Lessona) nel Biellese. Rivista Italiana di
Paleontologia e Stratigrafia, Milano, 59: 195-202.
Chirli C., 2008. Malacofauna pliocenica toscana. Neo-
taenioglossa. Vol. 6. Grafiche PDB, Tavernelle, 128
pp.
Chirli C. & Micali P., 2011. Malacofauna pliocenica to-
scana. Pyramidelloidea. Vol. 8. Grafiche PDB, Taver-
nelle, 132 pp.
Corliss B.H., 1985. Microhabitats of benthic foraminifera
within deep-sea sediments. Nature, 314: 435-438.
Corliss B.H., 1991. Morphology and microhabitat prefer-
ences of benthic foraminifera from the northwest
Atlantic Ocean. Marine Micropaleontology, 17: 195-
236.
Corliss B.H. & Emerson S., 1990. Distribution of Rose
Bengal stained deep-sea benthic foraminifera from
the Nova Scotian continental margin and Gulf of
Maine. Deep-Sea Research, 37: 381-400.
Damarco P., 1994. Alcuni esemplari eccezionali di Apor-
rhaidae fossili del Pliocene piemontese. World Shells,
3:28-30.
Fossil starfishes and paleontological analysis of the Pliocene of Cherasco, Piedmont region (NW Italy) 377
De Rijk S., Jorissen F.J., Rohling E.J. & Troelstra S.R.,
2000. Organic flux control on bathymetric zonation
of Mediterranean benthic foraminifera. Marine Mi-
cropaleontology, 40: 151-166.
De Stefani C. & Pantanelli D., 1878-80. Molluschi plio-
cenici dei dintomi di Siena. Bullettino della Societa
malacologica italiana, 4 (1-6): 5-48 [1878], 4 (7-14):
49-112 [1879], 4 (15-20): 113-160 [1879], 4 (21-30):
161-215 [1880],
Di Napoli Alliata E., Stefanini S. & Fioramonti G., 1970.
Etude de quelques carottes du plateau et du talus con-
tinental de la Sardaigne meridionale. Bollettino della
Societa Geologica Italiana, 89: 209-232.
Fontanier C., Jorissen F.J., Chaillou G., David C., An-
schutz R & Lafon V., 2003. Seasonal and interannual
variability of benthic foraminiferal faunas at 550 m
depth in the Bay of Biscay. Deep-Sea Research, Part
I: Oceanographic Research Papers, 50: 457-494.
Forli M., 1989. Considerazioni filogenetiche su alcune
specie del genere Aporrhais da Costa, 1778 (Mollu-
sca: Gastropoda) (ultima parte). Argonauta, 5: 49-54.
Huang B., Jian Z., Cheng X. & Wang P, 2002.
Foraminiferal responses to upwelling variations in
the South China Sea over the last 220000 years. Ma-
rine Micropaleontology, 47: 1-15.
Jannik N.T., Zachariasse W.J. & Van der Zwaan G.J.,
1998. Living (Rose Bengal stained) benthic
foraminifera from the Pakistan continental margin
(northern Arabian Sea). Deep-Sea Research Part I.
Oceanographic research Papers, 45: 1483-1513.
Jimenez A.P., Aguirre J. & Rivas P, 2009. Taxonomic
study of scallops (Pectinidae: Mollusca, Bivalvia)
from Pliocene deposits (Almeria, SE Spain). Re vista
Espanola de Paleontologia, 24: 1-30.
Kuhnt W., Hess S. & Jian Z., 1999. Quantitative compo-
sition of benthic foraminiferal assemblages as a
proxy indicator for organic carbon flux rates in the
South China Sea. Marine Geology, 156: 123-157.
Lentini F., 1969. Sezioni stratigrafiche plioceniche nella
Val d’Agri presso Gannano (Matera). Atti dell'Acca-
demia Gioenia di Scienze Naturali di Catania, 20
(Suppl. Sc. Geolog.): 19-79.
Lutze G.F., 1986. Uvigerina species of the eastern North
Atlantic. In: Van der Zwaan G.J., Jorissen F.J., Ver-
hallen P.J.J.M. & von Daniels C.H. (Eds.), Atlantic -
European Oligocene to Recent Uvigerina. Utrecht
Micropaleontological Bulletins, 35: 21-46.
Lutze G. & Coulbourn W., 1984. Recent benthic
foraminifera from the continental margin off north-
west Africa: community structure and distribution.
Marine Micropaleontology, 8: 361-401.
Mackensen A., Schmiedl G., Harloff J. & Giese M.,
1995. Deep-sea foraminifera in the South Atlantic
Ocean: ecology and assemblage generation. Micropa-
leontology, 41: 342-358.
MalatestaA., 1974. Malacofauna pliocenica umbra. Me-
morie per servire alia descrizione della carta geolo-
gica d'ltalia: 13: XI+498.
Morigi C., Jorissen F.J., Gervais A., Guichard S. & Bor-
setti A.M., 2001. Benthic foraminiferal faunas in sur-
face sediments off NW Africa: relationship with the
organic flux to the ocean floor. Journal of Foramini-
feral Research, 31: 350-368.
Murray J.W., 1991. Ecology and distribution. Benthos
90, Tokai University Press, Sendai.
Parenzan P, 1974. Carta d’identita delle conchiglie del
Mediterraneo. Vol. II. Bivalvi (prima parte). Bios
Taras Editrice, Taranto, 280 pp.
Pavia G., 1976. I Molluschi del Pliocene inferiore di
Monteu Roero (Alba, Italia NW). Bollettino della So-
cieta Paleontologica Italiana, 14: 99-175.
Peres J.M. & Picard J., 1964. Nouveau manuel de Bio-
nomie benthique de la Mer Mediterranee. Recueil des
Travaux de la Station Marine d’Endoume, 31: 1-137.
Poppe G.T. & Goto Y., 1991. European Seashells. Vol.
1 (Polyplacophora, Caudofoveata, Solenogastra,
Gastropoda). Verlag Christa Hemmen, Wiesbaden,
352 pp.
Poppe G.T. & Goto Y., 1993. European Seashells. Vol. 2.
(Scaphopoda, Bivalvia, Cephalopoda). Verlag Christa
Hemmen, Wiesbaden, 221 pp.
Riedl R., 1991. Fauna e Flora del Mediterraneo. Franco
Muzzio Editore, Padova, 777 pp.
Ruggieri G., 1972. Considerazioni su alcune Aporrhais
del Neogene italiano e sul loro significato stratigra-
fico. Rivista Mineraria Siciliana, Palermo, 22: 14-20.
Sacco F., 1893. Sopra alcuni Asteroidei fossili. Atti Regia
Accademia delle Scienze, Torino, 28: 739-745.
Sacco F., 1897. I Molluschi dei terreni terziarii del Pie-
monte e della Liguria. Parte XXIV. (Pectinidae).
Carlo Clausen, Torino, 84 pp., 21 pis.
Scaperrotta M., Bartolini S. & Bogi C., 2009. Accresci-
menti. Stadi di accrescimento dei molluschi marini
del Mediterraneo. Vol. I. L’lnformatore Piceno Ed.,
Ancona, 167 pp.
Scaperrotta M., Bartolini S. & Bogi C., 2011. Accresci-
menti. Stadi di accrescimento dei molluschi marini
del Mediterraneo. Vol. III. L’lnformatore Piceno Ed.,
Ancona, 184 pp.
Schmiedl G. & Mackensen A., 1997. Late Quaternary pa-
leoproductivity and deep water circulation in the east-
ern South Atlantic Ocean: evidence from benthic
foraminifera. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology,
Palaeoecology, 130: 43-80.
Schmiedl G., De Bovee F., Buscail R., Charriere B.,
Hemleben C., Medernach L. & Picon P, 2000. Tro-
phic control of benthic foraminiferal abundances and
microhabitat in the bathyal Gulf of Lions, western
Mediterranean Sea. Marine Micropaleontology, 40:
167-188.
378
Giovanni Repetto & Erica Bicchii
Schonfeld J., Alve E., Geslin E., Jorissen F., Korsun S.,
Spezzaferri S. and members of the FOBIMO group,
2012. The FOBIMO (FOraminiferal BIo-MOnitor-
ing) initiative - Towards a standardised protocol for
soft-bottom benthic foraminiferal monitoring studies.
Marine Micropaleontology, 94-95: 1-13.
Scott D.B., Schafer C.T. & Medioli F.S., 1980. Eastern
Canadian estuarine foraminifera: a framework for
comparison. Journal of Foraminiferal Research, 10:
205-234.
Sen Gupta B.K. & Machain-Castillo M.F., 1993. Benthic
foraminifera in oxygen-poor habitats. Marine Micropa-
leontology, 20: 183-201.
Tebble N., 1966. British Bivalve Seashells. The British
Museum of Natural History, Fondon, 212 pp.
Terreni G., 1981. Molluschi conchiferi del mare anti-
stante la costa toscana (Gastropoda, Scaphopoda,
Amphineura, Bivalvia, Cephalopoda). Tip. Benvenuti
& Cavaciocchi, Fivorno, 106 pp.
Thompson T.E., 1976. Biology of Opisthobranch Mol-
luscs. Vol. I. The Ray Society, Fondon, 206 pp.
Tortonese E., 1965. Echinodermata. Fauna d’ltalia, Vol.
VI. Calderini Ed., Bologna, 422 pp.
Van der Zwaan G.J., 1983. Quantitative analyses and the
reconstruction of benthic foraminiferal communities.
Utrecht Micropaleontological Bullettin, 26: 49-69.
Violanti D., 2012. Pliocene Mediterranean Foraminiferal
Biostratigraphy: A Synthesis and Application to the
Paleoenvironmental Evolution of Northwestern Italy,
Stratigraphic Analysis of Fayered Deposits. 123-160.
Dr. Omer Elitok (Ed.), InTech, Available from:
http://cdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/3632 1/InTech-
Pliocenejnediterranean foraminiferal biostratigra-
phy_a_synthesis_and_application_to_the_paleoenvi-
ronmental_evolution_of_northwestern_italy.pdf
Biodiversity Journal, 2013, 4 (2): 379-382
A remarkable new flightless Madrasostes Paulian, 1 975 from
Vietnam (Coleoptera Scarabaeoidea Hybosoridae Cerato-
canthinae)
Alberto Ballerio
Viale Venezia 45, 25123 Brescia, Italy, alberto.ballerio.bs@numerica.it
ABSTRACT Madrasostes bartolozzii n. sp. is described from Vietnam (Ba Be National Park) on the basis
of two females. Some remarks on this unusual flightless species are provided. Distinguishing
characters between Madrasostes Paulian, 1975 and Besuchestostes Paulian, 1972 are briefly
discussed.
KEY WORDS Ba Be National Park; Ceratocanthinae; Flightlessness; Madrasostes', new species.
Received 10.06.2013; accepted 26.06.2013; printed 30.06.2013
INTRODUCTION
The last (and only) synopsis of Vietnamese Ce-
ratocanthinae (Coleoptera Scarabaeoidea Hyboso-
ridae) was the volume by Renaud Paulian (1945)
on the Coleoptera Scarabaeoidea of French Indo-
china, which listed four species: Madrasostes ton-
kinense (Paulian, 1945), Pterorthochaetes incertus
Gestro, 1899, Pterorthochaetes coomani Paulian,
1945 and Pterorthochaetes armatus Paulian, 1945.
No additions have been recorded since then (Pau-
lian, 1978; Ocampo & Ballerio, 2006). Paulian's
work was based exclusively on material from Hoa
Binh region (Northern Vietnam), and the country
still awaits a proper exploration in order to inven-
tory its Ceratocanthine fauna, which will probably
score a final number several times larger than the
four species listed above (for instance the study of
the P incertus from Hoa Binh kept in the Museum
National d'Histoire Naturelle collection in Paris, in
the course of an ongoing revision of the genus Pte-
rorthochaetes Gestro, 1899, revealed that P. incer-
tus does not occur in Vietnam and that the alleged
P. incertus specimens actually represent three un-
described species). It is not surprising therefore that
an expedition organized in 20 1 1 by the team of the
Museo Zoologico La Specola of Florence discov-
ered a new species of the genus Madrasostes Pau-
lian, 1975, remarkable by its unusual morphology,
which is herein described.
METHODS
I refer to Ballerio et al. (2011) and references
therein quoted for methods and terminological
conventions. Habitus photographs were taken
with a Canon Eos D5 Mil with a macro objective
MP 65 mm, all photos were then mounted with
the Zerene Stacker software and cleaned and un-
masked using a photo processing software.
ABBREVIATIONS. EL = maximum elytral
length; EW = maximum total elytral width;
HL = maximum head length; HW maximum head
width; PL = maximum pronotal length at middle;
PW = maximum pronotal width at middle; W/L
ratio width length.
380
Alberto Ballerio
Madrasostes bartolozzii n. sp.
Examined material. Holotypus, female, in
Coll. Vietnam National Museum of Nature, Hanoi,
Vietnam: Northern Vietnam, Bac Kan Province, Ba
Be National Park (-350 m), 22°25'0.69"N
105°37'53.16"E, 3-8.VI.2011, L. Bartolozzi, S.
Bambi, F. Fabiano & E. Orbach leg. Paratypus, fe-
male, in Coll. Museo Zoologico La Specola, Fi-
renze: same data as holotypus.
Description of holotypus. HL =0.69 mm;
HW = 1.44 mm; PL = 1.38 mm; PW = 2.33 mm;
EL = 2.36 mm; EW = 2.27 mm.
Small sized Madrasostes (Figs. 1-4), flightless,
shiny dark-brown with green metallic sheen on re-
liefs, antennae, tarsi and sternum reddish-brown.
Glabrous (45 x). Head subpentagonal, wider than
long (W/L ratio= 1.26). Clypeal extremity pointed,
distinctly protruding forwards and apically slightly
bent upwards (probably a sexually dimorphic cha-
racter). Fore side of clypeus serrate, clypeopleuron
short, genae slightly protruding outwards, genal
canthus indistinct, dorsal ocular area absent. Head
dorsal surface completely covered by dense im-
pressed comma-shaped punctures, punctures lar-
ger on disc and frons and smaller on head base,
centrifugally oriented, each one bearing a simple
puncture next to inferior side, punctures dense, al-
most touching each other. Eyes small, longitudi-
nally elongate. Antennae 10-segmented, scape
long (about half the total length of antenna), sli-
ghtly clavate distad, pedicellus cupuliform, flagel-
lum short, made of short articles distinctly wider
than long, antennal club three-segmented, unifor-
mly hairy.
Mouthparts. Labrum wide and short, hemicircu-
lar, surface finely wrinkled, bearing medially a trans-
verse row of about ten long erect fine setae and
distally fringed by a dense fine setation directed for-
ward. Distal epipharynx bisinuate, longitudinally di-
vided by a strong anterior median process; median
brush and corypha absent; apical fringe made of
long, fine setae, absent in the middle. Mentum ven-
trally flat, widely emarginated in the middle,
emargination regularly wide-U-shaped; labial palpi
(including palpiger) four-segmented, first segment
short and transverse, segment two short, segment
three longer and plumper than preceding two toge-
ther, segment four subconical, about as long as seg-
ment three, apically bearing some short sensilla, all
segments, apart from the last one, fringed with long
setae. Maxillae with an elongate single membranous
lacinia, covered with fine long setae, monolobed
galea proximally sclerotized and distally clothed
with coarse long, fine setae with distinctive comb-
like tip (galeal brush), maxillary palpi (including
palpiger) four-segmented, palpiger small, segment
two wide and short, segment three short, segment
four long and subconical, about as long as preceding
two together, apically bearing some short sensilla.
Mandibles short, regularly curved, apicalis with
pointed apical tooth very short and blunt, not pro-
truding over mesal brush, lateral sclerite of apicalis
bearing a distinct large pore, mesal brush wide and
well developed, basalis with molar lobe strong.
Pronotum wider than long (W/L ratio= 1 .6), fore
angles truncate and sinuate externally, fore margin
bisinuate, with visible bead, lateral and basal margin
with a thick bead not visible from above, basal mar-
gin slightly swollen upwards, pronotal sculpturing
as follows: whole surface, apart from area near fore
angles, uniformly covered by veiy fine impressed
simple punctures, their distance being one or two
times their diameter. Area near fore angles covered
by a mix of coarse shallow comma-shaped and ocel-
late punctures. Two large longitudinal irregular
raised cariniform processes on disc, convergent
anteriad, basally, next to each cariniform process,
there is a large blunt tubercle, and next to the tuber-
cle there are two transversal processes subparallel to
each other, the superior one is an irregular carina,
while the inferior is a pair of tubercles; surface of
carinae and tubercles smooth, apart from a few
sparse large impressed simple punctures.
Scutellum wider than long (W/L ratio=l .4), sides
proximally subparallel and distinctly notched by ely-
tral articular process, then convergent to form a
triangle with elongate acute apex and sides slightly
curved inward. Surface slightly depressed in the
middle, covered by irregular impressed comma-
shaped punctures. Elytra slightly longer than wide
(W/L ratio=0.98), sutural interstria raised and
cariniform, another longitudinal strongly raised
complete carina next to sutural carina, one further
longitudinal complete raised carina, starting from
the end of proximal third and ending at the
beginning of the distal third, one fourth short raised
carina occupying most of median third and finally a
fifth longitudinal raised carina starting at humerus
A remarkable new flightless Madrasostes from Vietnam (Coleoptera Scarabaeoidea Hybosoridae Ceratocanthinae) 381
Figures 1-4. Madrasostes bartolozzii n. sp. Fig. 1: Holotypus dorsal view. Fig. 2: rolled up holotypus dorsal view. Fig. 3:
rolled up holotypus ventral view. Fig. 4: rolled up holotypus lateral view.
(and inglobating humeral callus) and ending near
apex, interruped medially in correspondence with
the fourth carina. Surface of carinae smooth, surface
between carinae covered by two irregular rows of
longitudinally oriented elongate and narrow shallow
horseshoe-shaped punctures, with opening back-
wards and having a simple puncture in the middle.
Pseudoepipleure absent, marginal area broad,
expanded outwards, coarsely wrinkled, inferior su-
tural stria not present, articular area not visible.
Fore tibiae ending with two outer teeth, outer mar-
gin coarsely serrate, apical spur long and broadly
curved downwards. Meso- and metatibiae ending
with two apical spurs.
Variability. The paratypus does not show any
appreciable variation compared to the holotypus in
size, colour, shape and sculpturing.
Etymology. I am pleased to dedicate this re-
markable new species to Dr. Luca Bartolozzi
(Museo Zoologico La Specola, Firenze), who col-
lected the type series.
Distribution and Biology. Known only from
the type locality, Ba Be national Park in Northern
Vietnam. The area falls within the South China-
Vietnam Subtropical Evergreen Forest ecoregion
(Wikramanayake et al., 2002). The type series was
collected by sifting leaf litter collected in the rain-
forest near the park headquarters (Bartolozzi, pers.
comm.).
Comparative notes. M. bartolozzii n. sp. can be
easily distinguished from all other Madrasostes be-
cause of the following combination of characters:
head with serrate clypeal margin, genal canthus in-
distinct without any dorsal ocular area, pronotum
with surface covered by a dense very fine punc-
turation, elytra with five strongly raised longitudi-
nal carinae, flightless.
Remarks. This new species strongly diverges
morphologically from all other known Madraso-
stes. No other known Madrasostes displays such a
combination of characters and at present it is not
382
Alberto Ballerio
possible even to find its closest relatives. The un-
usual puncturation pattern of pronotum, made of
very fine simple punctures is not found in any other
known Madrasostes and is unique even within Ce-
ratocanthinae. The combination of flightlessness, in-
distinct eye canthus and dorsal ocular area absent and
strong carinate elytra could lead to place this species
in the genus Besuchetostes Paulian, 1972, according
to the criteria set by Paulian (1978). However a re-
definition of the genus Besuchetostes in preparation
will soon circumscribe the genus to the Indian and
Sri Lankan species ascribed to it (Ballerio, in prep.).
Madrasostes bartolozzi n. sp. shares some characters
typical of the Perignamptus genus group, as defined
by Ballerio (2009), and absent in true Besuchetostes ,
such as the shape of epipharynx and the presence of
a basal pore in the mandibles. Indistinct eye canthus
and dorsal ocular area absent as well as strong cari-
nate elytra and the pattern of distribution of tubercles
on pronotum are probably the result of convergent
evolution, due to flightlessness and strong adaptation
to life in leaf litter.
Therefore the species is here attributed to Ma-
drasostes, even if as previously highlighted in Bal-
lerio (2009), this placement must be seen as
provisional, due to the unsatisfactory current de-
finition of the genus Madrasostes and its allies
within the Perignamptus generic group.
REFERENCES
Ballerio A., 2009. Unusual morphology in a new genus
and species of Ceratocanthinae from New Guinea
(Coleoptera: Scarabaeoidea: Hybosoridae). The Co-
leopterists Bulletin, 63: 44-53.
Ballerio A., B.D. Gill & V. Grebennikov. 2011. Illustrated
overview and identification key to Cameroonian Ce-
ratocanthinae beetles (Coleoptera: Scarabaeoidea:
Hybosoridae) with description of four new species.
Zootaxa2892: 1-24.
Ocampo F.C. & Ballerio A., 2006. Catalog of the subfa-
milies Anaidinae, Ceratocanthinae, Hybosorinae, Li-
parochrinae, and Pachyplectrinae (Scarabaeoidea:
Hybosoridae). In Ocampo F.C. (Ed.) Phylogenetic
analysis of the scarab family Hybosoridae and mono-
graphic revision of the New World subfamily Anaidi-
nae (Coleoptera: Scarabaeoidea). Bulletin of the
University of Nebraska State Museum, 19: 178-209.
Paulian R., 1945. Coleopteres Scarabaeides de l’lndo-
chine. Premiere partie. Faune de l’Empire Frangais
III. Librarie Larose, Paris, 228 pp.
Paulian R., 1978. Revision des Ceratocanthidae [Col.
Scarabaeoidea] II - Les especes orientales et austra-
liennes. Annales de la Societe Entomologique de
France, 14: 479-514.
Wikramanayake E., Dinerstein E., Loucks C.J., Olson
D.M., Morrison J., Lamoreux J., McKnight M. &
Hedao P., 2002. Terrestrial Ecoregions of the Indo-
Pacific. A Conservation Assessment. Island Press,
Washington, 643 pp.